SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  5
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Grain size dependence of fracture toughness and crack-growth resistance
of superelastic NiTi
Aslan Ahadi a,b
, Qingping Sun a,
⁎
a
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Hong Kong
b
School of Civil Engineering, State Key Lab of Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering, Wuhan University, China
a b s t r a c ta r t i c l e i n f o
Article history:
Received 12 August 2015
Received in revised form 10 October 2015
Accepted 22 October 2015
Available online xxxx
Keywords:
Shape memory alloys
Martensitic phase transformation
Microstructure
Toughness
Intrinsic and extrinsic toughening mechanisms
The grain size (GS) dependence of fracture toughness (KIC) and static crack-growth resistance (KR) of superelastic
NiTi with average GS from 10 to 1500 nm are investigated. The measurements of strain and temperature fields at
the crack-tip region are synchronized with the force–displacement curves under mode-I crack opening tests. It is
found that with GS reduction down to nanoscale, the KIC and the size of crack-tip phase transformation zone
monotonically decrease and the KR changes from a rising to a flat R-curve. The roles of intrinsic and extrinsic
toughening mechanisms in the GS dependence of the fracture process are discussed.
© 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Due to a reversible martensitic phase transformation (PT),
superelastic (SE) NiTi shape memory alloys (SMAs) are widely used in
a variety of applications. However, the narrow temperature window
of superelasticity [1], poor cyclic stability [2], and poor fatigue life [3],
significantly limit the applications of SE NiTi. In recent years, significant
steps have been taken to break the above limitations. Introducing de-
fects via doping [4,5], addition of Nb nanowires to NiTi [6], and GS re-
duction down to nanocrystalline (nc) regime [7–10] are unique ways
to achieve novel properties. It has been shown that with GS reduction
to nc regime, SE NiTi indeed exhibits novel properties such as linear
superelasticity with vanishing hysteresis [11], broadening of the tem-
perature window of superelasticity down to −60 °C [7], and improved
thermomechanical cyclic stability [8].
The fracture toughness (KIC) and crack-growth resistance (KR) are
essential properties for successful application of metals and alloys
[12]. It is well-known that with GS reduction to nc regime, metals exhib-
it lower KIC due to limited ductility [13]. Owing to a stress-induced mar-
tensitic PT, the most distinctive feature in the fracture process of SMAs is
the formation of a kidney-like crack tip PT zone which can transform
back at the crack wake [14]. In this regard, several experimental, analyt-
ical, and numerical researches have been published [12,15–20]. Howev-
er, the GS effects on the fracture behavior and intrinsic/extrinsic
toughening mechanisms of SE NiTi remain to be unveiled by systematic
experiments. In this paper, we have studied the KIC and KR behaviors of
SE NiTi with average GS from 10 to 1500 nm. The strain and tempera-
ture fields at the crack-tip region and the crack wake are synchronized
with the force–displacement curves by in-situ digital image correlation
(DIC) and in-situ infrared (IR) thermography under the mode-I crack
opening tests.
SE NiTi (Ti-50.9 at.% Ni) sheets with thickness of 1.7 mm were
sandwiched in stainless steel sheets and were cold-rolled to 42% of
thickness reduction. The as-rolled sheets were heat-treated at tempera-
tures of 250 °C for 45 min, 520 °C for 2 min, 520 °C for 3 min, 520 °C for
6 min, and 600 °C for 45 min followed by quenching in water [7,8,11].
The average GS of the cold-rolled and heat-treated specimens was mea-
sured with TEM (see Fig. S1) and Williamson–Hall method. Dog-bone
tensile specimens with thickness of 1 mm, width of 2 mm, and gauge
length of 30 mm were cut along the rolling direction and tested to ob-
tain stress–strain curves (see Fig. S2b) at a strain rate of 1 × 10−4
s−1
using an MTS (UTM-RT/10) machine. Transformation temperatures
were determined using differential scanning calorimeter (DSC-TA
Q1000) with heating/cooling rate of 10 K/min.
Notched compact tension (CT) specimens with the dimension shown
in Fig. S3a were EDM cut from the cold-rolled and heat-treated sheets.
The highly polished CT specimens were pre-cracked (see Fig. S3b)
with a MTS-858 table top machine at a frequency of 5 Hz with sinusoidal
wave function under decreasing load amplitudes (ΔPn b … b ΔP1) as
suggested by ASTM E 561-10 (ΔP = Pmax − Pmin). The load ratio of
R = Pmin/Pmax = 0.1 was used (see inset in Fig. S3c). Different lengths
of pre-cracks with 7.6 b a b 10.29 mm (0.4470 b a/W b 0.6053 mm)
were obtained. The crack length was monitored ex-situ using a Leica mi-
croscope. The strain and temperature fields at the vicinity of the crack tip
Scripta Materialia 113 (2016) 171–175
⁎ Corresponding author.
E-mail address: meqpsun@ust.hk (Q. Sun).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2015.10.036
1359-6462/© 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Scripta Materialia
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/scriptamat
were synchronized using in-situ DIC and IR thermography. The experi-
mental setup for mode-I crack opening tests is shown in Fig. S3c. To cre-
ate a fine and random pattern needed for strain field measurements
using DIC, silicon micro-particles (with average size of 1 μm) were
speckled to the specimen surface (Fig. S4). Ncorr open source 2D DIC
was used for DIC calculations [21]. A fast multi-detector IR thermal cam-
era (FLIR SC7700BB) equipped with a close-up lens with working dis-
tance of 30 cm and field of view of 9.6 × 7.2 mm2
was used to record
the temperature field at the crack-tip region. To achieve a uniform
black body, one side of the specimens' surface was covered with candle
fume. The mode-I crack opening tests were performed at the loading
rate of 5 mm/min in order to capture the temperature variations at the
crack-tip region. The fractography studies were performed in a JEOL-
JSM 6390 SEM.
The transformation temperatures measured from DSC (see Fig. S2a)
are summarized in Table 1. It is seen that all the transformation temper-
atures Af (austenite finish temperature), Ms (martensite start tempera-
ture), and Mf (martensite finish temperature) decrease with GS
reduction. The effects of GS on the isothermal stress–strain tensile prop-
erties are shown in supplementary materials (Fig. S2b). It is seen that all
