SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  42
a Novartis company
Process and Operational Excellence
synergies:
key drivers for cost savings
Marcelo Costa
SCM World Webinar 2013
2 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
About this presentation
 The material presented today is an adaptation of the practical
experience of a Continuous Improvement Program integration
into an established Process Engineering department which
supported a Pharmaceutical Packaging Operations plant to
boost its objective of increasing productivity
3 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Contents
1) Introduction
2) Continuous Improvement Deployment
3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle
4) Packaging Optimization Approach
5) Throughput Time Approach
6) Cost Savings Approach
4 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Contents
1) Introduction
2) Continuous Improvement Deployment
3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle
4) Packaging Optimization Approach
5) Throughput Time Approach
6) Cost Savings Approach
5 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Introduction
 The case study presented today is about an oral solid plant...
Global
pressure
Local
pressure
 COGS
 Headcount
 Service level
 No Global approach for continuous
improvement
 ....
 Pricing pressure
 Generic players
 Long production lead-times, low-level
agility
 No local approach for continuous
improvement in place
 ....
6 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Excellence
Optimization
Prevention
Stabilization
Reactive Action
Continuous Improvement – The Dilemma
a long but sustainable
journey ahead...
straight to
big wins!
Operational Process Performance
Build-up in excellence
Sustainable gains
Short term focus
Contingency (quick wins)
7 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Key Challenges
Scenario
Objective
Challenges
 Increase plant capacity
 How would we justify the
investment making it sure we
got the right equipment?
 How much extra capacity
could we find if we had less
losses?
 What problems could be
resolved by bringing together
people from different teams?
 Increasing volume forecast
 Products insourcing to
increase supply flexibility and
allow Interco transfers
 OEE did not meet capacity
needs, FTE reduction
pressure
8 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Contents
1) Introduction
2) Continuous Improvement Deployment
3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle
4) Packaging Optimization Approach
5) Throughput Time Approach
6) Cost Savings Approach
9 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Continuous Improvement Deployment
Process Engineering
Focused
Improvement
Autonomous
Maintenance
Planned
Maintenance
Training and
Education
Office TPM
Site Continuous Improvement
DRIVE
Project
OEE/ PRODUCTIVITY –– THROUGHPUT TIME –– COST SAVINGS
New In place
10 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Integration towards Business Goals
OEE/ PRODUCTIVITY THROUGHPUT TIME
 Reinforce OEE as main tool for
systemic Capital Asset freeing up
 Identify the main causes of non-
productive time
 Accurate standards for costing
 Output, material and headcount
optimization
 Product allocation and sequence
 Address the gap between bulk
production and packaging
 Reduce bulk holding time
impacts
 Synchronise support processes
COST SAVINGS
 Capital projects & new
technologies
 Generate opportunities for costing
savings with attractive payback
periods within pilot areas as well
as the entire organization
Process Engineering Continuous Improvement
GoalsEnablersKeyDrivers
 OEE, performance metrics and standards for product
costing
 Packaging Development: harmonization of
specifications, materials optimisation and operational
improvements
 Yearly budget: OEE TGT, utilization, and optimized
product line allocation definition
 Fine planning: best product sequence to minimise the
number of difficult changeovers
 Cost savings portfolio management across the site
 Capital projects for Innovation & Technology
enhancement
 Total Productive Maintenance (TPM)
 Focused Improvement Pillar focused on identifying
losses, performance indicators, actions prioritization
and losses reduction
 Autonomous, Preventive Maintenance and E&T Pillars
focused on restore of basic machine conditions,
preventive plans and staff training
 Leadership on production lead time reduction and
other continuous improvement initiatives
New In place
11 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Contents
1) Introduction
2) Continuous Improvement Deployment
3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle
4) Packaging Optimization Approach
5) Throughput Time Approach
6) Cost Savings Approach
12 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
OEE
 KPI to measure the overall ‘health’ of
the Manufacturing Operation
 The key enabler to increase capacity,
through making maximum productive
use of the asset capacity and resources
OEE deployment:
Should I measure and
improve the OEE of all
work centers?
 Identify the constraint operations of the plant, because bottlenecks limit the
throughput of the entire system
 Improvement to any of the other operations is of no benefit to the total process
Actual Process output
Target Process output
Maximum potential output
13 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Losses Tree
Losses Attack &
Elimination
Unscheduled
downtime
Set up
Effective
Uptime
Adjustment
Breakdown/
Failure
Speed Loss
Minor
Interruptions &
Others
Free up
capacity
