Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Loading in …3
×
1 of 48

More Related Content

You Might Also Like

Related Books

Free with a 30 day trial from Scribd

See all

Related Audiobooks

Free with a 30 day trial from Scribd

See all

Preliminary DBA Thesis - Basic Social Math

  1. 1. !"##$ "#! 0/('.$>+.'/,$9/)"$ $ !"#$%&'()#*+,+-'./,$0/('($1+2$3#(+,4'5-$)"#$ 3'-+263#,#4/5.#$7#8/)#$'5$9/5/-#*#5):$ $ ;2#,'*'5/2<$!"#('($1+2$70=$>)/-#$?$=((#((*#5)$ $ @$AB?A$8<$C/2#D$E##$F/5(+5$ $ ;2#(#5)#D$+5$AA:$??:$AB?A$ $ =)$G2#5+8,#$%.+,#$D#$9/5/-#*#5)$ ! ! >H&#24'(+2I$;/)2'.J$KL>H,,'4/5M$$ N')"$/DD')'+5/,$(H&#24'('+5$8<$C#/56;"','&&#$3#55/2D$O$9/2J$%(&+(')+$
  2. 2. %"&#'$()$*(+,'+,-$ ! "#$%&'()$"&# ******************************************************************************************************************************* +! ,"$-%.$(%-!%-/"-0 ******************************************************************************************************************** 1! &#$&,&2").,!#-2.$"&#3!45$6&,&257"'-&,&25****************************************************** 88! &#$&,&2").,!-4-%2-#)-3!%-,.$"/"94 ************************************************************************** 8:! &#$&,&2").,!;,(%.,"943!%-.,"94*********************************************************************************** 8<! &#$&,&2").,!(#"$53!$%.#9;.%-#$!9)"-#)-**************************************************************** :8! 9$.$-!&=!$6-!.%$!"#!4.#.2-4-#$!%-9-.%)6 ************************************************************ :+! >%"'2"#2!$6-!;6",&9&;6").,!'"/"'- ***************************************************************************** +8! %-9-.%)6!;%&;&9"$"&#********************************************************************************************************** +?! %-9-.%)6!4-$6&'&,&25 ****************************************************************************************************** @+! >">,"&2%.;65 ***************************************************************************************************************************** @@! ! $!
  3. 3. &'()*!+,*)'-!.'/01!! !"#$%&'()#*+,+-'./,$0/('($1+2$3#(+,4'5-$)"#$3'-+263#,#4/5.#$7#8/)#$'5$ 9/5/-#*#5):$ ! &2!3'456!755!8'9(,9! :$!;,<5=>54!$":$! ! ! ! .+,/(012,3(+$ ! ?,!@5A!/05!*B(/,6)'9(!,C!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0A!*'45!/0'/!>5-)5<)9D!/05!E'4/0!)(! C-'/!)(!(/)--!('9*/),956!)9!,B4!6)(*)F-)95!'(!<'-)6!(*)59*5G!! +,B96(!,B/4'D5,B(A!>B/!*B4459/!=5/0,6,-,D)5(!F4,<)65!9,!>'()(!C,4!(*)59/)C)*'--2! 45CB/)9D!(B*0!'!>5-)5C!@)/0!'92!5=F)4)*'-!5<)659*5H!! I**,46)9D!/,!J0)--)F(!'96!K(@)*LA!M$":$N!/05!(/'/5!,C!/05!'4/!)9!='9'D5=59/!)(! /0'/A!O@5!6,!9,/!59*,B9/54!'!F45P,4D'9)Q56!45'-)/2!/,!@0)*0!@5!'//'*0!-'>5-(A!>B/! 4'/054!'*/)<5-2!*,9(/4B*/!45'-)/2!/04,BD0!=5'9)9DCB-!)9/54'*/),9HR!MFSN! T0)(!=5'9(!)9!45(5'4*0!F4'*/)*5A!/0'/!)/U(!(*)59/)C)*'--2!<'-)6!C,4!,95!D4,BF!,C! F5,F-5!/,!)9/54'*/!@)/0!/05!F-'95/!'96!'*/)<5-2!*,9(/4B*/!'!45'-)/2!)9!@0)*0!/05! E'4/0!)(!C-'/H!! V/U(!5WB'--2!<'-)6!C,4!'9,/054!D4,BF!/,!)9/54'*/!@)/0!/05!('=5!F-'95/!C4,=!'! 6)CC5459/!F54(F5*/)<5!'96!'*/)<5-2!*,9(/4B*/!'!45'-)/2!)9!@0)*0!/05!E'4/0!)(!4,B96H!!! &,/0!45'-)/)5(!0'<5!/,!>5!*,9()65456!<'-)6!C4,=!/05!F54(F5*/)<5(!,C!/05!6)CC5459/! D4,BF(!@0,!*,9(/4B*/56!/05=H!859*5!(,=5!0'<5!*,9*-B656!/0'/!/0545!)(!9,! '>(,-B/5!/4B/0!F,(()>-5!)9!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0!M8,4L05)=54A!:XYZ!F$$:[! ?5<)9952!!+)5D5-A!$":$!F#PX[!])--)'=(A!$""%N!! T0)(!)(!=')9/')956!'(!'!(*)59/)C)*!F,(()>)-)/2A!>5*'B(5!/05!WB'-)/'/)<5!'96! WB'9/)/'/)<5!=5/0,6(!,C!'**456)/56!>B()95((!(*0,,-(!'96!/,F!='9'D5=59/! ^,B49'-(!45(/!,9!6)<)656!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!C,B96'/),9(!/0'/A!'(!J0)--)F(!!K(@)*L! M$":$N!'4DB5A!9,@!C'<,4!(,*)'--2!*,9(/4B*/56!45'-)/)5(H!O.,45!)=F,4/'9/-2A!/0)(! 95@!5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-!F,()/),9!B9654F)9(!'!9B=>54!,C!/05!=,(/!)=F,4/'9/!'96! '*/)<5!'45'(!,C!45(5'4*0!)9!,4D'9)Q'/),9!'96!='9'D5=59/!/05,42R!MF_NH! T0)(!)(A!,C!*,B4(5A!'!64'='/)*!*0'9D5!C4,=!/05!F,()/)<)(=!/0'/!6,=)9'/56! /05!C)5-6!F4),4!/,!/05!:X#"(H!I!-,,L!>'*L!'/!/05!-)/54'/B45!(0,@(!'9!)9/59(5! (/4BDD-5!'(!/05!05D5=,92!,C!F,()/)<)(=!'96!/05!WB'9/)/'/)<5!=5/0,6(!/0'/! %!
  4. 4. )/!*0'=F),956!@545!*0'--59D56!)9!/05!:XY"(!'96!:X#"(H!&2!/05!-'/5!:X#"(A! /0)(!(/4BDD-5!@'(!=,45!,4!-5((!,<54!'96!/05!/@,!,FF,()9D!5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-! F54(F5*/)<5(!)9!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0!0'6!45'*056!'9!B95'(2!>B/! @,4L'>-5!F5'*5H!MJ0)--)F(!!K(@)*LA!$":$A!F_N! `9C,4/B9'/5-2A!/0)(!O@,4L'>-5!F5'*5R!6,5(!9,/!5a/596!>52,96!/05!45'-)/2!,C! ='9'D5=59/!'*'65=)'H!T05!6)<)656!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!C,B96'/),9!@)/0)9!/05! 6)(*)F-)95!0'(!(F'4L56!*,9C-)*/!@)/0!F4'*/)*)9D!='9'D54(!,B/()65!,C!'*'65=)'A! @0,!0'<5!'*/)<5-2!*,9(/4B*/56!'!6)CC5459/!45'-)/2!,C!/05)4!,@9H!! I!6)45*/!*,9(5WB59*5!,C!/0)(!6)<)656!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!(/'9*5!)(!/0'/!>,/0!/05!45'-)/2! ,C!'*'65=)*(!'96!/05!45'-)/2!,C!F4'*/)/),954(!()=B-/'95,B(-2!5a)(/!)9!='9'D5=59/! 45(5'4*0!M.'aP;55CA!$""SNA!=5'9)9D!/05!E'4/0!*'9!>5!>,/0!C-'/!'96!4,B96A!'96!9,! 45*,9*)-)'/),9!,C!/05!/@,!F54(F5*/)<5(!*'9!>5!45'*056!@)/0)9!/05!*B4459/! )9*,==59(B4'>-5!F'4'6)D=(!,C!45(5'4*0!MbB09!:XZ$c:XY"[!])--)'=(!$""%[! ?5<)9952!!+)5D5-!$":$NH!! T0)(!0'(!F4,=F/56!='92!/,!'4DB5!/0'/!='9'D5=59/!)(!6)CC5459/!C4,=!F02()*'-! (*)59*5!M8,4L05)=54!:XYZ!F$:%[!])--)'=(!$""%NA!@0)*0!0'(!'--,@56!'*'65=)*(! /,!*,9/)9B5!@,4L)9D!@)/0)9!/05!O*-,(56!-,,FR!,C!/05)4!,@9!45'-)/2!M8'=>4)*LA! :XX_!WB,/56!)9!<'9!IL59!$"":c$""_[!d54=5B-59!$""S[!eB-'/)!$""Y[!J5'4*5!! 8B'9D!$":$NA!>B/!-5'<5(!/05!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!6)<)65!)9/'*/H! I(!'!45(B-/A!@059!/5(/)9D!02F,/05(5(!'>,B/!0,@!<'4)'>-5(!)9!'!OC-'/!E'4/0RP45'-)/2! =)D0/!>5!*,445-'/56A!/05!>5(/!/0'/!(B4<52!'96!)9/54<)5@!=5/0,6(!*'9!F4,6B*5!)(!'! D5954'-)Q56A!(B>^5*/)<5!F)*/B45!,C!@0'/!F'4/)*)F'9/(A!@0,!>5-)5<5!/052!'45! ,F54'/)9D!,9!'!C-'/!F-'95/A!(55H!! V9!C'*/A!KU&4)59A!5/!'-A!5=F0'()Q5!/0'/!O9,!,>(54<'/),9'-!(/B62!*'9!65C)9)/)<5-2! 5(/'>-)(0!*'B('-)/2R!M$":"A!FZ%XNH! Of,4!'-=,(/!$!65*'65(A!(*0,-'4(!/05=(5-<5(!0'<5!>559!5aF45(()9D! *,9*549(!/0'/!'9!5a*5(()<5!F45,**BF'/),9!@)/0!/05,42!=)D0/!>)96! >B()95((!(*0,,-!45(5'4*0!)9/,!'!O(/4')D0/^'*L5/R!/0'/!-)=)/(!)/(!45-5<'9*5! '96!<'-B5!/,!F4'*/)*5!M5HDHA!&5//)(A!:XX:[!?'C/!!75@)9A!:XX"NHR!MKU&4)59A!5/! '-A!$":"A!FZ%#N! T05!65>'/5!*,9/)9B5(!/,!/0)(!6'2!>5/@559!/05!*,=F5/)9D!45'-)/)5(!,C!'*'65=)'! '96!F4'*/)*5A!)9!@0'/!0'(!>5*,=5!L9,@9!'(!/05!Og)D,4Pg5-5<'9*5!?5>'/5R!,4!/05! Og5(5'4*0PJ4'*/)*5!e'FR!MI-6'DA!$":$[!&')-52!!f,46A!:XXZ[!&599)(!!KUT,,-5A! $""S[!&5//)(A!:XX:[!?'C/!!75@)9A!:XX"[!e45D,42A!$":$[!e45<5A!$":$[!eB-'/)A! $""Y[!8BD05(!#)$/,!$"::[!V45-'96A!$":$[!75'<)//A!:X#X[!.'4/)9A!$":$[!.)9/Q>54DA! :XXZ[!KU&4)59A!5/!'-A!$":"[!JC5CC54!!f,9DA!$""$[!J5'4*5!!8B'9DA!$":$[!J,4/54!! .*b)>>59A!:X##[!+0'F)4,A!b)4L='9A!!h,B4/952A!$""Y[!+/'4L52!!.'6'9A!$"":[! +/5@'4/!!&'44)*LA!$":$[!d'9!65!d59!!3,09(,9A!$""ZNH! 8BD05(!5/!'-HA!M$"::N!45=)96!B(!/0'/!O='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0!)(!'!C4'D=59/56!C)5-6! )9!@0)*0!/0545!)(!-)//-5!F'4'6)D=!*,9(59(B(!MT4'9C)5-6!!+/'4L52A!:XX#NR!MF_:NH!! I!='^,4!*,9*549A!C,4!(,=5A!)(!/0'/!>B()95((!(*0,,-(!='2!-,(5!/05)4! -5D)/)='*2!)9!L9,@-56D5!D5954'/),9!)C!/05)4!45(5'4*0!)(!(559!'(!)445-5<'9/! Mh4,@/054!!h'4/54A!$""$[!8BCCA!$"""[!+/'4L52A!$"":NH!T0)(!*,B-6!0'<5! _!
  5. 5. F,/59/)'--2!(54),B(!)=F-)*'/),9(!C,4!CB/B45!CB96)9D!'96!/05!05'-/02! ,F54'/),9!,C!/05!(5*/,4H!f,4!/0,(5!)9!/05!'*'65=)*!*,==B9)/2!@0,!>5-)5<5! /0'/!/0,(5!@0,!'FF-2!'*'65=)*!L9,@-56D5!'45!)=F,4/'9/!(/'L50,-654(! MI9654(,9A!8544),/A!!8,6DL)9(,9A!$"":NA!/05!F54<'()<595((!,C!/05!D'F! Mg295(A!$""YN!*'9!>5!'!(,B4*5!,C!(,=5!65(F')4H!M8BD05(A!5/!'-A!$"::A!F_:N! V9!054!'6645((!/,!/05!I*'65=2!,C!.'9'D5=59/!'/!/05!'99B'-!=55/)9D!)9!&,(/,9A! J45()659/!I995!+H!T(B)!*0'--59D56!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*054(!/,!O6'45!/,!*'45HR!! +05!-)(/56!/05!/,F!%!*0'--59D5(!/0'/!'45!OF45<59/)9D!B(!C4,=!59D'D)9D!)9!/05! (54),B(!='9'D5=59/!F4,>-5=(!)9!,4D'9)Q'/),9(!,4!/05!(54),B(!(,*)'-!)((B5(!)9! ,B4!(,*)5/)5(1R! :H T05!g5(5'4*0PJ4'*/)*5!e'F1!T0'/!,B4!45(5'4*0!)(!9,/!45-5<'9/!/,! (,*)5/2H! $H T05!h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d54=B5-59!M$""SN! 5-'>,4'/5(1! ?,!V!/0)9L!=2!'FF5'-!/,!(29/05()Q5!4)D,4!'96!45-5<'9*5!@)--!*0'9D5!/05! >50'<),4!,C!'*'65=)*!45(5'4*054(A!'/!-5'(/!,C!/0,(5!@0,!'D455!@)/0G!;,A!V! 6,!9,/i9,4!0'<5!'92!,C!/05!F45<),B(!F-5'(!C,4!45-5<'9*5H!V!>5-)5<5!/0)(! -'*L!,C!*0'9D5!,**B4(!>5*'B(5A!B-/)='/5-2A!,B4!'*'65=)*!(2(/5=!6,5(!9,/! <'-B5!45-5<'9*5H!T05!,9-2!@'2!/,!*0'9D5!/05!'//)/B65!'96!>50'<),4!,C! F5,F-5!)(!/,!*0'9D5!/05!(2(/5=!/0'/!/052!,F54'/5!)9!Mh,-5='9A!:XX%[! e0,(0'-!!&'4/-5//A!:XXYNH!859*5A!F5,F-5!@)--!,9-2!(/'4/!'6645(()9D!'96! *'4)9D!'>,B/!='9'D54)'-!45-5<'9*5!)C!/0'/!)(!@0'/!/05!(2(/5=!@)--!(BFF,4/! '96!'FF45*)'/5H!I96!*B4459/-2!)/!6,5(!9,/!6,!(,!M&599)(!!KUT,,-5A!$""SNH! MFX#"N!! T0'/U(!/05!(/'/5!,C!/05!'4/!)9!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0H!! I(!'!95@*,=54!/,!/05!C)5-6A!V!6,9U/!*'45!@0'/!/05!5a*B(5(!,4!'4DB=59/(!'45H!! T'-L!)(!*05'FH!! T05!()/B'/),9!)(!,B/4'D5,B(!@059!*,=F'456!@)/0!/05!)9*456)>-5!)99,<'/),9!'96! >45'L95*L!F'*5!,C!*0'9D5!,<54!/05!('=5!F54),6!,C!/)=5!/0'/!@5!(55!)9!,/054! C)5-6(!-)L5!)9C,4='/),9!/5*09,-,D2A!F54(,9'-!5-5*/4,9)*(A!,4!=56)*)95H! S!
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`9C,4/B9'/5-2A!@059!45'-!*'9*54!F'/)59/(!'*/B'--2!/'L5!/05!64BDA!/052!6)5H! 8,@!-,9D!6,5(!/05!6,*/,4U(!=5/0,6,-,D2!45=')9!*456)>-5!'96!(*)59/)C)*G! j5/!)9!='9'D5=59/A!@5!0'<5!<,-B=5(!,C!/05,45/)*'-!(/B6)5(!>5)9D!*,96B*/56A! FB>-)(056!'96!F4')(56!C,4!/05)4!k(*)59/)C)*!4)D,4AU!@0)-5!>B()95((5(A!5*,9,=)5(A! '96!D,<549=59/(!-'9DB)(0!)9!*4)()(H!J5,F-5!@0,!9556!05-F!C4,=!='9'D5=59/! (*0,-'4(0)F!/05!=,(/!'45!B9'>-5!/,!B(5!/05!C)96)9D(!FB>-)(056!)9!,B4!=,(/! F45(/)D),B(!='9'D5=59/!^,B49'-(!/,!45(,-<5!/05!='92!*4)(5(!@5!C'*5H! O]059!/05(5!F4,>-5=(!5a)(/A!0,@!*'9!@5!C55-!D,,6!'>,B/!,B4(5-<5(AR!I995!+H!T(B)! WB5(/),956!)9!054!F45()659/)'-!'6645((H!Ol@059!2,B!-,,L!'/!/0)(!-)(/A!)/!6,5(!9,/! *,9<52!'!<542!05'-/02!,4!0'FF2!'*'65=2HR!M$":$N! mB,/)9D!;'9*2!I6-54A!T(B)!'(L561!O?,!@5!0'<5!/05!*,B4'D5!/,!)='D)95! F,(()>)-)/)5(!5<59!@059!,B4!=,(/!/4B(/56!*,--5'DB5(!*,9()654!/05(5!F,(()>)-)/)5(! /,!>5!B945'-)(/)*A!B9'//')9'>-5A!C,,-)(0A!)44'/),9'-A!,4!*,44BF/)9DGR!M$":$N! I(!'!95@!6,*/,4'-!*'96)6'/5A!V!6,!9,/!(0'45!/05!('=5!65F45(()9D!,B/-,,L!C,4!/05! 6)(*)F-)95!,C!='9'D5=59/!'(!J45()659/!T(B)!'96!,/054(H!! `905'-/02!'96!B90'FF2!='2!>5!'9!'**5F/'>-5!(/'/5!,C!/05!'4/!'(!V!>5D)9!=2! 6,*/,4'-!6)((54/'/),9A!>B/!V!DB'4'9/2!/0'/!)/!@)--!9,!-,9D54!>5!'**5F/'>-5!>2!/05! /)=5!V!C)9)(0H!! ]02!'=!V!,F/)=)(/)*G!! V!(B>=)/!/0'/!/05!@0,-5!65>'/5!,<54!/05!45(5'4*0PF4'*/)*5!D'F!)(!)445-5<'9/A! >5*'B(5!)/!45F45(59/(!,B4!,@9!C')-B45A!'(!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*054(A!/,!*-'4)C2!'96! (,-)6)C2!/05!F,,4-2!*,9*5)<56!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!C,B96'/),9(!,C!,B4!6)(*)F-)95H!! d54=B5-59!M$""SNA!eB-'/)!M$""YNA!e45D,42!M$":$NA!'96!.'4/)9!M$":$N!'--!F,)9/! ,B/!/05!,><),B(1!,B4!45(5'4*0!(0,B-6!>5!>,/0!4)D,4,B(!'96!45-5<'9/H!! +,A!)C!/05!F4,>-5=!'4)(5(!C4,=!,B4!,@9!(2(/5=A!/059!V!>5-)5<5!@5!*'9!C)a!)/H!! fB4/054=,45A!()9*5!)/!)(!,B4!(2(/5=A!9,!,95!*'9!(/,F!B(!C4,=!C)a)9D!)/!>B/!B(H! ]5A!/05!*B(/,6)'9(!,C!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0A!'45!*,=F-5/5-2!)9!*,9/4,-!,C!/05! ,B/*,=5!0545H!! e45D,42!M$":$N!*'F/B456!/05!5((59*5!,C!@0'/!/0)(!4)D,4P45-5<'9*5!65>'/5! ()D9)C)5(!)9!/05!>4,'654!65<5-,F=59/!,C!/05!6)(*)F-)951! Z!
