SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  25
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
Chapter 11
A Case Study on the Incorporation
of Museum and Artifact-Based Fieldtrips
in the Teaching of Ancient Singapore
History: Teacher Reflections and Student
Learning
Lloyd Yeo, Sazryna Lee Samsudin, Cherie Heng, Ezal bin Sani,
and Teddy Y.H. Sim
Abstract Although there is no large-scale and coherent survey available on teacher-
1
guided history fieldtrips in Singapore, recent exploratory case studies have emerged
2
on the use of museums in the teaching of premodern Singapore history. This chapter
3
seeks to locate the efforts of a group of history teachers in the context of collaboration
4
with academic and professional bodies as well as a Networked Learning Commu-
5
nity who systematically sought to incorporate museum-based learning and embed
6
such teaching resources in the teaching of ancient Singapore history. Using Activity
7
Theory (AT) as a learning theory to explore these networks of collaboration, the
8
learning networks that were established showed that such approaches could lead to a
9
more effective co-creation of knowledge outcome for practitioner inquiry and have
10
some positive outcomes for student learning. Data was collected from teacher reflec-
11
tions and surveys as a basic unit of analysis and from students to gauge how they
12
benefited from such learning approaches. The analysis of teacher responses showed
13
that there was increased teacher confidence in the teaching of ancient Singapore
14
history, and students derived direct and indirect benefits from a networked system
15
L. Yeo (B)
The Academy of Singapore Teachers, Singapore, Singapore
e-mail: Lloyd_Luc_YEO@moe.gov.sg
S. L. Samsudin
Fairfield Methodist School, Singapore, Singapore
C. Heng
Seng Kang Secondary School, Singapore, Singapore
E. Sani
CHIJ Secondary School, Singapore, Singapore
T. Y.H. Sim
National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, Singapore
e-mail: yonghuei.sim@nie.edu.sg
© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2020
T. Sim et al. (eds.), Fieldwork in Humanities Education in Singapore,
Studies in Singapore Education: Research, Innovation & Practice,
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-15-8233-2_11
221
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
222 L. Yeo et al.
of learning. From the perspective of AT, although the collaborative linkages estab-
16
lished between the different institutions (museums, academic institutions, schools,
17
and Ministry of Education) were not bound by any fixed rules, the committed efforts
18
of the Master Teacher and teachers played an important role in setting up norms
19
of collaboration among the different institutions to impact student learning about
20
ancient Singapore.
21
11.1 Introduction
22
There is an abundance of research in the Western context on the value of conducting
23
fieldtrips to engage learners. However, such research mainly advocates how fieldtrips
24
can be conducted for general pedagogical use, such as their ability to enrich and
25
expand the curriculum or their importance in immersing students in sensory activities
26
(Nabors et al., 2009). In the Singapore context, a comprehensive or uniform survey
27
on the use of fieldtrips in schools is not available for the full range of humanities
28
subjects (Chew, 2008). E. Chew argued that in geography education in Singapore, the
29
intensity level of school fieldtrips varied based on the teacher’s training background
30
and the curriculum’s emphasis on fieldwork. J.D. Stoddard (2018) observed outdoor
31
history education in Singapore carried out by teacher trainees and noted that a fieldtrip
32
through a World War II heritage site (Labrador Park) facilitated a “more balanced
33
perspective of the historical event (of the fall of Singapore).” However, he also
34
questioned the degree to which trainees were able to comprehend the full historical
35
significance of the event just by taking selfies of themselves with statues of the
36
main protagonists (for example, the commander of the Japanese invasion force in
37
Southeast Asia, General Yamashita) and advocated for deeper research in this area
38
(Stoddard, 2018).
39
Since 2010, more studies have emerged on the use of fieldtrips to teach about
40
the ancient period of Singapore using archaeology and sherd resources. Oh (2018)
41
developed an archaeological “guide” in consultation with Associate Professor Goh
42
Geok Yian, and he utilized his own drawing and writing skills to have students
43
demonstrate their understanding of historical evidence and interpretation. However,
44
museum-based lessons are disadvantaged by the need for teachers to be able to
45
gather sufficient sample sherd sets for students to work on. The National Museum
46
of Singapore has developed museum education packages such as the “Investigating
47
History: Singapura Before 1819” resource to teach the topic; but while useful, these
48
resources are limited to students working with a limited and artificial set of simulated
49
artifacts. Sim’s chapter advocates for the adoption of a more diverse set of teaching
50
resources for studying the premodern history of Singapore (Sim, 2015).
51
Increasingly, museums are being seen as an important resource for teaching and
52
learning in Singapore schools. As such, it is necessary to further explore how schools
53
and museums can collaborate to extend learning for students and the kind of profes-
54
sional development programs that can be put in place to impact student learning.
55
According to M.F. Chee (2003), such professional development programs can help
56
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 223
determine the role that teachers play in the museum experience, which shapes the
57
quality of the experience for students.
58
This study seeks to locate the efforts of a group of history teachers in the context
59
of collaboration with academic and professional bodies as well as a Networked
60
Learning Community (NLC) who systematically sought to incorporate museum-
61
based learning and embed such teaching resources in the teaching of ancient Singa-
62
pore history. Analysis of the museum-based lessons was performed through the
63
paradigm of Activity Theory (AT), looking at students’ performance as an indicator
64
of the effectiveness of the program and collaboration.
65
Using AT as a learning theory to explore these networks of collaboration, this
66
case study uses AT terms to focus on teachers and students as “subjects” within the
67
main activity of teaching about ancient Singapore (AT is discussed further in the
68
“Methodology” section). It briefly explains the linkages between schools, academic
69
institutions, and museums and discusses the effect (or “outcome” in AT) on teachers
70
and students through an analysis of teacher reflections, in situ museum-based lesson
71
observations, and analyses of student worksheet-based answers and surveys. Data
72
was collected to explore four questions:
73
A. How can museum education be incorporated into a larger inquiry-based peda-
74
gogical approach to design learning experiences for the teaching of ancient
75
Singapore history?
76
B. What problems do teachers face in teaching about ancient Singapore, and what
77
role can museum-based professional development play in teaching this topic?
78
C. What have students learned from their museum experience?
79
D. What implications can be drawn from this case study for incorporating museum-
80
based fieldtrips in teaching about ancient Singapore?
81
This essay is divided into four parts:
82
A. The use of AT to describe the development of museum-based lessons and
83
teachers’ professional development training in the context of an NLC;
84
B. What teachers have learned from their fieldtrips;
85
C. Student learning about ancient Singapore;
86
D. Implications of incorporating museum fieldtrips and applying the AT paradigm
87
in the teaching of ancient Singapore history.
88
11.2 Application of Methodology and AT: From Master
89
Class to NLC on Museum-Based Inquiry Lessons
90
Collaborations across institutions are complex and require time to develop, and as
91
such, they are difficult to investigate. However, theories of contextual development
92
insituatedpractice,particularlyAT,canbedeployedtostudythisphenomenon(Enge-
93
strom, 1987; 2001; Vygotsky, 1987; Engestrom et al., 2003). AT originated from the
94
works of Russian psychologists such as L. Vygotsky, A. Leont’ev, and S. Rubinstein,
95
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
224 L. Yeo et al.
who pioneered their approaches by relating them to cultural-historical psychology
96
developed between the 1930s and 1950s. However, by the 1980s a separate strand
97
of AT had developed that was more concerned with neuropsychology. This evolved
98
into the western Scandinavian approach, which has become closely associated with
99
Y. Engestrom; he went on to refine and systematize the works of the earlier Russian
100
theorists.
101
AT of the 1980s sought to “understand human activities from the point of view
102
of systemic studies and studies of social phenomena and go beyond the paradigm of
103
classical conditioning and behaviourism” (Engestrom et al., 1999). AT is “more of a
104
descriptive meta- rather than predictive theory.” One of its strengths is that it “bridges
105
the gap between the individual subject(s) and the social ecosystem examining the
106
mediating activities.”
107
In figure 11.1 of the appendices, the unit of analysis in AT depicts the “concept
108
of object-oriented, collective and culturally-mediated human activity or ‘activity
109
system’” (Engestrom, 1999). This system includes “the object (or objective), subject,
110
mediating artifacts (signs and tools), rules, community and division of labour” (Enge-
111
strom, 2001). Since AT is not solely focused on the individual unit, the key element in
112
its application lies in exploring how the mediated linkages can be harnessed (syner-
113
gistically) or the challenges ameliorated to enhance the performance of the individual
114
Fig. 11.1 Activity Theory for museum-based learning for teachers and students (*indicates shared
common boundary between MTT, researcher, teachers in NLC, curators, and academic as research
area)
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 225
units (in this case, teachers), leading eventually to a more effective learning outcome
115
for the subjects (students) (Bertelsen and Bødker, 2003).
116
In this project, three secondary school history educators—Chris, Sally, and Eddie
117
(for their profiles, refer to table 11.2 in the appendices)—worked with a Master
118
Teacher (MT) from the Academy of Singapore Teachers to develop an NLC to work
119
together with museum staff as well as academics and researchers from the National
120
University of Singapore and National Institute of Education (NIE). The NLC sought
121
to investigate how archaeology could be embedded in museum-based experiences to
122
engage students in learning about the ancient history of Singapore as an inquiry-based
123
approach between 2017 and 2018.
124
Professional development activities involving collaboration and a networked
125
community carried out in the NLC provided background on how teachers enhanced
126
their abilities and confidence in conducting museum-based learning. To this end,
127
the museum-based inquiry lessons were developed across four different professional
128
development phases of the NLC to impact student learning, shown in figure 11.2 in
129
the appendices.
130
During phase 1, a two-day master class was conducted for teachers (n=24) with
131
Professor John Miksic and Dr. Michael Flecker providing new information, artifact
132
analysis, hands-on experience with sherds, and discussions on new historical inquiry
133
questions on Singapore’s ancient history. The main purpose of the master class was
134
to provide teachers with a deeper understanding of how academics use different data
135
Fig. 11.2 Professional development for teacher participants from 2016 to 2019
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
226 L. Yeo et al.
sets (primary sources, archaeology, accounts, cultural studies, and scientific analysis)
136
to develop new historical interpretations of ancient Singapore.
137
In phases 2 and 3, an NLC was formed between August 2017 and October 2018
138
to use the new knowledge acquired from the master class to design museum-based
139
inquiry lessons for Secondary 1 students. In the NLC, teachers worked and learned
140
collaboratively to examine and reflect on their practices (Jackson and Temperley,
141
2007; MOE, 2017). In this context, the NLC was an important professional develop-
142
ment platform that allowed the Master Teacher, teachers, museum staff, academics,
143
and researchers to come together to develop resources that teachers could adapt and
144
use in the history classroom.
145
The activities from phases 2 and 3 included the following:
146
• Discussion and development of a common purpose for shared student activities;
147
• Use of academic and pedagogical literature in designing museum-based inquiry
148
lessons;
149
• Visits to the NUS Museum by teachers to develop a coherent narrative experience
150
and design museum-based inquiry activities (refer to table 11.3 as well as Lesson
151
Sheets 1 and 2 in the appendices);
152
• Modification of museum-based learning to meet school-based history curriculum
153
needs and cater to different student profiles;
154
• Observation of other teachers’ fieldtrips for cycles of improvement and adaptation.
155
By the start of 2018, the NLC had developed three museum-based learning expe-
156
riences for students with clear lesson objectives and concepts that were interrelated
157
and linked to each other in a coherent manner. Later the same year, NLC participants
158
took their students to the museum and conducted museum-based lessons. Teacher
159
learning experiences were discussed through cycles of discussion and reflection at
160
NLC meetings to improve lesson designs and meet local school needs. (A summary of
161
the museum-based learning and activities involving collaboration within and outside
162
the NLC is provided in table 11.1 to illustrate the variety of inputs that came from
163
various quarters to make the lesson successful.)
164
In phase 4, after reflecting on their museum-based inquiry lessons, members of
165
the NLC decided to use their learning experiences and resources to conduct their own
166
workshop for other history educators (n= 22) at the NUS Museum. Their goal was
167
to work with other teachers who sought to embed museum-based lessons into their
168
own historical inquiry classroom projects (see table 11.3 on museum-based learning
169
and activities designed by the NLC in the appendices).
170
During phases 2 and 3, data collection took the form of semi-structured interviews
171
conducted with teachers and an analysis of teacher-written reflections as a primary
172
data source. Purposeful criterion sampling was used to identify teacher participants
173
for the research study. First, participants had to have had three or more years of
174
teaching so that a relatively rich teaching experience could be tapped into for discus-
175
sions on teaching the topic. Second, they had to be part of an NLC in order for
176
interviews, discussions, and museum-based lesson observations to be carried out.
177
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 227
Table
11.1
“Units
of
analysis,”
linkages
and
their
input
into
objective
and
activity
system
Units
of
analysis/subject(s)
How
teachers
benefited
Direct
transference
of
benefit
to
students
How
students
benefited
Challenges
in
collaborative
efforts
1A.
Academy
of
Singapore
Teachers
Master
Teacher
1D.
NLC
network
(MOE)
Academy
formed
to
facilitate
professional
development
of
teachers.
Master
Teacher
(MT)
from
here
initiated
and
coordinated
with
various
parties.
Other
than
coordinative
aspects,
MT
also
provided
resource
and
lesson
design
support
which
facilitated
students’
learning
in
a
direct
way.
Since
MT
acted
as
a
key
coordinative
point
for
all
collaborative
parties,
autobiographical
evidence
and
reflection
(on
challenges)
are
collected
from
this
perspective
on
this
round.
Schools
1B.
Teachers
Attended
training
on
artifacts
and
archaeology
by
(3A)
and
sharing
on
NLC
platform.
Students
benefited
from
expanded
and
deepened
knowledge
of
teachers
in
subject
matter
Demonstrate
to
the
teachers
the
advantages
of
joining
the
project:
i)
a
comprehensive,
innovative,
and
pragmatic
curricular
lesson
package
involving
session
at
the
museum
was
available
for
teachers
to
subscribe
to;
ii)
the
NLC
was
a
user-friendly
as
well
as
valuable
network
that
could
assist
teachers
in
sharing
and
updating
content
and
experiences
among
themselves.
(continued)
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
228 L. Yeo et al.
Table
11.1
(continued)
Units
of
analysis/subject(s)
How
teachers
benefited
Direct
transference
of
benefit
to
students
How
students
benefited
Challenges
in
collaborative
efforts
1C.
Students
2.
Museum
collaborators
(officer,
curator)
1D.
NLC
network
(possible
access
and
link
of
external
bodies
to
this)
Offered
use
of
sherds
(key
learning
resource)
to
be
used
as
sample
material
evidence
for
students’
training.
Other
than
providing
the
use
of
sherds,
museum
officer
also
provided
tips
and
guidance
during
lesson
in
the
sherds
handling
sessions.
Museum
collaborators
were
able
to
facilitate
the
approval
for
use
of
sherd
samples
in
students’
learning.
Relatively
smooth
process
not
to
be
taken
for
granted.
Academics
3A.
NUS
and
ISEAS
archaeology
and
content
Offered
specialized
training
on
artifacts
and
aspects
of
archaeology
to
teachers.
Expanded
and
deepened
information
on
artifacts
and
aspects
of
archaeology
presented
in
a
digestible
way
for
teachers
(in
turn
facilitated
transfer
to
students).
i)
“Master
class”
on
early
modern
Singapore,
archaeology
and
sherd
handling
facilitated
smoothly
at
NUS
because
of
the
rapport
built
(Professor
from
Dept
of
SEA
studies
and
researcher
from
ISEAS).
ii)
Advice
to
assist
in
the
accurate
assembly
of
photo
evidence
and
sherd
samples.
(continued)
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 229
Table
11.1
(continued)
Units
of
analysis/subject(s)
How
teachers
benefited
Direct
transference
of
benefit
to
students
How
students
benefited
Challenges
in
collaborative
efforts
3B.
NIE
education
research
Consulted
in
aspects
of
collection
of
data
for
documentation
of
program
process
leading
up
to
the
writing
of
academic
education
paper
(for
analysis
of
outcome
of
students’
learning).
Academic
paper
could
be
fed
back
into
the
“system
loop
(or
control)”
along
on-going
NLC
discussions
to
refine,
standardize,
and
expand
the
program.
MT,
mutual-teacher,
and
NIE
researcher’s
observations
of
lessons
assisted
with
in-process
adjustment
of
teachers’
teaching
approaches
on
NLC
platform.
Mutual
understanding
and
discussion
had
to
take
place
as
there
could
be
different
focus
in
the
presentation
of
findings.
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
230 L. Yeo et al.
Table 11.2 Description of participants
Participant Age Gender Education experience in teaching
ancient Singapore
No. of years in teaching
Sally XX female Eg. XX years teaching Lower Sec
history. Lower Sec Coordinator.
22 years
Chris XX female Eg. XX years teaching Lower Sec
History. LJ Coordinator
10 years
Eddie XX male Eg. XX years teaching Lower Sec
History.
4 years
Table 11.3 Museum-based learning and activities designed by NLC
Museum Activity Objective Topic of study
1 Gallery tour of ceramics
collection of the Lee Kong
Chian collection
Understand why people collect
material artifacts like in history
Understand how material,
design, and technology has
changed across time
Material Culture
2 Gallery tour of
Archaeology Library
Observe the kinds of
archaeological artifacts
collected from different parts
of Singapore
Understand the significance of
three objects found at the
museum
Porcelain pillow
Chinese porcelain compass
Glass beads and globules
Archaeology—place and
patterns
3 Map Activity Seed and attempt to answer
historical inquiry questions
about who lived in different
parts of Temasek in the
fourteenth century and the
kinds of activity they engaged
in.
Map activity—historical
evidence and interpretation
4 Sherd handling experience Experience one aspect of the
archaeological
process—sorting and