out of existing
facilities and
personnel staff
Unscheduled
downtime
Set up
Effective
Uptime
Adjustment
Breakdown/
Failure
Speed Loss
Minor Interruptions
& Others
Standard
Speed Increase
Losses Tree is a systematic approach
to priority-set loss elimination
Losses Attack &
Elimination
Increase
availability by
reducing speed
loss, stoppages
and changeover
time
Standard Speed
Increase
Reduce
Effective
Uptime by
increasing
maximum
validated speed
Losses Tree is used to create transparency on
the major areas of non-productive time
Losses Definition
Losses Identification
Working teams
(Priority Teams)
Application of Root
Cause Analysis Tools
CAPDO, PM Analysis
5 WHYs, 4M’s, etc.
Evaluating Results
Monitoring Results
Sustain counter
measures
to avoid reoccurrences
Roll out
New Technologies
(e.g. feeders)
Blister Optimization
Bulk in-process control
(e.g. tablet hardness)
Packaging material
enhancement
Machine capability
14 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Improvement Projects
Defined in the yearly budget during
capacity planning  OEE TGT
Losses Trend Analysis
Focused on identifying the outliers and
preventing recurrence according to losses
prioritization
Continuously Periodically
OEE
Monitoring & Evaluation
Losses Tree
Correction & Prevention
Daily Operations
Meeting
daily task accountability,
team board
Weekly Performance
Meeting
top problems and
solutions, action tracking
Yearly OEE
Target
Monthly Performance
Review
overall plant performance
project management
Yearly OEE
Review
Achievement of OEE TGTMaintenance of OEE TGT
Process Improvement cycle
1st wave 2nd wave 3rd wave
15 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Contents
1) Introduction
2) Continuous Improvement Deployment
3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle
4) Packaging Optimization Approach
5) Throughput Time Approach
6) Cost Savings Approach
16 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Packaging Optimization Cycle
Product
Allocation
Capacity
Assessment
Product Design
Capital Projects
Process
Improvement
 Leveling of packaging lines and bottleneck analysis
 Operations utilization assessment and OEE TGT calculation
 Process Improvement Cycle
 Rationalization of packaging machine set ups
 Blister optimization
 Packaging materials harmonization
 Capital projects for productivity increase5
4
1
2
3
17 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
1) Capacity Assessment
L6
L5
L4
L3
L2
CAMBE FACILITIES FULL CAPACITY [ % ]
DISPENSING tons/year 64%
SMALL DISPENSING tons/year 66%
MIXING tons/year 66% L1
GRANULATION 300kg tons/year 65%
GRANULATION 30kg tons/year 72%
TABLETING mio/year 84%
CAPSULING mio/year 65%
COATING 300kg tons/year 88%
COATING 30kg tons/year 37%
BLISTERING mio/year 88% Little room for shifts increase
CARTONING mio/year 95% No room for shifts increase
655
108
63
88
316
265
4
264
6
315
417
58
208
171
51
CAMBE FACILITIES OVERVIEW
70
55
5
84
15
96
54
USED CAPACITY
WORK CENTER
 Bottleneck analysis to define working areas of process improvement:
1st Level
2nd Level
18 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
 Lines Utilization and OEE TGT definition:
OEE calculated in order to
achieve Target Utilization:
 based on previous year losses
 next year volume demand
OEE challenged for:
 stretching Target Utilization
 redefining an achievable OEE
(should still be a step change)
1) Capacity Assessment
Working groups must be
defined according to:
 Bottleneck lines (higher
utilization) to be prioritized
 pareto losses stratification
 output increase projects
(products with higher
contribution to utilization)
1 2
19 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Achievement of OEE TGT: Identify process improvement projects ensuring sustainable problem solving
2) Process Improvement
C
A P
D
High minor stoppages,
further analysis
revealed several short
adjustments
Focus group
Causes:
• Bulk clogging
• Wrong unclogging
procedure leading to
feeder tubes damage
• Unstable bulk
process control
(height)
• Vibration system not
working
• Occurrence of
damaged plugs
Actions:
• Revised preventive
plan according to new
findings
• Revised spare parts
list
• Bulk troubleshooting
• OPL training
23,4 down to 17,6 %
15,4 down to 8,0 %
How much extra
capacity could
we find if we had
less losses?
Feeding System as
the main cause
20 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
2) Process Improvement
Maintenance of OEE TGT: KPIs actively used to generate reactive and preventive actions
Overview
WHO WHEN Status
Blisterflex Linha 2: Tivemos problema de quebra
de rolamento e desgaste das guias lineares
O conjunto encontrava-se danificado devido a soltura das
esferas do rolamento linear
Alteração da task list de manutenção
Marcos
Abra
30-mar-12 CONCLUDED
Cartopack Linha 2: Quebra de Taliscas
As taliscas se quebram devido o blister ter comprimento
mínimo estipulado, e caso haja alguma diferença entre as
mesmas ocorre o enrrosco e consequente quebra
Alteração do formato das guias de blister ( R$
8.000,00)
Marcos Abra30-mar-12 ONGOING
Blisterflex Linha 6: Tivemos problema de quebra
da mola de retorno da faca de corte.
Ocorreu a quebra da mola por fadiga Criação da Task list de manutenção para facas Marcos Abra30-nov-11 CONCLUDED
Cartopack Linha 6: Ocorreu um furo na mangueira
de sucção do vácuo na formação de cartuchos
A mangeira se desgastou por ficar em contato com a chapa
de proteção do equipamento
Criação de um ponto de apoio para fixação da
mesma
Tiago Lessa 15-jan-12 CONCLUDED
JAN
CAPDo
Result CommentsCheck Analyse Plan