  7. 7. V/!(55=(!/,!=5!/0'/!,B4!'*'65=)*!C)5-6!)(!D,)9D!/04,BD0!'6,-5(*59*5H!T05! /05,4)5(!/0'/!@545!65<5-,F56!)9!/05!:X#"(!'96!:XX"(!'45!>5)9D! *0'--59D56A!'(!/052!(0,B-6!>5A!'96!'!@0,-5!4'9D5!,C!95@!'FF4,'*05(!'96! F54(F5*/)<5(!'45!>5)9D!)9/4,6B*56!)9/,!/05!C)5-6A!'D')9A!'(!/052!(0,B-6!>5H! T559'D54(A!)9!/05!F4,*5((!,C!45'*0)9D!'6B-/0,,6A!=,<5!'@'2!C4,=!/05)4! F'459/(!'96!/42!/,!C,4D5!/05)4!,@9!=B-/)C'*5/56!)659/)/)5(H!V9!/05!F4,*5((! /0545!)(!5aF54)=59/'/),9A!C'--)9D!,B/!'96!5<59!(,=5!>'6!>50'<),B4H!MF$P%N! T0'/!@'(!/059H!T0)(!)(!9,@H!+,!0,@!6,!@5!C)9'--2!D4,@!BF!'96!=,<5!F'(/!'--!/0)(G! g'/054!/0'9!59D'D)9D!)9!'9,/054!=5'9)9D-5((!65>'/5A!V!@)--!65=,9(/4'/5!@0'/!)(! F,(()>-5!@059!@5!(29/05()Q5!'96!'FF-2!95@!L9,@-56D5!C4,=!6)<54(5!6)(*)F-)95(A! -)L5!95B4,(*)59*5A!*,=F-5a)/2!(*)59*5A!-)9DB)(/)*(A!'96!5<59!0B=>-5!'4)/0=5/)*!/,! C)9'--2!45(,-<5!/05!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!6)<)65!)9!,B4!,@9!6)(*)F-)95H! f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
  8. 8. I(!'!95@!45(5'4*054A!V!(55!'9!0)(/,4)*!,FF,4/B9)/2!/,!B9-5'(0!/05!95a/!D45'/!@'<5! ,C!)99,<'/),9!/0'/!@)--!,9*5!'D')9!/4'9(C,4=!,B4!@,4-6H!I!/45=596,B(!45<,-B/),9! )(!B9654@'2!)9!/05!@'2!@5!B9654(/'96!*,=F-5a!0B='9!(2(/5=(A!@0)*0!)(!64)<)9D! '!F'4'6)D=!(0)C/!5WB'-!)9!='D9)/B65!/,!/05!E'4/0!(0)C/)9D!C4,=!C-'/!/,!4,B96H!I(! ='9'D5=59/!(*0,-'4(A!@5!*'9!5)/054!>5!(@5F/!)9/,!)445-5<'9*5!/42)9D!/,!=')9/')9! /05!(/'/B(!WB,!,4!@5!*'9!*0,,(5!/,!B(054!)9!'!95@!5F,*0!)9!0B='9!65<5-,F=59/H!! T,!6,!(,A!@5!9556!/,!455a'=)95!,95!CB96'=59/'-A!>B/!5a/45=5-2!)=F,4/'9/A!>)DP F)*/B45!WB5(/),9A!'>,B/!/05!,9/,-,D2!@5!*0,,(5!'(!/05!C,B96'/),9!C,4! ='9'D5=59/!'(!'9!'(F)4)9D!(*)59/)C)*!6)(*)F-)95H!! ! IC/54!*,9()654)9D!/05!4'=)C)*'/),9(!,C!/05!6)CC5459/!F,(()>-5!'9(@54(!/,!/05! WB5(/),9!,C!,9/,-,D2A!@5!@)--!/059!5a'=)95!/05!C4'=5@,4L!)9!@0)*0!@5!*45'/5! =5'9)9DCB-!L9,@-56D5H!]5!@)--!5aF-,45!/05!='/05='/)*'-!)99,<'/),9(!/0'/!*'9! 05-F!B(!/,!=')9/')9!*-'4)/2!'96!F45*)(),9!)9!/05!45F45(59/'/),9(!@5!*45'/5!,C!/05! F059,=59'!@5!,>(54<5!)9!='9'D5=59/H!]5!@)--!/059!*,=F'45!@0'/!'!95@! 5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-!C4'=5!*'9!65-)<54!/,!>4)6D5!/05!45(5'4*0PF4'*/)*5!D'F!@)/0!@0'/! *B4459/!(/'/)(/)*'-!C4'=5(!0'<5!65-)<5456!/,!CB5-!/05!4)D,4P45-5<'9*5!65>'/5H!! ! &2!5a'=)9)9D!/05(5!/@,!CB96'=59/'-!)((B5(A!@5!@)--!>5!)9!'!>5//54!F,()/),9!/,! ='L5!'9!0,95(/!'((5((=59/!,C!@0,!@5!'45!'96!@0'/!@5!>5-)5<5!'>,B/!,B4!,@9! 5a)(/59*5!'(!(*0,-'4(!'96!F4'*/)/),954(!)9!='9'D5=59/H!I96!C)9'--2A!@5!9556!/,! 45*,995*/!/,!/05!5=F)4)*'-!C,B96'/),9(A!(F'99)9D!C4,=!/05!F059,=59'!@5!(/B62! /,!/05!*,9*-B(),9(!@5!45'*0A!(,!/0'/!@5!*'9!45(/,45!*,9C)659*5!)9!/05!-5D)/)='*2! ,C!,B4!@,4LH! #!
  9. 9. 43,'/",1/'$5'63'7$ ! KB4!*,--5*/)<5!C')-B45!/,!45(,-<5!/05!n:!*0'--59D5!)9!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0! (5<545-2!B9654=)95(!/05!*456)>)-)/2!,C!*B4459/!=5/0,6(!'96!/05!O4)D,4R!/0'/! 65C)95(!/05)4!<'-)6)/2H!! `9654!/05!)9C-B59*5!,C!'!>4,'6-2!*,9*5)<56!F,()/)<)(/!'**,B9/!,C!(*)59*5! 5F)(/5=,-,D2!0'(!>559!F4)<)-5D56!,<54!,9/,-,D2H!I**,46)9D!/,!/0)(! F,()/)<)(/!'**,B9/A!'!(*)59*5!59/54(!)/(!='/B45!(/'D5!@059!)/!45^5*/(! =5/'F02()*'-!'96!,9/,-,D)*'-!6,D='(!'96!45C-5*/(!,9!)/(!,@9!(/'/B(!'(!'! (*)59*5H!e,,6!(*)59*5!)(!(')6!/,!C,--,@!'!()=F-5!'96!@5--P65/')-56!(5/!,C! F4,*56B45(H!?5C)95!@0'/!*,B9/(!'(!/05!(5/!,C!5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-!'96! =5/0,6,-,D)*'-!F4,*56B45(!C,4!D5954'/)9D!-5D)/)='/5!L9,@-56D5!'96! 59(B45!/0'/!/05(5!'45!C,--,@56H!M]4)D0/!$""ZA!F$N! V9!='9'D5=59/A!/05!45(5'4*0PF4'*/)*5!D'F!0'(!5=54D56!C4,=!/05!6)<)656! F0)-,(,F0)*'-!(/'9*5!/0'/!6)CC5459/!5F)(/5=,-,D)5(!D5954'/5A!@059!/05!(/'96'46(! C,4!@0'/!*,B9/(!'(!<'-)6!L9,@-56D5!)9!/05!(,*)'-!*,9/5a/!,C!'*'65=)'!'45! 6)CC5459/!C4,=!@0'/!*,B9/(!'(!<'-)6!L9,@-56D5!)9!/05!(,*)'-!*,9/5a/!,C!F4'*/)*5! Mg,B((5'BA!.'99)9DA!!?59254A!$""#[!+04)<'(/'<'!!.)/4,CCA!:X#_NH!! +)9*5!*,B9/)9D!)(!'9!)9/54P(B>^5*/)<5!F4,*5((!M.'4/)9!$""_!)9!+'965-,@(L)!$""XNA! /0)(!F4,^5*/!@)--!>5D)9!>2!455a'=)9)9D!@0'/!*,B9/(!'(!(*)59/)C)*!L9,@-56D5! <54(B(!@0'/!*,B9/(!'(!FB45!(,*)'-!*,9(/4B*/),9H!T,!*-5'4-2!5(/'>-)(0!9,9P ,<54-'FF)9D!>,B96'4)5(A!@5!C)4(/!9556!/,!-,,L!'/!0,@!@5!D5954'/5!L9,@-56D5! '>,B/!/05!F059,=59'!@5!5aF54)59*5!)9!/05!59<)4,9=59/!)9!@0)*0!@5!5a)(/H!! I92!6)(*,B4(5!,9!5F)(/5=,-,D2!,4!=5/0,6,-,D2!)(!>,B96!/,!>5!=,45!,4! -5((!'4>)/4'42!@)/0,B/!'!F4),4!(F5*)C)*'/),9!,C!'9!,>^5*/!,C!)9WB)42H! EF)(/5=,-,D)*'-!WB5(/),9(!*'99,/!>5!(5//-56!)9!'6<'9*5!,CA!,4!6)(/)9*/! C4,=A!,9/,-,D)*'-!WB5(/),9(H!M]4)D0/!$""ZN! T05!9'/B45!,C!5a)(/59*5!)(!(B*0!/0'/!@5!*'9!)9<59/!@0'/5<54!(/,42!@5!@'9/!/,! 5aF-')9!0,@!>,/0!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'96!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!@,4LA!>B/! (*)59*5!45WB)45(!=,45H!]4)D0/!M$""ZN!5=F0'()Q5(!/0'/!OB9654(/'96)9D!/05! ,9/,-,D)*'-!6)CC5459*5(!/0'/!-)5!'/!/05!05'4/!,C!*,=F5/)9D!<)(),9(!,C!/05!@,4-6! (0,B-6!>5!/05!')=!,C!'92!F4,F54-2!*,9*5)<56!*4)/)*'-!6)(*)F-)95R!MF$NH! T05!=,(/!CB96'=59/'-!WB5(/),9(!*,=5!C4,=!,9/,-,D2!Mh,a!:XXZA!F:__[!]'-L54! :XX%A!F#$[!]596/!:XXXA!FZN!'96!45<,-<5!'4,B96!/05!9'/B45!,C!5a)(/59*5!)/(5-CH! ])/0!45(F5*/!/,!D5954'/)9D!L9,@-56D5A!@5!*'9!6)<)65!/05!WB5(/),9!)9!/@,!F'4/(1! ?,5(!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!='L5!/05!4B-5(!C,4!0,@!/05! 59<)4,9=59/!)9!@0)*0!@5!5a)(/!@,4L(G! K4!6,5(!/05!59<)4,9=59/!)9!@0)*0!@5!5a)(/A!5a/549'-!/,! 0B='9!*,D9)/),9A!65/54=)95!/05!4B-5(!C,4!0,@!/0)9D(! @,4LG! ?5F596)9D!,9!0,@!@5!'9(@54!/05!WB5(/),9(!,C!,9/,-,D2A! X!
  10. 10. @5!D5/!'!6)CC5459/!(5/!,C!4B-5(!C,4!@0'/!='L5(!(59(5A!C,4!@0'/!*'9!>5!*,9()65456! <'-)6!L9,@-56D5H!! EF)(/5=,-,D2!)(!-)L5!D4'=='4H!! T0545!'45!C,B4!F,(()>-5!@'2(!/,!'9(@54!/05!WB5(/),9(!,C! ,9/,-,D2A!5'*0!,95!F4,6B*)9D!'!6)CC5459/!-,D)*!'96!'! 6)CC5459/!>'()(!C,4!-5D)/)='*2!)9!L9,@-56D5!D5954'/),9A! )H5HA!'!6)CC5459/!5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-!D4'=='4A!'(!(0,@9!)9! T'>-5!:1! ! 8B='9!h,D9)/),9! Ea/549'-! +,B4*5!,C!/ABCDCEF!C,4! +,B4*5!,C! .'L5(!/05!gB-5(! E9<)4,9=59/! EF)(/5=,-,D)*'-!gB-5([! ,GHCECIAJF!C,4! C,4!8,@!/05! .'L5(!/05!gB-5(! -)=)/(!C,4!@0'/!)(! /05!D5954'/),9! E9<)4,9=59/! /0'/!8B='9! -,D)*'-A!C,4!@0'/! ,C!*'B('-! ],4L(! h,D9)/),9!.'F(! k='L5(!(59(5U1! L9,@-56D51! K9/,-,D)*'-!;5D'/),91! #K! #K! ?,=)9'/),9!! .2/0,-,D2cV65,-,D2! +BF549'/B4'-! K9/,-,D)*'-! ?5*45'()9D! 5GL! #K! E=54D59*51!g5-'/)<)(=!! h,9(59(B(!! h,9C-)*/! K9/,-,D)*'-!J-B4'-)(=1! g5*,9*)-5!! 5GL! 5GL! @cV9*45'()9D! g5'-)(=!M.B-/)F-5!g5'-)/)5(N! h,445(F,9659*5! K9/,-,D)*'-!`9)/21! h,445(F,9659*5! #K! 5GL! T4'9(F'459/!+*)59*5!! /,!Ea/549'-!E9</H! T'>-5!:1!.2!(B=='42!,C!/05!-'(/!$_!*59/B4)5(!,C!5<,-B/),9!)9!F0)-,(,F02H! .2!FB4F,(5!0545!)(!9,/!/,!*,96B*/!'9!5a0'B(/)<5!45<)5@!,C!/05!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!'96! ='/05='/)*'-!>,6)5(!,C!-)/54'/B45!(/45/*0)9D!>'*L!/,!/05!_/0!*59/B42!&h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a'=)95! /05!(/'/5!,C!,9/,-,D2!'96!5F)(/5=,-,D2!)9!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0!)9!,4654!/,!(55! 0,@!@5!=)D0/!45(,-<5!/05!*B4459/!4)D,4P45-5<'9*5!65>'/5H!f4,=!/0545A!/05! 6)(*)F-)95!'(!'!@0,-5!*'9!(/'4/!/,!>4)6D5!/05!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!6)<)65!'96!=,<5! >52,96!(55=)9D-2!596-5((!65>'/5(!/,!=,45!F4,6B*/)<5!)99,<'/),9H! :"!
  11. 11. 8+,(#(932"#$:'9",3(+;$<=,>(#(9=?.0'(#(9=$ ]5!*'9!>5D)9!@)/0!/05!e455L!F0)-,(,F054(!J-'/,!'96!I4)(/,/-5A!@0,!C'=,B(-2! 6)('D4556!,<54!/05!OB9)<54('-!C,4=(AR!/05!'>(/4'*/),9(!='FF56!)9!0B='9! *,D9)/),9A!'96!OF'4/)*B-'4!)9(/'9/)'/),9(AR!/05!(F5*)C)*!F02()*'-!,>^5*/(!,>(54<56H!!! I4)(/,/-5!'4DB56!'D')9(/!J-'/,A!=')9/')9)9D!/0'/!'!6)45*/!*,995*/),9!/,!/05! ='/54)'-!59<)4,9=59/A!)9!@0)*0!/05!OC,4=R!)(!O)9(/'9/)'/56R!M3,4)!$""%NA!@'(! 45WB)456!)9!,4654!/,!>5!*,9()65456!<'-)6H!T0B(A!I4)(/,/-5!(,BD0/!/,!D4,B96! L9,@-56D5!/04,BD0!5=F)4)*'-!5<)659*5!C4,=!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H! I4)(/,/-5o(!F4565*5((,4A!J-'/,A!'4DB56!/0'/!'--!/0)9D(!0'<5!'!B9)<54('-! C,4=A!@0)*0!*,B-6!>5!5)/054!'!F4,F54/2A!,4!'!45-'/),9!/,!,/054!/0)9D(H!]059! @5!-,,L!'/!'9!'FF-5A!C,4!5a'=F-5A!@5!(55!'9!'FF-5A!'96!@5!*'9!'-(,!'9'-2Q5! '!C,4=!,C!'9!'FF-5H!V9!/0)(!6)(/)9*/),9A!/0545!)(!'!F'4/)*B-'4!'FF-5!'96!'! B9)<54('-!C,4=!,C!'9!'FF-5H!M3,4)!$""%N! T05!OF'4/)*B-'4R!'FF-5!)(!/05!='/54)'-!,95!)9!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!T05! OC,4=R!,C!'9!'FF-5!)(!/05!'>(/4'*/!F4,^5*/),9!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9H!f4,=!/05! F,)9/!,C!<)5@!,C!5F)(/5=,-,D2A!/0)(!0'(!F4,C,B96!)=F-)*'/),9(!'(!@5!=,<5!C4,=! /05!5a'=F-5!,C!'9!'FF-5!/,!/05!-'4D54!WB5(/),9(!)9!D5954'/)9D!L9,@-56D5!'>,B/! /05!9'/B45!,C!/05!>4,'654!59<)4,9=59/!)9!@0)*0!@5!5a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a)(/56!)9!J-'/,U(!)9/549'-!*,D9)/)<5!='FA!9,/! /05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!)/(5-CH!T0)(!)(!FB45!(,*)'-!*,9(/4B*/),9!'(!/05!>'()(!,C! <'-)6)/2A!>5*'B(5!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!=B(/!*,9C,4=!/,!/05!4B-5(!65C)956!>2! /05,45/)*'-!=,65-(!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9A!9,/!/05!,/054!@'2!'4,B96H! V9!/0)(!@'2A!5WB'--2!<'-)6!L9,@-56D5!'-(,!*,=5(!C4,=!/05!>4,'654!*B-/B4'-! 9'44'/)<5!/0'/!@'(!='FF56!,B/!)9!J-'/,U(!*,D9)/)<5!C4'=5!'(!@5--H!OV9!0)(!k.2/0!,C! E4AU!'!(5*/),9!,C!/05!3#&<8,'.A!05!65(*4)>5(!/05!*,(=,(!'(!/05!+F)96-5!,C!;5*5(()/2A! '//59656!>2!/05!+)459(!'96!/B4956!>2!/05!/0455!f'/5(HR!Mf4'(54!$""ZNH!! T05!'4DB=59/!>5/@559!J-'/,!'96!I4)(/,/-5!='4L(!/05!*4,((4,'6(!>5/@559!@0'/! @5!*'9!*'--!,9/,-,D)*'-!95D'/),9!'96!,9/,-,D)*'-!5=54D59*5H!! ]5!*'9!*,9()654!,9/,-,D)*'-!95D'/),9!/,!>5!@0545!/05!(,B4*5!,C!<'-)6)/2!*,=5(! C4,=!/05!B9,>(54<'>-5!'>(/4'*/),9(!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!/0'/!'45!5=>56656! )9!/05!(,*)'--2P*,9(/4B*/56A!*B-/B4'-!9'44'/)<5(!,C!=2/0,-,D2!'96c,4!)65,-,D2H!! K9/,-,D)*'-!5=54D59*5A!/059A!)(!/05!*4,((,<54!F,)9/!@0545!<'-)6)/2!*,=5(!C4,=! (,=5!*,995*/),9!/,!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!/0'/!>4)9D(!0B='9!*,D9)/),9A!)/(5-CA! )9/,!5a)(/59*5A!9,/!C4,=!/05!(/,4)5(!/0'/!,9-2!5a)(/!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9H!!! ::!