the specimens are SE as they can recover large strains of 5%. With GS re-
duction to nc regime (GS b 60 nm) the stress–strain response changes
from a plateau-type superelasticity to hardening SE response with
much reduced hysteresis loop area [9]. The critical transformation stress
(σtr), determined from the cross-cutting of the tangent lines in the elas-
tic and PT regions (see Fig. S2b), increases from 381 MPa for GS =
1500 nm to 655 MPa for GS = 10 nm. The gradual increase of σtr with
GS reduction is due to the fact that the reduction of GS makes the PT
more difficult [11,22]. The plastic yield's stress of martensite (σY
M
), de-
termined from the cross-cutting of the tangent lines in the martensite
elastic deformation and plastic deformation regions, also increases
with GS reduction since dislocation activities are significantly sup-
pressed at nano-scale. Moreover, the strain to failure (εf) decreases
with GS reduction to nc indicating a gradual reduction in the ductility.
Fig. 1a shows the force–displacement curves of the CT specimens
with different average GS (a/W = 0.4501). It is seen that for all the spec-
imens, after an initial linear deformation (up to ~415 N), the force–
displacement curve deviates from linearity due to stress-induced
martensitic PT at the crack-tip region [23]. With further increase of
the displacement the force first reaches a maximum Pmax and then
decreases either gradually (for GS = 1500, 80, 18, and 10 nm) due to
relative stable crack growth or rapidly (for GS = 64 and 42 nm) due
to fast (burst-like) crack growth. It is evident that the amount of
deviation from linearity and the value of Pmax decrease with GS
reduction. This GS dependencies of the fracture behavior forms a stark
contrast with the uniform tensile stress–strain curves where specimens
with smaller GS can sustain larger loads. According to the linear elastic
fracture mechanics (LEFM), the critical stress intensity factor (KIC) for
mode-I loading can be calculated as:
KIC ¼
P max
B
ffiffiffiffiffiffi
W
p Á
2 þ a=Wð Þ
1−a=Wð Þ3=2
Á f a=Wð Þ ð1Þ
where Pmax is the applied maximum force, B is the specimen thick-
ness, W is the specimen width measured from the load line, a is the
physical crack length (see Fig. S3a), and f(a/W) can be expressed as
(see ASTM E 561-08):
f a=Wð Þ ¼ 0:886 þ 4:64 a=Wð Þ−13:32 a=Wð Þ2
þ 14:72 a=Wð Þ3
−5:6 a=Wð Þ4
h i
:
ð2Þ
When using Eq. (1) one has to note that this equation is only valid for
plane strain condition where the size of the PT zone is much smaller
than the specimen thickness. Looking at the size of PT zone in Fig. 2, it
is seen that this condition is barely met in our experiments. Therefore,
the values of KIC and KR reported here are nominal and only serve as
first approximations and are used for comparative purpose. More
exact calculations such as using finite element method is needed to de-
termine the K values. For each GS, the measured KIC averaged over eight
different values of a/W are shown in Fig. 1b. For the GS = 1500 and
80 nm, the KIC values are 46.3 MPa
ffiffiffiffiffi
m
p
and 42.4 MPa
ffiffiffiffiffi
m
p
, respectively.
These values are consistent with the reported values for SE NiTi of the
similar microstructure and stress–strain curves [16,23]. It is seen that
when GS is reduced below 80 nm, the value of KIC monotonically de-
creases and reaches 25.4 MPa
ffiffiffiffiffi
m
p
for GS = 10 nm. Fig. 1c shows the
GS dependence of crack-growth resistance KR (R-curve) as a function
of crack extension (a − a0). For GS = 1500 and 80 nm, the KR keeps in-
creasing (known as rising R-curve) with crack extension and eventually
saturates. However, for GS = 18 and 10 nm, the R-curves become flat. In
other words, more energy is dissipated during crack propagation for SE
NiTi with GS = 1500 and 80 nm while for the GS = 18 and 10 nm the
fracture behavior resembles those of brittle materials.
SEM images of the fracture surfaces of the CT specimens are shown in
Fig. 1d. The fracture surface of the specimen with GS = 1500 nm mainly
shows dimples indicating a dominant ductile fracture. For GS = 80 nm
the fracture surface is characterized by a mixture of dimples and cleavage
planes. With further GS reduction, the tendency of the cleavage increases
in the fracture process as it is shown for GS = 42 and 10 nm. Therefore,
based on the consistent observations of (1) stress–strain behavior
(2) crack-tip inelastic zone size (3) KR curves and (4) the SEM observa-
tions, it is suggested that the failure mode transitions from ductile to brit-
tle fracture when GS is reduced down to nanoscale.
The effects of GS on the strain (εyy) distribution around the crack-tip re-
gion taken at Pmax are shown in Fig. 2. It is seen that the strain field at the
crack-tip vicinity is in the shape of two lobes. For the GS = 1500 and 80 nm
the lobes are inclined to an angle of about 48 and 51° from the crack line,
respectively. The angle of inclination gradually increases to 63° for GS =
10 nm. Moreover, the DIC images indicate that with GS reduction the
size of the lobe at Pmax immediately prior to the crack growth decreases.
From the plot of εyy as a function of the distance from the crack tip,
as shown in Fig. 2, one can determine the size of the PT zone along the
x-axis rA → M by referring to the stress–strain curves [16,32]. For GS =
1500 nm the 0.25 ≤ rA → M ≤ 1.7 mm at the crack tip region and with GS re-
duction the rA → M monotonically decreases to 0.23 ≤ rA → M ≤ 0.81 mm for
GS = 80 nm and 0.19 ≤ rA → M ≤ 0.48 mm for GS = 64 nm. The measured
Table 1
The GS dependence of phase transformation properties of SE NiTi.
Heat treatment Average GS (nm) As/Af (°C) Ms/Mf (°C) σtr (MPa) σY
M
(MPa) EAust (GPa) H5% (MPa)
Cold-rolled 10 N/A N/A 655 N/A 50.5 1.05
250 °C — 45 min 18 N/A N/A 502 1465 45.8 3.4
520 °C — 2 min 42 −12.7/8 −60/−86 472 1452 49.8 6.9
520 °C — 3 min 64 −12.5/6 −55/−78 461 1457 46.3 9.51
520 °C — 6 min 80 −4.8/10 −50/−70 425 1411 47.4 11.25
600 °C — 45 min 1500 −4.6/3 −30/−33 381 527 45 13.11
172 A. Ahadi, Q. Sun / Scripta Materialia 113 (2016) 171–175
values of rA → M are consistent with the published data on nano-grained SE
NiTi [16]. The GS dependence of rA → M and stress distribution can be read-
ily explained by the theoretical models of stress-induced PT at the crack tip
region [18,24]. When the size of PT zone is small compared with the size of
the specimen (small scale PT), the size and the shape of PT zone for each
GS can be approximated as [25]:
rA→M θð Þ ¼
1
2π
Kapp
σtr
 2
cos2 θ
2
1 þ 3 sin2 θ
2
 