Do
MTBF - PACKAGING
22,04
37,77
48,45
33,05
20,36
38,69
44,31
82,68
77,08
46,86
71,71
44,42
37,00
22,04
33,72
36,89 44,71
41,17
42,69
40,00
35,21
35,78 36,98
40,43
43,18
43,56
44,42
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
PY10 PY11 Jan Fev Mar Abr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dez YTD TGT12
MTBF(hours)
MTBF MTBFAccumulated
WHY? Losses tree review, countermeasures and improvement ideas - action plan, follow-up and feedback
WHO? Process improvement associate, line technicians and operators
WHAT? Dashboards and line boards (OEE & weekly planning, TPM)
WHERE? Line
WHEN? Weekly according to defined meeting calendar
HOW?
1 2 4 5 6 7 8 9 11 12 13 14 15 16 18 19 20 21 22 23 25 26 27 28 29 30
Line 1
Line 2
Line 3
Line 4
Monthly Performance Review
Weekly Performance Meeting
2nd
and 3rd
W: Line prioritization according to deviations from targets - Trigger Root Cause Investigation when required
(30min)
Management team
Working Groups Working Groups
1st
W: Visualization of relevant information directly on the shopfloor (10 min each line)
4th
W: Follow-up according to was planned during weeks 2 and 3 (20 min)
5th
W: Review performance, feedback about counter measures and recognize main issues
Area
Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Week 5
21 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Implement countermeasures
and follow up
Remove dust and dirt on and
around the equipment to ensure
basic GMP rules and enable
inspection
Identify and inspect:
 Flaws
 Basic Conditions
 Hard to access areas
 Sources of contamination
 Safety
 Lubrication points
 Surrounding area
Cleaning
Inspection
Countermeasures
Abnormalities mapping
Flaws, Basic Conditions and
Safety abnormalities
identified and recorded
Establish the
basic
conditions to
maintain
equipment
performance
23
4 1
Autonomous Maintenance:
 Establishing simple and quick mechanisms for addressing and solving problems
by everyone, before they occur
 Enabling people to work and think at the same time!
SC - Sources of Contamination
HRA - Hard to Reach Areas
Hard to Reach Areas
Sources of Contamination
A
B
E
E
D
CB
0
0
A
0
C
H
0
D
0
0
0
G
0 0
0
D
2) Process Improvement
22 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Basic Principles of GMP:
 Avoidance of cross-contamination and mix-ups
HSE Risk Identification:
 elimination of safety failures
2) Process Improvement
One Point Lesson:
 preventing errors through knowledge
spreading
Correct vs. Incorrect:
variable data assembling
Correct vs. Incorrect:
embossing station set up
23 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
3) Product Allocation
Set up stratification:
A: simplified cleaning
B: A + form/ sealing exchange
C: full cleaning w/o tooling exchange
D: C + form/ sealing exchange
E: blister format change
Optimize packaging lines thru reducing tooling
format changes:
– set up downtime
– material losses
– operators patience...
A
B
C
D
E
 Find the right balance, useful rules:
• high output machine  same blister size, low
blister per package ratio, high volume products
• low output machine  high mix, low volume, but
evaluate “A or B” items allocated to ensure beginning
of the month production
Scenario 1: 1 blister format
(h) # average
Set Up A 252 234 1,1
Set Up B 54 32 1,7
Set Up C 10 6 1,6
Set Up D 226 91 2,5
Set Up E 0 0 0,0
541 363 1,7
Set Up Losses Tree: 14,8%
Scenario 2: 2 blisters format
(h) # average
Set Up A 252 234 1,1
Set Up B 54 34 1,6
Set Up C 10 5 2,0
Set Up D 113 45,5 2,5
Set Up E 273 45,5 6,0
701 364 2,6
Set Up Losses Tree: 19,1%
• Lines with same
embarked
technology
• B2 with 1 blister
format, B1 with 3
blister formats
• B2 with a favorable
product mix
• As result, B2
capacity is almost
3 times higher than
B1
Blister format
24 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Cartoner output is the mandatory
output of the entire line
180 blisters
minute
90 cartons
minute
divided by
2 blisters
carton
Before
divided by
1 blister
carton
180 blisters
minute
180 cartons
minute
After
Example:
10
tablets
per blister
3
blisters
per carton
Before
15
tablets
per blister
2
blisters
per carton
After
4) Product Design
Blister Optimization:
Reduce the number of blister per finished
good (SKU):
– increase output
– reduce material consumption
Secondary and Tertiary materials
A B C
54 x 30 x 120
54 x 44 x 120
25 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
5) Capital Projects
Project: semi-automatic case packer
Capital Projects for productivity increase
 Elimination of manual
handling (reduction of
one extra end-of-line
FTE per shift)
Evaluation of material
specification complexity
Evaluation of operational
issues
Harmonization:
 From 3 Folding
Boxes to 1 FB
 From 3 Shippers to 1
Optimization:
 FB positioning into
SB according to
Case Packer working
sequence
How would you
justify the
investment, and
make sure you got
the right
equipment?
Project: full packaging line (primary and secondary)
 Replacement of old-fashioned
primary machine which required
100% manual inspection of
blisters
 Elimination of manual packaging
line (10 FTEs per shift)
 Insource of alu x alu products
Evaluation of material
specification complexity
Evaluation of
operational issues
Harmonization:
 Products from 6 blisters
stacking to 4
 Allocation to lines with
same blister format
Optimization:
 New blister insertion
system for high blister
stacking products
26 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Packaging Pilot Lines results
 Line 4: first TPM line
+68%
OEE: 30 to 50%