  12. 12. I4)(/,/-5!45^5*/56!/05!)65'!/0'/!/05!'>(/4'*/),9(!)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!@545!/05! (,B4*5!,C!<'-)6)/2H!85!=')9/')956!/0'/!/05!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=R!*,B-6!9,/!>5!<'-)6!)C! /0545!@'(!9,!*,445(F,96)9D!O)9(/'9/)'/),9R!,C!/05!('=5!)9!/05!5a/549'-! 59<)4,9=59/H!J-'/,A!0,@5<54A!'4DB56!)9!C'<,4!,C!OB9)9(/'9/)'/56!B9)<54('-!C,4=(R! M3,4)!$""%NH! V9!/05!5a/45=5A!J-'/,U(!'4DB=59/!45(B-/(!)9!'!95D'/),9!,C!'92!,>(54<'>-5! ,9/,-,D)*'-!>'()(!C,4!*,9(/4B*/)9D!L9,@-56D5H!V/!95D'/5(!/05!59/)45! 65<5-,F=59/'-!F4,*5((!,C!95B4,>),-,D)*'-!'*/)<)/2!)9!/05!>4')9!/0'/!F45*5656!/05! 5=54D59*5!,C!/05!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=R!,C!'9!'FF-5!@)/0)9!0B='9! *,D9)/),9H!`()9D!/05!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=R!/0'/!5a)(/(!,9-2!@)/0)9! 0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'(!/05!(/'4/)9D!F,)9/!C,4!>B)-6)9D! L9,@-56D5!=5'9(!/0'/!@5!*'99,/!65/54=)95!/05!9'/B45!,C! 5a)(/59*5A!)/(5-CA!)9!'92!,>^5*/)<5!@'2A!>5*'B(5!@5!*'99,/! ,>(54<5!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!6)45*/-2A!5a*5F/!)9!,B4(5-<5(H!T052! '45!/05!F4,^5*/),9!,C!'9!'FF-5!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9A!9,/! /05!5a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a/549'-! O)9(/'9/)'/),9HR! 859*5A!)C!@5!*0,,(5!/,!(/'4/!C4,=!/05!'>(/4'*/),9(!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'(!/05! >'()(!C,4!<'-)6)/2A!/059!@5!95D'/5!,>(54<'/),9!@)/0)9!,9/,-,D2A!>5*'B(5!/05! 9'/B45!,C!5a)(/59*5!)(!@0'/5<54!@5!65C)95!)/!/,!>5!/$&2'+2'H! I--!L9,@-56D5!*45'/56!B9654!(B*0!*,96)/),9(!*,9/')9(! (,=5!>)'(!'96!(B>^5*/)<5!(,*)'-!*,9(/4B*/),9!/0'/!*'9! (B>(5WB59/-2!>5!4565C)956!'/!@)--H!T05!4B-5(!C,4!<'-)6)/2A!)9! /0)(!*'(5A!'45!>'(56!-'4D5-2!,9!/05!*B-/B4'-!9'44'/)<5(!,C! =2/0,-,D2!'96!)65,-,D2!)9!@0)*0!/05!,>(54<54!*,9(/4B*/(! =5'9)9DH!`()9D!/0)(!>'()(!C,4!<'-)6)/2!=5'9(!/0'/!9,!*-')=! /,!-5D)/)='*2!*'9!>5!5(/'>-)(056!5a*5F/!>2!C,4*5A! 6,=)9'/),9A!'96!(B>^BD'/),9H!! V9!/0)(!5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-!D4'=='4A!O.)D0/!='L5(!g)D0/AR!'96!-5D)/)='*2!)(! (B>(/'9/)'/56!/04,BD0!F,-)/)*'-!'4DB=59/(!,4!*-')=(!,C!(,=5!*,995*/),9!/,!/05! (BF549'/B4'-A!/,!(,=5!0)D054!45'-=!>52,96!/05!F02()*'-!59<)4,9=59/!@5! ,>(54<5A!(B*0!'(!J-'/,U(!O+F)96-5!,C!;5*5(()/2A!'//59656!>2!+)459(!'96!/B4956!>2! /05!/0455!f'/5(HR!T0)(!5F)(/5=,-,D2!D)<5(!/4B/0!*-')=(!(,=5!405/,4)*'-!'FF5'-!>2! ='L)9D!/05=!)=F54<),B(!/,!6)45*/!*0'--59D5!,4!*4)/)*)(=!>'(56!,9!5=F)4)*'-! 5<)659*5A!>B/!0)(/,42!65=,9(/4'/5(!/0'/!)/!)(!9,/!(B(/')9'>-5H!! 8+,(#(932"#$@A'/9'+2';$5'#",363-A$$ EB6,aB(!,C!h9)6B(A!@0,!@,4L56!@)/0!J-'/,A!65<5-,F56!'!-5((!=2/0)*'-A! =,45!='/05='/)*'-!5aF-'9'/),9!,C!/05!F-'95/(o!=,/),9!>'(56!,9!J-'/,o(! 6)*/B=!(/'/)9D!/0'/!'--!F059,=59'!)9!/05!05'<59(!*'9!>5!5aF-')956!@)/0! :$!
  13. 13. B9)C,4=!*)4*B-'4!=,/),9H!I4)(/,/-5!5-'>,4'/56!,9!EB6,aB(o!(2(/5=H! M85/054)9D/,9!$""ZN! T0,BD0!05!'-(,!*,9(/4B*/56!'!D5,*59/4)*!=,65-!,C!/05!B9)<54(5A!I4)(/,/-5! '6<,*'/56!=,45!,C!'!*2*-)*'-!5a*0'9D5!>5/@559!/05!)9/549'-!'>(/4'*/),9(!'96!/05! 5a/549'-!)9(/'9/)'/),9(!'(!/05!>'()(!C,4!@0'/!='L5(!(59(5!)9!/05!D5954'/),9!,C! L9,@-56D5!M3,4)!$""%NH!8)(!*,9/4)>B/),9(!/,!/05!C,B96'/),9(!,C!/05!(*)59/)C)*! =5/0,6!'96!)/(!)=F'*/!0'<5!>559!)9C-B59/)'-!)9!/05!F4,6B*/),9!,C!(*)59/)C)*! L9,@-56D5!5<54!()9*5[!(,=5!/)=5(!C,(/54)9D!F4,D45((A!,/054!/)=5(!)=F56)9D!)/H!! I4)(/,/-5U(!)9C-B59*5!@'(!(,!C'4!45'*0)9D!/0'/!$$!*59/B4)5(!'C/54!0)(!65'/0A!/05! *,9/5=F,4'42!F0)-,(,F054A!&54/4'96!gB((5--A!-'=59/56A!! O'-=,(/!5<542!(54),B(!)9/5--5*/B'-!'6<'9*5!0'(!0'6!/,!>5D)9!@)/0!'9!'//'*L! ,9!(,=5!I4)(/,/5-)'9!6,*/4)95RH!gB((5--!'-(,!45C54(!/,!I4)(/,/-5o(!5/0)*(!'(! O45FB-()<5RA!'96!*'--(!0)(!-,D)*!O'(!65C)9)/5-2!'9/)WB'/56!'(!J/,-5=')*! '(/4,9,=2RH!gB((5--!9,/5(!/0'/!/05(5!544,4(!='L5!)/!6)CC)*B-/!/,!6,! 0)(/,4)*'-!^B(/)*5!/,!I4)(/,/-5A!B9/)-!,95!45=5=>54(!0,@!-'4D5!,C!'9! '6<'9*5!05!='65!BF,9!'--!,C!0)(!F4565*5((,4(H!MgB((5--!:XY$pN! V/U(!5'(2!C,4!gB((5--!/,!-,,L!>'*L!@)/0!$"c$"!0)96()D0/!'96!(55!/05!C')-)9D(!,C! ,/054(H!]0'/U(!6)CC)*B-/!)(!-,,L)9D!C,4@'46!'96!(55)9D!0,@!,B4!F45(59/!C')-)9D(! '45!45F5'/)9D!='92!,C!/05!('=5!=)(/'L5(!,C!/05!F'(/H!! gB((5--!-'/54!'4DB5(!)9!C'<,4!,C!J-'/,U(!OB9)9(/'9/)'/56!B9)<54('-(R!@0545! B9,>(54<'>-5A!/05,45/)*!=,65-(!*'9!5a)(/!@)/0,B/!*,445(F,96)9DA!='/54)'-! )9(/'9/)'/),9(H!g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o(!@4)/)9D(!,9!(*)59*5!'45!-'4D5-2!WB'-)/'/)<5A!'(!,FF,(56!/,! WB'9/)/'/)<5H!&5D)99)9D!)9!/05!:Z/0!*59/B42A!(*)59/)(/(!>5D'9!'FF-2)9D! ='/05='/)*(!/,!/05!F02()*'-!(*)59*5(A!'96!I4)(/,/-5o(!@,4L!)9!/0)(!'45'! @'(!655=56!0,F5-5((-2!)9'65WB'/5H!8)(!C')-)9D(!@545!-'4D5-2!6B5!/,!/05! '>(59*5!,C!*,9*5F/(!-)L5!='((A!<5-,*)/2A!C,4*5!'96!/5=F54'/B45H!85!0'6!'! *,9*5F/),9!,C!(F556!'96!/5=F54'/B45A!>B/!9,!WB'9/)/'/)<5!B9654(/'96)9D! ,C!/05=A!@0)*0!@'(!F'4/-2!6B5!/,!/05!'>(59*5!,C!>'()*!5aF54)=59/'-! 65<)*5(A!-)L5!*-,*L(!'96!/054=,=5/54(H!M&B459/A!:X$#pN! V/!)(!)=F,4/'9/!/,!9,/5!/0'/!)9!/05!'>(59*5!,C!>'()*!5=F)4)*'-!=5/4)*(A!/05! ='FF)9D(!@5!*,9(/4B*/!,C!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!-'*L!F45*)(),9!'96!'**B4'*2H! T05!*,9(/4')9/(!,C!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!6,!9,/!-)=)/!@0'/!='L5(!(59(5! @)/0)9!/05!/05,45/)*'-!=,65-(!@5!*,9(/4B*/!)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9H!! :%!
  14. 14. I4)(/,/-5!D,5(!/,,!C'4!)9!654)<)9D!k-'@(!,C!/05!B9)<54(5U!C4,=!()=F-5! ,>(54<'/),9!'96!,<54P(/45/*056!45'(,9H!T,6'2U(!(*)59/)C)*!=5/0,6! '((B=5(!/0'/!(B*0!/0)9L)9D!@)/0,B/!(BCC)*)59/!C'*/(!)(!)95CC5*/)<5A!'96!/0'/! 6)(*549)9D!/05!<'-)6)/2!,C!,95U(!02F,/05()(!45WB)45(!C'4!=,45!4)D,4,B(! 5aF54)=59/'/),9!/0'9!/0'/!@0)*0!I4)(/,/-5!B(56!/,!(BFF,4/!0)(!-'@(H! M&B459/A!:X$#pN! T0B(!'(!@5!=,<5!'@'2!C4,=!/05!95D'/),9!,C!,>(54<'/),9!'96!/,@'46(!,9/,-,D)*'-! 5=54D59*5A!@5!>5D)9!/,!5(/'>-)(0!'!-)=)/56A!*2*-)*'-!-)9L!>5/@559!/05!'>(/4'*/! C,4=(!'96!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/A!>B/!/05!='FF)9D(!@5!D5954'/5!-'*L!'!CB--2! ,>^5*/)<5!>'()(!C,4!-5D)/)='*2H!+BF549'/B4'-!'96!)65,-,D)*'-!5aF-'9'/),9(A!@0545! '92/0)9D!)(!F,(()>-5A!45=')9!-,D)*'-!'96!<'-)6!)9!/05!D5954'/),9!,C!L9,@-56D5H! E<542/0)9D!)(!(/)--!(,=5@0'/!45-'/)<5!'96!/0545!)(!9,!'>(,-B/5!/4B/0A!5a*5F/!@0545! *,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!/05!'>(/4'*/!C,4=!'96!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!)(! *-5'4-2!5(/'>-)(056H! K9/,-,D)*'-!E=54D59*5!45(B-/(!)9!'!L)96!,C!g5-'/)<)(=A! @0545!'!*,9(59(B(P>'(56!-5D)/)='*2!)(!*,BF-56!@)/0!'!-,,(5! *,995*/),9!/,!5=F)4)*'-!5<)659*5!C4,=!/05!5a/549'-! 59<)4,9=59/H!K>(54<'/),9!)(!9,!-,9D54!95D'/56!)9!/05! 65/54=)9'/),9!,C!<'-)6)/2!)9!L9,@-56D5!*,9(/4B*/),9A!>B/!)9! )/(!-,,(5(/!WB'-)/'/)<5!C,4=A!/0)(!-5'6(!/,!f5254'>596U(! M:XYSN!k'92/0)9D!D,5(U!45-'/)<)(=H!K9-2!*,9C-)*/!5a)(/(! @)/0)9!/0)(!*'=FA!>5*'B(5!9,!65C)9)/)<5!45(,-B/),9!,C!65>'/5! )(!F,(()>-5H!75D)/)='*2!)(!5(/'>-)(056!/04,BD0!/05!*,9(59(B(! ,C!/05!,>(54<54(A!@)/0!FB9*/B'/56!=,=59/(!,C!*,445(F,9659*5!/,!/05!5a/549'-! 59<)4,9=59/!/0'/!'45!B(56!/,!(BFF,4/!/05!'(*59659*2!,C!,95!D4,BFU(!*,9(59(B(! ,<54!'9,/054U(H!! T0)(!'--,@(!C,4!'!=B*0!>4,'654!>'(5!,C!0B='9!5aF54)59*5!/,!>5!B(56!'(!/05! '4>)/54!,C!<'-)6)/2H!8,@5<54A!)/!6,5(!9,/!DB'4'9/2!*,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559! '>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!'96!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!)9!'92!4)D,4,B(!,4!/4'9(F'459/! @'2H!`9654!/05(5!*,96)/),9(A!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!(/)--!='L5(!/05!4B-5(!C,4!0,@!/05! 59<)4,9=59/!@,4L(A!@0)*0!=5'9(!/0'/!/05!*,9(/4B*/),9!,C!<'-)6!L9,@-56D5!@)--! >5!(B>^5*/!/,!>)'(!'96!)=F45*)(),9H!! VC!@5!*0,,(5!g5-'/)<)(=!'(!/05!5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-!>'()(!C,4! D5954'/)9D!<'-)6!L9,@-56D5A!/059!@5!D5/!)=F45*)(5!'96! >)'(56!45F45(59/'/),9(!,C!F059,=59'!'96!'9!O'92/0)9D! D,5(R!-,D)*!@)/0!,9-2!'!-,,(5!*,995*/),9!/,!5<)659*5!)9!/05! 5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!T0)(!)(!'9!'//4'*/)<5!F-'2D4,B96!C,4! '*'65=)*(!>5*'B(5!/05!65>'/)9D!CB9!95<54!596(H!V9!/0)(! F-'2D4,B96A!/05,4)5(!6,9U/!0'<5!/,!>5!*,9(/4')956!>2!/05! -)=)/(!/0'/!D,<549!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!O?)CC54)9D! /05,4)5(!'--!0'<5!/05)4!,@9!F4,F,(56!,9/,-,D2R!M]4)D0/! $""ZA!F_NH!I*'65=)*(!'45!C455!/,!C,--,@!)='D)9'/),9!'92@0545H!&B/!/0'/!6,5(9U/! =5'9!'92!,C!/05!OL9,@-56D5R!/052!D5954'/5!@)--!'*/B'--2!F4,6B*5!<)'>-5!/5*09)*'-! 'FF-)*'/),9(!)9!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!T0)(!-5'6(!/,!*,9C-)*/!>5*'B(5!/0,(5! @0,!0'<5!/,!F'2!/,!(BFF,4/!/05!'*'65=)*(U!CB9!6,9U/!'-@'2(!(0'45!/05!('=5! '//)/B65H!E<59/B'--2A!/052!(/'4/!'(L)9D!C,4!45/B49(!,C!OL9,@-56D5R!/052!*'9!B(5! :_!