classification
Archaeology—classification
Third, access to student worksheets for analysis was an important source of informa-
178
tion on student learning. Three field observations were also carried out as a secondary
179
approach to triangulate data yielded from teacher interviews and reflections.
180
In the area of student learning, 116 student surveys and post-fieldtrip work (see
181
Lesson Sheets 1 and 2 in the appendices) were collected and analyzed to ascertain
182
students’ learning in terms of their prior knowledge on the topic and what they had
183
learned on their museum trip. As part of the survey, after the museum experience
184
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 231
students were also required to fill out a worksheet designed to test their knowledge
185
of sherds from the fourteenth century.
186
Finally, reflections from the MT were also used as a form of reflective data collec-
187
tion to analyze how the various institutions in the activity system were linked up
188
for collaborative work and how the challenges to collaboration had been overcome.
189
These reflections were then discussed with an education consultant researcher from
190
NIE to provide a glimpse of how the different institutions in the AT came together
191
to support museum-based lessons in schools. Cross-referencing table 11.1 (appen-
192
dices), this will be elaborated and discussed under the subsection “Collaboration
193
Among Institutions” in the next section on “Teacher Learning.”
194
11.3 Discussion
195
11.3.1 Teacher Learning
196
The teacher community represented the unit of analysis that was closest to the object
197
(studentlearning)oftheactivitysystemandplayedanimportantroleinunderstanding
198
how archaeological knowledge and museum experience were put together to enhance
199
effective learning outcomes for students in a museum-based learning experience.
200
Hence, teachers’ motivation, their confidence, and actualization of their teaching
201
experiences in the museum had a direct consequence on learning as well as their
202
interaction with students.
203
During interviews, teachers shared their perspectives on teaching ancient Singa-
204
pore history; they viewed the content as “generally boring,” “dry,” “antiquated,” and
205
as such difficult to teach. Some of them expressed their lack of in-depth knowl-
206
edge about the history of the period and contextual knowledge of artifacts, accounts,
207
and other resources as impediments to effectively teaching the topic. In the surveys,
208
some teachers shared that they also lacked awareness of how material science, artifact
209
analysis, narrative structures, and geographical mapping of artifacts could be used to
210
engage students in meaningful historical inquiry. There was also a concern that the
211
topic of ancient Singapore history lacked age-appropriate resources for 13-year-olds
212
to explore as a historical inquiry project.
213
In order to change perceptions, the Academy of Singapore Teachers held a master
214
class and sessions conducted by NUS academics and NUS Museum staff in addi-
215
tion to setting up an NLC to help teachers uncover both the substantive content
216
and syntactic structures for the topic. This enabled teachers to design meaningful
217
historical inquiry projects for their students at the museum, as will be discussed
218
below.
219
Teacher Motivation, Museum Experience, and School-Based Needs. From
220
teacher interviews and reflections, it was evident that teachers in the NLC developed
221
a strong motivation and interest in incorporating museum-based education in the
222
teaching of ancient Singapore history through the professional development program.
223
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
232 L. Yeo et al.
However, sessions by NUS academics and museum staff need to be incorporated in
224
local schools in order to be viewed as practical for teacher use.
225
In her reflections, Chris was keen on using the museum experience to complement
226
existing school experiences. Her students had simulated archaeological digs as part
227
of their history lessons, and she sought to promote archaeological evidence as a
228
way to tell the story of ancient Singapore “through a process of logical inquiry and
229
argumentation.”
230
Like Chris, Sally wanted her students to better understand the discipline of
231
archaeology and sought to embed museum experiences within her school’s history
232
curriculum, which brought students to the Asian Civilisations Museum. She was
233
keen to use the NUS Museum fieldtrip to enrich her students’ learning by giving them
234
hands-on experience handling artifacts, as well as utilizing evidence from material
235
culture as a way to engage learners to “support their construction of knowledge about
236
Singapore’s early past.”
237
Eddie wanted to use “a different lens” to tell the story of ancient Singapore beyond
238
theuseof textbookresources as anenrichment activity. Hewas interestedinproviding
239
students with “sufficient and balanced” information in order for them to develop their
240
own historical interpretation of ancient Singapore.
241
The motivations of the teachers in the NLC may be summarized as follows:
242
11.4 Map of shipwrecks
243
A strong desire to embed museum-based experiences to complement the school-
244
based history curriculum;
245
• A belief that “experiential learning beyond the classroom” can be meaningful if
246
it incorporates hands-on, tactile experiences at museums to engage learners;
247
• Developing a common vision to conduct museum-based learning as a systematic,
248
well-designed “regular” experience for all students, with the aim of engaged
249
learning.
250
In sum, teachers’ beliefs on how they valued the importance of museum-based
251
lesson designs as a way to deeply engage students on the topic of ancient Singapore
252
formed the common purpose for designing NLC museum-based lesson experiences.
253
Connected to the AT paradigm, it is worth noting that while external parties might
254
not have the same priorities in lesson design as teachers, there were a variety of
255
reasons to bring all the different parties together as units of analysis for collaboration.
256
These reasons included the following:
257
• A desire to promote among students a wider awareness of ancient Singapore as
258
shared by Miksic;
259
• A desire to promote collaboration with schools and use of museum resources
260
through museum-based outreach sessions by the NUS Museum;
261
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 233
• A desire for the NIE consultant to probe into the dynamics of how students learned
262
about ancient Singapore.
263
Learning through Master Classes and NLCs: Teacher Confidence. Teacher
264
interviews and reflections revealed that new learning through the master class and
265
NLC provided rich and sustained professional experience for teachers. For example,
266
Chris and Eddie reported that they were able to pick up “specialist and interesting
267
information about archaeology and artifacts” from the sessions, which led them to
268
seek further knowledge on the topic by “reading up and developing their content
269
knowledge” before carrying out museum-based fieldtrips and other history lessons.
270
Eddie noted that the NLC helped him develop a deeper understanding of the relation-
271
ship between technology and the different types of pottery sherds found in the four-
272
teenth century, which in turn fostered a deeper appreciation for “the role that spatial
273
distribution of artifacts played in understanding the nature of Temasek society.” Sally
274
did not attend the master class but felt that the NLC-based discussions provided rich
275
opportunities for her own learning, which convinced her that there was “value in plan-
276
ning and conducting experiential learning journeys at museums” to engage students
277
in historical inquiry.
278
During field observations of the teachers conducting museum-based lessons, the
279
teachers were observed to be well acquainted with detailed information on various
280
artifacts and displays featured at the NUS Museum. They skillfully incorporated
281
this information into museum-based lessons as part of a coherent historical inquiry
282
experience. Sally, Chris, and Eddie presented students with a chronological narra-
283
tive of human civilizations by describing the functional and aesthetic aspects of
284
pottery across time in a detailed and convincing manner. Their increased levels of
285
historical understanding and confidence were evident also when they conducted their
286
own workshop in 2019, which received positive reviews from other history teachers
287
attending the session.
288
Teacher Challenges in Museum-Based Learning. The NLC teachers faced both
289
logistical and local-based issues that were often beyond their control. One challenge
290
involved space constraints within the museum, which limited teachers to bringing
291
just one class at a time for the field-based museum experience.
292
Time constraints and Internet connectivity issues were among the other chal-
293
lenges. Sally’s and Chris’s classes were able to spend only about two hours at
294
the museum instead of the longer duration laid out in their lesson plans. Chris
295
noted that attempts to use ICT-based (information and communications technology)
296
lessons to conduct the map activity were hampered by poor Internet connectivity.
297
Sally shared that at her school, common tests and other school activities prevented
298
her from designing consolidative lessons that would have enabled her students to
299
discuss, share, and present their rich learning with students who had not had the
300
museum-based experience.
301
Another field observation was variance in teacher preparedness and ability to
302
conduct museum-based learning, particularly in situations where students were split
303
into two groups (roughly 12 to 15 in each group) led by different teachers. In
304
one observation, while one teacher was able to confidently take students through
305
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
234 L. Yeo et al.
the activities and artifact explanations in the museum, another less experienced
306
teacher demonstrated lower confidence in dealing with students’ questions on various
307
artifacts from ancient Singapore.
308
Collaboration among Institutions. From the perspective of AT, weaving collab-
309
oration among the different schools in the NLC and among different institutions
310
to create a complex web of learning was an important aspect of facilitating direct
311
and indirect transference of learning experiences from academics to teachers and
312
students.
313
This was evident in the MT reflection, when the Master Teacher shared that within
314
the NLC he and the teachers had to work hard together to (i) promote the NLC as
315
a platform to encourage teacher innovation in the classroom; (ii) demonstrate how
316
museum-based learning lesson packages could be customized to meet teacher needs
317
in developing a comprehensive, innovative, and pragmatic approach to teach ancient
318
Singapore history; and (iii) develop the NLC as a professional and valuable network
319
for sharing content and pedagogical knowledge in designing museum-based inquiry
320
learning experiences for students.
321
The MT shared that he had to work closely with other institutions to assemble
322
the learning materials for teacher use in the NLC and to consciously document the
323
implementation of museum-based lessons. For example, during phases 2 and 3 of the
324
NLC, back-end work between the MT and Miksic played a critical role in providing
325
accurate photo evidence of artifacts for classroom use. In assembling the sample of
326
sherds for student use, museum staff, with Miksic’s advice, also worked closely with
327
the MT to conceptualize how the sherd handling experience could proceed. This close
328
collaboration and support revealed how mutual understanding, professional trust,
329
and clarity on how resources could be used were critical in designing museum-based
330
learning experiences for NLCs.
331
As part of the NLC, the process of researching the pedagogical approaches used in
332
designing museum-based learning experiences was equally important. The education
333
researcher from NIE had to work collaboratively with the MT and teachers to develop
334
mutual understanding, approaches, and discussions on how to scope, analyze, and
335
review the ways in which research could be conducted and presented.
336
11.5 Student Learning
337
The previous section examined the museum experience and learning of teachers, as
338
well as the benefits of collaboration with different stakeholders in the context of an
339
NLC. From the perspective of AT and referring to table 11.1, the biggest beneficiaries
340
of the collaboration among stakeholders were the students. This will be analyzed in
341
terms of what students learned from the museum-based lessons vis-à-vis how much
342
they knew about ancient Singapore before the lessons.
343
Prior Knowledge on Ancient History of Singapore. Students come to the class-
344
room with preconceptions about how the world works, and an important learning
345
science principle is to design a learning environment that builds on their existing
346
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 235
knowledge. K. Sawyer (2014) has argued that if teaching fails to engage students’
347
prior knowledge, then the students learn just well enough to pass tests and that they
348
revert to their misconceptions outside the classroom. Because of the central impor-
349
tance of prior knowledge, a survey of students (n=116) was carried out to investigate
350
their prior knowledge. The survey revealed that 73 percent of students had prior
351
knowledge of ancient history that was largely limited to content knowledge, ranging
352
from stories of Temasek (stories of Sang Nila Utama and the founding of Singapore)
353
to the British founding of Singapore in 1819 and the latter’s subsequent development
354
as a major port in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Their sources of knowl-
355
edge were the primary school social studies curriculum as well as informal sources
356
of learning such as museum visits, stories told by parents and grandparents, and
357
watching performances at the National Day parades.
358
It is noteworthy that students’ preconceptions about ancient Singapore were
359
based mostly on historical content (first-order concepts) rather than the analytical
360
concepts (second-order concepts) that are critical for historical inquiry. Such second-
361
order concepts are related to historical agency, causation, chronology, historical
362
empathy, evidence, perspective, and significance (von Heyking, 2004; Seixas and
363
Moreton, 2012). Several students also adopted schematic but anachronistic ways of
364
understanding ancient Singapore history by using political, economic, and cultural
365
paradigms as fixed approaches.
366
What Students Learned. In the post-museum “test” (see the Survey Form in
367
the appendices), which examined students’ understanding of their sherd handling
368
experience, students were able to make a more subtle distinction among the different
369
types of artifacts compared to their prior knowledge on ceramics presented through
370
textbookphotographs,perhapsbecauseoftheirsherdhandlingexperience.Theywere
371
able to distinguish between blue-and-white sherds and, to some degree, earthenware
372
and celadon with relatively accurate levels of differentiation.
373
With reference to tables 11.4 and 11.5 in the appendices, even though 94 percent of
374
students were able to clearly identify blue-and-white ceramics, they had less success
375
in identifying green celadon wares and earthenware. One interesting finding worth
376
deeper investigation is that in school B, 66.7 percent (n=16/24) of students were able
377
to accurately identify celadon but were unable to identify glazing as an important
378
characteristic of celadon (n=16/24), which could perhaps relate to the resource table
379
that students used for their categorization task.
380
Table 11.4 Students’ recognition of ceramics
School A (n=22) School B
(n = 24)
School C (n=70) %
Blue-and-White sherd 97.1%
Glazed/unglazed 20 24 66 94.8%
Typology 21 24 69 98.3%
Use 21 24 69 93.3%
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
236 L. Yeo et al.
Table 11.5 Students’ recognition of ceramics II
School A (n=22) School B
(n = 24)
School C (n=70) %
Blue-and-white jar 90.8%
Glazed/unglazed 18 24 62 89.7%
Typology 22 24 60 91.4%
Use 20 22 64 91.4%
Celadon 64.1%
Glazed/unglazed 20 16 41 66.4%
Typology 15 16 4 63.8%
Use 15 15 42 62.1%
Earthenware 81%
Glazed/unglazed 17 22 63 88%
Typology 17 21 62 86.2%
Use 17 17 46 69%
Across the schools, students also had some difficulty differentiating between
381
stoneware and porcelain, as evidenced from field observations and students’ answers
382
in the post-test. They also had difficulty determining the functional categorization of
383
the different wares (i.e., whether something was a pot or a jar), with only 65.6 percent
384
able to do so. However, with regard to students’ inability to distinguish between jars
385
and pots, the NIE researcher felt that such issues were minor misconceptions in
386
understanding ancient Singapore.
387
Survey findings showed that in the area of conceptual understanding, students
388
were generally able to establish connections between how trade, lifestyle, culture,
389
and societal structures on the one hand and artifacts displayed in the museum were
390
interrelated as abstract-concrete approaches to understanding the period. At the anec-
391
dotal level, one student shared, “Observing the artifacts gave me insights on early
392
Singapore. The designs showed the culture and taste of what people in the past had
393
and what they were like.” Another student felt that her visit to the NUS Museum
394
helped her “understand why artifacts are made for people in the past” and “understand
395
Temasek better through their cultures.”
396
Some students were able to make specific inferences about the societal structure
397
of ancient Singapore from the map work activity by viewing high-grade ceramics as
398
being linked to the high social status of people (e.g., royalty) living on the hill (Fort
399
Canning). Others were able to link the slag and glass blobs found on Fort Canning
400
to the possible handicraft trades, such as glassmaking, that existed on the hill. Some
401
of the students were able to use the fishing hooks, slag, and other ceramics found
402
near Singapore River as evidence of the past to infer that fishing activities, trade, and
403
blacksmithing were conducted near the Singapore River area.
404
In terms of the syntactic nature of understanding ancient Singapore as a topic,
405
some students demonstrated a deeper appreciation for the work that archaeologists do
406
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 237
in uncovering evidence for the historical interpretation of this period of Singapore’s
407
history. One student shared, “The artifacts are very important, and archaeologists
408
spend a lot of time examining artifacts.”
409
Another felt that she had “learned to differentiate the materials and texture of the
410
sherds from a different time/century … and how to tell what type of material was
411
used during the early centuries.”
412
Some students who may have been overwhelmed by the information shared on
413
ceramics were also beginning to see Singapore’s history as intertwined with larger
414
regional trade links. One such student shared candidly, “I still do not really under-
415
stand Temasek better, but I now understand China’s development better in terms of its
416
pottery culture and the connections between Temasek and other countries.” Yet other
417
students, notably from School B, sought to connect the artifacts of the Belitung ship-
418
wreck, which they had seen at the Asian Civilisations Museum, with items displayed
419
at the NUS Museum. They raised interesting questions for further discussion, such
420
as why Singapore traded mostly with China and what trade processes were like in
421
the Temasek period.
422
From the experiential angle, all students in the study relished the multisensory
423
experience of observing, touching, feeling, and even smelling sherds as a means of
424