+80%
Output: 1.500 to 2.700 packs/h

+47%
OEE: 26 to 39%

+56%
Output: 900 to 1.400 packs/h

 Line 5: start up in Feb, first line with Early
Management approach
27 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Packaging Area results
 OEE and productivity:
+23%

OEE: 40,8 to 50,1%
Productivity: 0,39 to 0,49
mio packs/ FTE
+24%

 Blister Optimization:
• 27 SKUs completed represent a
significant improvement in sustainable
packaging versus the packaging
solutions that before existed
Cost
savings
USD 201.200
Material
reduction
3,3 tons aluminum (lidding material)
7,7 tons PVC | 12.9 tons PVdC (forming
material)
Packaging
weight
reduction
SKUs specific: -9% for Trilax c/12 (3,6
tons/year);
-5% for Doxuran 30 FCT (1 ton/year)
GHG
emissions
transport
1,0 ton CO2e (from natural material only)
Other
savings
Waste reduction, improved packaging lead-
time and energy avoidance
28 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Contents
1) Introduction
2) Continuous Improvement Deployment
3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle
4) Packaging Optimization Approach
5) Throughput Time Approach
6) Cost Savings Approach
29 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Throughput Time
 Elapsed time from material issue to Quality release of finished product
buffer
Scenario
Objective
 Improve
systematically the
planning process
 End-to-end visibility
 Not stable production
planning
 High TpT numbers
Increasing
 High inventory levels
 Increased complexity
(e.g. batch re-
analysis)
30 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Process Flow Study and Areas of Opportunity
Setor Pontos Críticos Documentação Fluxo Procedimento
Chegada defasada das documentações (produção, embalagem e CQ) x
Gargalo no acúmulo de documentação (tempo ocioso X picos de demanda) x
Stock Out, interrompendo o fluxo de trabalho x
Fluxo inadequado na Informação da data de validade do lote x
Tempo excessivo para o encerramento dos desvios e ocorrências x
Demora dos outros setores na correção dos documentos x
Preenchimento incorreto da documentação - Sandoz x
Preenchimento incorreto da documentação - Terceiros x
Revisão da doc muito abrangente, não permitindo uma análise profunda pelo setor acarretando na
passagem do erro para o próximo revisor
x
Controle de devolução de lotes de bulk para a Produção no caso de retrabalho x
Stock out (quebra da programação) x
Programação Embalagem: não recebe bulk no momento programado x
Material sem custeio (financeiro) x
Fluxo inadequado na Informação da data de validade do lote x
Erros na configuração da documentação (PDF), ex: número de dígitos menor que o necessário x
Inexistência da FT x
Falta de material na linha: estrutura incorreta x
Falta de material na linha: baixa performance da linha de embalagem x
Falta de material na linha: sem material para reposição da linha no estoque x
Falta de material no estoque acarretando mudança na programação x
Falta de material na linha: erro na pick list, quantidade reservada errada x
Fechamento "virtual", acarreta em um esforço extra de liberação parcial, ajuste de saldo x
Descrição do código do material incorreto (IFT com estrutura) x
Material na secundária incorreto (tamanho, tipo de bula ou cartucho) em relação à estrutura x
Secundária tem que realizar reconciliação do documento da primária antes do apontamento
Aguardar reconciliação do documento da primária para apontamento x
Reconciliação de documentação: falta de campos assinados x
Reconciliação de documentação: divergência na quantidade de material x
Material em QT na hora do apontamento x
Aluminio Impresso em QT na hora do apontamento x
Estrutura do produto não "respeita" a alocação x
Documentos com o mesmo tipo de grandeza porém cada um com uma unidade diferente ex: kg e g x
Ajuste de estoque: fluxo financeiro x
Falta de ferramental x
Ajuste de estoque:diferença entre a necessidade e o tam do lote padrão do cliente x