  15. 15. >'*L!,9!/05!4,B96!F-'95/!E'4/0H!T0'/U(!@02!/0)(!(,4/!,C!45-'/)<)(=!-,(5(! *456)>)-)/2!'(!=,45!5<)659*5!5=54D5(!,<54!/)=5!'96!)9*45'()9D!*,445(F,9659*5! )(!5(/'>-)(056!/04,BD0!=,45!*,9/4,--56!5a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a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!! I4)(/,/-5A!@0,!6)56!)9!%$$!&hA!6)69U/!0'<5!/05!L)96!,C!='/05='/)*(!/0'/!*,B-6! 0'<5!5-5<'/56!0)(!@,4L!/,!/05!0)D054!-5<5-!,C!F45*)(),9!'96!45-)'>)-)/2!/0'/!@'(! '*0)5<56!*59/B4)5(!-'/54H!85!0'6!/,!45-2!,9!9'/B4'-!-'9DB'D5A!@0)*0!-'*L(!/05! 4)D,4!95*5(('42!/,!C4'=5!'96!*,9*-B()<5-2!'9(@54!/05!(*)59/)C)*!WB5(/),9(!05!@'(! )9<5(/)D'/)9DH!85!6)69U/!0'<5!/05!/,,-(A!>5*'B(5!/05!/2F5!,C!='/0!45WB)456!/,! F4,6B*5!'**B4'/5!*,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!*,9(/4B*/56!@)/0)9! 0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'96!/05)4!5a/549'-!O)9(/'9/)'/),9(R!0'6!9,/!>559!65<5-,F56!25/H!! 8+,(#(932"#$B#1/"#3-A;$5'"#3-A$$ OJ4),4!/,!/05!@,4L(!,C!EB*-)6!'4,B96!%""!&hA!e455L!(/B6)5(!)9!='/05='/)*(! ,<54-'FF56!@)/0!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!'96!=2(/)*'-!>5-)5C(R!MhB99)9D/,9!:X"_[!f)95! :#X:[!b'4F)9(L)!:XZS[!gB6='9!$""YNH!]5!/'L5!)/!C,4!D4'9/56!/,6'2A!>B/!5<59! ()=F-5!*'-*B-'/),9(!,C!'4)/0=5/)*!@545!<542!*,=F-5a!/,!*'442!,B/!@)/0)9!/05! -)9DB)(/)*!(2(/5=(!,C!I4)(/,/-5U(!/)=5H!! T05!5'4-)5(/!@4)//59!45*,46(!)96)*'/5!/05!ED2F/)'9(!'96!&'>2-,9)'9(!B(56! '--!/05!5-5=59/'42!'4)/0=5/)*!,F54'/),9(!'(!5'4-2!'(!$"""!&hH!T05(5! '4/)C'*/(!6,!9,/!'-@'2(!45<5'-!/05!(F5*)C)*!F4,*5((!B(56!C,4!(,-<)9D! F4,>-5=(A!>B/!/05!*0'4'*/54)(/)*(!,C!/05!F'4/)*B-'4!9B=54'-!(2(/5=! (/4,9D-2!)9C-B59*5!/05!*,=F-5a)/2!,C!/05!=5/0,6(H!T05!0)54,D-2F0)*! (2(/5=!C,4!ED2F/)'9!9B=54'-(A!-)L5!/05!-'/54!g,='9!9B=54'-(A!65(*59656! C4,=!/'--2!='4L(!B(56!C,4!*,B9/)9DH!V9!>,/0!*'(5(A!/0)(!,4)D)9!45(B-/56!)9! <'-B5(!/0'/!B(56!'!65*)='-!>'(5!>B/!6)6!9,/!)9*-B65!F,()/),9'-!9,/'/),9H! h,=F-5a!*'-*B-'/),9(!@)/0!g,='9!9B=54'-(!45WB)456!/05!'(()(/'9*5!,C!'! *,B9/)9D!>,'46!,4!/05!g,='9!'>'*B(!/,!,>/')9!/05!45(B-/(H! e455L!9B=54'-(A!654)<56!C4,=!/05!0)54'/)*!ED2F/)'9!(2(/5=A!'-(,!-'*L56! F,()/),9'-!9,/'/),9A!'96!/0545C,45!)=F,(56!/05!('=5!*,=F-5a)/2!,9!/05! >'()*!,F54'/),9(!,C!'4)/0=5/)*H!f,4!5a'=F-5A!/05!'9*)59/!='/05='/)*)'9! I4*0)=565(!65<,/56!0)(!59/)45!@,4L!!"#$=/5>$3#.?+5#2!=545-2!/,! 65<)()9D!'!9,/'/),9!C,4!'!*54/')9!-'4D5!)9/5D54H!MhB99)9D/,9!:X"_[!f)95! :#X:[!b'4F)9(L)!:XZS[!gB6='9!$""YN!! ;,/@)/0(/'96)9D!/05!-)9DB)(/)*!-)=)/'/),9(A!EB*-)6U(!%,#*#5)(!@'(!/05!C)4(/!/5a/!/,! *-5'4-2!5(/'>-)(0!e5,=5/42!@)/0!4)D,4,B(!F4,,C(!654)<56!C4,=!'a),=(H!EB*-)6!@'(! /0,BD0/!/,!0'<5!'//59656!J-'/,U(!+*0,,-!)9!I/059(!'96!@'(!'*/)<5!)9!I-5a'964)'! 6B4)9D!/05!45)D9!,C!J/,-5=2!V!C4,=!%$%!/,!$#%!&hH!8)(!>,,LA!%,#*#5)(A!@'(!'! F4)='42!/5a/>,,L!C,4!='/0!/0'/!*,9/)9B56!/,!>5!B(56!BF!/,!/05!-'/5!:X/0!*59/B42! :S!
  16. 16. M.'*'46-5A!5/!'-H!$""#NH!T05!L)96!,C!F4,,C(!65<5-,F56!)9!D5,=5/42!)=F,(5!4)D,4! ,9!/05!-)9DB)(/)*!C4'=5!/0'/!)(!B(56!/,!*,9(/4B*/!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!@)/0)9!0B='9! *,D9)/),9H!+/4B)L!M:XZYN!*,9*-B65(A!O/05)4!-,D)*'-!(/4B*/B45!0'(!)9C-B59*56! (*)59/)C)*!/0)9L)9D!F540'F(!=,45!/0'9!'92!,/054!/5a/!)9!/05!@,4-6R!MFH!S:NH! I-/0,BD0!='92!,C!/05!45(B-/(!)9!%,#*#5)(!,4)D)9'/56!@)/0!5'4-)54! ='/05='/)*)'9(A!,95!,C!EB*-)6o(!'**,=F-)(0=59/(!@'(!/,!F45(59/!/05=!)9! '!()9D-5A!-,D)*'--2!*,05459/!C4'=5@,4LA!='L)9D!)/!5'(2!/,!B(5!'96!5'(2!/,! 45C5459*5A!)9*-B6)9D!'!(2(/5=!,C!4)D,4,B(!='/05='/)*'-!F4,,C(!/0'/! 45=')9(!/05!>'()(!,C!='/05='/)*(!$%!*59/B4)5(!-'/54H!M+/4B)L!:XZYN! V/!)(!/04,BD0!/0)(!-)9DB)(/)*!4)D,4!/0'/!/05!'>(/4'*/),9(!'96!/05!'((,*)'/56! 45'(,9)9D!>5*,=5!*,9(/4')956!>2!/05!O)9(/'9/)'/),9(R!,C!/05!5a/549'-! 59<)4,9=59/A!9,/!/05!@0)=(!,C!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'96!/05!4565C)9)/),9!F,(()>-5! /0545)9!M<)(!'!<)(!f5254'>596!:XYSNH!V9!/0)(!@'2A!EB*-)6!*'9!>5!(559!'(!>B)-6)9D! /05!-)9DB)(/)*!>4)6D5!/,!/05!45'-)(=!,C!K9/,-,D)*'-!J-B4'-)(=!'96!/05!C,B96'/),9(! ,C!K9/,-,D)*'-!`9)/2A!@0)*0!V!@)--!65(*4)>5!)9!/05!95a/!(5*/),9H! V/U(!/0)(!-)9DB)(/)*!>4)6D5!/0'/!5='9*)F'/5(!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!C4,=!J-'/,U(! =2/0,-,D2!'96!)9/4,6B*5(!/05!*,9(/4')9/(!,C!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!I>(,-B/5! /4B/0!*'9!>5!5(/'>-)(056!/04,BD0!4)D,4,B(!F4,,C!>'(56!,9!/05!*,445(F,9659*5! >5/@559!/05!='FF)9D(!,C!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!'96!/05!5<)659*5!C4,=!/05!5a/549'-! 59<)4,9=59/H!V/U(!/05!'**B4'*2!,C!/0)(!*,445(F,9659*5!/0'/!)(!/05!(,B4*5!,C! -5D)/)='*2A!>B/!65<5-,F)9D!'**B4'/5!*,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!'>(/4'*/! /05,45/)*'-!=,65-(!'96!5a/549'-!O)9(/'9/)'/),9(R!/'L5(!/)=5H!V/!45WB)45(! (/'96'46)Q56!=5/4)*(!'96!'!=,45!C,4='-!-)9DB)(/)*!C4'=5!@0545!65C)9)/),9(!'96! =5'9)9D!'45!=,45!4)D)6!'96!*,9()(/59/!/0'9!)9!9'/B4'-!-'9DB'D5H!! T0)(!-)9DB)(/)*!(0)C/!5=54D5(!(-,@-2!'(!F5,F-5!65<5-,F!/05!*'F'*)/2!/,!*'-*B-'/5! =5'9)9D!)9!=,45!4)D,4,B(!@'2(H!?B4)9D!@0)*0!/)=5A!@5!*'9!(55!'9!,<54-'F! >5/@559!/05!(,*)'--2P*,9(/4B*/56!9'44'/)<5(!M=2/0,-,D2c)65,-,D2N!'96!/05! 9'44'/)<5!,C!5<)659*5!C4,=!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!/0'/!-5'6(!/,!,9/,-,D)*'-! 45'-)(=!@)/0)9!'!F-B4'-)(=!,C!6)CC5459/!(5/(!,C!4B-5(!C,4!='L)9D!(59(5!,C! ,>(54<'/),9(H!! gB((5--!M:XY$N!(F,L5!,C!'!D,,6!5a'=F-5!,C!/0)(!)9!J/,-5=')*!'(/4,9,=2H!h-'B6)B(! J/,-5='5B(!65<5-,F56!0)(!D5,*59/4)*!=,65-!,C!/05!B9)<54(5!)9!/05!$96!*59/B42! I?A!@)/0!)/(!65C5459/(!'96!5F)*2*-5(A!'96!)/!@'(!B(56!C,4!:AS""!25'4(!BF!/,!/05! -'/5!g59')(('9*5H!?B4)9D!/0)(!/)=5A!5<)659*5!@'(!B(56!C4,=!/05!-,*'/),9!,C!(/'4(! '96!F-'95/(!/,!65/54=)95!@05/054!,4!9,/!/05!*,=F-5a!*'-*B-'/),9(!@545!'**B4'/5H! T0)(!F4,<)656!/05!>'()(!C,4!'!=,45!k45'-)(/)*U!<)5@!/0'/!*,9C)4=56!/05!-5D)/)='*2! ,C!L9,@-56D5A!9,/!/05!=2/0,-,D)*'-!,4!)65,-,D)*'-!>5-)5C(!,C!*B-/B4'-!9'44'/)<5(H!!! E<)659*5!C4,=!,>(54<'/),9(!=,(/-2!(BFF,4/56!/05!*,9*-B(),9(!45'*056!<)'!/05! *,=F-5a!*'-*B-'/),9(!,C!5F)*2*-5(H!8,@5<54A!*B-/B4'-!9'44'/)<5(!*,B-6!'-(,!>5! =')9/')956!'(!-5D)/)='/5!)9!'!()65P>2P()65!*,P5<,-B/),9H!V9!/0)(!(0)C/!/,@'46(! 45'-)(=A!,>(54<'/),9(!,C!05'<59-2!>,6)5(!@545!B(56!/,!-596!*456)>)-)/2!/,!*-')=(! ,C!*,995*/),9!/,!/05!(BF549'/B4'-H!&B/!'(!/05!*-'(05(!>5/@559!*B-/B4'-!9'44'/)<5! '96!5=F)4)*'-!5<)659*5!>5D'9!/,!>5*,=5!=,45!F4,9,B9*56A!-5((!*,445(F,9659*5! 5=54D56!>5/@559!@0'/!='65!(59(5!*B-/B4'--2!'96!@0'/!='65!(59(5!@)/0)9!/05! 5<)659*5!C4,=!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/A!@0)*0!CB5-56!*,9C-)*/H!! :Z!
  17. 17. ! K9/,-,D)*'-!J-B4'-)(=!B(5(!)9*45'()9D!*,445(F,9659*5! >5/@559!'>(/4'*/!=,65-(!'96!5a/549'-!5<)659*5!/,! 45*,9*)-5!/05!*,9C-)*/)9D!<)5@(!05-6!>2!6)CC5459/!,>(54<54(H! 8,@5<54A!/05!45-'/)<)(=!,C!*,9(59(B(P>'(56!-5D)/)='*2!)(! F'4/)'--2!=')9/')956!)9!/05!O=B-/)F-5!45'-)/)5(R!/0'/!'FF5'4! /,!5a)(/!>5/@559!/05!6)CC5459/!*B-/B4'-!C4'=5(!,C!,>(54<54(H! ])/0)9!/0)(!F-B4'-)(=A!<'-)6)/2!)(!(/)--!5(/'>-)(056!@)/0)9!/05! *B-/B4'-!C4'=5!,C!6)CC5459/!,>(54<54(!'96!/059!0'(!/,!>5! /4'9(-'/56!'96!95D,/)'/56!>5/@559!/05(5!=B-/)F-5!45'-)/)5(H! I-/0,BD0!D45'/54!*,445(F,9659*5!)(!'*0)5<56A!/05!45-'/)<)(=!/0'/!)(!(/)--!F45(59/! B9654=)95(!*-')=(!,C!'>(,-B/5!/4B/0!'96!*54/')9/2!)9!L9,@-56D5!D5954'/),9H!V9! ,/054!@,46(A!@5!(/)--!='L5!/05!4B-5(A!'96!'B/0,4)/2!)(!=')9/')956!/04,BD0! F54),6)*A!*,9C)4='/,42!45C5459*5!/,!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!T0)(!@,4L(!C,4!'! @0)-5A!:AS""!25'4(!)9!/05!J/,-5=')*!.,65-U(!*'(5A!>B/!'(!@5!@)--!(55!)9!/05!*,9C-)*/! >5/@559!e'-)-5,!'96!/05!h'/0,-)*!h0B4*0U(!*B-/B4'-!9'44'/)<5A!)/!)(!B-/)='/5-2! B9(B(/')9'>-5H!!! VC!@5!*0,,(5!,9/,-,D)*'-!F-B4'-)(=!'(!/05!>'()(!C,4!<'-)6)/2A! /059!@5!'45!-,*L56!)9/,!'9!596-5((!*,9C-)*/!>5/@559! 45-'/)<)(=!'96!45'-)(=H!]5!'*L9,@-56D5!/0'/!(,=5!/4B/0! 6,5(!5a)(/A!5a/549'-!/,!0B='9!*,D9)/),9A!,B/!)9!/05! 59<)4,9=59/!)9!@0)*0!@5!'-(,!5a)(/H!&B/A!@5!*-)9D!/,!/05! *B-/B4'-!9'44'/)<5(!/0'/!F4,<)65!'!>4,'654!*,9(59(B(P >'(56!C4'=5@,4L!)9!@0)*0!@5!='L5!(59(5!,C!0,@!/05! 5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!@,4L(H!T0)(!*45'/5(!=B-/)F-5! 45'-)/)5(!/0'/!6)CC5459/!D4,BF(!=')9/')9!'96!(0'45!'(!/05! >'()(!C,4!@0'/!/052!*,9()654!-5D)/)='/5H!T05!(,F0)(/)*'/),9!,C!/5*09)WB5(!B(56!)9! L9,@-56D5!D5954'/),9A!-)L5!/05!*'-*B-'/),9!,C!5F)*2*-5(A!)(!/059!B(56!/,!'66! 405/,4)*'-!'FF5'-!'96!>,-(/54!/4B/0!*-')=(A!>5*'B(5!/052!*'99,/!45(/!,9!/05! 5<)659*5!'-,95!/0'/!5=54D5(!C4,=!/05!5a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a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H! ]4)D0/!M$""ZN!=,45!45*59/-2!'4DB56!C,4!'!O(*)59/)C)*!45'-)(=AR!@0)*0!(/'96(!)9! ,FF,()/),9!/,!J-'/,!'96!/05!F,()/)<)(/)*!=5/0,6(!/0'/!45(/!,9!gB((5--U(!-,D)*)(=! '96!)/(!OB9)9(/'9/)'/56!C,4=(AR!>B/!'-(,!(/,F(!@5--!(0,4/!,C!/05!45-'/)<)(=!,C! *,9(/4B*/)<)(/!=5/0,6(H!8)(!-59D/02!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!6)(*B((),9(!'>,B/!,9/,-,D2! '96!5F)(/5=,-,D2!(55=!/,!)96)*'/5!/0'/!'!=,<5!/,@'46(!)9*45'(56! *,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!'>(/4'*/!=,65-(!'96!5a/549'-!5<)659*5!@,B-6!F4,6B*5! :Y!