ð3Þ
where σtr is the critical transformation stress and depends on the GS and
Kapp is the applied stress intensity factor at the crack tip. For a stationary
crack = KIC. According to this equation, rA → M scales with (Kapp/σtr)2
.
Therefore, for a given Kapp a gradual reduction of rA → M with GS reduction
is expected since σtr increases significantly with GS reduction. Another ef-
fect of GS reduction is that for a given Kapp the stress levels in the PT zone
and plasticity zone are higher due to higher σtr and σY
M
as schematically
shown in Fig. S5. A direct consequence of such higher stress levels at the
crack tip region is that the fracture behaves more like brittle materials
and has features of brittle fracture such as a flat R-curve.
The synchronized IR thermographic images of the front surface of the
specimens at Pmax (loading rate of 5 mm/min) are shown in Fig. 3a. It is
seen that the crack-tip region is warmer than the rest of the specimen
due to release of PT latent heat and heat transfer via conduction and con-
vection [2,26,27]. The figure shows two important features. First, with GS
reduction the size of the hot zone decreases which is consistent with the
DIC measurements of rA → M (Fig. 2a). Second, under the given loading
rate of 5 mm/min, the magnitude of the temperature increase in the
PT zone decreases with GS. For example, the magnitude of the temper-
ature rise at the crack tip is 5.83 °C for GS = 1500 nm and it monoton-
ically decreases to 1.02 °C for GS = 18 nm, and 0.03 °C for a GS = 10 nm.
This is due to the reduction of latent heat with GS especially for GS =
18 nm (see Fig. S2b) [7–9]. Fig. 3b shows the thermographic images
during crack propagation. Comparing Fig. 3b with 3a, one can note a re-
markable increase in the size of the crack-tip hot zone for GS = 1500
and 80 nm. This is consistent with the rising R-curve characteristic of
the two specimens. Furthermore, it is clearly seen that once the crack
propagates it leaves two cold regions behind with temperatures lower
than the room temperature (black arrows). For the GS = 1500 nm the
minimum temperature in the crack wake is 15.5 °C which is 4.5 °C
below the room temperature. This cooling effect is due to a rapid
absorption of latent heat and provides a compelling evidence to the re-
verse PT when the crack passed by [26]. For the same reasons, the
cooling in the wake becomes also weaker with GS reduction.
To elucidate the effects of GS on the controlling mechanisms of KIC
and KR, a qualitative discussion of the intrinsic and extrinsic toughening
mechanisms at the crack-tip region and crack wake [28] are given in
Fig. 4a and b, respectively. For the intrinsic mechanisms, it is well-
known that the most dominant toughening mechanism in SE NiTi is
the formation of stress-induced martensite at the crack-tip region
which act as a shielding mechanism. According to Baxevanis et al. [12,
15], the degree of the toughening due to the crack-tip PT depends main-
ly on the dimensionless parameter α = σtr εtr/[σtr
2
/EA] (ratio of dissipat-
ed to stored energy) where σtr is the transformation stress, εtr is the
transformation strain, and EA is the Young's modulus of austenite. The
higher value of α is beneficial for toughness enhancement [25]. As
such, the gradual decrease of α (due to a gradual increase of σtr) is in-
deed the main reason for a gradual reduction of KIC [29]. Another factor
that needs to be considered is the GS dependence of the plastic yield's
stress of the martensite (σY
M
). As can be seen in Table 1, the σY
M
increases
with GS reduction to nc. In the same way as that of the elastic–plastic
Fig. 1. (a) GS effects on the force–displacement curves during mode-I monotonic crack opening fracture tests, (b) GS effects on the K = KIC (K at Pmax) for specimens of different initial crack
lengths (with 0.4470 b a/W b 0.6053 mm), (c) GS effects on the crack-growth resistance (KR), and (d) top-view SEM images of the fracture surface of CT specimens.
Fig. 2. GS effects on the variation of εyy with the distance (x) from the crack tip (in the x
direction). The inset shows the DIC images taken at Pmax with a field of view of
6.34 × 4.75 mm2
. A reduction of PT zone size with GS reduction is observed.
173A. Ahadi, Q. Sun / Scripta Materialia 113 (2016) 171–175
materials, a higher yield's stress indicates a smaller size of the plastic de-
formation zone and higher stress levels (see Fig. S5) at the crack tip
leading to less shielding effect and toughness enhancement. However,
it is important to note that the effect of plastic deformation zone at
the crack tip on the shielding and dissipation is believed to be small
compared with the dissipation due to PT [12]. In addition, with GS re-
duction, the tortuous crack-path configuration (see Fig. 4a1) becomes
straight (see Fig. 4a2). This causes a change in the mode of K from mix
of mode-I and mode-II in the former, to near mode-I in the latter. This
leads to a decrease of the threshold (critical) driving force for crack
propagation that in turn leads to reduction of KIC [30].
The effects of GS on the extrinsic mechanisms are schematically
shown in Fig. 4b1 (for GS ≥ 80 nm) and Fig. 4b2 (for nc NiTi). As it is
seen in Fig. 4b, during crack propagation the crack wake undergoes a
complete cycle of forward and reverse PT (see also Fig. 3b for the ther-
mographic evidence of the reverse PT at the crack wake). The toughness
enhancement ΔK = Ka − KIC for steady-state crack propagation due to
such forward/reverse PT or energy dissipation can be described by the
following equation [31]:
K2
a ¼ K2
IC þ
2E
1−υ2ð Þ
 Z H
0
Ud
yð Þdy ð4Þ
where E is the elastic modulus, υ is the Poisson's ratio, H is the height of
the crack wake, and Ud
( = ∮ σ dε) is the specific mechanical energy dis-
sipated in the wake and is represented by the σ − ε hysteresis loop area.
From Eq. (4) it is clearly seen that the gradual change of KR with GS
reduction (from a rising R-curve to a flat R-curve) is not only caused
by a reduction of H due to the increase of σtr, but also caused by a grad-
ual reduction of the stress hysteresis (Ud
→ 0) of the material [7].
In summary, the grain size (GS) dependence of fracture toughness
(KIC) and static crack-growth resistance (KR) of SE NiTi were
investigated by synchronized measurements of the force–displacement
curves and the crack-tip strain and temperature fields. It is shown that
with GS reduction to nanoscale, the KIC gradually decreases and KR tran-
sitions from rising to flat R-curve. The in-situ measurements showed a
monotonic reduction in the size of the phase transformation zone at
the crack-tip region. Using the controlling parameters of the fracture
process of NiTi SMAs and their grain size dependencies, the intrinsic
and extrinsic toughening mechanisms of the fracture behavior of the
NiTi were analyzed and discussed. The results provide a better under-
standing of the fracture behavior of nanocrystalline superelastic NiTi
which possesses exceptional thermomechanical properties.
The authors are grateful for the financial support of this work from
the Hong Kong Research Grant Council (RGC) through the GRF grant
(project no. 16214215) and the 973 Program of China (project no.
2014 CB046902). We also thank Maziar Jamishidi for DIC data analysis
and Hamed Mokhtari for helping with thermographic experiments.
Appendix A. Supplementary data
Supplementary data to this article can be found online at http://dx.
doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2015.10.036.
Fig. 3. (a) IR thermographic images showing the GS effects on the temperature field near the crack-tip region at K = KIC, (b) GS effects on the temperature field in the crack-growth regime
(a = a0 + Δa) showing heating/cooling due to forward/reverse PT in the crack-tip/wake.
Fig. 4. Schematics of the GS effects on (a) the intrinsic toughening mechanisms and (b) the extrinsic toughening mechanisms.
174 A. Ahadi, Q. Sun / Scripta Materialia 113 (2016) 171–175
References
[1] T. Omori, K. Ando, M. Okano, X. Xu, Y. Tanaka, I. Ohnuma, R. Kainuma, K. Ishida, Sci-
ence 333 (2011) 68 (80-.).
[2] H. Yin, Y. He, Q. Sun, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 67 (2014) 100.
[3] A.L. McKelvey, R.O. Ritchie, Metall. Mater. Trans. A 32 (2001) 731.
[4] D. Wang, Z. Zhang, J. Zhang, Y. Zhou, Y. Wang, X. Ding, Y. Wang, X. Ren, Acta Mater.
58 (2010) 6206.
[5] Y. Nii, T. Arima, H.Y. Kim, S. Miyazaki, Phys. Rev. B 82 (2010) 214104.
[6] S. Hao, L. Cui, F. Guo, Y. Liu, X. Shi, D. Jiang, D.E. Brown, Y. Ren, Sci. Rep. 5 (2015)
8892.
[7] A. Ahadi, Q.P. Sun, Appl. Phys. Lett. 103 (2013) 021902.
[8] A. Ahadi, Q.P. Sun, Acta Mater. 76 (2014) 186.
[9] A. Ahadi, Q.P. Sun, Acta Mater. 90 (2015) 272.
[10] K. Tsuchiya, M. Inuzuka, D. Tomus, A. Hosokawa, H. Nakayama, K. Morii, Y. Todaka,
M. Umemoto, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 438-440 (2006) 643.
[11] Q.P. Sun, A. Ahadi, M. Li, M. Chen, Sci. China Technol. Sci. 57 (2014) 671.
[12] T. Baxevanis, C.M. Landis, D.C. Lagoudas, J. Appl. Mech. 81 (2013) 041005.
[13] M. Dao, L. Lu, R. Asaro, J. Dehosson, E. Ma, Acta Mater. 55 (2007) 4041.
[14] A. Boulbitch, A.L. Korzhenevskii, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107 (2011) 085505.
[15] T. Baxevanis, A.F. Parrinello, D.C. Lagoudas, Int. J. Plast. 50 (2013) 158.
[16] S. Daly, A. Miller, G. Ravichandran, K. Bhattacharya, Acta Mater. 55 (2007) 6322.
[17] M.R. Daymond, M.L. Young, J.D. Almer, D.C. Dunand, Acta Mater. 55 (2007) 3929.
[18] C. Maletta, F. Furgiuele, Acta Mater. 58 (2010) 92.
[19] M.L. Young, S. Gollerthan, A. Baruj, J. Frenzel, W.W. Schmahl, G. Eggeler, Acta Mater.
61 (2013) 5800.
[20] T. Baxevanis, D.C. Lagoudas, Int. J. Fract. 191 (2008) 191.
[21] J. Blaber, B.S. Adair, A. Antoniou, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 86 (2015) 035111.
[22] J.R. Wollants, P. De Bonte, M. Roos, Z. Met. 82 (1979) 113.
[23] S. Gollerthan, M.L. Young, A. Baruj, J. Frenzel, W.W. Schmahl, G. Eggeler, Acta Mater.
57 (2009) 1015.
[24] C. Maletta, F. Furgiuele, Int. J. Solids Struct. 48 (2011) 1658.
[25] Y. Freed, L. Bankssills, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 55 (2007) 2157.
[26] S. Gollerthan, M.L. Young, K. Neuking, U. Ramamurty, G. Eggeler, Acta Mater. 57
(2009) 5892.
[27] H. Yin, Y. Yan, Y. Huo, Q.P. Sun, Mater. Lett. 109 (2013) 287.
[28] R.O. Ritchie, Nat. Mater. 10 (2011) 817.
[29] Q.S. Mei, L. Zhang, K. Tsuchiya, H. Gao, T. Ohmura, K. Tsuzaki, Scr. Mater. 63 (2010)
977.
[30] B. Lawn, Fracture of Brittle Solids, 2nd ed. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,
1975.
[31] Q.P. Sun, X.J. Xu, Mater. Sci. 30 (1995) 439.
[32] W. LePage, S. Daly, The influence of crystallographic texture on fracture of the
shape-memory alloys, in: A. Bajaj, P. Zavattieri, M. Koslowski, T. Siegmund (Eds.), Pro-
ceedings of the Society of Engineering Science 51st Annual Technical Meeting, October
1-3, 2014, Purdue University Libraries Scholarly Publishing Services, West Lafayette,
2014.
175A. Ahadi, Q. Sun / Scripta Materialia 113 (2016) 171–175