Atraso na geração do documento mestre (produtos novos ou alterações) x
Falta de material na pesagem: erro na pick list, quantidade reservada errada x
Ajuste de estoque:diferença entre a necessidade e o tam do lote padrão do cliente x
Erro na quantidade/ falta de material na pick list x IFP x
Ausência de MP dentro da área de pesagem (pick list correta) x
EPI adequados para situações ou produtos novos x
MP vencida (no momento da reserva estava ok) x
MP com problemas de qualidade x
Ajuste de estoque: fluxo financeiro x
Material sem custeio (financeiro) x
Custeio incorreto do produto (refazer processo IFS) x
Falta de material "não consumível" ex: sacos plásticos, lacre x
Falta de fração no pallet (pesagem, granulação, mistura) x
Inserção de dado incorreto no relatório (equipamento mistura) x
Perda de material pelo operador ou perda de material no bin x
Documentação: erro de transcrição x
Documentação: etiqueta, pesagem, assinatura x
Stock out (quebra da programação) x
Erros no preparo das "soluções" x
Erro na transcrição de informação (documentação CQ) x
Erro no input de dados (HPLC) x
Falta de reagentes x
Organização: MP analisadas junto com a ser analisadas etc... x
Impressão do método em toda a análise (perda de papel) x
Stock Out, interrompendo o fluxo de trabalho x
Perda da documentação x
OSS identificada apenas na reconciliação da documentação x
Gargalo de documentação no fechamento do laudo
Assuntos que deveriam ser vistos antecipadamente
Erros operacionais
Erros em documentos (treinamento, mudança no doc, etc)
Organização
Fluxo entre clientes (internos ou externos)
Planejamento/ Programação
Finanças
GQ
Embalagem
Produção
CQ
Staging Bulk Prod. QC Packaging QA
Waste
does not add any value
to a product
Incidental activity
Work that does not directly
add customer value, but
which is currently necessary
to maintain
Value-added activity
Work that directly increases
the value of the product
Areas of Opportunity
1. Production Flows
2. Administrative Flows
3. Material Flows
4. Documentation
43%
54%
3%
Brainstorming
31 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
 Synchronisation between end of manufacturing and packaging
 Optimised sequence of orders - “packaging point of view”
(pacemaker)
1. Production Flows
Production Control
Monthly planning
Dispensing
I I I
Granulation Tableting Packaging
Packaging
Production Control
Monthly planning
oxox
oxox
Dispensing Granulation Tableting
II I
before
after
- pacemaker process,
monthly demand
scheduling
Lead Time =
WIP /
Production
Rate
32 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
 Collaborative Planning Process with weekly reports and reviews
• at SKU level – what, when, who and why!
2. Administrative Flows
33 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
packaging
room
3. Material Flows
 Bulk pallets in parallel to packaging rooms:
bulk operator left the pallet in any open
position
 Buffer not organized according to lines
product allocation
 Too many time wasted searching from the
right bulk batch
 No visual management if a batch was left
behind
before after
 Bulk pallets in line with rooms: bulk operator places
the pallet in the correct line according to the product
allocation
 Packaging material from Staging to be placed
according to bulk position and priority
 Reduced time to search for materials even if product
prioritization has been changed
 Clear visual management of all batches
34 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
4. Documentation
 Finished good data-sheet simplification
As is
After
Improvement
Result D%
Checking items 13 8 - 5 - 38,5%
Page numbers 11 4 - 7
- 63,6%
Pages per year 13.200 4.800 - 8.400
before after
35 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
TpT Results
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
2000
WorkingProcess(kUSD)
PY ACT
-40%
950
960
970
980
990
1000
1010
1020
1030
1040
Volume(kbulkunits)
PY ACT
5%
-67%