understanding historical artifacts and their link to ancient Singapore. Such object-
425
based approaches have been shown to increase empathy, interest, and engagement
426
among students in relation to classroom topics studied in different subjects (Smith,
427
2007). In retrospect, the archaeological and hands-on experiences embedded in
428
museum-based inquiry lessons enlivened and helped create a vivid and memorable
429
experience for students. The experience focused on the use of historical evidence and
430
interpretation, material culture, and archaeology serving as foundational concepts
431
to teach ancient Singapore history. The museum-based activities came together to
432
inform students on the culture, consumption habits, and societal makeup of ancient
433
Singapore. Beyond the scope of this article, teachers also likely followed up on
434
the museum learning with some form of discursive or consolidative activity in a
435
direct (face-to-face) classroom activity or indirect online discussion to consolidate
436
the museum-based learning experience. This shows that the apprehensions, barriers,
437
and obstacles to conducting museum lessons in schools were—to some degree—
438
overcome through the collaborative approaches among the different institutions via
439
the master class and NLC-based activities designed for teacher learning.
440
11.6 Implications for Teaching and Learning
441
There is a rich body of research on museum-based learning, and it is difficult to
442
adopt any one single framework to discuss its implications on teaching and learning,
443
because museum sites and approaches used to engage students are highly contextual
444
and varied. Nonetheless, general guideposts may be formed on how the specific topic
445
of ancient Singapore can be taught to engage students in a museum-based learning
446
experience.
447
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
238 L. Yeo et al.
First, this exploratory case study highlights the importance of teacher motiva-
448
tion and interest in designing interesting learning experiences for museum-based
449
learning. This case study demonstrates that there are enthusiastic teachers who are
450
interested in teaching ancient Singapore history in an experiential and engaging
451
manner by incorporating diverse sets of historical evidence for student engagement.
452
Master classes, sessions conducted by university academics and museums, NLCs,
453
and teacher-designed experiences need to be intertwined as an ecosystem to design
454
meaningful experiences for students. These experiences may be modified over recur-
455
sive cycles of teacher learning to provide authentic and meaningful ways for teachers
456
to collaborate with academics, researchers, curators, and other teachers for engaged
457
student learning. One approach is to encourage such forms of learning among lower
458
secondary history educators in order to help them design classroom lessons. Such
459
lessons, based on specialized knowledge about museum-based learning, could be
460
part of the embedded NLC-based professional development setup.
461
Second, when it comes to designing such experiences, museum-based learning
462
needs to be based on the design construct of situated learning, so that learning expe-
463
riences at museums can be “naturally tied to authentic activity, context and culture”
464
(Brown et al., 1989). The unique museum-based learning experiences in this case
465
study were not limited to students interacting with objects but were shaped through
466
constructivist approaches of students interacting with historical materials. This
467
process engaged students through multidisciplinary learning experiences. Equally
468
important in the design of such experiences is the role of the school-based curriculum
469
in supplementing, complementing, and augmenting school-based experiences with
470
museum-based learning. This could involve teachers planning and implementing
471
other museum visits, explicit classroom instruction and videos, and tapping into
472
students’ prior knowledge and experiences as myriad ways to engage students in
473
pre-museum activities.
474
Third, in the area of professional development in teaching ancient Singapore
475
history, learning experiences in the museum could involve replicating the “authen-
476
tic” work that historians and archaeologists engage in—namely, sherd handling as
477
an authentic laboratory archaeological experience and map activity that replicates
478
the kind of historical inquiry questions, evidence, and interpretation that historians
479
engage in. Such sessions could involve artifact and archaeology training sessions by
480
academics such as Miksic, which were conducted as part of the master class and
481
aimed at deepening subject matter knowledge for teachers, yet were presented in a
482
coherent and useful way for teachers to design classroom experiences. The pre- and
483
post-master class readings and discussions at the NLC allowed teachers to follow
484
up on their learning in a concrete manner focused on designing lessons for students
485
in the museum. The expanded and deep knowledge that teachers acquired from
486
such a master class allowed teachers to skillfully link and extend the school history
487
curriculum at the Secondary 1 level to specialized content knowledge linked with
488
the works of historians and curated museum collections.
489
Fourth, at the research level, more work needs to be done on teachers’ and
490
students’ understanding of specific topics such as ancient Singapore, pedagogical
491
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 239
approaches on museum-based learning, and the design and effectiveness of profes-
492
sional development as an ecosystem for designing museum-based historical inquiry
493
for students. The application of AT in this chapter sought to locate the efforts of a
494
group of schoolteachers in an NLC to systematically incorporate and embed artifact
495
resources in teaching about the ancient period of Singapore’s history, supported by
496
academic and museum institutions. The linkages between stakeholders and within the
497
teaching community (via NLC) led to enhanced teacher competencies and confidence
498
in designing positive learning experiences on the lesson topic, leading to favorable
499
student outcomes as discussed in this section.
500
Rather than classroom teaching, museum-based learning, and academic research
501
by historians being treated as distinct activity systems, closer levels of collaboration
502
need to be developed to impact museum-based and classroom-based learning expe-
503
riences for history students. Depending on the institutions involved, exploration can
504
also be carried out to develop age-appropriate resources for students through such
505
online tools as the National Heritage Board’s resources at roots.sg or NUS Press’s
506
Southeast Asian Archaeological Site Reports collections, which feature photographs
507
of other archaeological artifacts.
508
Given the positive response and outcomes among students, this case study
509
demonstrates that students’ learning about ancient Singapore or any other topic
510
in Singapore’s history can be collected, analyzed, discussed, and shared purpose-
511
fully at NLC meetings, workshops, and symposiums and as research write-ups for
512
museum-based learning and classroom design. Lastly, with regard to the minu-
513
tiae of teaching students the sherd-differentiating process, the surveys reveal that
514
even though students may find it challenging to distinguish between dull-colored
515
sherds/wares (i.e., celadon versus earthenware) or glossy sherds/wares (earthenware
516
versus stoneware), hands-on experience provides a tactile, interactive, and engaging
517
means of “doing history” on the topic of ancient Singapore. To this end, specific
518
improvements can be made in designing a clearer flowchart of criteria for students
519
to identify sherds and later use such relics of the past to develop interpretations of
520
the period.
521
Appendices
522
Museum-Based Learning Program, Learning Intentions, and Inquiry Questions
523
Inquiry question
524
1. What can archaeological evidence tell us about the people living in Temasek and
525
the kind of activities they were engaged in, in the fourteenth century?
526
Guiding questions:
527
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
240 L. Yeo et al.
1. How does archaeology work? What is the archaeological process like?
528
2. How has human material culture developed over time?
529
3. What were the kinds of artifacts discovered in Singapore?
530
4. What do these artifacts tell you about the people living in Temasek in the 14th
531
C?
532
5. What can you infer about the kind of activities that the people in Temasek were
533
doing in the 14th C?
534
Museum Learning Program
535
1. To enable students to have a better understanding of the archaeological process
536
and the work of archaeologists in supporting historians to construct knowledge
537
about Singapore’s early past.
538
2. To provide students with a broad understanding of the development of human
539
material culture.
540
3. To provide students with an opportunity for a hands-on experience in handling
541
and studying artifacts
542
Learning Intentions
543
Students will be able to
544
1. Classify and sort the sherds/ceramics according to their different types
545
2. Identify on the Singapore map where selected artifacts were discovered
546
3. Make inferences about the people living in Singapore and the kind of activities
547
that took place in Singapore in the fourteenth century, based on the artifacts
548
discovered and the additional contextual information provided
549
Student Activity Sheets. Activity 1: The Lost Bag of Sherds! Sort the Sherds!
550
Archaeology involves more than just excavation of sites to search for artifacts.
551
It also involves laboratory work to clean, catalogue, and analyze artifacts. Refer
552
to the poster for a more complete understanding of the archaeological process.
553
The Lost Bag of Sherds.
554
Study the bag of sherds on the table
555
Sort the sherds into different categories
556
Use the table that describes the characteristics of the different types of pottery to
557
guide you
558
Examine the following before sorting them
559
• Texture
560
• Color
561
• Design
562
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 241
Explain why you categorize the sherds in those ways
563
Activity 2: Plot it On a Map
564
The map shows you 3 major excavations sites in Singapore:
565
Fort Canning Hill
566
St Andrews’ Cathedral
567
River Area: Empress Place/ Parliament House Complex / Old Parliament House
568
/ Padang
569
Archaeologists discovered various artifacts in these three areas and more is written
570
about them in the cards
571
Study the pictures of artifacts and the additional information given to you.
572
Sort the artifacts according to where they were discovered in Singapore.
573
Plot these artifacts on the map.
574
575
Courtesy of the National Museum of Singapore, National Heritage Board.
576
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
242 L. Yeo et al.
577
Look for two or three other artifacts that were discovered in Singapore from the
578
Archaeology Library (not mentioned in the pictures) and then plot them on the map.
579
• Map your activity and then answer the following questions
580
• What was life like for people who lived in the different areas in Ancient Singapore?
581
• What evidence supports your argument?
582
Sample survey: Survey on the learning of ancient Singapore and sherd handling
583
Write down five keywords about what you learned in chapters 1 and 2 on Temasek
584
Singapore.
585
586
Did you know about Temasek Singapore (Temasek) before you study it in school?
587
Yes/No
588
What did you know about Temasek Singapore?
589
How did you know about Temasek Singapore then?
590
591
What did you like about the trips to the museums?
592
593
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 243
Write down 3–5 keywords about what you learned at the Asian Civilisations
594
Museum (ACM)?
595
596
How did going to the NUS Museum help you better understand Temasek
597
Singapore?
598
599
Can you make a suggestion to improve learning at the museums?
600
601
References
602
Bertelsen, O. W.,  Bødker, S. (2003). Activity theory. In J. Carroll (Ed.), HCI models, theories,
603
and framewors: Toward an interdisciplinary science. San Francisco: Morgan Kaufmann.
604
Brown, J. S., Collins, A.,  Duguid, P. (1989). Situated cognition and the culture of learning.
605
Educational Researcher, 18(1), 32–42.
606
Chew, E. (2008). Views, values and perceptions in geographical fieldwork in Singapore schools.
607
International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 17(4), 307–329.
608
Chee, M. F. (2006). Training teachers for the Effective Use of Museum. International Journal of
609
Historical Learning, Teaching and Research, 6(1), 10–16.
610
Crowley, K., Pierroux, P.,  Knutson, K. (2014). Informal Learning in Museums. In K. Sawyer
611
(Ed.), Cambridge Handbook of the Learning Sciences (pp. 461–478). Cambridge: Cambridge
612
University Press.
613
Engestrom, Y. (1987). Learning by expanding: An activity-theoretical approach to developmental
614
research. Helsinki: Orienta-Konsultit.
615
Engeström,Y.,Miettinen,R.,Punamäki,R.-L.(1999).Perspectivesonactivitytheory.Cambridge:
616
Cambridge University Press.
617
Engestrom, Y. (2001). Expansive learning at work: Toward an activity theoretical reconceptualiza-
618
tion. Journal of Education and Work, 14, 133–156.
619
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
244 L. Yeo et al.
Engestrom, Y., Puonti, A.,  Seppanen, L. (2003). Spatial and temporal expansion of the object as
620
a challenge for reorganizing work In D. Nicolini, S. Gherardi  D. Yanow (Eds.), Knowing in
621
organizations: A practice-based approach (pp. 151-186). New York: Routledge.
622
MOE (2017). Guide to Effective Professional Development, Volume 3: Networked Learning
623
Community. Retrieved from http://tinyurl.com/Effective-PD-NLC.
624
Hollen, D.,  Throop, J. (2008). Whatever happened to empathy? Ethos, 36(4), 385–401.
625
J. Park. (2014). A Conceptual Framework for Analysing Social Systems surrounding Korean
626
National Museumsinthe Digital Age.InMuseumsandthe WebAsia 2014,N.ProctorR.Cherry
627
(eds). Silver Spring, MD: Museums and the Web. Published September 29, 2014. Consulted May
628
22, 2020. https://mwa2014.museumsandtheweb.com/paper/a-conceptual-framework-for-analys
629
ing-social-systems-surrounding-korean-national-museums-in-the-digital-age/. With permissions
630
from Juhee Park.
631
Jackson, D.,  Temperley, J. (2007). From professional learning community to networked learning
632
community. In L. Stoll  K. S. Louis (Eds.), Professional learning communities: Divergence,
633
depth and dilemmas (pp. 45–62). Maidenhead: Open University Press.
634
Oh, Y. J. (2018). Historical Evidence: Archaeological Practice as a Pedagogical Tool for Historical
635
Education in Singapore. HSSE Online, 6(2). Retrieved from https://www.hsseonline.edu.sg/jou
636
rnal/volume-7-issue-2-2018/historical-evidence-archaeological-practice-pedagogical-tool on 11
637
June 2019.
638
Seixas, D. P.,  Morton, T. (2013). The Big Six Historical Thinking Concepts. Toronto: Nelson
639
Education.
640
Sim, Teddy. (2015). Exploring sources on pre-modern history of Singapore: Review essay of
641
“Jacques de Coutre’s and Mantelieff’s Singapore and Johor”. HSSE Online, 4(2), 17–35.
642
Stoddard, J. D. (2018). Learning history beyond school. In S. Metzger  L. Harris (Eds.), The Wiley
643
International Handbook of History Teaching and Learning (pp. 631–51). Hoboken: Wiley.
644
Nabors, M. L., Edwards, L. C.,  Murray, R. K. (2009). Making the case for field trips: what
645
research tells us and what site coordinators have to say. Education, 129(4), 661–667.
646
National Museum (2017). National Museum resources, Retrieved from https://www.nationalm
647
useum.sg/-/media/nms2017/documents/school-programmes/teachers-hi-resource-unit-1-precol
648
onial.pdf
649
Seixas,P.,Moreton,T.(2012).TheBigSix:Historicalthinkingconcepts.Toronto:NelsonCollege.
650
Smith, M. M. (200). Sensing the Past: Seeing, Hearing, Smell, Tasting and Touching in History.
651
California: University of California Press.
652
Heyking, A. V. (2004). Historical Thinking in the Elementary Years: A Review of Current Research.
653
Canadian Social Studies, 39(1). Retrieved from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1073974.pdf.
654
Rieber, R. W.,  Carton, A. S. (Eds). (1987). The collected works of L.S.Vygotsky, Vol 1: Problems
655
of general psychology. New York: Plenum.
656
Lloyd Yeo Tze Chiang is a Master Teacher at the Academy of Singapore Teachers (AST) in
657
History. He graduated from the National University of Singapore (BA Hons) specializing in the
658
American Civil War in 1996 and obtained his Master Of Education: Curriculum and Teachingin
659
2013. He has taught in Singapore’s Gabrielite Schools for almost 20 years has authored and co-
660
authored more than 12 publications and articles. His research interests include history education,
661
pedagogy, literacies and curriculum design, teacher identity and narrative inquiry.
662
Sazryna Lee Samsudin is a Senior Teacher (History) based in Singapore, teaching both History
663
and Social Studies at Seng Kang Secondary School. She graduated from the National Univer-
664
sity of Singapore with a BA in History and Sociology, and had also attained a Post-Graduate
665
Diploma in Education (PGDE) at the National Institute of Education, Singapore. She has taught
666
secondary school students for about 20 years and is always looking for ways to better engage the
667
students in the learning of History, such as through Inquiry-based Learning, Experiential Learning
668
and Differentiated Instruction. This has led her to collaborate with other like-minded Senior and
669
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
U
N
C
O
R
R
E
C
T
E
D
P
R
O
O
F
11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 245
Lead Teachers from other schools to form Networked Learning Communities (NLC), led by the
670
Master Teachers from the AST, to design learning experiences and activities in these areas so as
671
to develop students’ interest in and deepen their understanding of History. In 2017, she had co-
672
presented with her NLC team on ‘Differentiated Instruction in the Humanities Classroom’ at the
673
MOE Excelfest, while in 2019, she had co-conducted a Teacher-led Workshop with her NLC team
674
on ‘Using Historical Evidence in Teaching Pre-Modern Singapore.’
675
Cherie Heng is an educator who teaches History and Social Studies at Secondary level. She
676
graduated from the National University of Singapore (BA Hons) specializing in Southeast Asian
677
Studies and obtained her Master of Education (Education Psychology) from NIE/NTU. Her
678
research interests include History pedagogy and curriculum design, Concept-based Learning as
679
well as Educational Psychology. She is currently Senior Teacher at CHIJ Secondary School.
680
Ezal Bin Sani is a Lead Teacher (History) based in Singapore, who teaches both History and
681
Social studies at Fairfield Methodist School (Secondary). He is passionate about promoting active
682
learners in the History classroom and is also a strong advocate of maximising ICT affordances in
683
and out of the classroom. An MOE Teaching award recipient, he attained a BA in History and
684
English Language at the National University of Singapore in and a Post Graduate Diploma in
685
Education (PGDE) in Education at the National Institute of Education.
686
Teddy Y. H. Sim (FRHistS) is currently lecturing at the Institute of Education in Nanyang Tech-
687
nological University in Singapore. He has published on specific involvements of the Portuguese
688
in the East. He is the author of Portuguese Enterprise in the East: Survival in the Years 1707-57
689
and editor of Piracy and surreptitious activities in the Malay Archipelago and adjacent seas 1600-
690
1840 and Maritime defence of China: Ming general Qi Jiguang and beyond. Teddy is passionate
691
about fieldtrips in his history courses on South and Southeast Asia. His courses usually feature a
692
local or overseas trip that facilitates as part of the overall study and exploration.
693
473006_1_En_11_Chapter  TYPESET DISK LE  CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard

Contenu connexe

Tendances

The Statutory Implementation of the new maths curriculum in England
The Statutory Implementation of the new maths curriculum in EnglandThe Statutory Implementation of the new maths curriculum in England
The Statutory Implementation of the new maths curriculum in EnglandFiona Henchley
 
Seminar Proposal "Penerapan Pendekatan Penemuan Terbimbing Untuk Meningkatkan...
Seminar Proposal "Penerapan Pendekatan Penemuan Terbimbing Untuk Meningkatkan...Seminar Proposal "Penerapan Pendekatan Penemuan Terbimbing Untuk Meningkatkan...
Seminar Proposal "Penerapan Pendekatan Penemuan Terbimbing Untuk Meningkatkan...Nasrullah Sulaiman
 
Evaluation of topical coverage and study questions of approved
Evaluation of topical coverage and study questions of approvedEvaluation of topical coverage and study questions of approved
Evaluation of topical coverage and study questions of approvedAlexander Decker
 
Common Core State Standards: Many Paths to Museum Educational Competency
Common Core State Standards: Many Paths to Museum Educational CompetencyCommon Core State Standards: Many Paths to Museum Educational Competency
Common Core State Standards: Many Paths to Museum Educational CompetencyWest Muse
 
Making authentic science accesible to students
Making authentic science accesible to studentsMaking authentic science accesible to students
Making authentic science accesible to studentsSheila Shamuganathan
 
Thinking+Beyond+the+Classroom
Thinking+Beyond+the+ClassroomThinking+Beyond+the+Classroom
Thinking+Beyond+the+Classroomazstt
 
Elephants, Butterflies and Moths in the Amazon Rainforest: High Epistemic Qua...
Elephants, Butterflies and Moths in the Amazon Rainforest: High Epistemic Qua...Elephants, Butterflies and Moths in the Amazon Rainforest: High Epistemic Qua...
Elephants, Butterflies and Moths in the Amazon Rainforest: High Epistemic Qua...Brian Hudson
 
Nigerian science teachers’ perceptions of effective science teaching and thei...
Nigerian science teachers’ perceptions of effective science teaching and thei...Nigerian science teachers’ perceptions of effective science teaching and thei...
Nigerian science teachers’ perceptions of effective science teaching and thei...Alexander Decker
 
International conference on jaipur final2007
International conference on jaipur final2007International conference on jaipur final2007
International conference on jaipur final2007Dr.Amol Ubale
 
Effectiveness of Concept Mapping Strategy on Cognitive Process in Sciences at...
Effectiveness of Concept Mapping Strategy on Cognitive Process in Sciences at...Effectiveness of Concept Mapping Strategy on Cognitive Process in Sciences at...
Effectiveness of Concept Mapping Strategy on Cognitive Process in Sciences at...Ramakanta Mohalik
 

Tendances (11)

Conasta cwsd pres
Conasta cwsd presConasta cwsd pres
Conasta cwsd pres
 
The Statutory Implementation of the new maths curriculum in England
The Statutory Implementation of the new maths curriculum in EnglandThe Statutory Implementation of the new maths curriculum in England
The Statutory Implementation of the new maths curriculum in England
 
Seminar Proposal "Penerapan Pendekatan Penemuan Terbimbing Untuk Meningkatkan...
Seminar Proposal "Penerapan Pendekatan Penemuan Terbimbing Untuk Meningkatkan...Seminar Proposal "Penerapan Pendekatan Penemuan Terbimbing Untuk Meningkatkan...
Seminar Proposal "Penerapan Pendekatan Penemuan Terbimbing Untuk Meningkatkan...
 
Evaluation of topical coverage and study questions of approved
Evaluation of topical coverage and study questions of approvedEvaluation of topical coverage and study questions of approved
Evaluation of topical coverage and study questions of approved
 
Common Core State Standards: Many Paths to Museum Educational Competency
Common Core State Standards: Many Paths to Museum Educational CompetencyCommon Core State Standards: Many Paths to Museum Educational Competency
Common Core State Standards: Many Paths to Museum Educational Competency
 
Making authentic science accesible to students
Making authentic science accesible to studentsMaking authentic science accesible to students
Making authentic science accesible to students
 
Thinking+Beyond+the+Classroom
Thinking+Beyond+the+ClassroomThinking+Beyond+the+Classroom
Thinking+Beyond+the+Classroom
 
Elephants, Butterflies and Moths in the Amazon Rainforest: High Epistemic Qua...
Elephants, Butterflies and Moths in the Amazon Rainforest: High Epistemic Qua...Elephants, Butterflies and Moths in the Amazon Rainforest: High Epistemic Qua...
Elephants, Butterflies and Moths in the Amazon Rainforest: High Epistemic Qua...
 
Nigerian science teachers’ perceptions of effective science teaching and thei...
Nigerian science teachers’ perceptions of effective science teaching and thei...Nigerian science teachers’ perceptions of effective science teaching and thei...
Nigerian science teachers’ perceptions of effective science teaching and thei...
 
International conference on jaipur final2007
International conference on jaipur final2007International conference on jaipur final2007
International conference on jaipur final2007
 
Effectiveness of Concept Mapping Strategy on Cognitive Process in Sciences at...
Effectiveness of Concept Mapping Strategy on Cognitive Process in Sciences at...Effectiveness of Concept Mapping Strategy on Cognitive Process in Sciences at...
Effectiveness of Concept Mapping Strategy on Cognitive Process in Sciences at...
 

Similaire à Use of museum and artifact based fieldtrips in the teaching of ancient singapore

Research proposal museum magnet school program
Research proposal  museum magnet school programResearch proposal  museum magnet school program
Research proposal museum magnet school programRozekRuzaini Tajuddin
 
Improvisation of Teacher-Made Instructional Media and Students’ Performance ...
 Improvisation of Teacher-Made Instructional Media and Students’ Performance ... Improvisation of Teacher-Made Instructional Media and Students’ Performance ...
Improvisation of Teacher-Made Instructional Media and Students’ Performance ...Research Journal of Education
 
Strategic Intervention Material SIM for Grade 11 Science
Strategic Intervention Material SIM for Grade 11 ScienceStrategic Intervention Material SIM for Grade 11 Science
Strategic Intervention Material SIM for Grade 11 Scienceijtsrd
 
The laboratory in science
The laboratory in scienceThe laboratory in science
The laboratory in scienceArys Rivera
 
A Representation Construction Approach
A Representation Construction ApproachA Representation Construction Approach
A Representation Construction ApproachAmy Cernava
 
Making scientific concepts explicit through explanations simulations of a hig...
Making scientific concepts explicit through explanations simulations of a hig...Making scientific concepts explicit through explanations simulations of a hig...
Making scientific concepts explicit through explanations simulations of a hig...Lazar Stosic
 
Using Augmented Reality for Teaching Physics.
Using Augmented Reality for Teaching Physics.Using Augmented Reality for Teaching Physics.
Using Augmented Reality for Teaching Physics.Prachyanun Nilsook
 
Integration of Phet Interactive Simulations in Online Synchronous and Asynchr...
Integration of Phet Interactive Simulations in Online Synchronous and Asynchr...Integration of Phet Interactive Simulations in Online Synchronous and Asynchr...
Integration of Phet Interactive Simulations in Online Synchronous and Asynchr...ijtsrd
 
Environmental Education in Cyprus
Environmental Education in CyprusEnvironmental Education in Cyprus
Environmental Education in CyprusRafailia Katsioula
 
Science Fiction in Education - ICEM conference in Eger
Science Fiction in Education - ICEM conference in EgerScience Fiction in Education - ICEM conference in Eger
Science Fiction in Education - ICEM conference in EgerCharalambos Vrasidas, Ph.D.
 
SPIRAL PROGRESSION APPROACH IN THE K TO 12 SCIENCE CURRICULUM: A LITERATURE R...
SPIRAL PROGRESSION APPROACH IN THE K TO 12 SCIENCE CURRICULUM: A LITERATURE R...SPIRAL PROGRESSION APPROACH IN THE K TO 12 SCIENCE CURRICULUM: A LITERATURE R...
SPIRAL PROGRESSION APPROACH IN THE K TO 12 SCIENCE CURRICULUM: A LITERATURE R...ijejournal
 
Thinking through Ethnoscientific Scenarios for Physics Teaching Implication f...
Thinking through Ethnoscientific Scenarios for Physics Teaching Implication f...Thinking through Ethnoscientific Scenarios for Physics Teaching Implication f...
Thinking through Ethnoscientific Scenarios for Physics Teaching Implication f...ijtsrd
 
An inquiry based cellulase laboratory
An inquiry based cellulase laboratoryAn inquiry based cellulase laboratory
An inquiry based cellulase laboratorykamegasilvia
 
Implementing strategies in science teaching, Menelaos Sotiriou
Implementing strategies in science teaching, Menelaos SotiriouImplementing strategies in science teaching, Menelaos Sotiriou
Implementing strategies in science teaching, Menelaos SotiriouBrussels, Belgium
 
E. Kyza: Motivating teacher and student science learning
E. Kyza:	Motivating teacher and student science learning E. Kyza:	Motivating teacher and student science learning
E. Kyza: Motivating teacher and student science learning Brussels, Belgium
 
Tojde 2017 1463-published
Tojde 2017 1463-publishedTojde 2017 1463-published
Tojde 2017 1463-publishedzakaria Arif
 
Teacher action research project summary report
Teacher action research project summary reportTeacher action research project summary report
Teacher action research project summary reportScottish TNE
 

Similaire à Use of museum and artifact based fieldtrips in the teaching of ancient singapore (20)

Research proposal museum magnet school program
Research proposal  museum magnet school programResearch proposal  museum magnet school program
Research proposal museum magnet school program
 
Improvisation of Teacher-Made Instructional Media and Students’ Performance ...
 Improvisation of Teacher-Made Instructional Media and Students’ Performance ... Improvisation of Teacher-Made Instructional Media and Students’ Performance ...
Improvisation of Teacher-Made Instructional Media and Students’ Performance ...
 
Strategic Intervention Material SIM for Grade 11 Science
Strategic Intervention Material SIM for Grade 11 ScienceStrategic Intervention Material SIM for Grade 11 Science
Strategic Intervention Material SIM for Grade 11 Science
 
The laboratory in science
The laboratory in scienceThe laboratory in science
The laboratory in science
 
A Representation Construction Approach
A Representation Construction ApproachA Representation Construction Approach
A Representation Construction Approach
 
Making scientific concepts explicit through explanations simulations of a hig...
Making scientific concepts explicit through explanations simulations of a hig...Making scientific concepts explicit through explanations simulations of a hig...
Making scientific concepts explicit through explanations simulations of a hig...
 
Using Augmented Reality for Teaching Physics.
Using Augmented Reality for Teaching Physics.Using Augmented Reality for Teaching Physics.
Using Augmented Reality for Teaching Physics.
 
Integration of Phet Interactive Simulations in Online Synchronous and Asynchr...
Integration of Phet Interactive Simulations in Online Synchronous and Asynchr...Integration of Phet Interactive Simulations in Online Synchronous and Asynchr...
Integration of Phet Interactive Simulations in Online Synchronous and Asynchr...
 
Environmental Education in Cyprus
Environmental Education in CyprusEnvironmental Education in Cyprus
Environmental Education in Cyprus
 
172157
172157172157
172157
 
Science Fiction in Education - ICEM conference in Eger
Science Fiction in Education - ICEM conference in EgerScience Fiction in Education - ICEM conference in Eger
Science Fiction in Education - ICEM conference in Eger
 
SPIRAL PROGRESSION APPROACH IN THE K TO 12 SCIENCE CURRICULUM: A LITERATURE R...
SPIRAL PROGRESSION APPROACH IN THE K TO 12 SCIENCE CURRICULUM: A LITERATURE R...SPIRAL PROGRESSION APPROACH IN THE K TO 12 SCIENCE CURRICULUM: A LITERATURE R...
SPIRAL PROGRESSION APPROACH IN THE K TO 12 SCIENCE CURRICULUM: A LITERATURE R...
 
Thinking through Ethnoscientific Scenarios for Physics Teaching Implication f...
Thinking through Ethnoscientific Scenarios for Physics Teaching Implication f...Thinking through Ethnoscientific Scenarios for Physics Teaching Implication f...
Thinking through Ethnoscientific Scenarios for Physics Teaching Implication f...
 
An inquiry based cellulase laboratory
An inquiry based cellulase laboratoryAn inquiry based cellulase laboratory
An inquiry based cellulase laboratory
 
Implementing strategies in science teaching, Menelaos Sotiriou
Implementing strategies in science teaching, Menelaos SotiriouImplementing strategies in science teaching, Menelaos Sotiriou
Implementing strategies in science teaching, Menelaos Sotiriou
 
E. Kyza: Motivating teacher and student science learning
E. Kyza:	Motivating teacher and student science learning E. Kyza:	Motivating teacher and student science learning
E. Kyza: Motivating teacher and student science learning
 
Tojde 2017 1463-published
Tojde 2017 1463-publishedTojde 2017 1463-published
Tojde 2017 1463-published
 
Fieldwork report museum magnet
Fieldwork report   museum magnetFieldwork report   museum magnet
Fieldwork report museum magnet
 
Teacher action research project summary report
Teacher action research project summary reportTeacher action research project summary report
Teacher action research project summary report
 
EFFECTIVENESS OF HEUTAGOGY INTEGRATED E-CONTENT MODULES ON UNDESTANDING OSMOS...
EFFECTIVENESS OF HEUTAGOGY INTEGRATED E-CONTENT MODULES ON UNDESTANDING OSMOS...EFFECTIVENESS OF HEUTAGOGY INTEGRATED E-CONTENT MODULES ON UNDESTANDING OSMOS...
EFFECTIVENESS OF HEUTAGOGY INTEGRATED E-CONTENT MODULES ON UNDESTANDING OSMOS...
 