  18. 18. /0)(!O(*)59/)C)*!45'-)(=HR!8,@5<54A!05!F4,<)65(!9,!-)9DB)(/)*!>4)6D5!/,!D5/!/0545H! 8)(!59/)45!'9'-2()(!)(!9'44'/)<5!F0)-,(,F02A!9,/!='/05='/)*'-H!V/!)(!>'(56!,9! 9'/B4'-!-'9DB'D5!'96!*B-/B4'-!C4'=5(!,C!(59(5!='L)9D!@)/0!'--!/05!=B-/)F-5! =5'9)9D(!'96!'=>)DB)/)5(!/052!*,9/')9!M&'9('-!#)$/,A!$":$A!F#"P#:NH!8)(! 5aF-'9'/),9(!'45!0)D0-2!'>(/4'*/!'96!6)CC)*B-/!/,!F-'*5!)9!'!*,9/5a/!/0'/!,/054! ,>(54<54(!*'9!5'()-2!='L5!(59(5!,CA!C)96!*,05459*5!)9A!'96!45C54!>'*L!/,A!B9-)L5! EB*-)6U(!D5,=5/4)*!F4,,C(H! ]4)D0/!(55=(!/,!>5!,9!/05!4,'6!/,!45(,-B/),9A!@0)*0!>5D(!/05!WB5(/),9!,C!@0'/! -)9DB)(/)*!)99,<'/),9!*,B-6!05-F!=,<5!*,9(59(B(!/,@'46(!*,445(F,9659*5!#5$ */((#A!C'*)-)/'/)9D!/05!(0)C/!C4,=!/05!45-'/)<)(=!)9!,9/,-,D)*'-!5=54D59*5!/,!=,45! ,C!/05!45'-)(=!,C!,9/,-,D)*'-!F-B4'-)(=G! ]5!*'9!'9(@54!/0)(!WB5(/),9!>2!-,,L)9D!>'*L!'/!0,@!/05!('=5!(0)C/!@'(!='65! >5/@559!/05!/)=5!,C!J/,-5='5B(!'96!;)*0,-'(!h,F549)*B(!M:S_%NH!K9*5!'D')9A!@5! (55!CB4/054!65<5-,F=59/!)9!/05!='/05='/)*'-!C4'=5!/0'/!='65!*'-*B-'/),9(! 5'()54!'96!=,45!*,9()(/59/H!T0)(!5aF'9656!'96!(/459D/05956!/05!-)9DB)(/)*! >4)6D5!(/'4/56!>2!EB*-)6A!='L)9D!)/!5'()54!/,!5(/'>-)(0!*,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559! '>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'96!O)9(/'9/)'/),9(R!)9!/05!5a/549'-! 59<)4,9=59/H!! T05!D4'6B'-!65<5-,F=59/!,C!8)96BPI4'>)*!9B=54'-(!)965F59659/-2! 65<)(56!/05!F-'*5P<'-B5!*,9*5F/!'96!F,()/),9'-!9,/'/),9A!@0)*0!*,=>)956! /05!()=F-54!=5/0,6(!C,4!*,=FB/'/),9(!@)/0!'!65*)='-!>'(5!'96!/05!B(5!,C! '!6)D)/!45F45(59/)9D!Q54,H!T0)(!'--,@56!/05!(2(/5=!/,!*,9()(/59/-2! 45F45(59/!>,/0!-'4D5!'96!(='--!)9/5D54(H!T0)(!'FF4,'*0!5<59/B'--2! 45F-'*56!'--!,/054!(2(/5=(H!! I-/0,BD0!/05!h,65a!d)D)-'9B(!65(*4)>56!'9!5'4-2!C,4=!,C!I4'>)*!9B=54'-(! M,=)//)9D!Q54,N!>2!XYZ!I?A!f)>,9'**)!@'(!F4)='4)-2!45(F,9()>-5!C,4! (F45'6)9D!/05)4!B(5!/04,BD0,B/!EB4,F5!'C/54!/05!FB>-)*'/),9!,C!0)(!>,,L! A'8#2$B8/.'!)9!:$"$H!85!*,9()65456!/05!()D9)C)*'9*5!,C!/0)(!q95@q! 45F45(59/'/),9!,C!9B=>54(A!@0)*0!05!(/2-56!/05!q.5/0,6!,C!/05!V96)'9(q! M7'/)9!9+><($C5>+2<*NA!(,!CB96'=59/'-!/0'/!'--!45-'/56!='/05='/)*'-! C,B96'/),9(A!)9*-B6)9D!/05!45(B-/(!,C!J2/0'D,4'(!'96!/05!'-D,4)(=! 65(*4)>)9D!/05!=5/0,6(!C,4!F54C,4=)9D!'*/B'-!*'-*B-'/),9(A!@545!q'-=,(/!'! =)(/'L5q!)9!*,=F'4)(,9H! T05!C-,B4)(0)9D!,C!'-D5>4'!)9!/05!=56)5<'-!V(-'=)*!@,4-6!'96!)9! g59')(('9*5!EB4,F5!@'(!'9!,B/D4,@/0!,C!/05!59,4=,B(!()=F-)C)*'/),9!,C! *,=FB/'/),9!/04,BD0!65*)='-!9,/'/),9H!MhB99)9D/,9!:X"_[!f)95!:#X:[! b'4F)9(L)!:XZS[!gB6='9!$""YN! T05(5!'6<'9*5(!@545!-'4D5-2!-)9DB)(/)*H!T0'/!)(!/,!('2!/0'/!/052!'45!>'(56!,9!0,@! @5!(2=>,-)*'--2!45F45(59/!/05!F4,*5((!,C!*'-*B-'/),9H!I(!=,45!F5,F-5!C4,=! 6)<54(5!*,9/5a/(!>5D'9!/,!'6,F/!/05!('=5!F4,*5((5(!,C!*'-*B-'/),9A!D45'/54! *,9(59(B(!*,B-6!>5!45'*056!>5/@559!@0'/!*,B9/56!'(!'9!'**B4'/5-2! *,445(F,9656!=,65-!'96!@0'/!6)6!9,/H!T0)(!)9/54(B>^5*/)<5!F4,*5((!)(!@0'/! =,<5(!/05!>'()(!,C!-5D)/)='*2!'@'2!C4,=!*,9(59(B(!/,@'46(!*,445(F,9659*5H!]5! *'9!(55!0,@!/0)(!0'FF5956!@)/0!h,F549)*B(U!05-),*59/4)*!=,65-!M:S_%N!'96!/05! 5<)659*5!/0'/!e'-)-5,!M:Z"XN!,>(54<56!/04,BD0!0)(!/5-5(*,F5!'96!FB>-)(056!/,! :#!
  19. 19. (BFF,4/!/05!<'-)6)/2!,C!@0'/!h,F549)*B(!*-')=56H!I-/0,BD0!/0)(!=,65-!@'(!'-(,! -'/54!(0,@9!/,!>5!)9*,=F-5/5!'96!9,/!CB--2!'**B4'/5A!/05!5<)659*5!*,--5*/56!>2! e'-)-5,!(B><54/56!/05!>4,'654!/4B/0!*-')=(!@)/0)9!/05!*B-/B4'-!9'44'/)<5!,C!/05! h'/0,-)*!h0B4*0A!>5*'B(5!/05!5<)659*5!C4,=!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!9,!-,9D54! *,445(F,9656!/,!/05!5aF-'9'/),9(!D)<59!>2!'B/0,4)/)5(!)9!/05!*0B4*0H!I92! ,>(54<54!*,B-6!<)5@!/05!5a/549'-!5<)659*5!'96!45F5'/!/05!*'-*B-'/),9(!/,!<'-)6'/5! /05!*,9*-B(),9(H! b5F-54!6)6!^B(/!/0'/!@)/0!0)(!:Z"X!'96!:Z:X!*'-*B-'/),9(!/0'/!'**B4'/5-2! F456)*/56!/05!/4'9()/!,C!d59B(!)9!:Z%:H!85!CB4/054!<'-)6'/56!/0)(!95@!-)9DB)(/)*! C4'=5U(!'>)-)/2!/,!5(/'>-)(0!D45'/54!*,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R! '96!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!&B/!/05!-)9DB)(/)*!C4'=5!/0'/!b5F-54!B(56!/,!6,!0)(! *'-*B-'/),9(!@'(!(/)--!9,/!/05!='/0!/0'/!@5!L9,@!/,6'2H!;,4!@'(!5<542,95! F54(B'656!'/!/05!/)=5!>2!/05!'**B4'*2!,C!0)(!F456)*/),9(H!V/!/,,L!/05!h'/0,-)*! h0B4*0!'9,/054!_""!25'4(!>5C,45!(0)C/)9D!)/(!,@9!*,9(59(B(P>'(56!-5D)/)='*2! /,@'46(!/05!=,45!45'-)(/)*!F,()/),9!/'L59!>2!e'-)-5,H! f,4!(,=5/0)9D!/0'/!(55=(!(,!,><),B(!/,6'2A!@02!6,5(!)/!/'L5!(,!-,9D!C,4! )9(/)/B/),9'-)Q56!'B/0,4)/2!/,!='L5!(B*0!(0)C/(A!@059!-,9D!5aF54)59*5! 65=,9(/4'/5(!/0'/!)/!-5'6(!B(!/,!(,!=B*0!F4,D45((!'96!65<5-,F=59/H!! 7B96P?5'9!'96!3,--2!M$":$N!D)<5!B(!(,=5!=,6549!)9()D0/!>2!-,,L)9D!'/!/05!('=5! L)96!,C!5<)659*5!'(!e'-)-5,H!T052!'(L!/05!('=5!WB5(/),9!'>,B/!-5'49)9D!)9!D5954'-! '96!@02!F5,F-5!45()(/!)/H!T052!'9(@54!/05!WB5(/),9A!9,/!>2!-,,L)9D!/04,BD0! e'-)-5,U(!/5-5(*,F5A!>B/!>2!-,,L)9D!/04,BD0!/05!=)*4,(*,F5!,C!95B4,(*)59*5!)9/,! /05!95B4,*05=)*'-!)9/54'*/),9(!/0'/!D)<5!4)(5!/,!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!)/(5-CH!T052! 65(*4)>5!@0'/!0'FF59(!)9!/05!*,9C-)*/(!>5/@559!/05!O=B-/)F-5!45'-)/)5(R!,C! ,9/,-,D)*'-!F-B4'-)(=! T0)(!)(!'!*05=)*'-!'*/),9!)9!/05!>4')9A!'96!F4,<,*'/)<5!5aF54)59*5(!/4)DD54! 5=,/),9'-!*05=)*'-!45'*/),9(H!J,()/)<5!5aF54)59*5(!C'*)-)/'/5!-5'49)9DA! >4)9D)9D!'!C55-)9D!,C!F-5'(B45H!;5D'/)<5!5aF54)59*5(!/4)DD54!(/45((!,4!C5'4A! F,/59/)'--2!6'='D)9D!'45'(!,C!/05!>4')9!'((,*)'/56!@)/0!-5'49)9D!M(55!rB--A! $""$1!#:s#%A!C,4!'!CB--54!65(*4)F/),9NH!MF$%:N! +,A!@059!@5!59*,B9/54!/05!*,9C-)*/(!,C!45-'/)<)(=!/0'/!'4)(5!C4,=!6)CC5459/! *B-/B4'-!9'44'/)<5(!>5)9D!B(56!'(!/05!(,B4*5!,C!<'-)6!L9,@-56D5A!/0)(!)95<)/'>-2! -5'6(!/,!'9!5a)(/59/)'-!*4)()(!@)/0)9!,9/,-,D)*'-!F-B4'-)(=H!T05!*4)()(!5=54D5(! >5*'B(5!)C!5<542/0)9D!)(!=545-2!*,9(/4B*/56!)9!/05!=)96A!'96!9,!45'-!/4B/0!5a)(/(A! /059!0,@!6,!V!L9,@!/0'/!V!5a)(/G! T0)(!*'9!/4)DD54!/05!C5'4!/0'/!7B96P?5'9!'96!3,--2!45C54!/,A!>5*'B(5!)/!(BDD5(/(! /0'/!@5!*'9!95<54!L9,@!'92/0)9D!C,4!(B45H!T05!B9*54/')9/2!/4)DD54(!/05!(/45((!,4! C5'4!MrB--!$""$1!#:P#%NH!g595!?5(*'4/5(!M:Z%YN!*,9C4,9/56!/0)(!*4)()(!>2! '9(@54)9D!/05!WB5(/),9!,C!,9/,-,D2!@)/0!O*,D)/,!54D,!(B=AR!,C/59!/4'9(-'/56!)9! E9D-)(0!'(!OV!/0)9LA!/0545C,45!V!'=HR!V9!6,)9D!(,A!05!'*L9,@-56D56!/05!6)(/)9*/),9! >5/@559!/05!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!@5!*,9(/4B*/!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'96!/05! 5a/549'-!@,4-6!/0'/!>4)9D(!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!)/(5-C!)9/,!5a)(/59*5H!! .'/05='/)*'--2A!?5(*'4/5(!/4'9(-'/56!D5,=5/4)*!F4,,C(!)9/,!'-D5>4')*! C,4=B-'/),9(A!*45'/)9D!'!-)9DB)(/)*!(2(/5=!/0'/!,F54'/),9'-)Q56!/05!*'-*B-'/),9(! :X!
  20. 20. *,96B*/56!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9H!T0)(!5a/59656!/05!-)9DB)(/)*!>4)6D5!/0'/!'--! ,>(54<54(!*'9!B(5!/,!>5//54!5(/'>-)(0!4)D,4,B(!*,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!/05! '>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!'96!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!! 85!@'(!C)4(/!/,!'(()D9!'!CB96'=59/'-!F-'*5!C,4!'-D5>4'!)9!,B4!(2(/5=!,C! L9,@-56D5A!'96!>5-)5<56!/0'/!ABHGMNA!OAL!A!IGEPKD!EK!AQEKIAEG!KN! IGJPARCSG!NGALKRCRHA!F'4/)*B-'4-2!'>,B/!'>(/4'*/A!B9L9,@9!WB'9/)/)5(H! EB4,F5'9!='/05='/)*)'9(!0'6!F45<),B(-2!<)5@56!D5,=5/42!'(!'!=,45! CB96'=59/'-!C,4=!,C!='/05='/)*(A!(54<)9D!'(!/05!C,B96'/),9!,C!'-D5>4'H! I-D5>4')*!4B-5(!@545!D)<59!D5,=5/4)*!F4,,C(!>2!='/05='/)*)'9(!(B*0!'(! J'*),-)A!h'46'9A!T'4/'D-)'!'96!f544'4)H!EWB'/),9(!,C!65D455!0)D054!/0'9!/05! /0)46!@545!45D'4656!'(!B945'-A!>5*'B(5!'!/0455!6)=59(),9'-!C,4=A!(B*0!'(! '!*B>5A!,**BF)56!/05!-'4D5(/!6)=59(),9!,C!45'-)/2H!?5(*'4/5(!F4,C5((56!/0'/! /05!'>(/4'*/!WB'9/)/2!'$!*,B-6!45F45(59/!-59D/0!'(!@5--!'(!'9!'45'H!T0)(! @'(!)9!,FF,()/),9!/,!/05!/5'*0)9D(!,C!='/05='/)*)'9(A!(B*0!'(!d)5/'A!@0,! '4DB56!/0'/!)/!*,B-6!45F45(59/!,9-2!'45'H!I-/0,BD0!?5(*'4/5(!6)6!9,/! FB4(B5!/05!(B>^5*/A!05!F45*5656!75)>9)Q!)9!59<)(),9)9D!'!=,45!D5954'-! (*)59*5!,C!'-D5>4'!,4!qB9)<54('-!='/05='/)*(Aq!'(!'!F45*B4(,4!/,!(2=>,-)*! -,D)*A!/0'/!*,B-6!59*,=F'((!-,D)*'-!F4)9*)F-5(!'96!=5/0,6(!(2=>,-)*'--2A! '96!IGJPARCSG!HGRGNAB!NGALKRCRHH!Mb-)95!:XY$A!FH!$#"P$#:N!tE=F0'()(! '6656Hu! T0B(!'9'-2/)*!D5,=5/42!@'(!>,49!-5'6)9D!/,!CB4/054!'6<'9*5=59/(!)9! )9C)9)/5()='-!*'-*B-B(!>2!;5@/,9!'96!75)>9)QH!;5@/,9)'9!F02()*(!(,,9!C,--,@56! M:Z#YNA!@0545!/05!'FF-5!C'=,B(-2!455=54D5(!'(!/05!5=F)4)*'-!5<)659*5!/0'/! )9(F)456!;5@/,9U(!/05,42!,C!B9)<54('-!D4'<)/'/),9H!V9!/0)(!*'(5A!)/!@'(!/05! ='/54)'-!'FF-5!/0'/!05!,>(54<56!C'--)9D!C4,=!'!/455A!9,/!)/(!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=R!/0'/! F4,<)656!/05!(,B4*5!,C!<'-)6)/2H!! I!(/B659/!,C!75)>9)QA!V=='9B5-!b'9/!M:Y#:N!*'B(56!'!Oh,F549)*'9!g5<,-B/),9R!)9! F0)-,(,F02!>2!B()9D!/05!('=5!(,B4*5!,C!<'-)6)/2!/,!WB5(/),9!/05!9'/B45!,C!0,@! /05!>4')9!*,9(/4B*/(!L9,@-56D5!'96!/0545C,45!/05!9'/B45!,C!45'-)/2!)/(5-CH!! b'9/!B(56!/05!95@!B9654(/'96)9D!'>,B/!/05!F4,F54/)5(!,C!-)D0/!/,!*,9(/4B*/!/05! (/,42!,C!0,@!6'/'!C4,=!/05!5a/549'-!@,4-6!59/54(!/05!525(!'96!/0)(!(59(,42!)9FB/! /059!D,5(!/04,BD0!(,=5!L)96!,C!='FF)9D!F4,*5((!)9!/05!>4')9H!! +)9*5!/05!>4')9!@'(! (,=50,@!)9<,-<56!)9! /05!D5954'/),9!,C! 5<542/0)9D!@5! F54*5)<5A!b'9/!'4DB56! /0'/!,B4!L9,@-56D5!,C! /05!@,4-6!@'(!9,/! ='/54)'--2!45'-H!! I/!/05!/)=5A!b'9/!*,B-6! (55!/0'/A!/04,BD0!(,=5! F,,4-2!D4,B9656! F4,*5((A!/05!>4')9!@'(! '*/)<5-2!*,9(/4B*/)9D! $"!
  21. 21. 5<542/0)9D!@5!F'(()<5-2!'96!B9*,9(*),B(-2!F54*5)<5!'(!O45'-RH!T0'/U(!@02!)/!@'(! 9,/!F,(()>-5!/,!6)(/)9DB)(0!>5/@559!@0'/!,95!F54(,9!F54*5)<5(!'(!O45'-R!'96! @0'/!'9,/054!F54(,9!F54*5)<5(!'(!O45'-RH!&,/0!<54(),9(!,C!F54*5)<56!45'-)/2!'45! 5WB'--2!45'-!/,!/05!45(F5*/)<5!F54*5)<54H!859*5A!*-')=(!,C!L9,@-56D5!'96!/4B/0! >5*,=5!45-'/)<5A!9,/!'>(,-B/5H!! ! T0)(!)(!/05!(,B4*5!,C!,9/,-,D)*'-!F-B4'-)(=1!/05!>5-)5C!/0'/!=B-/)F-5!45'-)/)5(!*,P 5a)(/!()=B-/'95,B(-2A!@)/0!9,!()9D-5!45'-)/2!'>-5!/,!*-')=!'92!D45'/54!-5D)/)='*2! /0'9!'92!,C!/05!,/054(H!I96!/0)(!0'(!D)<59!4)(5!/,!/05!6)<)656!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!(/'9*5! /0'/!B9654-)5(!/05!*B4459/!4)D,4P45-5<'9*5!65>'/5!)9!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0H!! ]0'/!F4,F,959/(!,C!,9/,-,D)*'-!F-B4'-)(=!C')-!/,!45*,D9)Q5!)(!/05!6)CC5459*5! >5/@559!*,9(/4B*/),9(!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'96!/05!5<)659*5!C4,=!/05! 5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!)/(5-CH! 8+,(#(932"#$C+3,=;$%/"+-D"/'+,$E23'+2'$$ K9/,-,D)*'-!`9)/2!D)<5(!B(!/4'9(F'459/!(*)59*5!>'(56!,9!/05!5<)659*5!/0'/! 5=54D5(!C4,=!/05!,9/,-,D)*'--2!()9DB-'4A!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/A!9,/!/05!O=B-/)F-5! 45'-)/)5(R!*,9(/4B*/56!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9H!T'L)9D!/0)(!F,()/),9!45WB)45(!/0'/! @5!45^5*/!J-'/,U(!'4DB=59/!/0'/!OB9)9(/'9/)'/56!C,4=(R!'45!<'-)6H!! V9(/5'6A!@5!/'L5!/05!F,()/),9!,C!I4)(/,/-5!'96!45^5*/!/05!)65'!/0'/!0B='9! *,D9)/),9!='L5(!/05!4B-5(!C,4!0,@!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!@,4L(H!]5! '*L9,@-56D5!/05!*2*-)*'-!-)9L!>5/@559!/05!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!'96!/05! O)9(/'9/)'/),9(R!/0'/!F4,<)65!/05!5<)659*5!B(56!)9!/05!='FF)9D!F4,*5((H!V9!/0)(! *'(5A!/05!5<)659*5!(F5'L(!C,4!)/(5-C!'96!45WB)45(!9,!C,4*5CB-!'((54/),9!,C!'B/0,4)/2! /,!>,-(/54!/4B/0!*-')=(H!d'-)6!L9,@-56D5!D5954'/),9!)(!>'(56!,9!/05!65D455!,C! *,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!/05!'>(/4'*/!C,4=(!@5!*,9(/4B*/!)9!*,D9)/),9!'96!/05! 5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!! T0)(!,9/,-,D)*'-!B9)/2!(/'96(!C)4=-2!BF,9!'9!,>^5*/)<5!>,62!,C!5<)659*5!/0'/!*'9! >5!B(56!/,!45*,9*)-5!'92!'96!'--!F54(F5*/)<5(!,C!6)CC5459/!,>(54<54(H!&B/!='FF)9D! )/!45WB)45(!=,45!4)D,4,B(!-)9DB)(/)*!(/'96'46(!/0'9!@0'/!9'/B4'-!-'9DB'D5!*'9! 65-)<54H!I!=,45!4)D,4,B(!-)9DB)(/)*!>4)6D5!=B(/!>5!B(56!/,!59(B45!'96!=')9/')9! $:!