TpT: 85,6 to 27,9 days
On time % (orders released on TGT): 30 to 71% +136%
 What problems could
be resolved by
bringing together
people from different
teams?
36 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Contents
1) Introduction
2) Continuous Improvement Deployment
3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle
4) Packaging Optimization Approach
5) Throughput Time Approach
6) Cost Savings Approach
37 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Costing Savings Approach
 DRIVE is a global program that focuses on tracking and reporting of
cost improvements initiatives
38 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
COGS reduction
0.28
0.02
0.45
Total Bulk
2.43
Total Bulk
2.15
Total Bulk
2.13 Total Bulk
1.69
0
1
1
2
2
3
3
Manufacturing Breakdown
0.05 0.01 0.09Pack 0.44 Pack 0.39 Pack 0.38 Pack 0.290
1
1
2
2
3
3
Baseline Short-term
(2012)
Short-term
(2013)
Mid-term
(2015)
Packaging Breakdown
0.33
0.03
0.53
TPC
2.87 TPC
2.54
TPC
2.51 TPC
1.98
0
1
1
2
2
3
3 Product Cost Evolution
• API Price negotiation
• Yield Factor increase
• Opadry scrap reduction
• Reduced Coating
processing time
• Batch size increase
• New API supplier
• Forming foil: new supplier
under development
• Lidding foil: 21 microns to 25
• Leaflet: New Supplier BID2012
39 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
 Bulk Production
What: automatic CIP
detergent re-filling
Why: “always had been
done” manually by 2
operators
 Maintenance
What: calibration station for up
to 8 equipment simultaneously
Why: speed up calibration task
previously done one after other
Initiatives across areas (1 of 2)
 Logistics In-bound
What: optimized layout
and material flow layout
for sampling
Why: QC analysts spent
much time searching for
materials to sample
 IT
What: 2S (Sort + Set in order) in Data Storage for
100% of associates
Why: TechOps used to pay USD 95k for data
storage (almost 1 Tb) and storage quota was
almost exhausted
40 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Initiatives across areas (2 of 2)
 Utilities
What: Energy Management based on PDCA methodology
Why: offset production growths, pursue energy cost savings whilst reducing CO2
emissions
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
26,000
27,000
28,000
29,000
30,000
31,000
32,000
33,000
0 500 1,000 1,500
EnergyinGJ
mio SDU
Energy Trend:
Production vs. Consumption
Trend before EM*
*EM = Energy Management started in mid 2010 Trend first 2 yrs.
Trend after 2 yrs.
41 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Takeaways
 Do not wait for a Global approach to start your journey into Excellence
• but having a global support would spare you a lot of stress
 Do not copy and paste Continuous Improvement programs to your organization
• it must be devised based on your needs and adapted to your company’s culture
 Do not ask your staff “what can we do better?”
• give them a standard framework to focus on the process and results – What to
do and When to do It
 Do not work harder, work smarter
• priority-set loss elimination
 Do not only rely on a few well-intentioned people to sustain your journey
• drive accountability through company’s Values and Job descriptions
 Bad apples can jeopardize your Excellence journey
• Leader’s job is to make sure things are working - no pain no gain
42 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013
Thank you!
For further feedback, questions and
suggestions please contact
marcelo.costa_rodriguez@sandoz.com
+49 39203 71-6762