Plus de Lloyd Yeo

Interview with Kwek Keng Tee
Interview with Kwek Keng TeeInterview with Kwek Keng Tee
Interview with Kwek Keng TeeLloyd Yeo
 
Poems by Mamoru Shinozaki
Poems by Mamoru Shinozaki Poems by Mamoru Shinozaki
Poems by Mamoru Shinozaki Lloyd Yeo
 
Poems of Maurice Crowther
Poems of  Maurice CrowtherPoems of  Maurice Crowther
Poems of Maurice CrowtherLloyd Yeo
 
Poems by Mary Thomas
Poems by Mary ThomasPoems by Mary Thomas
Poems by Mary ThomasLloyd Yeo
 
Map of SIngapore excavation sites
Map of SIngapore excavation sitesMap of SIngapore excavation sites
Map of SIngapore excavation sitesLloyd Yeo
 
Sources for NUS museum visit by students
Sources for NUS museum visit by studentsSources for NUS museum visit by students
Sources for NUS museum visit by studentsLloyd Yeo
 
Coach classic (adapted from Coach's piece, 2000)
Coach classic (adapted from Coach's piece, 2000)Coach classic (adapted from Coach's piece, 2000)
Coach classic (adapted from Coach's piece, 2000)Lloyd Yeo
 
Student interpretations of 14th century Singapore
Student interpretations of 14th century SingaporeStudent interpretations of 14th century Singapore
Student interpretations of 14th century SingaporeLloyd Yeo
 
Use of cartoons in the history classroom (open source)
Use of cartoons in the history classroom (open source)Use of cartoons in the history classroom (open source)
Use of cartoons in the history classroom (open source)Lloyd Yeo
 
Impact and chronology of Japanese Occupation in Singapore and Malaya
Impact and chronology of Japanese Occupation in Singapore and MalayaImpact and chronology of Japanese Occupation in Singapore and Malaya
Impact and chronology of Japanese Occupation in Singapore and MalayaLloyd Yeo
 
Excerpts of preface (i found a bone and other poems)
Excerpts of preface (i found a bone and other poems)Excerpts of preface (i found a bone and other poems)
Excerpts of preface (i found a bone and other poems)Lloyd Yeo
 
I Found a Bone by Teo Kah Leng (and historical background)
I Found a Bone by Teo Kah Leng (and historical background)I Found a Bone by Teo Kah Leng (and historical background)
I Found a Bone by Teo Kah Leng (and historical background)Lloyd Yeo
 
14th century sg artifacts and info links
14th century sg artifacts and info links14th century sg artifacts and info links
14th century sg artifacts and info linksLloyd Yeo
 
Anthropology archaeology and accounts samples
Anthropology archaeology and accounts samplesAnthropology archaeology and accounts samples
Anthropology archaeology and accounts samplesLloyd Yeo
 
Pedagogical value of cartoons in the History Classroom
Pedagogical value of cartoons in the History ClassroomPedagogical value of cartoons in the History Classroom
Pedagogical value of cartoons in the History ClassroomLloyd Yeo
 
Student interpreations of Singapore Immigration in the 19th century
Student interpreations of Singapore Immigration in the 19th centuryStudent interpreations of Singapore Immigration in the 19th century
Student interpreations of Singapore Immigration in the 19th centuryLloyd Yeo
 
Cuban missile crisis review lesson
Cuban missile crisis review lessonCuban missile crisis review lesson
Cuban missile crisis review lessonLloyd Yeo
 
Teacher Leader Framework
Teacher Leader Framework Teacher Leader Framework
Teacher Leader Framework Lloyd Yeo
 
Teacher Leader Development: A Narrative Inquiry
Teacher Leader Development: A Narrative InquiryTeacher Leader Development: A Narrative Inquiry
Teacher Leader Development: A Narrative InquiryLloyd Yeo
 
Augmented Reality: A Case Study on an Interactive Heritage Trail for High Sch...
Augmented Reality: A Case Study on an Interactive Heritage Trail for High Sch...Augmented Reality: A Case Study on an Interactive Heritage Trail for High Sch...
Augmented Reality: A Case Study on an Interactive Heritage Trail for High Sch...Lloyd Yeo
 

Plus de Lloyd Yeo (20)

Interview with Kwek Keng Tee
Interview with Kwek Keng TeeInterview with Kwek Keng Tee
Interview with Kwek Keng Tee
 
Poems by Mamoru Shinozaki
Poems by Mamoru Shinozaki Poems by Mamoru Shinozaki
Poems by Mamoru Shinozaki
 
Poems of Maurice Crowther
Poems of  Maurice CrowtherPoems of  Maurice Crowther
Poems of Maurice Crowther
 
Poems by Mary Thomas
Poems by Mary ThomasPoems by Mary Thomas
Poems by Mary Thomas
 
Map of SIngapore excavation sites
Map of SIngapore excavation sitesMap of SIngapore excavation sites
Map of SIngapore excavation sites
 
Sources for NUS museum visit by students
Sources for NUS museum visit by studentsSources for NUS museum visit by students
Sources for NUS museum visit by students
 
Coach classic (adapted from Coach's piece, 2000)
Coach classic (adapted from Coach's piece, 2000)Coach classic (adapted from Coach's piece, 2000)
Coach classic (adapted from Coach's piece, 2000)
 
Student interpretations of 14th century Singapore
Student interpretations of 14th century SingaporeStudent interpretations of 14th century Singapore
Student interpretations of 14th century Singapore
 
Use of cartoons in the history classroom (open source)
Use of cartoons in the history classroom (open source)Use of cartoons in the history classroom (open source)
Use of cartoons in the history classroom (open source)
 
Impact and chronology of Japanese Occupation in Singapore and Malaya
Impact and chronology of Japanese Occupation in Singapore and MalayaImpact and chronology of Japanese Occupation in Singapore and Malaya
Impact and chronology of Japanese Occupation in Singapore and Malaya
 
Excerpts of preface (i found a bone and other poems)
Excerpts of preface (i found a bone and other poems)Excerpts of preface (i found a bone and other poems)
Excerpts of preface (i found a bone and other poems)
 
I Found a Bone by Teo Kah Leng (and historical background)
I Found a Bone by Teo Kah Leng (and historical background)I Found a Bone by Teo Kah Leng (and historical background)
I Found a Bone by Teo Kah Leng (and historical background)
 
14th century sg artifacts and info links
14th century sg artifacts and info links14th century sg artifacts and info links
14th century sg artifacts and info links
 
Anthropology archaeology and accounts samples
Anthropology archaeology and accounts samplesAnthropology archaeology and accounts samples
Anthropology archaeology and accounts samples
 
Pedagogical value of cartoons in the History Classroom
Pedagogical value of cartoons in the History ClassroomPedagogical value of cartoons in the History Classroom
Pedagogical value of cartoons in the History Classroom
 
Student interpreations of Singapore Immigration in the 19th century
Student interpreations of Singapore Immigration in the 19th centuryStudent interpreations of Singapore Immigration in the 19th century
Student interpreations of Singapore Immigration in the 19th century
 
Cuban missile crisis review lesson
Cuban missile crisis review lessonCuban missile crisis review lesson
Cuban missile crisis review lesson
 
Teacher Leader Framework
Teacher Leader Framework Teacher Leader Framework
Teacher Leader Framework
 
Teacher Leader Development: A Narrative Inquiry
Teacher Leader Development: A Narrative InquiryTeacher Leader Development: A Narrative Inquiry
Teacher Leader Development: A Narrative Inquiry
 
Augmented Reality: A Case Study on an Interactive Heritage Trail for High Sch...
Augmented Reality: A Case Study on an Interactive Heritage Trail for High Sch...Augmented Reality: A Case Study on an Interactive Heritage Trail for High Sch...
Augmented Reality: A Case Study on an Interactive Heritage Trail for High Sch...
 

Dernier

4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx
4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx
4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptxmary850239
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
Q4-PPT-Music9_Lesson-1-Romantic-Opera.pptx
Q4-PPT-Music9_Lesson-1-Romantic-Opera.pptxQ4-PPT-Music9_Lesson-1-Romantic-Opera.pptx
Q4-PPT-Music9_Lesson-1-Romantic-Opera.pptxlancelewisportillo
 
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptxmary850239
 
ClimART Action | eTwinning Project
ClimART Action    |    eTwinning ProjectClimART Action    |    eTwinning Project
ClimART Action | eTwinning Projectjordimapav
 
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptxROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptxVanesaIglesias10
 
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdfInclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdfTechSoup
 
Visit to a blind student's school🧑‍🦯🧑‍🦯(community medicine)
Visit to a blind student's school🧑‍🦯🧑‍🦯(community medicine)Visit to a blind student's school🧑‍🦯🧑‍🦯(community medicine)
Visit to a blind student's school🧑‍🦯🧑‍🦯(community medicine)lakshayb543
 
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17Celine George
 
Transaction Management in Database Management System
Transaction Management in Database Management SystemTransaction Management in Database Management System
Transaction Management in Database Management SystemChristalin Nelson
 
Oppenheimer Film Discussion for Philosophy and Film
Oppenheimer Film Discussion for Philosophy and FilmOppenheimer Film Discussion for Philosophy and Film
Oppenheimer Film Discussion for Philosophy and FilmStan Meyer
 
Concurrency Control in Database Management system
Concurrency Control in Database Management systemConcurrency Control in Database Management system
Concurrency Control in Database Management systemChristalin Nelson
 
Student Profile Sample - We help schools to connect the data they have, with ...
Student Profile Sample - We help schools to connect the data they have, with ...Student Profile Sample - We help schools to connect the data they have, with ...
Student Profile Sample - We help schools to connect the data they have, with ...Seán Kennedy
 
The Contemporary World: The Globalization of World Politics
The Contemporary World: The Globalization of World PoliticsThe Contemporary World: The Globalization of World Politics
The Contemporary World: The Globalization of World PoliticsRommel Regala
 
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4JOYLYNSAMANIEGO
 
How to do quick user assign in kanban in Odoo 17 ERP
How to do quick user assign in kanban in Odoo 17 ERPHow to do quick user assign in kanban in Odoo 17 ERP
How to do quick user assign in kanban in Odoo 17 ERPCeline George
 
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTSGRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTSJoshuaGantuangco2
 
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for ParentsChoosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parentsnavabharathschool99
 

Dernier (20)

4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx
4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx
4.16.24 Poverty and Precarity--Desmond.pptx
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 3 STEPS Using Odoo 17
 
Q4-PPT-Music9_Lesson-1-Romantic-Opera.pptx
Q4-PPT-Music9_Lesson-1-Romantic-Opera.pptxQ4-PPT-Music9_Lesson-1-Romantic-Opera.pptx
Q4-PPT-Music9_Lesson-1-Romantic-Opera.pptx
 
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
4.16.24 21st Century Movements for Black Lives.pptx
 
ClimART Action | eTwinning Project
ClimART Action    |    eTwinning ProjectClimART Action    |    eTwinning Project
ClimART Action | eTwinning Project
 
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptxROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
ROLES IN A STAGE PRODUCTION in arts.pptx
 
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdfInclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
Inclusivity Essentials_ Creating Accessible Websites for Nonprofits .pdf
 
Visit to a blind student's school🧑‍🦯🧑‍🦯(community medicine)
Visit to a blind student's school🧑‍🦯🧑‍🦯(community medicine)Visit to a blind student's school🧑‍🦯🧑‍🦯(community medicine)
Visit to a blind student's school🧑‍🦯🧑‍🦯(community medicine)
 
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
How to Add Barcode on PDF Report in Odoo 17
 
INCLUSIVE EDUCATION PRACTICES FOR TEACHERS AND TRAINERS.pptx
INCLUSIVE EDUCATION PRACTICES FOR TEACHERS AND TRAINERS.pptxINCLUSIVE EDUCATION PRACTICES FOR TEACHERS AND TRAINERS.pptx
INCLUSIVE EDUCATION PRACTICES FOR TEACHERS AND TRAINERS.pptx
 
Transaction Management in Database Management System
Transaction Management in Database Management SystemTransaction Management in Database Management System
Transaction Management in Database Management System
 
Oppenheimer Film Discussion for Philosophy and Film
Oppenheimer Film Discussion for Philosophy and FilmOppenheimer Film Discussion for Philosophy and Film
Oppenheimer Film Discussion for Philosophy and Film
 
Concurrency Control in Database Management system
Concurrency Control in Database Management systemConcurrency Control in Database Management system
Concurrency Control in Database Management system
 
Student Profile Sample - We help schools to connect the data they have, with ...
Student Profile Sample - We help schools to connect the data they have, with ...Student Profile Sample - We help schools to connect the data they have, with ...
Student Profile Sample - We help schools to connect the data they have, with ...
 
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptxYOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
YOUVE GOT EMAIL_FINALS_EL_DORADO_2024.pptx
 
The Contemporary World: The Globalization of World Politics
The Contemporary World: The Globalization of World PoliticsThe Contemporary World: The Globalization of World Politics
The Contemporary World: The Globalization of World Politics
 
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4
Daily Lesson Plan in Mathematics Quarter 4
 
How to do quick user assign in kanban in Odoo 17 ERP
How to do quick user assign in kanban in Odoo 17 ERPHow to do quick user assign in kanban in Odoo 17 ERP
How to do quick user assign in kanban in Odoo 17 ERP
 
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTSGRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
GRADE 4 - SUMMATIVE TEST QUARTER 4 ALL SUBJECTS
 
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for ParentsChoosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
Choosing the Right CBSE School A Comprehensive Guide for Parents
 