  22. 22. *,9*5F/B'-!'-)D9=59/!'96!*,9()(/59/!(2=>,-)*!45F45(59/'/),9!'**,46)9D!/,! B9)C,4=!4B-5(!,C!6'/'!F4,*5(()9D!@)/0)9!/05!*'-*B-'/),9!,C!=5'9)9DH!! V9!/05!F02()*'-!(*)59*5(A!@5!(55!0,@!/05!(0)C/!/,!,9/,-,D)*'-!B9)/2!/,,L!F-'*5!)9!'9! 5aF-,()<5!@'2!@)/0!/05!'6<59/!,C!WB'9/B=!=5*0'9)*(!'96!E)9(/5)9U(!%$D$*.E! M:X"SNH!V/U(!9,/!/0'/!E)9(/5)9!*'=5!BF!@)/0!/05!O='D)*!9B=>54!>#$@+<2R!/0'/!='65! 0)(!@,4L!-5D)/)='/5A!>B/!/0'/!/05!-)D0/!C4,=!'!(/'4!>50)96!/05!(B9!@'(!<)()>-5! 6B4)9D!'9!5*-)F(5A!*,9C)4=)9D!/0'/!-)D0/!@'(!)9C-B59*56!>2!/05!(B9U(!D4'<)/2H!8)(! /05,45/)*'-!=,65-!*,445(F,9656!/,!/05!5<)659*5!)9!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!! I(!/05!-)9DB)(/)*!>4)6D5!,C!='/0!*,9/)9B56!/,!5a/596!,B4!<)(),9!CB4/054!'96! CB4/054!>52,96!,B4!9'/B4'-!4'9D5!,C!()D0/!/,!/05!(B>'/,=)*!-5<5-A!/05!5a/549'-! 59<)4,9=59/!>5*'=5!/05!()9DB-'4!(,B4*5!,C!<'-)6)/2!)9!65/54=)9)9D!/05!'**B4'*2! ,C!/05,45/)*'-!=,65-(!B(56!)9!/05!D5954'/),9!,C!L9,@-56D5H!V/!)(!C4,=!/0)(!B9)C)56! F0)-,(,F0)*'-!(/'9*5!/0'/!/05!)99,<'/),9(!,C!/05!F'(/!:""!25'4(!)9!F02()*'-! (*)59*5!0'<5!5=54D56A!9,/!C4,=!'92!OB9)9(/'9/)'/56!C,4=(R!,4!/05,45/)*'-!=,65-(! /0'/!,9-2!5a)(/!@)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9H! ;5@/,9)'9!J02()*(!@'(!'!0BD5!)=F4,<5=59/A!>B/!)/!@'(9U/! /05!*,=F-5/5!F)*/B45H!I(!='/0!C4'=5(!*,9/)9B56!/,!5a/596! ,B4!<)(),9A!'9!5<59!*-5'454!F)*/B45!,C!/05!5a/549'-! 59<)4,9=59/!>5D'9!/,!>5!='FF56!,B/!'96!*,445(F,9656! @)/0)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9H!E)9(/5)9!='4L56!/05!(0)C/!C4,=! ,9/,-,D)*'-!F-B4'-)(=!/,!,9/,-,D)*'-!B9)/2A!'/!-5'(/!@)/0)9! /05!F02()*'-!(*)59*5(H!T0545C,45A!@5!*'9!*,9()654! K9/,-,D)*'-!`9)/2!/,!>5!@059!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!='F(!/05! 4B-5(!,C!/05!,9/,-,D)*'--2!()9DB-'4A!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!'96!/05!65D455!,C! '**B4'/5!*,445(F,9659*5!65/54=)95(!/05!='FU(!<'-)6)/2!)9!/05!F4,*5((!,C! L9,@-56D5!D5954'/),9H!! T0)(!F4,*5((!)(!'9!)/54'/)<5!*2*-5A!9,/!'!-)95'4!F4,D45((),9!C4,=!'>(/4'*/!C,4=A!,4! /05,45/)*'-!=,65-A!/,!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/A!'(!)9!F,()/)<)(=H!;,4!)(!)/!'!-)95'4! F4,D45((),9!C4,=!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!/,!/05!'>(/4'*/!C,4=A!,4!/05,45/)*'-! =,65-A!'(!)9!*,9(/4B*/)<)(=H!! V9!/0)(!*'(5A!)/!)(!>,/0H!! &,/0!)96B*/),9!'96!656B*/),9!)9!'!*,9/)9B,B(!*2*-5!/0'/!45WB)45(!-)9DB)(/)*!4)D,4! '96!/4'9(F'459*2!)9!/05!=5*0'9)Q'/),9!,C!45'(,9!/,!5(/'>-)(0!6)45*/! *,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!'96!/05!F059,=59'!>5)9D!=,65-56! C4,=!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!M&'4Q)-')A!$""XN! T0545!'45!*,=F5/)9D!<)5@(!)9!F02()*'-!(*)59*5A!'!F-B4'-)(=! ,C!9'44'/)<5(A!>B/!)/!)(!/05!*,445(F,9659*5!/,!5<)659*5!)9! /05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!/0'/!0'(!5=54D56!'(!/05!(,B4*5! ,C!-5D)/)='*2A!9,/!/05!/05,45/)*'-!=,65-(!*,9(/4B*/56!)9! 0B='9!*,D9)/),9H!T0'/!*,445(F,9659*5!)(!<'-)6'/56! /04,BD0!/05!-)9DB)(/)*!4)D,4(!,C!>'()*!='/0H! VC!@5!B(5!/05!(,*)'--2!*,9(/4B*/56!9'44'/)<5(!,C!*B-/B45!'(! /05!4B-5(!C,4!@0'/!)(!-,D)*'-!'96!@0'/!='L5(!(59(5A!/059! $$!
  23. 23. @5!596!BF!@)/0!'--!/05!F4,>-5=(!,C!)=F45*)(5!'96!)9*,9()(/59/!-'9DB'D5!'96! 4565C)9)/),9!/0'/!='4L(!h,9(/4B*/)<)(=H!VC!@5!'*L9,@-56D5!/05!-)9DB)(/)*!4)D,4!'/! /05!CB96'=59/'-!596!,C!='/0!'96!B(5!)/!/,!*-'4)C2!'96!'9*0,4!=5'9)9D!/,!/05! 5=F)4)*'-!9'44'/)<5!,C!5<)659*5!C4,=!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/A!/059!@5!D5/!'--! /05!*-'4)/2!'96!)99,<'/),9!/0'/!,9/,-,D)*'-!B9)/2!*'9!65-)<54!)9!/05!65<5-,F=59/! ,C!/4'9(F'459/!(*)59*5!'96!/5*09,-,D2H!! T0)(!)(!9,/!/'L)9D!/05!OL9,@-56D5!,C!)9/549'-!*,D9)/),9R!'(!>5)9D!/4B/0A!'(! '((B=56!>2!J,()/)<)(=A!>B/!(55L)9D!/,!5(/'>-)(0!*,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!/05! )9/549'-!='FF)9D(!'96!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!@)/0!'!:1:!4'/),!(*'-5!,C! '**B4'*2H!75D)/)='*2!)(!5(/'>-)(056!/04,BD0!'9!)/54'/)<5!*2*-5!,C!65<5-,F=59/A! 9,/!'!,95P@'2!-)95'4!F4,D45((),9!C4,=!5a)(/)9D!/05,45/)*'-!=,65-(!/,!02F,/05()(! /5(/)9D!,C!*,445-'/),9(!>5/@559!(5-5*/!<'4)'>-5(A!C,--,@56!>2!*,=F-5a! /4'9(-'/),9(!>5/@559!*B-/B4'-!*,9/5a/(!@)/0!9,!65C)9)/)<5!*,9*-B(),9(!5<54! F,(()>-5!M'(!)9!KU&4)59A!$":"NH!! ]059!@5!='65!/05!(0)C/!/,!,9/,-,D)*'-!B9)/2!)9!F02()*'-!(*)59*5A!'--!,C!/05!6)<54(5! F54(F5*/)<5(!,C!6)CC5459/!*B-/B4'-!C4'=5(!>5*'=5!5WB'-H!T052!'45!'--!5WB'-!)9!/0'/! /052!F4,<)65!'!CB9*/),9'-A!>B/!)9*,=F-5/5!<)5@!,C!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!)9! @0)*0!@5!'--!,F54'/5H!T0)(!F,()/),9!45WB)45(!(,=5!)9/5--5*/B'-!0B=)-)/2!/,! '*L9,@-56D5A!>B/!)/!5-)=)9'/5(!/05!9556!/,!*,=F5/5!C,4!6,=)9'9*5!)9!/05! 5a54*)(5!,C!'B/0,4)/2H!K9!/05!*,9/4'42A!='L)9D!/05!(0)C/!59'>-5(!/05!<'-B5!)9! 6)<54()/2!,C!F54(F5*/)<5!/,!5=54D5A!>5*'B(5!5'*0!*B-/B4'-!C4'=5!*,9/')9(!<'-B'>-5! )9C,4='/),9!M8'Q2!$":$N!'>,B/!/05!-'4D54!F)*/B45!,C!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/! /0'/!9,!()9D-5!,95!CB--2!*'F/B45(H!! E,",'$()$,>'$F/,$3+$<"+"9'A'+,$5'-'"/2>$ ?5<)9952!'96!+)5D5-!M$":$N!45*59/-2!(B=='4)Q56!/05!(/'/5!,C!,B4!6)(*)F-)951! .'9'D5=59/!)(!'9!'='-D'=!,C!C,B4!(,*)'-!(*)59*5!6)(*)F-)95(1!F(2*0,-,D2A! (,*),-,D2A!5*,9,=)*(A!'96A!/,!'!-5((54!5a/59/A!F,-)/)*'-!(*)59*5H!V9!/05(5! (,*)'-!(*)59*5(A!OF4,,CR!)(!0'46-2!'>(,-B/5A!'96!^,B49'-(!(5-6,=!FB>-)(0! /05!/2F5!,C!*,9/4,--56!(/B62!,95!,>(54<5(!)9!/05!F02()*'-!(*)59*5(H!]0'/! '6<'9*5(!5'*0!(,*)'-!(*)59*5!)(!/05!'>)-)/2!/,!65/54=)95!/05!<54'*)/2!,C! /05,4)5(!/0'/!'45!5<,-<)9DA!>'(56!,9!WB'9/)/'/)<5!'96!WB'-)/'/)<5!5<)659*5H! MF:N! ])--)'=(!M$""%N!>4)9D(!B(!C4,=!gB((5--U(!*,9/4)>B/),9(!/,!-,D)*)(=!M:X"%N!BF!/,! /05!F45(59/!65>'/5!,<54!4)D,4!<54(B(!45-5<'9*5A!@0545!/05!O-,D)*'-!F,()/)<)(/!C,4=! 6,=)9'/56!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!/0)9L)9D!'>,B/!9'/B4'-!'96!(,*)'-!(*)59*5!)9!/05!C)4(/! 0'-C!,C!/05!/@59/)5/0!*59/B42HR! T05!)9C-B59*5!,9!(,*)'-!45(5'4*0!@'(!9,/!B(B'--2!6)45*/A!>B/!=B*0!=,45! <)'!/05!)=F,4/'9*5!'//'*056!/,!(/'/)(/)*'-!5<)659*5!'96!/05!*,9(5WB59/! F4),4)/)Q'/),9!,C!(/'/)(/)*'-!6'/'!C,4!F,-)*2P='L)9DA!F'4/)*B-'4-2!)9!/05! `9)/56!+/'/5(!M(55!J-'//A!:XXZNH!+,*)'-!45(5'4*0!@'(!6,=)9'/56!>2!'! F4,C5((),9!k/4')956!)9!(/'/)(/)*'-!=5/0,6(A!@)/0!=B/B'--2!45)9C,4*)9D! =,/)<'/),9(!/,!@)9!F4,=,/),9!'96!F4,6B*5!/05!OC'*/(R!955656!>2!='2,4(A! F45()659/(!'96!*,4F,4'/),9(U!M.'9)*'(A!:X#Y1!$$ZNH!T05!=5/0,6(!,C!/0)(! F54),6!@545!F4)='4)-2!/05!(,*)'-!(B4<52A!)9!@0)*0!(/'96'46)Q56!6'/'!@545! $%!
  24. 24. *,--5*/56!C4,=!)659/)C)56!D4,BF(!)9!/05!F,FB-'/),9!,9!'!4'9D5!,C!/,F)*(!'(! 6)<54(5!'(!F,-)/)*'-!F,--)9D!'96!'4=2!-)C5H!M])--)'=(!$""%N! J5'4*5!'96!8B'9D!M$":$N!45=)96!B(A!! .,45!/0'9!S"!25'4(!'D,!/05!f,46!Me,46,9!!8,@5--A!:XSXN!'96!h'495D)5! f,B96'/),9(!MJ)54(,9A!:XSXN!'4DB56!/0'/!I=54)*'9!B9)<54()/2!>B()95((! (*0,,-(!(0,B-6!(0)C/!C4,=!5aF54)59*56!5a5*B/)<5(!'(!/5'*054(!/,@'46! =,45!5=F0'()(!,9!/05!(*0,-'4P/5'*054!=,65-!,C!56B*'/),9!F45<'-59/!)9! /05!,/054!(,*)'-!(*)59*5(H!I)656!>2!/05!(B>(/'9/)'-!CB96(!F4,<)656!>2! /0,(5!C,B96'/),9(A!I=54)*'9!='9'D5=59/!(*0,,-(!='65!/0'/!(0)C/! >5D)99)9D!)9!/05!:XZ"(H! Oj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e4'9!+'((,!C)96)9D(!,C!C'(/54P/0'9P-)D0/!95B/4)9,(A! @0545!'!(='--!(5/!,C!C)96)9D(!*'9!>5!=,45!,4!-5((!65C)9)/)<5!)C!*,9C)4=56H! +*)59/)C)*!'6<'9*5=59/!)9!='9'D5=59/!'96!/05!(,*)'-!(*)59*5(!4'45-2!)(! '*0)5<56!<)'!'!(='--!(5/!,C!*4)/)*'-!5aF54)=59/(!M.'2,A!:XXZNH!f,4!B(A! )9/5--5*/B'-!F4,D45((!59/')-(!=B*0!=,45!,C!/05!9B6D)9DA!FB(0)9DA! *,=F5/)9DA!'96!*,9<)9*)9D!/0'/!='4L!bB09)'9P(/2-5!(*)59/)C)*!(2(/5=(! MbB09A!:XY"NH!M?5<)9952!!+)5D5-A!$":$N! VC!)9/5--5*/B'-!F4,D45((!45WB)45(!O9B6D)9DA!FB(0)9DA!*,=F5/)9DA!'96!*,9<)9*)9DAR! @0545!'45!@5!@)/0!45(F5*/!/,!,9/,-,D2!'96!/05!(,B4*5!,C!-5D)/)='*2G!+55!T'>-5!$H! 8B='9!h,D9)/),9! Ea/549'-! +,B4*5!,C!/ABCDCEF!C,4! +,B4*5!,C! .'L5(!/05!gB-5(! E9<)4,9=59/! EF)(/5=,-,D)*'-!gB-5([! ,GHCECIAJF!C,4! C,4!8,@!/05! .'L5(!/05!gB-5(! -)=)/(!C,4!@0'/!)(! /05!D5954'/),9! E9<)4,9=59/! /0'/!8B='9! -,D)*'-A!C,4!@0'/! ,C!*'B('-! ],4L(! h,D9)/),9!.'F(! k='L5(!(59(5U1! L9,@-56D51! K9/,-,D)*'-!;5D'/),91! #K! #K! ?,=)9'/),9!! .2/0,-,D2cV65,-,D2! +BF549'/B4'-! K9/,-,D)*'-! ?5*45'()9D! 5GL! #K! E=54D59*51!g5-'/)<)(=!! h,9(59(B(!! h,9C-)*/! K9/,-,D)*'-!J-B4'-)(=1! g5*,9*)-5!! 5GL! 5GL! @cV9*45'()9D! g5'-)(=!M.B-/)F-5!g5'-)/)5(N! h,445(F,9659*5! K9/,-,D)*'-!`9)/21! h,445(F,9659*5! #K! 5GL! T4'9(F'459/!+*)59*5!! /,!Ea/549'-!E9</H! $_!
  25. 25. T'>-5!$1!T05!(/'/5!,C!'4/!)9!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0!)(!,9/,-,D)*'-!F-B4'-)(=H! ]02!6,5(9U/!,B4!OWB'9/)/'/)<5!'96!WB'-)/'/)<5!5<)659*5R!M?5<)9952!'96!+)5D5-! $":$N!*'442!/05!('=5!-5D)/)='*2!'(!e'-)-5,U(!5<)659*5G! &'9('-A!#)$/,A!M$":$N!D)<5!B(!/05!'9(@541! l45(5'4*054(!'96!F4'*/)/),954(!45F45(59/!)9C,4='/),9!)9!6)CC5459/!@'2(! '96!B(5!6)CC5459/!-'9DB'D5!'96!(/4'/5D)5(!Mb5-5=59!!&'9('-A!$""$[! b)5(54!!75)954A!$""XNA!'96!45(5'4*054(!'96!F4'*/)/),954(!0'<5!6)CC5459/! 5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-!(/'9*5(!Mg,B((5'BA!.'99)9DA!!?59254A!$""#[!+04)<'(/'<'! !.)/4,CCA!:X#_NH!M&'9('-A!#)$/,!$":$N! T05!-5D)/)='*2!,C!,B4!OWB'9/)/'/)<5!'96!WB'-)/'/)<5!5<)659*5R!*'9!'-@'2(!>5! WB5(/),956!>5*'B(5!)/!45(/(!,9!6)<)656!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!C,B96'/),9(H!T05!6)<)65! *,=5(!C4,=!/05!@'2!@5!*B4459/-2!'9(@54!/05!WB5(/),9(!,C!,9/,-,D21! ?,5(!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!='L5!/05!4B-5(G! h,9(/4B*/)<)(=!('2(A!Oj5(HR! ?,5(!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!='L5!/05!4B-5(G! J,()/)<)(=!('2(A!Oj5(HR!! J0)--)F(!'96!K(@)*L!M$":$N!45)/54'/5!/0'/!O>,/0!'45!<'-)6!5F)(/5=,-,D)5(HR!]0)*0! >4)9D(!B(!>'*L!/,!/05!O@,4L'>-5!F5'*5R!>5/@559!J,()/)<)(=!'96!h,9(/4B*/)<)(=! MF_N!'96!/05!65>'/5!,<54!4)D,4!<54(B(!45-5<'9*5H!! T05!*,9C-)*/!9,@!)(!>5/@559!/05!=B-/)F-5!45'-)/)5(!,C!'*'65=)*(A!@0,!B(5!4)D,4!'(! /05!>'()(!C,4!<'-)6)/2A!'96!F4'*/)/),954(A!@0,!B(5!45-5<'9*5!'(!/05!>'()(!C,4! <'-)6)/2H!!! T0)(!*'9!>5!/4'*56!>'*L!/,!/05!F4,>-5=!/0'/!<5a56!b'9/!'96!*B4459/!F0)-,(,F054(! ,C!0,@!/05!>4')9!'*/B'--2!*,9(/4B*/(!@0'/!@5!5aF54)59*5!'(!45'-)/2!,4! *,9(*),B(95((H!V/U(!/05!F4,*5((!,C!='FF)9D!5a/549'-!F059,=59'!)9!/05!>4')9!/0'/! b'9/!45C54456!/,!'(!>5)9D!9,/!CB--2!D4,B9656H! V9!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0A!(/'/)(/)*(!'45!/05!F4)='42!OWB'9/)/'/)<5R!C,4=!,C!='/0! B(56!)9!/05!F4,*5((!,C!='FF)9DH!V9!WB'9/)/'/)<5!=5/0,6(A!@0)*0!B(5!/05! 5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-!(/'9*5!,C!F,()/)<)(=A!)/!)(!*,9()65456!O4)D,4,B(R!/,!(/'4/!@)/0!/05! F45<')-)9D!/05,42!M'>(/4'*/!kC,4=UN!@)/0)9!'!D)<59!(/45'=!,C!='9'D5=59/! -)/54'/B45A!65<5-,F!02F,/05(5(!/,!/5(/!/0'/!/05,42A!'96!/059!65()D9!'!(B4<52!/,! D'/054!6'/'!C4,=!'!/'4D5/!F,FB-'/),9!/,!(55!)C!/05!02F,/05(5(!'45!/4B5!,4!C'-(5H! T0)(!C,--,@(!'!-)95'4!F4,D45((),9!C4,=!'!/05,45/)*'-!=,65-!/,!'!*,9*-B(),9H! +/'/)(/)*(!B(5(!'((B=F/)<5!D5954'-)Q'/),9!M.5456)/0!:XX#NA!@0)*0!=5'9(!<'-)6)/2! 45(/(!,9!/05!B9654-2)9D!/05,45/)*'-!=,65-A!9,/!,9!@05/054!/05(5!'>(/4'*/!C,4=(! *,445(F,96!/,!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!! OT05!,>^5*/)<)/2!'//4)>B/56!/,!/05)4!9B=54)*'-!F45*)(),9!)95(*'F'>-2!45(/(! ,9!(B>^5*/)<5!65*)(),9(!='65!>2!/05!45(5'4*054(!65()D9)9D!/05! WB5(/),99')45(!'96!/05!F'4/)*)F'9/(!@0,!'45!'(L56!/,!*0,,(5!/05!<54>'-! $S!