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental
Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimentalSize effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental
Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimentaleSAT Publishing House
 
Acta Mater 57 (2009) 559 Investigation Of The Indentation Size Effect
Acta  Mater 57 (2009) 559  Investigation Of The Indentation Size EffectActa  Mater 57 (2009) 559  Investigation Of The Indentation Size Effect
Acta Mater 57 (2009) 559 Investigation Of The Indentation Size EffectDierk Raabe
 
Precdicting corrosion crack rates growth
Precdicting corrosion crack rates growthPrecdicting corrosion crack rates growth
Precdicting corrosion crack rates growthDương Phúc
 
Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental study
Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental studySize effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental study
Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental studyeSAT Journals
 
D.H. Gordon et al., Polymer, 35, (1994) 2554 - 2559.
D.H. Gordon et al., Polymer, 35, (1994) 2554 - 2559.D.H. Gordon et al., Polymer, 35, (1994) 2554 - 2559.
D.H. Gordon et al., Polymer, 35, (1994) 2554 - 2559.Duncan Gordon
 
Numerical modeling of the welding defect influence on fatigue life of the wel...
Numerical modeling of the welding defect influence on fatigue life of the wel...Numerical modeling of the welding defect influence on fatigue life of the wel...
Numerical modeling of the welding defect influence on fatigue life of the wel...inventy
 
Mathematical Relationships between the Compressive Strength and Some Other St...
Mathematical Relationships between the Compressive Strength and Some Other St...Mathematical Relationships between the Compressive Strength and Some Other St...
Mathematical Relationships between the Compressive Strength and Some Other St...IOSR Journals
 
Predicting the Nonlinear Material Behaviour under Monotonic and Cyclic loadin...
Predicting the Nonlinear Material Behaviour under Monotonic and Cyclic loadin...Predicting the Nonlinear Material Behaviour under Monotonic and Cyclic loadin...
Predicting the Nonlinear Material Behaviour under Monotonic and Cyclic loadin...IJERA Editor
 
Growth and Magnetic properties of MnGeP2 thin films
Growth and Magnetic properties of MnGeP2 thin filmsGrowth and Magnetic properties of MnGeP2 thin films
Growth and Magnetic properties of MnGeP2 thin filmsinventy
 
An Experimental Investigation into the Grindability Aspects of Newly Develope...
An Experimental Investigation into the Grindability Aspects of Newly Develope...An Experimental Investigation into the Grindability Aspects of Newly Develope...
An Experimental Investigation into the Grindability Aspects of Newly Develope...IDES Editor
 
SLIDING WEAR OF AA6061/CARBON BLACK METAL MATRIX COMPOSITES
SLIDING WEAR OF AA6061/CARBON BLACK METAL MATRIX COMPOSITESSLIDING WEAR OF AA6061/CARBON BLACK METAL MATRIX COMPOSITES
SLIDING WEAR OF AA6061/CARBON BLACK METAL MATRIX COMPOSITESIAEME Publication
 
Vibrational Analysis Of Cracked Rod Having Circumferential Crack
Vibrational Analysis Of Cracked Rod Having Circumferential Crack Vibrational Analysis Of Cracked Rod Having Circumferential Crack
Vibrational Analysis Of Cracked Rod Having Circumferential Crack IDES Editor
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development
International Journal of Engineering Research and DevelopmentInternational Journal of Engineering Research and Development
International Journal of Engineering Research and DevelopmentIJERD Editor
 

Tendances (18)

Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental
Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimentalSize effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental
Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental
 
Acta Mater 57 (2009) 559 Investigation Of The Indentation Size Effect
Acta  Mater 57 (2009) 559  Investigation Of The Indentation Size EffectActa  Mater 57 (2009) 559  Investigation Of The Indentation Size Effect
Acta Mater 57 (2009) 559 Investigation Of The Indentation Size Effect
 
Precdicting corrosion crack rates growth
Precdicting corrosion crack rates growthPrecdicting corrosion crack rates growth
Precdicting corrosion crack rates growth
 
Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental study
Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental studySize effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental study
Size effect of plain concrete beams–an experimental study
 
pub-14-10
pub-14-10pub-14-10
pub-14-10
 
8 iiste photo 7
8 iiste photo 78 iiste photo 7
8 iiste photo 7
 
D.H. Gordon et al., Polymer, 35, (1994) 2554 - 2559.
D.H. Gordon et al., Polymer, 35, (1994) 2554 - 2559.D.H. Gordon et al., Polymer, 35, (1994) 2554 - 2559.
D.H. Gordon et al., Polymer, 35, (1994) 2554 - 2559.
 
Numerical modeling of the welding defect influence on fatigue life of the wel...
Numerical modeling of the welding defect influence on fatigue life of the wel...Numerical modeling of the welding defect influence on fatigue life of the wel...
Numerical modeling of the welding defect influence on fatigue life of the wel...
 
Mm207 group 9 numericals
Mm207 group 9 numericalsMm207 group 9 numericals
Mm207 group 9 numericals
 
Ch5 epfm
Ch5 epfmCh5 epfm
Ch5 epfm
 
Mathematical Relationships between the Compressive Strength and Some Other St...
Mathematical Relationships between the Compressive Strength and Some Other St...Mathematical Relationships between the Compressive Strength and Some Other St...
Mathematical Relationships between the Compressive Strength and Some Other St...
 
Predicting the Nonlinear Material Behaviour under Monotonic and Cyclic loadin...
Predicting the Nonlinear Material Behaviour under Monotonic and Cyclic loadin...Predicting the Nonlinear Material Behaviour under Monotonic and Cyclic loadin...
Predicting the Nonlinear Material Behaviour under Monotonic and Cyclic loadin...
 
Growth and Magnetic properties of MnGeP2 thin films
Growth and Magnetic properties of MnGeP2 thin filmsGrowth and Magnetic properties of MnGeP2 thin films
Growth and Magnetic properties of MnGeP2 thin films
 
An Experimental Investigation into the Grindability Aspects of Newly Develope...
An Experimental Investigation into the Grindability Aspects of Newly Develope...An Experimental Investigation into the Grindability Aspects of Newly Develope...
An Experimental Investigation into the Grindability Aspects of Newly Develope...
 
SLIDING WEAR OF AA6061/CARBON BLACK METAL MATRIX COMPOSITES
SLIDING WEAR OF AA6061/CARBON BLACK METAL MATRIX COMPOSITESSLIDING WEAR OF AA6061/CARBON BLACK METAL MATRIX COMPOSITES
SLIDING WEAR OF AA6061/CARBON BLACK METAL MATRIX COMPOSITES
 
Vibrational Analysis Of Cracked Rod Having Circumferential Crack
Vibrational Analysis Of Cracked Rod Having Circumferential Crack Vibrational Analysis Of Cracked Rod Having Circumferential Crack
Vibrational Analysis Of Cracked Rod Having Circumferential Crack
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development
International Journal of Engineering Research and DevelopmentInternational Journal of Engineering Research and Development
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development
 
CST
CSTCST
CST
 

Similaire à Grain size dependence of fracture toughness and crack growth resistance in superelastic NiTi

Effect of cold rolling on low cycle fatigue behavior
Effect of cold rolling on low cycle fatigue behavior Effect of cold rolling on low cycle fatigue behavior
Effect of cold rolling on low cycle fatigue behavior eSAT Journals
 
Structure, microstructure and dielectric study of (ba0.6 sr0.4)(zr0.6ti0.4)o3...
Structure, microstructure and dielectric study of (ba0.6 sr0.4)(zr0.6ti0.4)o3...Structure, microstructure and dielectric study of (ba0.6 sr0.4)(zr0.6ti0.4)o3...
Structure, microstructure and dielectric study of (ba0.6 sr0.4)(zr0.6ti0.4)o3...eSAT Publishing House
 
Effect of broaching on high temperature fatigue behavior
Effect of broaching on high temperature fatigue behaviorEffect of broaching on high temperature fatigue behavior
Effect of broaching on high temperature fatigue behaviorPhuong Dx
 