Use of museum and artifact based fieldtrips in the teaching of ancient singapore

  • 1. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F Chapter 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based Fieldtrips in the Teaching of Ancient Singapore History: Teacher Reflections and Student Learning Lloyd Yeo, Sazryna Lee Samsudin, Cherie Heng, Ezal bin Sani, and Teddy Y.H. Sim Abstract Although there is no large-scale and coherent survey available on teacher- 1 guided history fieldtrips in Singapore, recent exploratory case studies have emerged 2 on the use of museums in the teaching of premodern Singapore history. This chapter 3 seeks to locate the efforts of a group of history teachers in the context of collaboration 4 with academic and professional bodies as well as a Networked Learning Commu- 5 nity who systematically sought to incorporate museum-based learning and embed 6 such teaching resources in the teaching of ancient Singapore history. Using Activity 7 Theory (AT) as a learning theory to explore these networks of collaboration, the 8 learning networks that were established showed that such approaches could lead to a 9 more effective co-creation of knowledge outcome for practitioner inquiry and have 10 some positive outcomes for student learning. Data was collected from teacher reflec- 11 tions and surveys as a basic unit of analysis and from students to gauge how they 12 benefited from such learning approaches. The analysis of teacher responses showed 13 that there was increased teacher confidence in the teaching of ancient Singapore 14 history, and students derived direct and indirect benefits from a networked system 15 L. Yeo (B) The Academy of Singapore Teachers, Singapore, Singapore e-mail: Lloyd_Luc_YEO@moe.gov.sg S. L. Samsudin Fairfield Methodist School, Singapore, Singapore C. Heng Seng Kang Secondary School, Singapore, Singapore E. Sani CHIJ Secondary School, Singapore, Singapore T. Y.H. Sim National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, Singapore e-mail: yonghuei.sim@nie.edu.sg © Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2020 T. Sim et al. (eds.), Fieldwork in Humanities Education in Singapore, Studies in Singapore Education: Research, Innovation & Practice, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-15-8233-2_11 221 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 2. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 222 L. Yeo et al. of learning. From the perspective of AT, although the collaborative linkages estab- 16 lished between the different institutions (museums, academic institutions, schools, 17 and Ministry of Education) were not bound by any fixed rules, the committed efforts 18 of the Master Teacher and teachers played an important role in setting up norms 19 of collaboration among the different institutions to impact student learning about 20 ancient Singapore. 21 11.1 Introduction 22 There is an abundance of research in the Western context on the value of conducting 23 fieldtrips to engage learners. However, such research mainly advocates how fieldtrips 24 can be conducted for general pedagogical use, such as their ability to enrich and 25 expand the curriculum or their importance in immersing students in sensory activities 26 (Nabors et al., 2009). In the Singapore context, a comprehensive or uniform survey 27 on the use of fieldtrips in schools is not available for the full range of humanities 28 subjects (Chew, 2008). E. Chew argued that in geography education in Singapore, the 29 intensity level of school fieldtrips varied based on the teacher’s training background 30 and the curriculum’s emphasis on fieldwork. J.D. Stoddard (2018) observed outdoor 31 history education in Singapore carried out by teacher trainees and noted that a fieldtrip 32 through a World War II heritage site (Labrador Park) facilitated a “more balanced 33 perspective of the historical event (of the fall of Singapore).” However, he also 34 questioned the degree to which trainees were able to comprehend the full historical 35 significance of the event just by taking selfies of themselves with statues of the 36 main protagonists (for example, the commander of the Japanese invasion force in 37 Southeast Asia, General Yamashita) and advocated for deeper research in this area 38 (Stoddard, 2018). 39 Since 2010, more studies have emerged on the use of fieldtrips to teach about 40 the ancient period of Singapore using archaeology and sherd resources. Oh (2018) 41 developed an archaeological “guide” in consultation with Associate Professor Goh 42 Geok Yian, and he utilized his own drawing and writing skills to have students 43 demonstrate their understanding of historical evidence and interpretation. However, 44 museum-based lessons are disadvantaged by the need for teachers to be able to 45 gather sufficient sample sherd sets for students to work on. The National Museum 46 of Singapore has developed museum education packages such as the “Investigating 47 History: Singapura Before 1819” resource to teach the topic; but while useful, these 48 resources are limited to students working with a limited and artificial set of simulated 49 artifacts. Sim’s chapter advocates for the adoption of a more diverse set of teaching 50 resources for studying the premodern history of Singapore (Sim, 2015). 51 Increasingly, museums are being seen as an important resource for teaching and 52 learning in Singapore schools. As such, it is necessary to further explore how schools 53 and museums can collaborate to extend learning for students and the kind of profes- 54 sional development programs that can be put in place to impact student learning. 55 According to M.F. Chee (2003), such professional development programs can help 56 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 3. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 223 determine the role that teachers play in the museum experience, which shapes the 57 quality of the experience for students. 58 This study seeks to locate the efforts of a group of history teachers in the context 59 of collaboration with academic and professional bodies as well as a Networked 60 Learning Community (NLC) who systematically sought to incorporate museum- 61 based learning and embed such teaching resources in the teaching of ancient Singa- 62 pore history. Analysis of the museum-based lessons was performed through the 63 paradigm of Activity Theory (AT), looking at students’ performance as an indicator 64 of the effectiveness of the program and collaboration. 65 Using AT as a learning theory to explore these networks of collaboration, this 66 case study uses AT terms to focus on teachers and students as “subjects” within the 67 main activity of teaching about ancient Singapore (AT is discussed further in the 68 “Methodology” section). It briefly explains the linkages between schools, academic 69 institutions, and museums and discusses the effect (or “outcome” in AT) on teachers 70 and students through an analysis of teacher reflections, in situ museum-based lesson 71 observations, and analyses of student worksheet-based answers and surveys. Data 72 was collected to explore four questions: 73 A. How can museum education be incorporated into a larger inquiry-based peda- 74 gogical approach to design learning experiences for the teaching of ancient 75 Singapore history? 76 B. What problems do teachers face in teaching about ancient Singapore, and what 77 role can museum-based professional development play in teaching this topic? 78 C. What have students learned from their museum experience? 79 D. What implications can be drawn from this case study for incorporating museum- 80 based fieldtrips in teaching about ancient Singapore? 81 This essay is divided into four parts: 82 A. The use of AT to describe the development of museum-based lessons and 83 teachers’ professional development training in the context of an NLC; 84 B. What teachers have learned from their fieldtrips; 85 C. Student learning about ancient Singapore; 86 D. Implications of incorporating museum fieldtrips and applying the AT paradigm 87 in the teaching of ancient Singapore history. 88 11.2 Application of Methodology and AT: From Master 89 Class to NLC on Museum-Based Inquiry Lessons 90 Collaborations across institutions are complex and require time to develop, and as 91 such, they are difficult to investigate. However, theories of contextual development 92 insituatedpractice,particularlyAT,canbedeployedtostudythisphenomenon(Enge- 93 strom, 1987; 2001; Vygotsky, 1987; Engestrom et al., 2003). AT originated from the 94 works of Russian psychologists such as L. Vygotsky, A. Leont’ev, and S. Rubinstein, 95 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 4. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 224 L. Yeo et al. who pioneered their approaches by relating them to cultural-historical psychology 96 developed between the 1930s and 1950s. However, by the 1980s a separate strand 97 of AT had developed that was more concerned with neuropsychology. This evolved 98 into the western Scandinavian approach, which has become closely associated with 99 Y. Engestrom; he went on to refine and systematize the works of the earlier Russian 100 theorists. 101 AT of the 1980s sought to “understand human activities from the point of view 102 of systemic studies and studies of social phenomena and go beyond the paradigm of 103 classical conditioning and behaviourism” (Engestrom et al., 1999). AT is “more of a 104 descriptive meta- rather than predictive theory.” One of its strengths is that it “bridges 105 the gap between the individual subject(s) and the social ecosystem examining the 106 mediating activities.” 107 In figure 11.1 of the appendices, the unit of analysis in AT depicts the “concept 108 of object-oriented, collective and culturally-mediated human activity or ‘activity 109 system’” (Engestrom, 1999). This system includes “the object (or objective), subject, 110 mediating artifacts (signs and tools), rules, community and division of labour” (Enge- 111 strom, 2001). Since AT is not solely focused on the individual unit, the key element in 112 its application lies in exploring how the mediated linkages can be harnessed (syner- 113 gistically) or the challenges ameliorated to enhance the performance of the individual 114 Fig. 11.1 Activity Theory for museum-based learning for teachers and students (*indicates shared common boundary between MTT, researcher, teachers in NLC, curators, and academic as research area) 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 5. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 225 units (in this case, teachers), leading eventually to a more effective learning outcome 115 for the subjects (students) (Bertelsen and Bødker, 2003). 116 In this project, three secondary school history educators—Chris, Sally, and Eddie 117 (for their profiles, refer to table 11.2 in the appendices)—worked with a Master 118 Teacher (MT) from the Academy of Singapore Teachers to develop an NLC to work 119 together with museum staff as well as academics and researchers from the National 120 University of Singapore and National Institute of Education (NIE). The NLC sought 121 to investigate how archaeology could be embedded in museum-based experiences to 122 engage students in learning about the ancient history of Singapore as an inquiry-based 123 approach between 2017 and 2018. 124 Professional development activities involving collaboration and a networked 125 community carried out in the NLC provided background on how teachers enhanced 126 their abilities and confidence in conducting museum-based learning. To this end, 127 the museum-based inquiry lessons were developed across four different professional 128 development phases of the NLC to impact student learning, shown in figure 11.2 in 129 the appendices. 130 During phase 1, a two-day master class was conducted for teachers (n=24) with 131 Professor John Miksic and Dr. Michael Flecker providing new information, artifact 132 analysis, hands-on experience with sherds, and discussions on new historical inquiry 133 questions on Singapore’s ancient history. The main purpose of the master class was 134 to provide teachers with a deeper understanding of how academics use different data 135 Fig. 11.2 Professional development for teacher participants from 2016 to 2019 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 6. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 226 L. Yeo et al. sets (primary sources, archaeology, accounts, cultural studies, and scientific analysis) 136 to develop new historical interpretations of ancient Singapore. 137 In phases 2 and 3, an NLC was formed between August 2017 and October 2018 138 to use the new knowledge acquired from the master class to design museum-based 139 inquiry lessons for Secondary 1 students. In the NLC, teachers worked and learned 140 collaboratively to examine and reflect on their practices (Jackson and Temperley, 141 2007; MOE, 2017). In this context, the NLC was an important professional develop- 142 ment platform that allowed the Master Teacher, teachers, museum staff, academics, 143 and researchers to come together to develop resources that teachers could adapt and 144 use in the history classroom. 145 The activities from phases 2 and 3 included the following: 146 • Discussion and development of a common purpose for shared student activities; 147 • Use of academic and pedagogical literature in designing museum-based inquiry 148 lessons; 149 • Visits to the NUS Museum by teachers to develop a coherent narrative experience 150 and design museum-based inquiry activities (refer to table 11.3 as well as Lesson 151 Sheets 1 and 2 in the appendices); 152 • Modification of museum-based learning to meet school-based history curriculum 153 needs and cater to different student profiles; 154 • Observation of other teachers’ fieldtrips for cycles of improvement and adaptation. 155 By the start of 2018, the NLC had developed three museum-based learning expe- 156 riences for students with clear lesson objectives and concepts that were interrelated 157 and linked to each other in a coherent manner. Later the same year, NLC participants 158 took their students to the museum and conducted museum-based lessons. Teacher 159 learning experiences were discussed through cycles of discussion and reflection at 160 NLC meetings to improve lesson designs and meet local school needs. (A summary of 161 the museum-based learning and activities involving collaboration within and outside 162 the NLC is provided in table 11.1 to illustrate the variety of inputs that came from 163 various quarters to make the lesson successful.) 164 In phase 4, after reflecting on their museum-based inquiry lessons, members of 165 the NLC decided to use their learning experiences and resources to conduct their own 166 workshop for other history educators (n= 22) at the NUS Museum. Their goal was 167 to work with other teachers who sought to embed museum-based lessons into their 168 own historical inquiry classroom projects (see table 11.3 on museum-based learning 169 and activities designed by the NLC in the appendices). 170 During phases 2 and 3, data collection took the form of semi-structured interviews 171 conducted with teachers and an analysis of teacher-written reflections as a primary 172 data source. Purposeful criterion sampling was used to identify teacher participants 173 for the research study. First, participants had to have had three or more years of 174 teaching so that a relatively rich teaching experience could be tapped into for discus- 175 sions on teaching the topic. Second, they had to be part of an NLC in order for 176 interviews, discussions, and museum-based lesson observations to be carried out. 177 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 7. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 227 Table 11.1 “Units of analysis,” linkages and their input into objective and activity system Units of analysis/subject(s) How teachers benefited Direct transference of benefit to students How students benefited Challenges in collaborative efforts 1A. Academy of Singapore Teachers Master Teacher 1D. NLC network (MOE) Academy formed to facilitate professional development of teachers. Master Teacher (MT) from here initiated and coordinated with various parties. Other than coordinative aspects, MT also provided resource and lesson design support which facilitated students’ learning in a direct way. Since MT acted as a key coordinative point for all collaborative parties, autobiographical evidence and reflection (on challenges) are collected from this perspective on this round. Schools 1B. Teachers Attended training on artifacts and archaeology by (3A) and sharing on NLC platform. Students benefited from expanded and deepened knowledge of teachers in subject matter Demonstrate to the teachers the advantages of joining the project: i) a comprehensive, innovative, and pragmatic curricular lesson package involving session at the museum was available for teachers to subscribe to; ii) the NLC was a user-friendly as well as valuable network that could assist teachers in sharing and updating content and experiences among themselves. (continued) 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 8. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 228 L. Yeo et al. Table 11.1 (continued) Units of analysis/subject(s) How teachers benefited Direct transference of benefit to students How students benefited Challenges in collaborative efforts 1C. Students 2. Museum collaborators (officer, curator) 1D. NLC network (possible access and link of external bodies to this) Offered use of sherds (key learning resource) to be used as sample material evidence for students’ training. Other than providing the use of sherds, museum officer also provided tips and guidance during lesson in the sherds handling sessions. Museum collaborators were able to facilitate the approval for use of sherd samples in students’ learning. Relatively smooth process not to be taken for granted. Academics 3A. NUS and ISEAS archaeology and content Offered specialized training on artifacts and aspects of archaeology to teachers. Expanded and deepened information on artifacts and aspects of archaeology presented in a digestible way for teachers (in turn facilitated transfer to students). i) “Master class” on early modern Singapore, archaeology and sherd handling facilitated smoothly at NUS because of the rapport built (Professor from Dept of SEA studies and researcher from ISEAS). ii) Advice to assist in the accurate assembly of photo evidence and sherd samples. (continued) 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 9. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 229 Table 11.1 (continued) Units of analysis/subject(s) How teachers benefited Direct transference of benefit to students How students benefited Challenges in collaborative efforts 3B. NIE education research Consulted in aspects of collection of data for documentation of program process leading up to the writing of academic education paper (for analysis of outcome of students’ learning). Academic paper could be fed back into the “system loop (or control)” along on-going NLC discussions to refine, standardize, and expand the program. MT, mutual-teacher, and NIE researcher’s observations of lessons assisted with in-process adjustment of teachers’ teaching approaches on NLC platform. Mutual understanding and discussion had to take place as there could be different focus in the presentation of findings. 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 10. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 230 L. Yeo et al. Table 11.2 Description of participants Participant Age Gender Education experience in teaching ancient Singapore No. of years in teaching Sally XX female Eg. XX years teaching Lower Sec history. Lower Sec Coordinator. 22 years Chris XX female Eg. XX years teaching Lower Sec History. LJ Coordinator 10 years Eddie XX male Eg. XX years teaching Lower Sec History. 4 years Table 11.3 Museum-based learning and activities designed by NLC Museum Activity Objective Topic of study 1 Gallery tour of ceramics collection of the Lee Kong Chian collection Understand why people collect material artifacts like in history Understand how material, design, and technology has changed across time Material Culture 2 Gallery tour of Archaeology Library Observe the kinds of archaeological artifacts collected from different parts of Singapore Understand the significance of three objects found at the museum Porcelain pillow Chinese porcelain compass Glass beads and globules Archaeology—place and patterns 3 Map Activity Seed and attempt to answer historical inquiry questions about who lived in different parts of Temasek in the fourteenth century and the kinds of activity they engaged in. Map activity—historical evidence and interpretation 4 Sherd handling experience Experience one aspect of the archaeological process—sorting and classification Archaeology—classification Third, access to student worksheets for analysis was an important source of informa- 178 tion on student learning. Three field observations were also carried out as a secondary 179 approach to triangulate data yielded from teacher interviews and reflections. 