  26. 26. '9*0,4!/0'/!>5(/!45F45(59/(!/05)4!5aF54)59*5!,C!/05!/'4D5/!F059,=59,9R! M+'965-,@(L)!$""XNH! 8B>>'46!'96!+'=B5-(,9!M$""XN!*,P'B/0,456!'9!'4/)*-5!D)<)9D!'!65/')-56! 5aF-'9'/),9!,C!0,@!/05!OD5954'-!-'*L!,C!5=F)4)*)(=!)9!/05!=,65-)9D!*B-/B45!)(!'9! B9'6645((56!)((B5R!M$ZNH! T0)(!=5'9(!/0'/!5<59!)9!,B4!WB'9/)/'/)<5!=5/0,6(A!@5!(/)--!59*,B9/54!/05!('=5! F4,>-5=!/0'/!I4)(/,/-5!C'*56!)9!0)(!WB'-)/'/)<5!@,4LH!]5!(/'4/!C4,=!'!/05,45/)*'-! =,65-!'96!B(5!/05!='/05='/)*'-!/5*09)WB5!>#$@+<2!/,!*'-*B-'/5!'96!5aF-')9A!>B/! @5!-'*L!5=F)4)*'-!=5/4)*(1!/05!O*-,*L(!'96!/054=,=5/54(HR!hB4459/!=5/0,6(!'45! ,9!/05!('=5!()65!'(!J-'/,!)9!/0)(!*'(5!'(!C'4!'(!<'-)6)/2!)(!*,9*54956H!! J-'/,!'4DB56!/0'/!/0545!'45!(,=5!B9)<54('-!C,4=(!/0'/!'45!9,/!'!F'4/!,C! F'4/)*B-'4!/0)9D(H!f,4!5a'=F-5A!)/!)(!F,(()>-5!/0'/!/0545!)(!9,!F'4/)*B-'4! D,,6!)9!5a)(/59*5A!>B/!qD,,6q!)(!(/)--!'!F4,F54!B9)<54('-!C,4=H!&54/4'96! gB((5--!)(!'!*,9/5=F,4'42!F0)-,(,F054!@0,!'D4556!@)/0!J-'/,!,9!/05! 5a)(/59*5!,C!qB9)9(/'9/)'/56!B9)<54('-(HR!M3,4)!$""%N! V9!/05!65<5-,F=59/!,C!(/'/)(/)*'-!=5/0,6(A!gB((5--!/,,L!/05!()65!,C!J-'/,H!d'-)6)/2! @'(!/0B(!C,B9656!,9!'!*,9(59(B(!,<54!'>(/4'*/!OC,4=(R!/0'/!='2!,4!='2!9,/!>5! 4)D,4,B(-2!*,445(F,9656!/,!'92!O)9(/'9/)'/),9R!)9!/05!5a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
  27. 27. h,9(/4B*/)<)(=A!@0)*0!)(!/05!5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-!(/'9*5!,C!WB'-)/'/)<5!=5/0,6(A!/'L5(! /05!OC,4=R!='FF56!)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'96!'*L9,@-56D5(!/0'/!)/!)(!(B>^5*/)<5! '96!45-'/)<5A!(,!/0545!*'9!>5!9,!'>(,-B/5!/4B/0H!V/!/059!F4,*556(!)9!'!-)95'4! F4,D45((),9!'96!*-')=(!/,!D5954'/5!<'-)6!L9,@-56D5A!>B/!,9-2!,9!'!*'(5P>2P*'(5! >'()(!@)/0!<542!-)//-5!D5954'-)Q'>)-)/2H!! J,()/)<)(=!'((B=5(!/0'/!/05!OL9,@-56D5R!D5954'/56!>'(56!,9!'!4)D,4,B(! )9<5(/)D'/),9!,C!/05!5a/549'-A!O,>^5*/)<5R!@,4-6!)(!/05!-5D)/)='/5!O/4B/0R!>B/!C')-(! /,!CB--2!'*L9,@-56D5!/05!)9/549'-!>)'(5(!,C!/05!,>(54<54[!(,=5/)=5(!45C54456!/,! '(!O?5(*'4/5(U!E44,4R!Me)->54/A!:XX:[!?'9)5-A!:XXSNH!J0)--)F(!'96!K(@)*L!M$":$N! 5aF-')9!0,@!h,9(/4B*/)<)(=!0'(!5=54D56!)9!45'*/),9!/,!/0)(1! l/05!/@59/)5/0!*59/B42!054'-656!'!4'6)*'-!65F'4/B45!C4,=!<)5@(!,C! -'9DB'D5!'(!'!()=F-5!=)44,4!,C!9'/B45!Mg,4/2A!:XYXNH!T05!-)9DB)(/)*!/B49A!'/! )/(!=,(/!>'()*A!@'(!'!4'6)*'-!*0'--59D5!/,!/05!)65'!/0'/!-'9DB'D5!)(!=545-2! '!*,96B)/!C,4!*,==B9)*'/)9D!)9C,4='/),9H!V9(/5'6A!-'9DB'D5!M65C)956! >4,'6-2N!@'(!45*,D9)Q56!'(!>5)9D!CB96'=59/'--2!)=F-)*'/56!)9!/05! F4,6B*/),9!,C!(,*)'-!45'-)/2H!! T4'6)/),9'--2A!-'9DB'D5!0'6!>559!(559!'(!'!F'(()<5!65(*4)F/,4!,C!F45P 5a)(/)9D!,>^5*/(!45(B-/)9D!C4,=!/05!65<5-,F=59/!,C!'FF4,F4)'/5!-'>5-(!/,! C'*)-)/'/5!5CC5*/)<5!*,==B9)*'/),9!'>,B/!/05=H!7'9DB'D5!C4,=!/0)(! <)5@F,)9/!)(!O/4B5R!@059!)/!*,445*/-2!45C-5*/(!45'-)/2!'96!OC'-(5R!@059!)/! 6,5(!9,/H!g5'-)/2!)(!/0545C,45!'-@'2(!/05!'4>)/54!,C!*-')=(!/,!/4B/0!)9!/0)(! <)5@H!I!9B=>54!,C!F0)-,(,F054(!(F59/!*,9()654'>-5!/)=5!'96!5CC,4/! 65<5-,F)9D!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!C4'=5@,4L(!/0'/!5aF-')956!/0)(!45-'/),9!,C! -'9DB'D5!'96!45'-)/2H!T0)(!<)5@!45'*056!)/(!Q59)/0!)9!/05!:X$"(!'96!:X%"(! @)/0!/05!65<5-,F=59/!,C!-,D)*'-!F,()/)<)(=!MJ0)--)F(!!K(@)*LA!$":$N! h,9(/4B*/)<)(=!(@)9D(!)9!/05!,FF,()/5!6)45*/),9!'96!'((B=5(!/0'/!OL9,@-56D5R!)(! ,9-2!/05!(B>^5*/)<5!*,9(/4B*/),9(!,C!/05!=)96H!J0)--)F(!'96!K(@)*L!M$":$N! *,9/)9B5A! l/05!F,(/P@'4!54'!('@!'!65*)()<5!(0)C/!)9!C,*B(!@)/0!-'9DB'D5!)9*45'()9D-2! (559!'(!F54C,4=)9D!'!<542!6)CC5459/!4,-51!4'/054!/0'9!^B(/!45C-5*/)9D!'!F45P 5a)(/)9D!45'-)/2A!)/!>5D'9!/,!>5!B9654(/,,6!'(!0'<)9D!'!F4,C,B96!4,-5!)9!/05! '*/B'-!*,9(/)/B/),9!,C!@0'/!@5!5aF54)59*5!'(!'!F45P5a)(/)9D!'96! )965F59659/!(,*)'-!45'-)/2H!f4,=!/0)(!F,)9/!,C!<)5@A!@5!6,!9,/!59*,B9/54!'! F45P,4D'9)Q56!45'-)/2!/,!@0)*0!@5!'//'*0!-'>5-(A!>B/!4'/054!'*/)<5-2! *,9(/4B*/!45'-)/2!/04,BD0!=5'9)9DCB-!)9/54'*/),9H! T0)(!CB96'=59/'-!*0'9D5!)9!B9654(/'96)9D!)9)/)'/56!'!95@!54'!)9!/05! (,*)'-!(*)59*5(!@0545!(,*)'-!45'-)/2!)(!B9654(/,,6!'(!>5)9D!629'=)*'--2! *,9(/4B*/56!/04,BD0!0B='9!'*/),9H!MJ0)--)F(!!K(@)*LA!$":$N! 8,@5<54A!*,9(/4B*/)<)(=!C')-(!/,!'*L9,@-56D5!/0'/!/0545!)(!'9!5a/549'-!(,B4*5!,C! (59(,42!)9FB/!C4,=!@0)*0!/05(5!)9/549'-!*,9(/4B*/),9(!'45!D5954'/56!/04,BD0!'9! ,>(54<'>-5!F4,*5((!,C!95B4'-!95/@,4L!C,4='/),9!)9!/05!>4')9H!T05!45(B4D59*5!,C! WB'-)/'/)<5!=5/0,6(!)(!'!45'*/),9!/,!/05!C')-)9D(!,C!F,()/)<)(=A!>B/!)/!6,5(!9,/!/'L5! B(!>52,96!,9/,-,D)*'-!F-B4'-)(=!/,!/4'9(F'459/!(*)59*5H!&,/0!,C!/05=!C')-!/,! $Y!
  28. 28. 45*,D9)Q5!/05!6)CC5459*5!>5/@559!/05!5a/549'-!='/54)'-!45'-)/2!'96!/05!)9/549'-! *,9(/4B*/56!45'-)/)5(!,C!6)CC5459/!,>(54<54(H! +/'/)(/)*'-!'96!V9/54<)5@! T! =5/0,6(!,C!mB'9cmB'-! 45(5'4*0!'45!/'L)9D!6'/'! C4,=!/05!(,*)'--2! *,9(/4B*/56!45'-)/)5(A! 9,/!/05!5=F)4)*'-! 5<)659*5!,C!/05!5a/549'-! 59<)4,9=59/H! ! f4,=!/05!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!F,)9/!,C!<)5@A!@5!0'<5!9,/!='65!'!*-5'4!-)9DB)(/)*! 6)(/)9*/),9!>5/@559!@0'/!*,B9/(!'(!O5=F)4)*'-!5<)659*5R!C4,=!/05!5a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c:X:"N!'96! ?5@52!M:X:"NA!/,!@0)*0!'45!'6656!bB09!M:XY"NA!JB/9'=!M$"":NA!mB)95!M:XZ:N! '96!g,4/2!M:X#XNAR!/0'/!L9,@-56D5!D5954'/56!/04,BD0!)9WB)42!9556(!/,!>5! /4'9(-'/56!>5/@559!/05!C4'=5@,4L(!,C!6)CC5459/!*,==B9)/)5(H!OJ4'D='/)(=!)(!'--! '>,B/!*,=F'4)(,9R!MF:"X:NH 3B(/)C2)9D!'!L9,@-56D5!*-')=A!5<59!)9!/54=(!,C!)/!>5)9D!B(5CB-!L9,@-56D5A! )(!5aF5*/56!/,!>5!()D9)C)*'9/-2!6)CC5459/!C,4!5'*0!6)CC5459/!*,==B9)/2H! +*)59*5A!,C!*,B4(5A!0'(!)/(!5WB)<'-59/!)9!bB09U(!F'4'6)D=(!,4!(*0,,-(!,C! $#!
  29. 29. (*)59/)C)*!/0,BD0/H!]0'/!)(!'!45'(,9'>-5!5aF-'9'/),9!)9!,95!*,==B9)/2!)(! 9,9(59(5!)9!'9,/054H!T0545C,45A!F4,>-5=!(,-B/),9(!@)--!9556!/,!>5! ^B(/)C)56!)9!@'2(!45-5<'9/!/,!/05!'-/549'/)<5!(/'L50,-654!*,==B9)/)5(H! M.5/*'-C5!$""#A!F:"X$NH! 8,@5<54A!/0)(!(/)--!65F596(!,9!*,9(59(B(P>'(56!-5D)/)='*2!'96!6,5(!9,/!F4,<)65! '!=,45!4)D,4,B(!-)9DB)(/)*!>4)6D5!/,!D45'/54!*,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!'>(/4'*/! =,65-(!'96!5a/549'-!5<)659*5H!! J4'D='/)(=!F4,<)65(!9,!@'2!/,!45*,9*)-5!>5/@559!*,9C-)*/)9D!F54(F5*/)<5(A!-)L5! @0'/!@5!(55!)9!/05!4)D,4P45-5<'9*5!65>'/5H!!! e)<59!/0)(!*,=F-5a)/2A!-'9DB'D5!@'44'9/(!F'4/)*B-'4!'//59/),9!@)/0)9! ,4D'9)Q'/),9!(/B6)5(!'96!0'(!45*5)<56!5<54P)9*45'()9D!'//59/),9!'(! 45(5'4*054(!5aF-,45!/0)(!)=F,4/'9/!'(F5*/!,C!,4D'9)Q'/),9'-!F059,=59'H! I/!/05!('=5!/)=5A!(,=5!(*0,-'4(!'45!5aF45(()9D!*,9*549!/0'/!/05!C,*B(!0'(! =,<56!C4,=!,4D'9)Q'/),9!'(!'9!,>^5*/!/,!>5!=5'(B456!/,!/05!9'44,@!(/B62! ,C!-'9DB'D5!)9!'9!,4D'9)Q'/),9'-!*,9/5a/!@0)-5!=)(()9D!/05!F4)='42!-5((,9! ,C!/05!-)9DB)(/)*!/B491! .,(/!,C!/05(5!(/B6)5(!-,,L!'/!/5a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
  30. 30. T0)(!)(!9,/!/05!O()9D-5A!*,05459/!C4'=5@,4LR!,C!EB*-)6!/0'/!0'(!F4,<59!)/(5-C! B(5CB-!C,4!$%v!*59/B4)5(!'(!'!-)9DB)(/)*!>4)6D5H!V9(/5'6A!)/!>45'L(!/05!-)9L!>5/@559! '>(/4'*/!C,4=(!)9!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'96!/05!5a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k'>(,-B/5!F4,,CU!>5*'B(5!/05!5a/549'-A!='/54)'-! *,9/5a/A!)9!@0)*0!*-')=(!*'9!>5!)965F59659/-2!/5(/56!'96!,>^5*/)<5-2!<54)C)56A! (/'96(!,9!/05!('=5!,9/,-,D)*'-!D4,B96!'(!/05!)9/549'-!*,9(/4B*/56!45'-)/)5(!,C! 0B='9!*,D9)/),9H!! f4,=!'!='FF)9D!F,)9/!,C!<)5@A!45*,9*)-)9D!/05!6)CC5459*5(!>5/@559!(,*)'--2! *,9(/4B*/56!45'-)/)5(!)(!<542!*,=F-5a!F4,*5((!>5*'B(5!/05!B9654-2)9D!(5/(!,C! 4B-5(A!/0'/!'45!'--!*,9()65456!-5D)/)='/5A!6,!9,/!'-)D9!)9!*,9()(/59/!@'2(H! f,--,@)9D!/05!-)9DB)(/)*!/B49A!)/!)(!05-FCB-!/,!-,,L!'/!-'9DB'D5!=,45!D5954'--2!/,! (55!0,@!@5!45*,9*)-5!=5'9)9D(!@059!@5!/4'9(-'/5!>5/@559!/05=A!'96!*,9()654! /05!)=F-)*'/),9(!/0)(!0'(!,9!0,@!@5!'9(@54!/05!WB5(/),9(!,C!,9/,-,D2H! E'*0!(2=>,-)*!45F45(59/'/),9!)--B(/4'/5(!/05!45-'/)<5!k/4B/0(U!,C!(,*)'-! *,9(/4B*/),9(!'96!F)*/B45!45F45(59/(!/05!,>^5*/)<5!/4B/0!,C!5=F)4)*'-!5<)659*5H! ]5!(55!/05!k=B-/)F-5!45'-)/)5(U!*,9(/4B*/56!>2!0B='9!*,D9)/),9!'96!/05!5=F)4)*'-! ,>^5*/!C4,=!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!g5*,9*)-)'/),9!,C!=5'9)9D!)(!'*0)5<56!>2! '9*0,4)9D!/,!/05!5=F)4)*'-!,>^5*/!/0'/!5'*0!-'9DB'D5!45F45(59/(!)9!)/(!,@9!@'2H! V9!='9'D5=59/A!@0)*0!,95!'45!@5!D,)9D!/,!B(5!'(!/05!>'()(! C,4!<'-)6)/2!'(!'!k(*)59/)C)*U!6)(*)F-)951!!/05!9'44'/)<5!,C!/05! (,*)'-!*,9(/4B*/),9(!,4!/05!9'44'/)<5!,C!/05!5<)659*5! 5=54D)9D!C4,=!/05!5=F)4)*'-!*,9/5a/G!! E'*0!,C!/05!C)4(/!/0455!0'(!'9!B9654-2)9D!OD4'=='4R!/0'/!6,5(!9,/!'-)D9! ='/05='/)*'--2!@)/0!/05!,/054(A!>5*'B(5!5'*0!@'(!)965F59659/-2!*,9(/4B*/56!>2! %"!