The Effect of Direct- and Cross-Rolling on Mechanical Properties and Microstr...
The Effect of Direct- and Cross-Rolling on Mechanical Properties and Microstr...The Effect of Direct- and Cross-Rolling on Mechanical Properties and Microstr...
The Effect of Direct- and Cross-Rolling on Mechanical Properties and Microstr...Kaveh Rahimi Mamaghani
 
Evaluation of fracture toughness of sintered silica nickel nanocomposites
Evaluation of fracture toughness of sintered silica nickel nanocompositesEvaluation of fracture toughness of sintered silica nickel nanocomposites
Evaluation of fracture toughness of sintered silica nickel nanocompositeseSAT Journals
 
Conference Paper
Conference PaperConference Paper
Conference PaperSoham Shah
 
Effect of sintering time on the particle size and dielectric properties of La...
Effect of sintering time on the particle size and dielectric properties of La...Effect of sintering time on the particle size and dielectric properties of La...
Effect of sintering time on the particle size and dielectric properties of La...ijceronline
 
ultra fine grained steels
ultra fine grained steelsultra fine grained steels
ultra fine grained steelsDierk Raabe
 
Monitoring of strain and seismic vibrations in structures
Monitoring of strain and seismic vibrations in structuresMonitoring of strain and seismic vibrations in structures
Monitoring of strain and seismic vibrations in structureskalyanabooshnam
 
The Effects of Copper Addition on the compression behavior of Al-Ca Alloy
The Effects of Copper Addition on the compression behavior of Al-Ca AlloyThe Effects of Copper Addition on the compression behavior of Al-Ca Alloy
The Effects of Copper Addition on the compression behavior of Al-Ca AlloyIOSR Journals
 
Abhijeet_UTokyo_Research Presentation
Abhijeet_UTokyo_Research PresentationAbhijeet_UTokyo_Research Presentation
Abhijeet_UTokyo_Research PresentationAbhijeet Soni
 
Vacuum furnace simuwu_improved_vacuum_heat-treatment_for_fine-blanking
Vacuum furnace simuwu_improved_vacuum_heat-treatment_for_fine-blankingVacuum furnace simuwu_improved_vacuum_heat-treatment_for_fine-blanking
Vacuum furnace simuwu_improved_vacuum_heat-treatment_for_fine-blankingEVP Vacuum pump
 
Effect of Thickness and Annealing Temperature on Optical Properties of CuIn1-...
Effect of Thickness and Annealing Temperature on Optical Properties of CuIn1-...Effect of Thickness and Annealing Temperature on Optical Properties of CuIn1-...
Effect of Thickness and Annealing Temperature on Optical Properties of CuIn1-...IJMREMJournal
 
A fracture mechanics based method for prediction of
A fracture mechanics based method for prediction ofA fracture mechanics based method for prediction of
A fracture mechanics based method for prediction ofSAJITH GEORGE
 
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of Al- Zn-Mg alloy
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of Al- Zn-Mg alloyA refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of Al- Zn-Mg alloy
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of Al- Zn-Mg alloyIJERA Editor
 
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of AlZn-Mg alloy
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of AlZn-Mg alloy A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of AlZn-Mg alloy
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of AlZn-Mg alloy IJERA Editor
 
Characterization of expanded austenite in stainless steels by ion carburizati...
Characterization of expanded austenite in stainless steels by ion carburizati...Characterization of expanded austenite in stainless steels by ion carburizati...
Characterization of expanded austenite in stainless steels by ion carburizati...Javier García Molleja
 
Effect of Notch Angle on the Fracture Toughness of Al7075 T6 Alloy- An Experi...
Effect of Notch Angle on the Fracture Toughness of Al7075 T6 Alloy- An Experi...Effect of Notch Angle on the Fracture Toughness of Al7075 T6 Alloy- An Experi...
Effect of Notch Angle on the Fracture Toughness of Al7075 T6 Alloy- An Experi...IOSR Journals
 

Similaire à Grain size dependence of fracture toughness and crack growth resistance in superelastic NiTi (20)

Effect of cold rolling on low cycle fatigue behavior
Effect of cold rolling on low cycle fatigue behavior Effect of cold rolling on low cycle fatigue behavior
Effect of cold rolling on low cycle fatigue behavior
 
Structure, microstructure and dielectric study of (ba0.6 sr0.4)(zr0.6ti0.4)o3...
Structure, microstructure and dielectric study of (ba0.6 sr0.4)(zr0.6ti0.4)o3...Structure, microstructure and dielectric study of (ba0.6 sr0.4)(zr0.6ti0.4)o3...
Structure, microstructure and dielectric study of (ba0.6 sr0.4)(zr0.6ti0.4)o3...
 
Effect of broaching on high temperature fatigue behavior
Effect of broaching on high temperature fatigue behaviorEffect of broaching on high temperature fatigue behavior
Effect of broaching on high temperature fatigue behavior
 
The Effect of Direct- and Cross-Rolling on Mechanical Properties and Microstr...
The Effect of Direct- and Cross-Rolling on Mechanical Properties and Microstr...The Effect of Direct- and Cross-Rolling on Mechanical Properties and Microstr...
The Effect of Direct- and Cross-Rolling on Mechanical Properties and Microstr...
 
Evaluation of fracture toughness of sintered silica nickel nanocomposites
Evaluation of fracture toughness of sintered silica nickel nanocompositesEvaluation of fracture toughness of sintered silica nickel nanocomposites
Evaluation of fracture toughness of sintered silica nickel nanocomposites
 
CGS-LSA IWJT2009 TI UTEK
CGS-LSA IWJT2009 TI UTEKCGS-LSA IWJT2009 TI UTEK
CGS-LSA IWJT2009 TI UTEK
 
Conference Paper
Conference PaperConference Paper
Conference Paper
 
Effect of sintering time on the particle size and dielectric properties of La...
Effect of sintering time on the particle size and dielectric properties of La...Effect of sintering time on the particle size and dielectric properties of La...
Effect of sintering time on the particle size and dielectric properties of La...
 
ultra fine grained steels
ultra fine grained steelsultra fine grained steels
ultra fine grained steels
 
Monitoring of strain and seismic vibrations in structures
Monitoring of strain and seismic vibrations in structuresMonitoring of strain and seismic vibrations in structures
Monitoring of strain and seismic vibrations in structures
 
The Effects of Copper Addition on the compression behavior of Al-Ca Alloy
The Effects of Copper Addition on the compression behavior of Al-Ca AlloyThe Effects of Copper Addition on the compression behavior of Al-Ca Alloy
The Effects of Copper Addition on the compression behavior of Al-Ca Alloy
 
Abhijeet_UTokyo_Research Presentation
Abhijeet_UTokyo_Research PresentationAbhijeet_UTokyo_Research Presentation
Abhijeet_UTokyo_Research Presentation
 
Vacuum furnace simuwu_improved_vacuum_heat-treatment_for_fine-blanking
Vacuum furnace simuwu_improved_vacuum_heat-treatment_for_fine-blankingVacuum furnace simuwu_improved_vacuum_heat-treatment_for_fine-blanking
Vacuum furnace simuwu_improved_vacuum_heat-treatment_for_fine-blanking
 
Effect of Thickness and Annealing Temperature on Optical Properties of CuIn1-...
Effect of Thickness and Annealing Temperature on Optical Properties of CuIn1-...Effect of Thickness and Annealing Temperature on Optical Properties of CuIn1-...
Effect of Thickness and Annealing Temperature on Optical Properties of CuIn1-...
 
A fracture mechanics based method for prediction of
A fracture mechanics based method for prediction ofA fracture mechanics based method for prediction of
A fracture mechanics based method for prediction of
 
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of Al- Zn-Mg alloy
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of Al- Zn-Mg alloyA refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of Al- Zn-Mg alloy
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of Al- Zn-Mg alloy
 
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of AlZn-Mg alloy
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of AlZn-Mg alloy A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of AlZn-Mg alloy
A refined energy-based model for friction stir processing of AlZn-Mg alloy
 
Characterization of expanded austenite in stainless steels by ion carburizati...
Characterization of expanded austenite in stainless steels by ion carburizati...Characterization of expanded austenite in stainless steels by ion carburizati...
Characterization of expanded austenite in stainless steels by ion carburizati...
 