180 In the area of student learning, 116 student surveys and post-fieldtrip work (see 181 Lesson Sheets 1 and 2 in the appendices) were collected and analyzed to ascertain 182 students’ learning in terms of their prior knowledge on the topic and what they had 183 learned on their museum trip. As part of the survey, after the museum experience 184 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 11. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 231 students were also required to fill out a worksheet designed to test their knowledge 185 of sherds from the fourteenth century. 186 Finally, reflections from the MT were also used as a form of reflective data collec- 187 tion to analyze how the various institutions in the activity system were linked up 188 for collaborative work and how the challenges to collaboration had been overcome. 189 These reflections were then discussed with an education consultant researcher from 190 NIE to provide a glimpse of how the different institutions in the AT came together 191 to support museum-based lessons in schools. Cross-referencing table 11.1 (appen- 192 dices), this will be elaborated and discussed under the subsection “Collaboration 193 Among Institutions” in the next section on “Teacher Learning.” 194 11.3 Discussion 195 11.3.1 Teacher Learning 196 The teacher community represented the unit of analysis that was closest to the object 197 (studentlearning)oftheactivitysystemandplayedanimportantroleinunderstanding 198 how archaeological knowledge and museum experience were put together to enhance 199 effective learning outcomes for students in a museum-based learning experience. 200 Hence, teachers’ motivation, their confidence, and actualization of their teaching 201 experiences in the museum had a direct consequence on learning as well as their 202 interaction with students. 203 During interviews, teachers shared their perspectives on teaching ancient Singa- 204 pore history; they viewed the content as “generally boring,” “dry,” “antiquated,” and 205 as such difficult to teach. Some of them expressed their lack of in-depth knowl- 206 edge about the history of the period and contextual knowledge of artifacts, accounts, 207 and other resources as impediments to effectively teaching the topic. In the surveys, 208 some teachers shared that they also lacked awareness of how material science, artifact 209 analysis, narrative structures, and geographical mapping of artifacts could be used to 210 engage students in meaningful historical inquiry. There was also a concern that the 211 topic of ancient Singapore history lacked age-appropriate resources for 13-year-olds 212 to explore as a historical inquiry project. 213 In order to change perceptions, the Academy of Singapore Teachers held a master 214 class and sessions conducted by NUS academics and NUS Museum staff in addi- 215 tion to setting up an NLC to help teachers uncover both the substantive content 216 and syntactic structures for the topic. This enabled teachers to design meaningful 217 historical inquiry projects for their students at the museum, as will be discussed 218 below. 219 Teacher Motivation, Museum Experience, and School-Based Needs. From 220 teacher interviews and reflections, it was evident that teachers in the NLC developed 221 a strong motivation and interest in incorporating museum-based education in the 222 teaching of ancient Singapore history through the professional development program. 223 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 12. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 232 L. Yeo et al. However, sessions by NUS academics and museum staff need to be incorporated in 224 local schools in order to be viewed as practical for teacher use. 225 In her reflections, Chris was keen on using the museum experience to complement 226 existing school experiences. Her students had simulated archaeological digs as part 227 of their history lessons, and she sought to promote archaeological evidence as a 228 way to tell the story of ancient Singapore “through a process of logical inquiry and 229 argumentation.” 230 Like Chris, Sally wanted her students to better understand the discipline of 231 archaeology and sought to embed museum experiences within her school’s history 232 curriculum, which brought students to the Asian Civilisations Museum. She was 233 keen to use the NUS Museum fieldtrip to enrich her students’ learning by giving them 234 hands-on experience handling artifacts, as well as utilizing evidence from material 235 culture as a way to engage learners to “support their construction of knowledge about 236 Singapore’s early past.” 237 Eddie wanted to use “a different lens” to tell the story of ancient Singapore beyond 238 theuseof textbookresources as anenrichment activity. Hewas interestedinproviding 239 students with “sufficient and balanced” information in order for them to develop their 240 own historical interpretation of ancient Singapore. 241 The motivations of the teachers in the NLC may be summarized as follows: 242 11.4 Map of shipwrecks 243 A strong desire to embed museum-based experiences to complement the school- 244 based history curriculum; 245 • A belief that “experiential learning beyond the classroom” can be meaningful if 246 it incorporates hands-on, tactile experiences at museums to engage learners; 247 • Developing a common vision to conduct museum-based learning as a systematic, 248 well-designed “regular” experience for all students, with the aim of engaged 249 learning. 250 In sum, teachers’ beliefs on how they valued the importance of museum-based 251 lesson designs as a way to deeply engage students on the topic of ancient Singapore 252 formed the common purpose for designing NLC museum-based lesson experiences. 253 Connected to the AT paradigm, it is worth noting that while external parties might 254 not have the same priorities in lesson design as teachers, there were a variety of 255 reasons to bring all the different parties together as units of analysis for collaboration. 256 These reasons included the following: 257 • A desire to promote among students a wider awareness of ancient Singapore as 258 shared by Miksic; 259 • A desire to promote collaboration with schools and use of museum resources 260 through museum-based outreach sessions by the NUS Museum; 261 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 13. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 233 • A desire for the NIE consultant to probe into the dynamics of how students learned 262 about ancient Singapore. 263 Learning through Master Classes and NLCs: Teacher Confidence. Teacher 264 interviews and reflections revealed that new learning through the master class and 265 NLC provided rich and sustained professional experience for teachers. For example, 266 Chris and Eddie reported that they were able to pick up “specialist and interesting 267 information about archaeology and artifacts” from the sessions, which led them to 268 seek further knowledge on the topic by “reading up and developing their content 269 knowledge” before carrying out museum-based fieldtrips and other history lessons. 270 Eddie noted that the NLC helped him develop a deeper understanding of the relation- 271 ship between technology and the different types of pottery sherds found in the four- 272 teenth century, which in turn fostered a deeper appreciation for “the role that spatial 273 distribution of artifacts played in understanding the nature of Temasek society.” Sally 274 did not attend the master class but felt that the NLC-based discussions provided rich 275 opportunities for her own learning, which convinced her that there was “value in plan- 276 ning and conducting experiential learning journeys at museums” to engage students 277 in historical inquiry. 278 During field observations of the teachers conducting museum-based lessons, the 279 teachers were observed to be well acquainted with detailed information on various 280 artifacts and displays featured at the NUS Museum. They skillfully incorporated 281 this information into museum-based lessons as part of a coherent historical inquiry 282 experience. Sally, Chris, and Eddie presented students with a chronological narra- 283 tive of human civilizations by describing the functional and aesthetic aspects of 284 pottery across time in a detailed and convincing manner. Their increased levels of 285 historical understanding and confidence were evident also when they conducted their 286 own workshop in 2019, which received positive reviews from other history teachers 287 attending the session. 288 Teacher Challenges in Museum-Based Learning. The NLC teachers faced both 289 logistical and local-based issues that were often beyond their control. One challenge 290 involved space constraints within the museum, which limited teachers to bringing 291 just one class at a time for the field-based museum experience. 292 Time constraints and Internet connectivity issues were among the other chal- 293 lenges. Sally’s and Chris’s classes were able to spend only about two hours at 294 the museum instead of the longer duration laid out in their lesson plans. Chris 295 noted that attempts to use ICT-based (information and communications technology) 296 lessons to conduct the map activity were hampered by poor Internet connectivity. 297 Sally shared that at her school, common tests and other school activities prevented 298 her from designing consolidative lessons that would have enabled her students to 299 discuss, share, and present their rich learning with students who had not had the 300 museum-based experience. 301 Another field observation was variance in teacher preparedness and ability to 302 conduct museum-based learning, particularly in situations where students were split 303 into two groups (roughly 12 to 15 in each group) led by different teachers. In 304 one observation, while one teacher was able to confidently take students through 305 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 14. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 234 L. Yeo et al. the activities and artifact explanations in the museum, another less experienced 306 teacher demonstrated lower confidence in dealing with students’ questions on various 307 artifacts from ancient Singapore. 308 Collaboration among Institutions. From the perspective of AT, weaving collab- 309 oration among the different schools in the NLC and among different institutions 310 to create a complex web of learning was an important aspect of facilitating direct 311 and indirect transference of learning experiences from academics to teachers and 312 students. 313 This was evident in the MT reflection, when the Master Teacher shared that within 314 the NLC he and the teachers had to work hard together to (i) promote the NLC as 315 a platform to encourage teacher innovation in the classroom; (ii) demonstrate how 316 museum-based learning lesson packages could be customized to meet teacher needs 317 in developing a comprehensive, innovative, and pragmatic approach to teach ancient 318 Singapore history; and (iii) develop the NLC as a professional and valuable network 319 for sharing content and pedagogical knowledge in designing museum-based inquiry 320 learning experiences for students. 321 The MT shared that he had to work closely with other institutions to assemble 322 the learning materials for teacher use in the NLC and to consciously document the 323 implementation of museum-based lessons. For example, during phases 2 and 3 of the 324 NLC, back-end work between the MT and Miksic played a critical role in providing 325 accurate photo evidence of artifacts for classroom use. In assembling the sample of 326 sherds for student use, museum staff, with Miksic’s advice, also worked closely with 327 the MT to conceptualize how the sherd handling experience could proceed. This close 328 collaboration and support revealed how mutual understanding, professional trust, 329 and clarity on how resources could be used were critical in designing museum-based 330 learning experiences for NLCs. 331 As part of the NLC, the process of researching the pedagogical approaches used in 332 designing museum-based learning experiences was equally important. The education 333 researcher from NIE had to work collaboratively with the MT and teachers to develop 334 mutual understanding, approaches, and discussions on how to scope, analyze, and 335 review the ways in which research could be conducted and presented. 336 11.5 Student Learning 337 The previous section examined the museum experience and learning of teachers, as 338 well as the benefits of collaboration with different stakeholders in the context of an 339 NLC. From the perspective of AT and referring to table 11.1, the biggest beneficiaries 340 of the collaboration among stakeholders were the students. This will be analyzed in 341 terms of what students learned from the museum-based lessons vis-à-vis how much 342 they knew about ancient Singapore before the lessons. 343 Prior Knowledge on Ancient History of Singapore. Students come to the class- 344 room with preconceptions about how the world works, and an important learning 345 science principle is to design a learning environment that builds on their existing 346 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 15. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 235 knowledge. K. Sawyer (2014) has argued that if teaching fails to engage students’ 347 prior knowledge, then the students learn just well enough to pass tests and that they 348 revert to their misconceptions outside the classroom. Because of the central impor- 349 tance of prior knowledge, a survey of students (n=116) was carried out to investigate 350 their prior knowledge. The survey revealed that 73 percent of students had prior 351 knowledge of ancient history that was largely limited to content knowledge, ranging 352 from stories of Temasek (stories of Sang Nila Utama and the founding of Singapore) 353 to the British founding of Singapore in 1819 and the latter’s subsequent development 354 as a major port in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Their sources of knowl- 355 edge were the primary school social studies curriculum as well as informal sources 356 of learning such as museum visits, stories told by parents and grandparents, and 357 watching performances at the National Day parades. 358 It is noteworthy that students’ preconceptions about ancient Singapore were 359 based mostly on historical content (first-order concepts) rather than the analytical 360 concepts (second-order concepts) that are critical for historical inquiry. Such second- 361 order concepts are related to historical agency, causation, chronology, historical 362 empathy, evidence, perspective, and significance (von Heyking, 2004; Seixas and 363 Moreton, 2012). Several students also adopted schematic but anachronistic ways of 364 understanding ancient Singapore history by using political, economic, and cultural 365 paradigms as fixed approaches. 366 What Students Learned. In the post-museum “test” (see the Survey Form in 367 the appendices), which examined students’ understanding of their sherd handling 368 experience, students were able to make a more subtle distinction among the different 369 types of artifacts compared to their prior knowledge on ceramics presented through 370 textbookphotographs,perhapsbecauseoftheirsherdhandlingexperience.Theywere 371 able to distinguish between blue-and-white sherds and, to some degree, earthenware 372 and celadon with relatively accurate levels of differentiation. 373 With reference to tables 11.4 and 11.5 in the appendices, even though 94 percent of 374 students were able to clearly identify blue-and-white ceramics, they had less success 375 in identifying green celadon wares and earthenware. One interesting finding worth 376 deeper investigation is that in school B, 66.7 percent (n=16/24) of students were able 377 to accurately identify celadon but were unable to identify glazing as an important 378 characteristic of celadon (n=16/24), which could perhaps relate to the resource table 379 that students used for their categorization task. 380 Table 11.4 Students’ recognition of ceramics School A (n=22) School B (n = 24) School C (n=70) % Blue-and-White sherd 97.1% Glazed/unglazed 20 24 66 94.8% Typology 21 24 69 98.3% Use 21 24 69 93.3% 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 16. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 236 L. Yeo et al. Table 11.5 Students’ recognition of ceramics II School A (n=22) School B (n = 24) School C (n=70) % Blue-and-white jar 90.8% Glazed/unglazed 18 24 62 89.7% Typology 22 24 60 91.4% Use 20 22 64 91.4% Celadon 64.1% Glazed/unglazed 20 16 41 66.4% Typology 15 16 4 63.8% Use 15 15 42 62.1% Earthenware 81% Glazed/unglazed 17 22 63 88% Typology 17 21 62 86.2% Use 17 17 46 69% Across the schools, students also had some difficulty differentiating between 381 stoneware and porcelain, as evidenced from field observations and students’ answers 382 in the post-test. They also had difficulty determining the functional categorization of 383 the different wares (i.e., whether something was a pot or a jar), with only 65.6 percent 384 able to do so. However, with regard to students’ inability to distinguish between jars 385 and pots, the NIE researcher felt that such issues were minor misconceptions in 386 understanding ancient Singapore. 387 Survey findings showed that in the area of conceptual understanding, students 388 were generally able to establish connections between how trade, lifestyle, culture, 389 and societal structures on the one hand and artifacts displayed in the museum were 390 interrelated as abstract-concrete approaches to understanding the period. At the anec- 391 dotal level, one student shared, “Observing the artifacts gave me insights on early 392 Singapore. The designs showed the culture and taste of what people in the past had 393 and what they were like.” Another student felt that her visit to the NUS Museum 394 helped her “understand why artifacts are made for people in the past” and “understand 395 Temasek better through their cultures.” 396 Some students were able to make specific inferences about the societal structure 397 of ancient Singapore from the map work activity by viewing high-grade ceramics as 398 being linked to the high social status of people (e.g., royalty) living on the hill (Fort 399 Canning). Others were able to link the slag and glass blobs found on Fort Canning 400 to the possible handicraft trades, such as glassmaking, that existed on the hill. Some 401 of the students were able to use the fishing hooks, slag, and other ceramics found 402 near Singapore River as evidence of the past to infer that fishing activities, trade, and 403 blacksmithing were conducted near the Singapore River area. 404 In terms of the syntactic nature of understanding ancient Singapore as a topic, 405 some students demonstrated a deeper appreciation for the work that archaeologists do 406 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 17. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 237 in uncovering evidence for the historical interpretation of this period of Singapore’s 407 history. One student shared, “The artifacts are very important, and archaeologists 408 spend a lot of time examining artifacts.” 409 Another felt that she had “learned to differentiate the materials and texture of the 410 sherds from a different time/century … and how to tell what type of material was 411 used during the early centuries.” 412 Some students who may have been overwhelmed by the information shared on 413 ceramics were also beginning to see Singapore’s history as intertwined with larger 414 regional trade links. One such student shared candidly, “I still do not really under- 415 stand Temasek better, but I now understand China’s development better in terms of its 416 pottery culture and the connections between Temasek and other countries.” Yet other 417 students, notably from School B, sought to connect the artifacts of the Belitung ship- 418 wreck, which they had seen at the Asian Civilisations Museum, with items displayed 419 at the NUS Museum. They raised interesting questions for further discussion, such 420 as why Singapore traded mostly with China and what trade processes were like in 421 the Temasek period. 