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Pre-Production Tools Presentation
Pre-Production Tools PresentationPre-Production Tools Presentation
Pre-Production Tools PresentationConnor Baker
 
Improvement Projects 2008
Improvement Projects 2008Improvement Projects 2008
Improvement Projects 2008Marcelo Costa
 
TPM in pilot packaging line
TPM in pilot packaging lineTPM in pilot packaging line
TPM in pilot packaging lineMarcelo Costa
 
Sandoy Cambé 2012: Energy Management Results
Sandoy Cambé 2012: Energy Management ResultsSandoy Cambé 2012: Energy Management Results
Sandoy Cambé 2012: Energy Management ResultsMarcelo Costa
 
PDCA cycle applied for Sustainable Management of Energy Efficiency Policy
PDCA cycle applied for Sustainable Management of Energy Efficiency PolicyPDCA cycle applied for Sustainable Management of Energy Efficiency Policy
PDCA cycle applied for Sustainable Management of Energy Efficiency PolicyMarcelo Costa
 
Marcelo Costa - Pharma Talk 2013 Berlin
Marcelo Costa - Pharma Talk 2013 BerlinMarcelo Costa - Pharma Talk 2013 Berlin
Marcelo Costa - Pharma Talk 2013 BerlinMarcelo Costa
 
TPM BPN F2F3_Sandoz BR_Increasing OEE throughout Manufacturing Operations
TPM BPN F2F3_Sandoz BR_Increasing OEE throughout Manufacturing OperationsTPM BPN F2F3_Sandoz BR_Increasing OEE throughout Manufacturing Operations
TPM BPN F2F3_Sandoz BR_Increasing OEE throughout Manufacturing OperationsMarcelo Costa
 
Visual Storytelling Guide: A Guide to the Video Production Process
Visual Storytelling Guide: A Guide to the Video Production ProcessVisual Storytelling Guide: A Guide to the Video Production Process
Visual Storytelling Guide: A Guide to the Video Production ProcessJJisd
 
2015/11 - Meet Sanofi Management
2015/11 - Meet Sanofi Management2015/11 - Meet Sanofi Management
2015/11 - Meet Sanofi ManagementSanofi
 
Documentary Making 101
Documentary Making 101Documentary Making 101
Documentary Making 101Andy Carvin
 
Delivering Synergies : A closer look at post merger integration
Delivering Synergies : A closer look at post merger integrationDelivering Synergies : A closer look at post merger integration
Delivering Synergies : A closer look at post merger integrationSanjay Uppal
 

En vedette (11)

Pre-Production Tools Presentation
Pre-Production Tools PresentationPre-Production Tools Presentation
Pre-Production Tools Presentation
 
Improvement Projects 2008
Improvement Projects 2008Improvement Projects 2008
Improvement Projects 2008
 
TPM in pilot packaging line
TPM in pilot packaging lineTPM in pilot packaging line
TPM in pilot packaging line
 
Sandoy Cambé 2012: Energy Management Results
Sandoy Cambé 2012: Energy Management ResultsSandoy Cambé 2012: Energy Management Results
Sandoy Cambé 2012: Energy Management Results
 
PDCA cycle applied for Sustainable Management of Energy Efficiency Policy
PDCA cycle applied for Sustainable Management of Energy Efficiency PolicyPDCA cycle applied for Sustainable Management of Energy Efficiency Policy
PDCA cycle applied for Sustainable Management of Energy Efficiency Policy
 
Marcelo Costa - Pharma Talk 2013 Berlin
Marcelo Costa - Pharma Talk 2013 BerlinMarcelo Costa - Pharma Talk 2013 Berlin
Marcelo Costa - Pharma Talk 2013 Berlin
 