A012130105
A012130105A012130105
A012130105
 
Effect of Notch Angle on the Fracture Toughness of Al7075 T6 Alloy- An Experi...
Effect of Notch Angle on the Fracture Toughness of Al7075 T6 Alloy- An Experi...Effect of Notch Angle on the Fracture Toughness of Al7075 T6 Alloy- An Experi...
Effect of Notch Angle on the Fracture Toughness of Al7075 T6 Alloy- An Experi...
 

Grain size dependence of fracture toughness and crack growth resistance in superelastic NiTi

  • 1. Grain size dependence of fracture toughness and crack-growth resistance of superelastic NiTi Aslan Ahadi a,b , Qingping Sun a, ⁎ a Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Hong Kong b School of Civil Engineering, State Key Lab of Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering, Wuhan University, China a b s t r a c ta r t i c l e i n f o Article history: Received 12 August 2015 Received in revised form 10 October 2015 Accepted 22 October 2015 Available online xxxx Keywords: Shape memory alloys Martensitic phase transformation Microstructure Toughness Intrinsic and extrinsic toughening mechanisms The grain size (GS) dependence of fracture toughness (KIC) and static crack-growth resistance (KR) of superelastic NiTi with average GS from 10 to 1500 nm are investigated. The measurements of strain and temperature fields at the crack-tip region are synchronized with the force–displacement curves under mode-I crack opening tests. It is found that with GS reduction down to nanoscale, the KIC and the size of crack-tip phase transformation zone monotonically decrease and the KR changes from a rising to a flat R-curve. The roles of intrinsic and extrinsic toughening mechanisms in the GS dependence of the fracture process are discussed. © 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Due to a reversible martensitic phase transformation (PT), superelastic (SE) NiTi shape memory alloys (SMAs) are widely used in a variety of applications. However, the narrow temperature window of superelasticity [1], poor cyclic stability [2], and poor fatigue life [3], significantly limit the applications of SE NiTi. In recent years, significant steps have been taken to break the above limitations. Introducing de- fects via doping [4,5], addition of Nb nanowires to NiTi [6], and GS re- duction down to nanocrystalline (nc) regime [7–10] are unique ways to achieve novel properties. It has been shown that with GS reduction to nc regime, SE NiTi indeed exhibits novel properties such as linear superelasticity with vanishing hysteresis [11], broadening of the tem- perature window of superelasticity down to −60 °C [7], and improved thermomechanical cyclic stability [8]. The fracture toughness (KIC) and crack-growth resistance (KR) are essential properties for successful application of metals and alloys [12]. It is well-known that with GS reduction to nc regime, metals exhib- it lower KIC due to limited ductility [13]. Owing to a stress-induced mar- tensitic PT, the most distinctive feature in the fracture process of SMAs is the formation of a kidney-like crack tip PT zone which can transform back at the crack wake [14]. In this regard, several experimental, analyt- ical, and numerical researches have been published [12,15–20]. Howev- er, the GS effects on the fracture behavior and intrinsic/extrinsic toughening mechanisms of SE NiTi remain to be unveiled by systematic experiments. In this paper, we have studied the KIC and KR behaviors of SE NiTi with average GS from 10 to 1500 nm. The strain and tempera- ture fields at the crack-tip region and the crack wake are synchronized with the force–displacement curves by in-situ digital image correlation (DIC) and in-situ infrared (IR) thermography under the mode-I crack opening tests. SE NiTi (Ti-50.9 at.% Ni) sheets with thickness of 1.7 mm were sandwiched in stainless steel sheets and were cold-rolled to 42% of thickness reduction. The as-rolled sheets were heat-treated at tempera- tures of 250 °C for 45 min, 520 °C for 2 min, 520 °C for 3 min, 520 °C for 6 min, and 600 °C for 45 min followed by quenching in water [7,8,11]. The average GS of the cold-rolled and heat-treated specimens was mea- sured with TEM (see Fig. S1) and Williamson–Hall method. Dog-bone tensile specimens with thickness of 1 mm, width of 2 mm, and gauge length of 30 mm were cut along the rolling direction and tested to ob- tain stress–strain curves (see Fig. S2b) at a strain rate of 1 × 10−4 s−1 using an MTS (UTM-RT/10) machine. Transformation temperatures were determined using differential scanning calorimeter (DSC-TA Q1000) with heating/cooling rate of 10 K/min. Notched compact tension (CT) specimens with the dimension shown in Fig. S3a were EDM cut from the cold-rolled and heat-treated sheets. The highly polished CT specimens were pre-cracked (see Fig. S3b) with a MTS-858 table top machine at a frequency of 5 Hz with sinusoidal wave function under decreasing load amplitudes (ΔPn b … b ΔP1) as suggested by ASTM E 561-10 (ΔP = Pmax − Pmin). The load ratio of R = Pmin/Pmax = 0.1 was used (see inset in Fig. S3c). Different lengths of pre-cracks with 7.6 b a b 10.29 mm (0.4470 b a/W b 0.6053 mm) were obtained. The crack length was monitored ex-situ using a Leica mi- croscope. The strain and temperature fields at the vicinity of the crack tip Scripta Materialia 113 (2016) 171–175 ⁎ Corresponding author. E-mail address: meqpsun@ust.hk (Q. Sun). http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2015.10.036 1359-6462/© 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Scripta Materialia journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/scriptamat
  • 2. were synchronized using in-situ DIC and IR thermography. The experi- mental setup for mode-I crack opening tests is shown in Fig. S3c. To cre- ate a fine and random pattern needed for strain field measurements using DIC, silicon micro-particles (with average size of 1 μm) were speckled to the specimen surface (Fig. S4). Ncorr open source 2D DIC was used for DIC calculations [21]. A fast multi-detector IR thermal cam- era (FLIR SC7700BB) equipped with a close-up lens with working dis- tance of 30 cm and field of view of 9.6 × 7.2 mm2 was used to record the temperature field at the crack-tip region. To achieve a uniform black body, one side of the specimens' surface was covered with candle fume. The mode-I crack opening tests were performed at the loading rate of 5 mm/min in order to capture the temperature variations at the crack-tip region. The fractography studies were performed in a JEOL- JSM 6390 SEM. The transformation temperatures measured from DSC (see Fig. S2a) are summarized in Table 1. It is seen that all the transformation temper- atures Af (austenite finish temperature), Ms (martensite start tempera- ture), and Mf (martensite finish temperature) decrease with GS reduction. The effects of GS on the isothermal stress–strain tensile prop- erties are shown in supplementary materials (Fig. S2b). It is seen that all the specimens are SE as they can recover large strains of 5%. With GS re- duction to nc regime (GS b 60 nm) the stress–strain response changes from a plateau-type superelasticity to hardening SE response with much reduced hysteresis loop area [9]. The critical transformation stress (σtr), determined from the cross-cutting of the tangent lines in the elas- tic and PT regions (see Fig. S2b), increases from 381 MPa for GS = 1500 nm to 655 MPa for GS = 10 nm. The gradual increase of σtr with GS reduction is due to the fact that the reduction of GS makes the PT more difficult [11,22]. The plastic yield's stress of martensite (σY M ), de- termined from the cross-cutting of the tangent lines in the martensite elastic deformation and plastic deformation regions, also increases with GS reduction since dislocation activities are significantly sup- pressed at nano-scale. Moreover, the strain to failure (εf) decreases with GS reduction to nc indicating a gradual reduction in the ductility. Fig. 1a shows the force–displacement curves of the CT specimens with different average GS (a/W = 0.4501). It is seen that for all the spec- imens, after an initial linear deformation (up to ~415 N), the force– displacement curve deviates