  31. 31. 6)CC5459/!(,*)'-!D4,BF(!>'(56!,9!/05)4!,@9!*,9(59(B(A!059*5!/052!'45!(B>^5*/)<5H! T05!5=F)4)*'-!'FF-5!'-(,!0'(!'9!B9654-2)9D!OD4'=='4AR!>B/!)/!)(!65/54=)956!>2! /05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/!)/(5-CA!059*5!)/!)(!,>^5*/)<5H!! K9/,-,D)*'-!F-B4'-)(=!(55L(!/,!=')9/')9!/05!6)CC5459/!D4'=='4(!,C!*B-/B4'-! 9'44'/)<5(!'(!/05!>'()(!C,4!5F)(/5=,-,D)*'-!<'-)6)/2A!4'/054!/0'9!(55L)9D!/,!*-'4)C2! /05!4B-5(!/0'/!5=54D5!C4,=!/05!5<)659*5!)9!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H! +,A!'(!'9!'(F)4)9D!(*)59/)C)*!6)(*)F-)95A!@0'/!6,!@5!6,!)9!/0)(!()/B'/),9G!! ?,!@5!C,--,@!J-'/,!'96!B(5!*B-/B4'-!9'44'/)<5(!F-B(!/05!O='D)*!9B=>54!>#$@+<2R! /,!>,-(/54!405/,4)*'-!'FF5'-!)9!/05!FB4(B)/!,C!*,9(59(B(G! K4A!6,!@5!C,--,@!EB*-)6!'96!>B)-6!'!-)9DB)(/)*!>4)6D5!/,!*,445(F,9659*5!'96! 4)D,4,B(!F4,,CG! G/3093+9$,>'$B>3#(-(D>32"#$H3630'$ T05!*B4459/!F0)-,(,F0)*'-!6)<)65!5=54D5(!C4,=!b'9/U(!5F)(/5=,-,D2!M:Y#:N!'96! gB((5--U(!-,D)*!M:X"%N!/0'/!<'-)6!L9,@-56D5!*'9!>5!D5954'/56!>'(56!,9! OB9)9(/'9/)'/56!C,4=(AR!,4!/05,45/)*'-!=,65-(A!@)/0!9,!*,445(F,9659*5!/,!'92! F'4/)*B-'4!)9(/'9/)'/),9!)9!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!I--!/05!(/'/)(/)*'-!'96! 9,4='/)<5!=,65-)9D!/0'/!@5!(55!)9!WB'9/)/'/)<5!=5/0,6(!F4,*556(!C4,=!/0)(! C,B96'/),9A!-5'6)9D!/,!/05!*B4459/!(/'/5!,C!65>'/5!,<54!/05!45-5<'9*5!,C! L9,@-56D5!/,!/05!5a/549'-A!='/54)'-!45'-)/2!/0'/!*,9(/4')9(!F4'*/)*5H!! J-'/,!*-')=56!OB9)(/'9/)'/56!C,4=(R!/,!>5!<'-)6!>5*'B(5!05!L95@!/052!5a)(/56! @)/0)9!0)(!*,D9)/),9A!(B*0!'(!OD,,6R!,4!O>'6AR!>B/!05!*,B-6!9,/!(55!@0545!/052! 5a)(/56!)9!/05!*,9/5a/!,C!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H!!85!*,B-6!9,/!(55!)9()65!/05! >4')9!/,!5a'=)95!/05!95B4,>),-,D)*'-!(2(/5=(!/0'/!D)<5!4)(5!/,!/05!5=,/),9(!'96! *,D9)/),9!,C!0B='9!^B6D=59/A!/05!OF'4/)*B-'4!C,4=R!/0'/!I4)(/,/-5!)9()(/56!BF,9H!! T0'/!@'(!/059H!T0)(!)(!9,@H! +,!9,@A!6,!@5!*,9/)9B5!/,!C,--,@!J-'/,!M=2/0!'96!='D)*!9B=>54(NA!,4!6,!@5! C,--,@!EB*-)6!M='/0!'96!*,445(F,9659*5NG!! V!(B>=)/!/0'/!/05!65>'/5!>5/@559!J,()/)<)(=!'96!h,9(/4B*/)<)(=!)(!'!C'-(5! 6)*0,/,=2A!>5*'B(5!95)/054!45C-5*/(!'!*,=F-5/5!<)5@!,C!/05!F4,*5((!/0'/! D5954'/5(!L9,@-56D5!=,45!D5954'--2H!75'49)9D!'96!65<5-,F=59/!*'9!>5!>5//54! B9654(/,,6!@059!@5!-,,L!6,@9!/05!=)*4,(*,F5!,C!95B4,(*)59*5!/,!D5/!'!*-5'4! <)5@!,C!/05!>),=5*0'9)*(!)9()65!/05!>4')9H!]059!@5!-,,L!'/!/05!5a/549'-! 5<)659*5A!@5!C)9'--2!D5/!/,!,>(54<5!@0545!/05!OB9)9(/'9/)'/56!C,4=(AR!-)L5!OD,,6R! ,4!O>'6AR!'45!'*/B'--2!)9(/'9/)'/56!)9!/05!95B4,>),-,D)*'-!(2(/5=(!'96!95B4,P *05=)*'-!)9/54'*/),9(!/0'/!@5!5aF54)59*5!'(!/05!5=,/),9(!/0'/!B9654-)5!0B='9! *,D9)/),9A!-5'49)9DA!'96!(,*)'-!65*)(),9!='L)9D!MV==,46)9,Pj'9D!!?'='(),A! $""YNH! ;5B4,(*)59*5!)(!/05!=)*4,(*,F5A!-)L5!e'-)-5,U(!/5-5(*,F5A!/0'/!'--,@(!B(!/05!(55! /05!O)9(/'9/)'/),9R!,C!OC,4=(R!/0'/!gB((5--!>5-)5<56!/,!>5!B9,>(54<'>-5H!! 7B96P?5'9!'96!3,--52!M$":$N!(B=='4)Q5!@0'/!0'FF59(!@059!@5!<)5@!/05! D5954'-!F4,*5((!,C!-5'49)9D!C4,=!/0)(!95@!5=F)4)*'-!F54(F5*/)<51! %:!
  32. 32. rB--!M$""$NA!'!>),-,D)(/!>B)-6)9D!F02(),-,D)*'--2!,9!b,->U(!5aF54)59/)'-! -5'49)9D!*2*-5A!,CC54(!'!65/')-56!'**,B9/!,C!@0'/!0'FF59(!/,!/05!>4')9! @0)-5!59*,B9/54)9D!95@!L9,@-56D5!'96!*0,,()9D!0,@!/,!0'96-5!)/i@0'/! @5!@,B-6!*'--!O-5'49)9DHR!`()9D!b,->U(!-5'49)9D!*2*-5A!rB--!M$""$1!_"N! (BDD5(/(!/0'/!95@!95B4'-!95/@,4L(!'45!*45'/56!6B4)9D!'!/4'9(C,4='/),9!,C! O6'/'R!)9/,!O)65'(A!F-'9(A!'96!'*/),9(R!,4!'**5F/)9D!95@!L9,@-56D5H!M7B96P ?5'9!!3,--2A!$":$A!$%:N! T0545!)(!'!='/54)'-!*,9/5a/!)9!@0)*0!/05(5!F4,*5((5(!'45!='9)C5(/A!>B/!@5!0'<5! 9,/!5(/'>-)(056!*,445(F,9659*5!/,!/0)(!>,62!,C!5<)659*5!'(!'!>'()(!C,4!-5D)/)='*2! )9!='9'D5=59/!45(5'4*0H!! V9(/5'6A!@5!B(5!*,9(59(B(P>'(56!-5D)/)='*2!'96!/059!-'>5-!,B4!@,4L!(*)59/)C)*! >5*'B(5!@5!B(56!(,=5!(/'/)(/)*'-!6'/'!'9'-2()(A!@0)*0!-,,L(!(*)59/)C)*!'96!*'44)5(! /05!405/,4)*'-!'FF5'-!,C!9B=>54(A!>B/!9,/!/05!O(-'=!6B9LR!-5D)/)='*2!,C!5=F)4)*'-! 5<)659*5H! I4=(/4,9D!M$":$N!5aF-')9(!=,451! ?5(F)/5!@'49)9D(!,<54!/05!F'(/!0'-CP*59/B42!,4!=,45!Mr5--954A!$"":A! /4'*5(!/0)(!>'*L!/,!+)4!8'4,-6!35CC452(!)9!/05!=)6P:X""(NA!'!F4),4)!'9'-2()(! (55=(!/,!>5!D)<)9D!@'2!'=,9D!'*'65=)*!45(5'4*054(!/,!/05!>5-)5C!/0'/! @)/0!59,4=,B(!6'/'>'(5(!/052!*'9!B(5!*,=F-5a!=5/0,6(!'96!'9'-2/)*'-! =5'(B45(!(B*0!'(!4$!'96!/P(/'/)(/)*(!/,!*45'/5!=,65-(H!T052!5<59!/42! <'4),B(!/4'9(C,4='/),9(!,4!6)CC5459/!-'D(!,C!<'4)'>-5(!/,!(55!@0)*0!>5(/!C)/! /05!0)(/,4)*'-!6'/'H!E)90,49!M:XY$N!*,9*-B656A!O3B(/!'(!/05!'-*05=)(/(! @545!9,/!(B**5((CB-!)9!/B49)9D!>'(5!=5/'-!)9/,!D,-6A!/05!=,6549! 45(5'4*054!*'99,/!45-2!,9!/05!k*,=FB/54U!/,!/B49!0)(!6'/'!)9/,!=5'9)9DCB-! '96!<'-B'>-5!(*)59/)C)*!)9C,4='/),9HR!M%N! f4556='9!M$""ZN!(B=='4)Q5(!/05!*,9*-B(),9(!,C!'9!5a/59()<5!)9WB)42!,9!/05! ='//54A! g5D45((),9!=,65-(!C,4!*'B('/),9!B(B'--2!65(*4)>5!45-'/),9(0)F(!'=,9D! <'4)'>-5(H!7)5>54(,9!M:X#SN!C)96(!-)//-5!=54)/!)9!(B*0!=,65-(1!C)954PD4')9! '9'-2/)*!=5/0,6(!'45!955656!C,4!*'B('-!)9C5459*5H!I>>,//!M:XXYA!:XX#N! 45'*05(!()=)-'4!*,9*-B(),9(1!(/'/)(/)*'-!<'4)'>-5(!='2!>5!/,,!/0)9!/,! (BFF,4/!65/')-56!(,*)'-P(*)59*5!)9<5(/)D'/),9(A!'96!=,65-(!@)--!4'45-2!D)<5! /05!5WB)<'-59/!,C!5aF54)=59/'-!*,9/4,-H!I-(,!(55!+,>5-!M$"""NH!856(/4w=! '96!+@56>54D!M:XX#N!C)96!/0'/!=,65-(!(0,B-6!D4,@!C4,=!,B4! B9654(/'96)9D!,C!(,*)'-!=5*0'9)(=(1!NGHNGLLCKR!IKDGBL!HGRGNABBF!UACB! EPCL!EGLE*!7)5>54(,9!'96!7299!M$""$N!(BDD5(/!/0'/!B()9D!45D45((),9!/,! =)=)*!5aF54)=59/'-!*,9/4,-!)(!/05!@4,9D!F'4'6)D=!C,4!/05!(,*)'-!(*)59*5(H! Mf4556='9A!$""ZA!FSN!tE=F0'()(!'6656Hu! I4=(/4,9D!M$":$N!5-'>,4'/5(A!OV/!(55=(!*,==,9!(59(5!/0'/!*,=F-5a!(,-B/),9(! '45!955656!C,4!*,=F-5a!'96!B9*54/')9!F4,>-5=(H!g5(5'4*0!C)96)9D(!(BDD5(/!/05! ,FF,()/5HR!85!-)(/(!(5<54'-!5a'=F-5(!'96!*,9*-B65(A!OE<)659*5!C'<,4)9D!()=F-)*)/2! 0'(!*,9/)9B56!/,!'FF5'4!,<54!/05!F'(/!WB'4/54!*59/B42H!]02!/059!)(!/0545!(B*0!'! (/4,9D!)9/545(/!)9!*,=F-5a!45D45((),9!'9'-2(5(G!J540'F(!/0)(!)(!6B5!/,!'*'65=)*(U! %$!
  33. 33. F45C5459*5!C,4!*,=F-5a!(,-B/),9(A!'(!8,D'4/0!M$":$N!65(*4)>5(R!MI4=(/4,9DA! $":$A!%P!_NH! +,60)!M$""XN!45*59/-2!@4,/5!'>,B/!/05!*,=F5/)/)<5!'6<'9/'D5(!/0'/!F02()*)(/(! 0'<5!,<54!,F54'/),9(!45(5'4*054(H!J02()*)(/(!'45!OC,*B(56!,9!45(B-/(!4'/054!)9! 65=,9(/4'/)9D!(,F0)(/)*'/),9!)9!/05!B(5!,C!/5*09)WB5(R!M:#NH!85!D,5(!,9!/,!*)/5! 5a'=F-5(!)9!/05!-)/54'/B45!@0545!45(5'4*054(!B(5!O-,/(!,C!(,F0)(/)*'/),9!)9! =,65-)9DA!5HDHA!)9!/05!'FF-)*'/),9!,C!D'=5!/05,42A!@)/0!9,/0)9D!)9/545(/)9D!/,! (0,@!C,4!)9!/05!596R!M+,60)!$""XA!:#NH!I4=(/4,9D!'66(1! ]5!'--!*-')=!/,!B9654(/'96!/0'/!*,445-'/),9!)(!9,/!*'B('/),9H!T05! *,445-'/),9(!=)D0/!,**B4!>5*'B(5!I!*'B(5(!&A!,4!&!*'B(5(!IA!,4!/052!'45! 5'*0!45-'/56!/,!hA!,4!/052!*,B-6!>5!(FB4),B(H!&B/!@059!F45(59/56!@)/0! (,F0)(/)*'/56!'96!*,=F-5a!45D45((),9(A!F5,F-5!,C/59!C,4D5/!/0'/[! g5(5'4*054(!)9!=56)*)95A!5*,9,=)*(A!F(2*0,-,D2A!C)9'9*5A!='4L5/)9DA! (,*),-,D2A!'96!(,!,9A!C)--!^,B49'-(!'96!95@(F'F54(!@)/0!)9/545(/)9D!>B/! 544,95,B(HHH'96!5<59!*,(/-2HHHC)96)9D(H!T05!(,-B/),9!)(!/,!>'(5!*'B('-)/2!,9! =5/'P'9'-2(5(!,C!5aF54)=59/'-!(/B6)5(!MZNH! g5D45((),9!'9'-2()(!*'9!F-'2!'9!)=F,4/'9/!4,-5!@059!'9'-2Q)9D!9,9P 5aF54)=59/'-!6'/'H!d'4),B(!)--B(),9(!*'9!456B*5!/05!'**B4'*2!,C!45D45((),9! '9'-2()(A!-5'6!/,!'!C'-(5!(59(5!,C!*,9C)659*5A!'96!0'4=!65*)(),9P='L)9DH! K<54!/05!F'(/!*59/B42!,4!(,A!5CC5*/)<5!(,-B/),9(!0'<5!>559!65<5-,F56!/,! 65'-!@)/0!/05!)--B(),9(H!$PG!MALCJ!VNKMBGI!CL!EPAE!EPG!LKBQECKRL!ANG! KUEGR!CHRKNGD!CR!VNAJECJG****"E!CL!NGIANWAMBG!EPAE!LK!BCEEBG! GXVGNCIGREAECKR!PAL!MGGR!DKRG!,<54!/05!F'(/!*59/B42!/,!65/54=)95! @0)*0!45D45((),9!=5/0,6(!@,4L!>5(/!B9654!@0'/!*,96)/),9(!MI4=(/4,9DA! $":$A!XNH!tE=F0'()(!'6656Hu! T05!(/'/B(!WB,!F4,F,()/),9!)(!/,!*,9/)9B5!)9!/05!45-'/)<)(=!,C!(,*)'--2!*,9(/4B*/56! 9'44'/)<5(!'96!/4'9(-'/5!>5/@559!/05!=B-/)F-5!45'-)/)5(!,C!*B-/B4'-!C4'=5(!/0'/!'45! B(56!C,4!(59(5!='L)9D!)9!/05!*'-*B-'/),9!,C!=5'9)9DH!T05!*B4459/!6)<)656!(/'9*5! '-(,!*,9/)9B5(!@)/0!/05!F,()/)<)(/!C4'=5A!@0)*0!B(5(!/05!B9)9(/'9/)'/56!C,4=(! '6<,*'/56!)9!*,9/5=F,4'42!F0)-,(,F02!>2!gB((5--!'96!)9*,4F,4'/5(!/05!='D)*! 9B=>54!>#$@+<2A!(/'/)(/)*(A!/0'/!B9654-)5!9,4='/)<5!'96!F4,>'>)-)(/)*!=,65-)9DH! gB((5--U(!(/B659/A!])//D59(/5)9!M:XS%N!5<59/B'--2!'>'96,956!'96!*4)/)*)Q56!/0)(! 'FF4,'*0H!85!*'--56!/0)(!O-'9DB'D5!D,95!,9!0,-)6'2HR!85!(')6!/0)(!@'(!-)L5!(,-<)9D! F0)-,(,F0)*'-!F4,>-5=(!,9!C4)*/),9-5((!)*5A!>5*'B(5!5<542/0)9D!D,5(!(=,,/0-2!)9! /05!'>(/4'*/!C,4=A!>B/!9,!@,4L!'*/B'--2!D5/(!6,95!)9!F4'*/)*'-!/54=(!M+5*/),9! :"YNH!T05!65>'/5!,<54!4)D,4!'96!45-5<'9*5!)9!='9'D5=59/!(55=(!/,!*,9C)4=!0)(! '4DB=59/H!T05!4)D,4!'((,*)'/56!@)/0!9B=>54(A!6,5(!9,/!6,!/05!k(*)59/)C)*U!@,4L!)9! /05!(59(5!,C!5(/'>-)(0)9D!*,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!='FF)9D(!@)/0)9!0B='9! *,D9)/),9!'96!5<)659*5!)9!/05!5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/H! VC!@5!'45!/,!/'L5!/05!4,B/5!,C!EB*-)6A!/059!@5!9556!/,!5aF'96!/05!C4'=5!,C!='/0!)9! ,4654!/,!5(/'>-)(0!4)D,4,B(!*,445(F,9659*5!>5/@559!/05,45/)*'-!=,65-(!'96!/05! 5a/549'-!59<)4,9=59/A!(,!/0'/!@5!*'9!F4,6B*5!='/05='/)*'-!F4,,C(A!)9(/5'6!,C! =,45!(,*)'--2!*,9(/4B*/56!=2/0(!'96!)65,-,D)5(H! %%!

×