422 From the experiential angle, all students in the study relished the multisensory 423 experience of observing, touching, feeling, and even smelling sherds as a means of 424 understanding historical artifacts and their link to ancient Singapore. Such object- 425 based approaches have been shown to increase empathy, interest, and engagement 426 among students in relation to classroom topics studied in different subjects (Smith, 427 2007). In retrospect, the archaeological and hands-on experiences embedded in 428 museum-based inquiry lessons enlivened and helped create a vivid and memorable 429 experience for students. The experience focused on the use of historical evidence and 430 interpretation, material culture, and archaeology serving as foundational concepts 431 to teach ancient Singapore history. The museum-based activities came together to 432 inform students on the culture, consumption habits, and societal makeup of ancient 433 Singapore. Beyond the scope of this article, teachers also likely followed up on 434 the museum learning with some form of discursive or consolidative activity in a 435 direct (face-to-face) classroom activity or indirect online discussion to consolidate 436 the museum-based learning experience. This shows that the apprehensions, barriers, 437 and obstacles to conducting museum lessons in schools were—to some degree— 438 overcome through the collaborative approaches among the different institutions via 439 the master class and NLC-based activities designed for teacher learning. 440 11.6 Implications for Teaching and Learning 441 There is a rich body of research on museum-based learning, and it is difficult to 442 adopt any one single framework to discuss its implications on teaching and learning, 443 because museum sites and approaches used to engage students are highly contextual 444 and varied. Nonetheless, general guideposts may be formed on how the specific topic 445 of ancient Singapore can be taught to engage students in a museum-based learning 446 experience. 447 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 18. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 238 L. Yeo et al. First, this exploratory case study highlights the importance of teacher motiva- 448 tion and interest in designing interesting learning experiences for museum-based 449 learning. This case study demonstrates that there are enthusiastic teachers who are 450 interested in teaching ancient Singapore history in an experiential and engaging 451 manner by incorporating diverse sets of historical evidence for student engagement. 452 Master classes, sessions conducted by university academics and museums, NLCs, 453 and teacher-designed experiences need to be intertwined as an ecosystem to design 454 meaningful experiences for students. These experiences may be modified over recur- 455 sive cycles of teacher learning to provide authentic and meaningful ways for teachers 456 to collaborate with academics, researchers, curators, and other teachers for engaged 457 student learning. One approach is to encourage such forms of learning among lower 458 secondary history educators in order to help them design classroom lessons. Such 459 lessons, based on specialized knowledge about museum-based learning, could be 460 part of the embedded NLC-based professional development setup. 461 Second, when it comes to designing such experiences, museum-based learning 462 needs to be based on the design construct of situated learning, so that learning expe- 463 riences at museums can be “naturally tied to authentic activity, context and culture” 464 (Brown et al., 1989). The unique museum-based learning experiences in this case 465 study were not limited to students interacting with objects but were shaped through 466 constructivist approaches of students interacting with historical materials. This 467 process engaged students through multidisciplinary learning experiences. Equally 468 important in the design of such experiences is the role of the school-based curriculum 469 in supplementing, complementing, and augmenting school-based experiences with 470 museum-based learning. This could involve teachers planning and implementing 471 other museum visits, explicit classroom instruction and videos, and tapping into 472 students’ prior knowledge and experiences as myriad ways to engage students in 473 pre-museum activities. 474 Third, in the area of professional development in teaching ancient Singapore 475 history, learning experiences in the museum could involve replicating the “authen- 476 tic” work that historians and archaeologists engage in—namely, sherd handling as 477 an authentic laboratory archaeological experience and map activity that replicates 478 the kind of historical inquiry questions, evidence, and interpretation that historians 479 engage in. Such sessions could involve artifact and archaeology training sessions by 480 academics such as Miksic, which were conducted as part of the master class and 481 aimed at deepening subject matter knowledge for teachers, yet were presented in a 482 coherent and useful way for teachers to design classroom experiences. The pre- and 483 post-master class readings and discussions at the NLC allowed teachers to follow 484 up on their learning in a concrete manner focused on designing lessons for students 485 in the museum. The expanded and deep knowledge that teachers acquired from 486 such a master class allowed teachers to skillfully link and extend the school history 487 curriculum at the Secondary 1 level to specialized content knowledge linked with 488 the works of historians and curated museum collections. 489 Fourth, at the research level, more work needs to be done on teachers’ and 490 students’ understanding of specific topics such as ancient Singapore, pedagogical 491 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 19. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 239 approaches on museum-based learning, and the design and effectiveness of profes- 492 sional development as an ecosystem for designing museum-based historical inquiry 493 for students. The application of AT in this chapter sought to locate the efforts of a 494 group of schoolteachers in an NLC to systematically incorporate and embed artifact 495 resources in teaching about the ancient period of Singapore’s history, supported by 496 academic and museum institutions. The linkages between stakeholders and within the 497 teaching community (via NLC) led to enhanced teacher competencies and confidence 498 in designing positive learning experiences on the lesson topic, leading to favorable 499 student outcomes as discussed in this section. 500 Rather than classroom teaching, museum-based learning, and academic research 501 by historians being treated as distinct activity systems, closer levels of collaboration 502 need to be developed to impact museum-based and classroom-based learning expe- 503 riences for history students. Depending on the institutions involved, exploration can 504 also be carried out to develop age-appropriate resources for students through such 505 online tools as the National Heritage Board’s resources at roots.sg or NUS Press’s 506 Southeast Asian Archaeological Site Reports collections, which feature photographs 507 of other archaeological artifacts. 508 Given the positive response and outcomes among students, this case study 509 demonstrates that students’ learning about ancient Singapore or any other topic 510 in Singapore’s history can be collected, analyzed, discussed, and shared purpose- 511 fully at NLC meetings, workshops, and symposiums and as research write-ups for 512 museum-based learning and classroom design. Lastly, with regard to the minu- 513 tiae of teaching students the sherd-differentiating process, the surveys reveal that 514 even though students may find it challenging to distinguish between dull-colored 515 sherds/wares (i.e., celadon versus earthenware) or glossy sherds/wares (earthenware 516 versus stoneware), hands-on experience provides a tactile, interactive, and engaging 517 means of “doing history” on the topic of ancient Singapore. To this end, specific 518 improvements can be made in designing a clearer flowchart of criteria for students 519 to identify sherds and later use such relics of the past to develop interpretations of 520 the period. 521 Appendices 522 Museum-Based Learning Program, Learning Intentions, and Inquiry Questions 523 Inquiry question 524 1. What can archaeological evidence tell us about the people living in Temasek and 525 the kind of activities they were engaged in, in the fourteenth century? 526 Guiding questions: 527 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 20. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 240 L. Yeo et al. 1. How does archaeology work? What is the archaeological process like? 528 2. How has human material culture developed over time? 529 3. What were the kinds of artifacts discovered in Singapore? 530 4. What do these artifacts tell you about the people living in Temasek in the 14th 531 C? 532 5. What can you infer about the kind of activities that the people in Temasek were 533 doing in the 14th C? 534 Museum Learning Program 535 1. To enable students to have a better understanding of the archaeological process 536 and the work of archaeologists in supporting historians to construct knowledge 537 about Singapore’s early past. 538 2. To provide students with a broad understanding of the development of human 539 material culture. 540 3. To provide students with an opportunity for a hands-on experience in handling 541 and studying artifacts 542 Learning Intentions 543 Students will be able to 544 1. Classify and sort the sherds/ceramics according to their different types 545 2. Identify on the Singapore map where selected artifacts were discovered 546 3. Make inferences about the people living in Singapore and the kind of activities 547 that took place in Singapore in the fourteenth century, based on the artifacts 548 discovered and the additional contextual information provided 549 Student Activity Sheets. Activity 1: The Lost Bag of Sherds! Sort the Sherds! 550 Archaeology involves more than just excavation of sites to search for artifacts. 551 It also involves laboratory work to clean, catalogue, and analyze artifacts. Refer 552 to the poster for a more complete understanding of the archaeological process. 553 The Lost Bag of Sherds. 554 Study the bag of sherds on the table 555 Sort the sherds into different categories 556 Use the table that describes the characteristics of the different types of pottery to 557 guide you 558 Examine the following before sorting them 559 • Texture 560 • Color 561 • Design 562 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 21. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 241 Explain why you categorize the sherds in those ways 563 Activity 2: Plot it On a Map 564 The map shows you 3 major excavations sites in Singapore: 565 Fort Canning Hill 566 St Andrews’ Cathedral 567 River Area: Empress Place/ Parliament House Complex / Old Parliament House 568 / Padang 569 Archaeologists discovered various artifacts in these three areas and more is written 570 about them in the cards 571 Study the pictures of artifacts and the additional information given to you. 572 Sort the artifacts according to where they were discovered in Singapore. 573 Plot these artifacts on the map. 574 575 Courtesy of the National Museum of Singapore, National Heritage Board. 576 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 22. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 242 L. Yeo et al. 577 Look for two or three other artifacts that were discovered in Singapore from the 578 Archaeology Library (not mentioned in the pictures) and then plot them on the map. 579 • Map your activity and then answer the following questions 580 • What was life like for people who lived in the different areas in Ancient Singapore? 581 • What evidence supports your argument? 582 Sample survey: Survey on the learning of ancient Singapore and sherd handling 583 Write down five keywords about what you learned in chapters 1 and 2 on Temasek 584 Singapore. 585 586 Did you know about Temasek Singapore (Temasek) before you study it in school? 587 Yes/No 588 What did you know about Temasek Singapore? 589 How did you know about Temasek Singapore then? 590 591 What did you like about the trips to the museums? 592 593 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 23. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 243 Write down 3–5 keywords about what you learned at the Asian Civilisations 594 Museum (ACM)? 595 596 How did going to the NUS Museum help you better understand Temasek 597 Singapore? 598 599 Can you make a suggestion to improve learning at the museums? 600 601 References 602 Bertelsen, O. W., Bødker, S. (2003). Activity theory. In J. Carroll (Ed.), HCI models, theories, 603 and framewors: Toward an interdisciplinary science. San Francisco: Morgan Kaufmann. 604 Brown, J. S., Collins, A., Duguid, P. (1989). Situated cognition and the culture of learning. 605 Educational Researcher, 18(1), 32–42. 606 Chew, E. (2008). Views, values and perceptions in geographical fieldwork in Singapore schools. 607 International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 17(4), 307–329. 608 Chee, M. F. (2006). Training teachers for the Effective Use of Museum. International Journal of 609 Historical Learning, Teaching and Research, 6(1), 10–16. 610 Crowley, K., Pierroux, P., Knutson, K. (2014). Informal Learning in Museums. In K. Sawyer 611 (Ed.), Cambridge Handbook of the Learning Sciences (pp. 461–478). Cambridge: Cambridge 612 University Press. 613 Engestrom, Y. (1987). Learning by expanding: An activity-theoretical approach to developmental 614 research. Helsinki: Orienta-Konsultit. 615 Engeström,Y.,Miettinen,R.,Punamäki,R.-L.(1999).Perspectivesonactivitytheory.Cambridge: 616 Cambridge University Press. 617 Engestrom, Y. (2001). Expansive learning at work: Toward an activity theoretical reconceptualiza- 618 tion. Journal of Education and Work, 14, 133–156. 619 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 24. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 244 L. Yeo et al. Engestrom, Y., Puonti, A., Seppanen, L. (2003). Spatial and temporal expansion of the object as 620 a challenge for reorganizing work In D. Nicolini, S. Gherardi D. Yanow (Eds.), Knowing in 621 organizations: A practice-based approach (pp. 151-186). New York: Routledge. 622 MOE (2017). Guide to Effective Professional Development, Volume 3: Networked Learning 623 Community. Retrieved from http://tinyurl.com/Effective-PD-NLC. 624 Hollen, D., Throop, J. (2008). Whatever happened to empathy? Ethos, 36(4), 385–401. 625 J. Park. (2014). A Conceptual Framework for Analysing Social Systems surrounding Korean 626 National Museumsinthe Digital Age.InMuseumsandthe WebAsia 2014,N.ProctorR.Cherry 627 (eds). Silver Spring, MD: Museums and the Web. Published September 29, 2014. Consulted May 628 22, 2020. https://mwa2014.museumsandtheweb.com/paper/a-conceptual-framework-for-analys 629 ing-social-systems-surrounding-korean-national-museums-in-the-digital-age/. With permissions 630 from Juhee Park. 631 Jackson, D., Temperley, J. (2007). From professional learning community to networked learning 632 community. In L. Stoll K. S. Louis (Eds.), Professional learning communities: Divergence, 633 depth and dilemmas (pp. 45–62). Maidenhead: Open University Press. 634 Oh, Y. J. (2018). Historical Evidence: Archaeological Practice as a Pedagogical Tool for Historical 635 Education in Singapore. HSSE Online, 6(2). Retrieved from https://www.hsseonline.edu.sg/jou 636 rnal/volume-7-issue-2-2018/historical-evidence-archaeological-practice-pedagogical-tool on 11 637 June 2019. 638 Seixas, D. P., Morton, T. (2013). The Big Six Historical Thinking Concepts. Toronto: Nelson 639 Education. 640 Sim, Teddy. (2015). Exploring sources on pre-modern history of Singapore: Review essay of 641 “Jacques de Coutre’s and Mantelieff’s Singapore and Johor”. HSSE Online, 4(2), 17–35. 642 Stoddard, J. D. (2018). Learning history beyond school. In S. Metzger L. Harris (Eds.), The Wiley 643 International Handbook of History Teaching and Learning (pp. 631–51). Hoboken: Wiley. 644 Nabors, M. L., Edwards, L. C., Murray, R. K. (2009). Making the case for field trips: what 645 research tells us and what site coordinators have to say. Education, 129(4), 661–667. 646 National Museum (2017). National Museum resources, Retrieved from https://www.nationalm 647 useum.sg/-/media/nms2017/documents/school-programmes/teachers-hi-resource-unit-1-precol 648 onial.pdf 649 Seixas,P.,Moreton,T.(2012).TheBigSix:Historicalthinkingconcepts.Toronto:NelsonCollege. 650 Smith, M. M. (200). Sensing the Past: Seeing, Hearing, Smell, Tasting and Touching in History. 651 California: University of California Press. 652 Heyking, A. V. (2004). Historical Thinking in the Elementary Years: A Review of Current Research. 653 Canadian Social Studies, 39(1). Retrieved from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1073974.pdf. 654 Rieber, R. W., Carton, A. S. (Eds). (1987). The collected works of L.S.Vygotsky, Vol 1: Problems 655 of general psychology. New York: Plenum. 656 Lloyd Yeo Tze Chiang is a Master Teacher at the Academy of Singapore Teachers (AST) in 657 History. He graduated from the National University of Singapore (BA Hons) specializing in the 658 American Civil War in 1996 and obtained his Master Of Education: Curriculum and Teachingin 659 2013. He has taught in Singapore’s Gabrielite Schools for almost 20 years has authored and co- 660 authored more than 12 publications and articles. His research interests include history education, 661 pedagogy, literacies and curriculum design, teacher identity and narrative inquiry. 662 Sazryna Lee Samsudin is a Senior Teacher (History) based in Singapore, teaching both History 663 and Social Studies at Seng Kang Secondary School. She graduated from the National Univer- 664 sity of Singapore with a BA in History and Sociology, and had also attained a Post-Graduate 665 Diploma in Education (PGDE) at the National Institute of Education, Singapore. She has taught 666 secondary school students for about 20 years and is always looking for ways to better engage the 667 students in the learning of History, such as through Inquiry-based Learning, Experiential Learning 668 and Differentiated Instruction. This has led her to collaborate with other like-minded Senior and 669 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard
  • 25. U N C O R R E C T E D P R O O F 11 A Case Study on the Incorporation of Museum and Artifact-Based … 245 Lead Teachers from other schools to form Networked Learning Communities (NLC), led by the 670 Master Teachers from the AST, to design learning experiences and activities in these areas so as 671 to develop students’ interest in and deepen their understanding of History. In 2017, she had co- 672 presented with her NLC team on ‘Differentiated Instruction in the Humanities Classroom’ at the 673 MOE Excelfest, while in 2019, she had co-conducted a Teacher-led Workshop with her NLC team 674 on ‘Using Historical Evidence in Teaching Pre-Modern Singapore.’ 675 Cherie Heng is an educator who teaches History and Social Studies at Secondary level. She 676 graduated from the National University of Singapore (BA Hons) specializing in Southeast Asian 677 Studies and obtained her Master of Education (Education Psychology) from NIE/NTU. Her 678 research interests include History pedagogy and curriculum design, Concept-based Learning as 679 well as Educational Psychology. She is currently Senior Teacher at CHIJ Secondary School. 680 Ezal Bin Sani is a Lead Teacher (History) based in Singapore, who teaches both History and 681 Social studies at Fairfield Methodist School (Secondary). He is passionate about promoting active 682 learners in the History classroom and is also a strong advocate of maximising ICT affordances in 683 and out of the classroom. An MOE Teaching award recipient, he attained a BA in History and 684 English Language at the National University of Singapore in and a Post Graduate Diploma in 685 Education (PGDE) in Education at the National Institute of Education. 686 Teddy Y. H. Sim (FRHistS) is currently lecturing at the Institute of Education in Nanyang Tech- 687 nological University in Singapore. He has published on specific involvements of the Portuguese 688 in the East. He is the author of Portuguese Enterprise in the East: Survival in the Years 1707-57 689 and editor of Piracy and surreptitious activities in the Malay Archipelago and adjacent seas 1600- 690 1840 and Maritime defence of China: Ming general Qi Jiguang and beyond. Teddy is passionate 691 about fieldtrips in his history courses on South and Southeast Asia. His courses usually feature a 692 local or overseas trip that facilitates as part of the overall study and exploration. 693 473006_1_En_11_Chapter TYPESET DISK LE CP Disp.:16/11/2020 Pages: 245 Layout: T1-Standard