from linearity due to stress-induced martensitic PT at the crack-tip region [23]. With further increase of the displacement the force first reaches a maximum Pmax and then decreases either gradually (for GS = 1500, 80, 18, and 10 nm) due to relative stable crack growth or rapidly (for GS = 64 and 42 nm) due to fast (burst-like) crack growth. It is evident that the amount of deviation from linearity and the value of Pmax decrease with GS reduction. This GS dependencies of the fracture behavior forms a stark contrast with the uniform tensile stress–strain curves where specimens with smaller GS can sustain larger loads. According to the linear elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM), the critical stress intensity factor (KIC) for mode-I loading can be calculated as: KIC ¼ P max B ffiffiffiffiffiffi W p Á 2 þ a=Wð Þ 1−a=Wð Þ3=2 Á f a=Wð Þ ð1Þ where Pmax is the applied maximum force, B is the specimen thick- ness, W is the specimen width measured from the load line, a is the physical crack length (see Fig. S3a), and f(a/W) can be expressed as (see ASTM E 561-08): f a=Wð Þ ¼ 0:886 þ 4:64 a=Wð Þ−13:32 a=Wð Þ2 þ 14:72 a=Wð Þ3 −5:6 a=Wð Þ4 h i : ð2Þ When using Eq. (1) one has to note that this equation is only valid for plane strain condition where the size of the PT zone is much smaller than the specimen thickness. Looking at the size of PT zone in Fig. 2, it is seen that this condition is barely met in our experiments. Therefore, the values of KIC and KR reported here are nominal and only serve as first approximations and are used for comparative purpose. More exact calculations such as using finite element method is needed to de- termine the K values. For each GS, the measured KIC averaged over eight different values of a/W are shown in Fig. 1b. For the GS = 1500 and 80 nm, the KIC values are 46.3 MPa ffiffiffiffiffi m p and 42.4 MPa ffiffiffiffiffi m p , respectively. These values are consistent with the reported values for SE NiTi of the similar microstructure and stress–strain curves [16,23]. It is seen that when GS is reduced below 80 nm, the value of KIC monotonically de- creases and reaches 25.4 MPa ffiffiffiffiffi m p for GS = 10 nm. Fig. 1c shows the GS dependence of crack-growth resistance KR (R-curve) as a function of crack extension (a − a0). For GS = 1500 and 80 nm, the KR keeps in- creasing (known as rising R-curve) with crack extension and eventually saturates. However, for GS = 18 and 10 nm, the R-curves become flat. In other words, more energy is dissipated during crack propagation for SE NiTi with GS = 1500 and 80 nm while for the GS = 18 and 10 nm the fracture behavior resembles those of brittle materials. SEM images of the fracture surfaces of the CT specimens are shown in Fig. 1d. The fracture surface of the specimen with GS = 1500 nm mainly shows dimples indicating a dominant ductile fracture. For GS = 80 nm the fracture surface is characterized by a mixture of dimples and cleavage planes. With further GS reduction, the tendency of the cleavage increases in the fracture process as it is shown for GS = 42 and 10 nm. Therefore, based on the consistent observations of (1) stress–strain behavior (2) crack-tip inelastic zone size (3) KR curves and (4) the SEM observa- tions, it is suggested that the failure mode transitions from ductile to brit- tle fracture when GS is reduced down to nanoscale. The effects of GS on the strain (εyy) distribution around the crack-tip re- gion taken at Pmax are shown in Fig. 2. It is seen that the strain field at the crack-tip vicinity is in the shape of two lobes. For the GS = 1500 and 80 nm the lobes are inclined to an angle of about 48 and 51° from the crack line, respectively. The angle of inclination gradually increases to 63° for GS = 10 nm. Moreover, the DIC images indicate that with GS reduction the size of the lobe at Pmax immediately prior to the crack growth decreases. From the plot of εyy as a function of the distance from the crack tip, as shown in Fig. 2, one can determine the size of the PT zone along the x-axis rA → M by referring to the stress–strain curves [16,32]. For GS = 1500 nm the 0.25 ≤ rA → M ≤ 1.7 mm at the crack tip region and with GS re- duction the rA → M monotonically decreases to 0.23 ≤ rA → M ≤ 0.81 mm for GS = 80 nm and 0.19 ≤ rA → M ≤ 0.48 mm for GS = 64 nm. The measured Table 1 The GS dependence of phase transformation properties of SE NiTi. Heat treatment Average GS (nm) As/Af (°C) Ms/Mf (°C) σtr (MPa) σY M (MPa) EAust (GPa) H5% (MPa) Cold-rolled 10 N/A N/A 655 N/A 50.5 1.05 250 °C — 45 min 18 N/A N/A 502 1465 45.8 3.4 520 °C — 2 min 42 −12.7/8 −60/−86 472 1452 49.8 6.9 520 °C — 3 min 64 −12.5/6 −55/−78 461 1457 46.3 9.51 520 °C — 6 min 80 −4.8/10 −50/−70 425 1411 47.4 11.25 600 °C — 45 min 1500 −4.6/3 −30/−33 381 527 45 13.11 172 A. Ahadi, Q. Sun / Scripta Materialia 113 (2016) 171–175
  • 3. values of rA → M are consistent with the published data on nano-grained SE NiTi [16]. The GS dependence of rA → M and stress distribution can be read- ily explained by the theoretical models of stress-induced PT at the crack tip region [18,24]. When the size of PT zone is small compared with the size of the specimen (small scale PT), the size and the shape of PT zone for each GS can be approximated as [25]: rA→M θð Þ ¼ 1 2π Kapp σtr 2 cos2 θ 2 1 þ 3 sin2 θ 2 ð3Þ where σtr is the critical transformation stress and depends on the GS and Kapp is the applied stress intensity factor at the crack tip. For a stationary crack = KIC. According to this equation, rA → M scales with (Kapp/σtr)2 . Therefore, for a given Kapp a gradual reduction of rA → M with GS reduction is expected since σtr increases significantly with GS reduction. Another ef- fect of GS reduction is that for a given Kapp the stress levels in the PT zone and plasticity zone are higher due to higher σtr and σY M as schematically shown in Fig. S5. A direct consequence of such higher stress levels at the crack tip region is that the fracture behaves more like brittle materials and has features of brittle fracture such as a flat R-curve. The synchronized IR thermographic images of the front surface of the specimens at Pmax (loading rate of 5 mm/min) are shown in Fig. 3a. It is seen that the crack-tip region is warmer than the rest of the specimen due to release of PT latent heat and heat transfer via conduction and con- vection [2,26,27]. The figure shows two important features. First, with GS reduction the size of the hot zone decreases which is consistent with the DIC measurements of rA → M (Fig. 2a). Second, under the given loading rate of 5 mm/min, the magnitude of the temperature increase in the PT zone decreases with GS. For example, the magnitude of the temper- ature rise at the crack tip is 5.83 °C for GS = 1500 nm and it monoton- ically decreases to 1.02 °C for GS = 18 nm, and 0.03 °C for a GS = 10 nm. This is due to the reduction of latent heat with GS especially for GS = 18 nm (see Fig. S2b) [7–9]. Fig. 3b shows the thermographic images during crack propagation. Comparing Fig. 3b with 3a, one can note a re- markable increase in the size of the crack-tip hot zone for GS = 1500 and 80 nm. This is consistent with the rising R-curve characteristic of the two specimens. Furthermore, it is clearly seen that once the crack propagates it leaves two cold regions behind with temperatures lower than the room temperature (black arrows). For the GS = 1500 nm the minimum temperature in the crack wake is 15.5 °C which is 4.5 °C below the room temperature. This cooling effect is due to a rapid absorption of latent heat and provides a compelling evidence to the re- verse PT when the crack passed by [26]. For the same reasons, the cooling in the wake becomes also weaker with GS reduction. To elucidate the effects of GS on the controlling mechanisms of KIC and KR, a qualitative discussion of the intrinsic and extrinsic toughening mechanisms at the crack-tip region and crack wake [28] are given in Fig. 4a and b, respectively. For the intrinsic mechanisms, it is well- known that the most dominant toughening mechanism in SE NiTi is the formation of stress-induced martensite at the crack-tip region which act as a shielding mechanism. According to Baxevanis et al. [12, 15], the degree of the toughening due to the crack-tip PT depends main- ly on the dimensionless parameter α = σtr εtr/[σtr 2 /EA] (ratio of dissipat- ed to stored energy) where σtr is the transformation stress, εtr is the transformation strain, and EA is the Young's modulus of austenite. The higher value of α is beneficial for toughness enhancement [25]. As such, the gradual decrease of α (due to a gradual increase of σtr) is in- deed the main reason for a gradual reduction of KIC [29]. Another factor that needs to be considered is the GS dependence of the plastic yield's stress of the martensite (σY M ). As can be seen in Table 1, the σY M increases with GS reduction to nc. In the same way as that of the elastic–plastic Fig. 1. (a) GS effects on the force–displacement curves during mode-I monotonic crack opening fracture tests, (b) GS effects on the K = KIC (K at Pmax) for specimens of different initial crack lengths (with 0.4470 b a/W b 0.6053 mm), (c) GS effects on the crack-growth resistance (KR), and (d) top-view SEM images of the fracture surface of CT specimens. Fig. 2. GS effects on the variation of εyy with the distance (x) from the crack tip (in the x direction). The inset shows the DIC images taken at Pmax with a field of view of 6.34 × 4.75 mm2 . A reduction of PT zone size with GS reduction is observed. 173A. Ahadi, Q. Sun / Scripta Materialia 113 (2016) 171–175
  • 4. materials, a higher yield's stress indicates a smaller size of the plastic de- formation zone and higher stress levels (see Fig. S5) at the crack tip leading to less shielding effect and toughness enhancement. However, it is important to note that the effect of plastic deformation zone at the crack tip on the shielding and dissipation is believed to be small compared with the dissipation due to PT [12]. In addition, with GS re- duction, the tortuous crack-path configuration (see Fig. 4a1) becomes straight (see Fig. 4a2). This causes a change in the mode of K from mix of mode-I and mode-II in the former, to near mode-I in the latter. This leads to a decrease of the threshold (critical) driving force for crack propagation that in turn leads to reduction of KIC [30]. The effects of GS on the extrinsic mechanisms are schematically shown in Fig. 4b1 (for GS ≥ 80 nm) and Fig. 4b2 (for nc NiTi). As it is seen in Fig. 4b, during crack propagation the crack wake undergoes a complete cycle of forward and reverse PT (see also Fig. 3b for the ther- mographic evidence of the reverse PT at the crack wake). The toughness enhancement ΔK = Ka − KIC for steady-state crack propagation due to such forward/reverse PT or energy dissipation can be described by the following equation [31]: K2 a ¼ K2 IC þ 2E 1−υ2ð Þ Z H 0 Ud yð Þdy ð4Þ where E is the elastic modulus, υ is the Poisson's ratio, H is the height of the crack wake, and Ud ( = ∮ σ dε) is the specific mechanical energy dis- sipated in the wake and is represented by the σ − ε hysteresis loop area. From Eq. (4) it is clearly seen that the gradual change of KR with GS reduction (from a rising R-curve to a flat R-curve) is not only caused by a reduction of H due to the increase of σtr, but also caused by a grad- ual reduction of the stress hysteresis (Ud → 0) of the material [7]. In summary, the grain size (GS) dependence of fracture toughness (KIC) and static crack-growth resistance (KR) of SE NiTi were investigated by synchronized measurements of the force–displacement curves and the crack-tip strain and temperature fields. It is shown that with GS reduction to nanoscale, the KIC gradually decreases and KR tran- sitions from rising to flat R-curve. The in-situ measurements showed a monotonic reduction in the size of the phase transformation zone at the crack-tip region. Using the controlling parameters of the fracture process of NiTi SMAs and their grain size dependencies, the intrinsic and extrinsic toughening mechanisms of the fracture behavior of the NiTi were analyzed and discussed. The results provide a better under- standing of the fracture behavior of nanocrystalline superelastic NiTi which possesses exceptional thermomechanical properties. The authors are grateful for the financial support of this work from the Hong Kong Research Grant Council (RGC) through the GRF grant (project no. 16214215) and the 973 Program of China (project no. 2014 CB046902). We also thank Maziar Jamishidi for DIC data analysis and Hamed Mokhtari for helping with thermographic experiments. Appendix A. Supplementary data Supplementary data to this article can be found online at http://dx. doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2015.10.036. Fig. 3. (a) IR thermographic images showing the GS effects on the temperature field near the crack-tip region at K = KIC, (b) GS effects on the temperature field in the crack-growth regime (a = a0 + Δa) showing heating/cooling due to forward/reverse PT in the crack-tip/wake. Fig. 4. Schematics of the GS effects on (a) the intrinsic toughening mechanisms and (b) the extrinsic toughening mechanisms. 174 A. Ahadi, Q. Sun / Scripta Materialia 113 (2016) 171–175
  • 5. References [1] T. Omori, K. Ando, M. Okano, X. Xu, Y. Tanaka, I. Ohnuma, R. Kainuma, K. Ishida, Sci- ence 333 (2011) 68 (80-.). [2] H. Yin, Y. He, Q. Sun, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 67 (2014) 100. [3] A.L. McKelvey, R.O. Ritchie, Metall. Mater. Trans. A 32 (2001) 731. [4] D. Wang, Z. Zhang, J. Zhang, Y. Zhou, Y. Wang, X. Ding, Y. Wang, X. Ren, Acta Mater. 58 (2010) 6206. [5] Y. Nii, T. Arima, H.Y. Kim, S. Miyazaki, Phys. Rev. B 82 (2010) 214104. [6] S. Hao, L. Cui, F. Guo, Y. Liu, X. Shi, D. Jiang, D.E. Brown, Y. Ren, Sci. Rep. 5 (2015) 8892. [7] A. Ahadi, Q.P. Sun, Appl. Phys. Lett. 103 (2013) 021902. [8] A. Ahadi, Q.P. Sun, Acta Mater. 76 (2014) 186. [9] A. Ahadi, Q.P. Sun, Acta Mater. 90 (2015) 272. [10] K. Tsuchiya, M. Inuzuka, D. Tomus, A. Hosokawa, H. Nakayama, K. Morii, Y. Todaka, M. Umemoto, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 438-440 (2006) 643. [11] Q.P. Sun, A. Ahadi, M. Li, M. Chen, Sci. China Technol. Sci. 57 (2014) 671. [12] T. Baxevanis, C.M. Landis, D.C. Lagoudas, J. Appl. Mech. 81 (2013) 041005. [13] M. Dao, L. Lu, R. Asaro, J. Dehosson, E. Ma, Acta Mater. 55 (2007) 4041. [14] A. Boulbitch, A.L. Korzhenevskii, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107 (2011) 085505. [15] T. Baxevanis, A.F. Parrinello, D.C. Lagoudas, Int. J. Plast. 50 (2013) 158. [16] S. Daly, A. Miller, G. Ravichandran, K. Bhattacharya, Acta Mater. 55 (2007) 6322. [17] M.R. Daymond, M.L. Young, J.D. Almer, D.C. Dunand, Acta Mater. 55 (2007) 3929. [18] C. Maletta, F. Furgiuele, Acta Mater. 58 (2010) 92. [19] M.L. Young, S. Gollerthan, A. Baruj, J. Frenzel, W.W. Schmahl, G. Eggeler, Acta Mater. 61 (2013) 5800. [20] T. Baxevanis, D.C. Lagoudas, Int. J. Fract. 191 (2008) 191. [21] J. Blaber, B.S. Adair, A. Antoniou, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 86 (2015) 035111. [22] J.R. Wollants, P. De Bonte, M. Roos, Z. Met. 82 (1979) 113. [23] S. Gollerthan, M.L. Young, A. Baruj, J. Frenzel, W.W. Schmahl, G. Eggeler, Acta Mater. 57 (2009) 1015. [24] C. Maletta, F. Furgiuele, Int. J. Solids Struct. 48 (2011) 1658. [25] Y. Freed, L. Bankssills, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 55 (2007) 2157. [26] S. Gollerthan, M.L. Young, K. Neuking, U. Ramamurty, G. Eggeler, Acta Mater. 57 (2009) 5892. [27] H. Yin, Y. Yan, Y. Huo, Q.P. Sun, Mater. Lett. 109 (2013) 287. [28] R.O. Ritchie, Nat. Mater. 10 (2011) 817. [29] Q.S. Mei, L. Zhang, K. Tsuchiya, H. Gao, T. Ohmura, K. Tsuzaki, Scr. Mater. 63 (2010) 977. [30] B. Lawn, Fracture of Brittle Solids, 2nd ed. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1975. [31] Q.P. Sun, X.J. Xu, Mater. Sci. 30 (1995) 439. [32] W. LePage, S. Daly, The influence of crystallographic texture on fracture of the shape-memory alloys, in: A. Bajaj, P. Zavattieri, M. Koslowski, T. Siegmund (Eds.), Pro- ceedings of the Society of Engineering Science 51st Annual Technical Meeting, October 1-3, 2014, Purdue University Libraries Scholarly Publishing Services, West Lafayette, 2014. 175A. Ahadi, Q. Sun / Scripta Materialia 113 (2016) 171–175