TPM BPN F2F3_Sandoz BR_Increasing OEE throughout Manufacturing Operations
TPM BPN F2F3_Sandoz BR_Increasing OEE throughout Manufacturing OperationsTPM BPN F2F3_Sandoz BR_Increasing OEE throughout Manufacturing Operations
TPM BPN F2F3_Sandoz BR_Increasing OEE throughout Manufacturing Operations
 
Visual Storytelling Guide: A Guide to the Video Production Process
Visual Storytelling Guide: A Guide to the Video Production ProcessVisual Storytelling Guide: A Guide to the Video Production Process
Visual Storytelling Guide: A Guide to the Video Production Process
 
2015/11 - Meet Sanofi Management
2015/11 - Meet Sanofi Management2015/11 - Meet Sanofi Management
2015/11 - Meet Sanofi Management
 
Documentary Making 101
Documentary Making 101Documentary Making 101
Documentary Making 101
 
Delivering Synergies : A closer look at post merger integration
Delivering Synergies : A closer look at post merger integrationDelivering Synergies : A closer look at post merger integration
Delivering Synergies : A closer look at post merger integration
 

Similaire à Process and operational excellence synergies

[Pem Zhipeng Xie] project management: lean six sigma
[Pem Zhipeng Xie] project management: lean six sigma[Pem Zhipeng Xie] project management: lean six sigma
[Pem Zhipeng Xie] project management: lean six sigmaPem Zhipeng Xie
 
Just In Time
Just In TimeJust In Time
Just In Timedvyvjy
 
IRJET- Implementing Lean Manufacturing Principle in Fabrication Process- A...
IRJET- 	  Implementing Lean Manufacturing Principle in Fabrication Process- A...IRJET- 	  Implementing Lean Manufacturing Principle in Fabrication Process- A...
IRJET- Implementing Lean Manufacturing Principle in Fabrication Process- A...IRJET Journal
 
Project cycle
Project cycleProject cycle
Project cycleDema Dias
 
Process improvement techniques and its applicability in pharma mfg an overview
Process improvement techniques and its applicability in pharma mfg   an overviewProcess improvement techniques and its applicability in pharma mfg   an overview
Process improvement techniques and its applicability in pharma mfg an overviewVikalpNagori1
 
Transforming the manufacturing department of centrale laitière into a busines...
Transforming the manufacturing department of centrale laitière into a busines...Transforming the manufacturing department of centrale laitière into a busines...
Transforming the manufacturing department of centrale laitière into a busines...Mohammed MARZAK
 
Achieving Customer Specifications Through Process Improv.docx
Achieving Customer  Specifications Through  Process Improv.docxAchieving Customer  Specifications Through  Process Improv.docx
Achieving Customer Specifications Through Process Improv.docxbartholomeocoombs
 
Resume-Johnson Shi.docx(1)
Resume-Johnson Shi.docx(1)Resume-Johnson Shi.docx(1)
Resume-Johnson Shi.docx(1)shi weihua
 
Mtm Turkey Handout
Mtm Turkey HandoutMtm Turkey Handout
Mtm Turkey HandoutTmtm Tmtm
 
Jxhakim industrial 08'2016 ( updated )
Jxhakim industrial  08'2016 ( updated )Jxhakim industrial  08'2016 ( updated )
Jxhakim industrial 08'2016 ( updated )Jehanzeb Hakim
 
Jxhakim industrial 08'2016 ( updated )
Jxhakim industrial  08'2016 ( updated )Jxhakim industrial  08'2016 ( updated )
Jxhakim industrial 08'2016 ( updated )Jehanzeb Hakim
 
Zws Corporate Presentation Agile Implementation Approach
Zws Corporate Presentation  Agile Implementation ApproachZws Corporate Presentation  Agile Implementation Approach
Zws Corporate Presentation Agile Implementation ApproachZero Wait-State
 
Logistics Case Study
Logistics Case StudyLogistics Case Study
Logistics Case StudyDonald Cross
 
Lean Management Methods in Product Development – A Case Study
Lean Management Methods in Product Development – A Case Study Lean Management Methods in Product Development – A Case Study
Lean Management Methods in Product Development – A Case Study António J. Baptista
 
SAPience UserDay 2015 TheValueChain UMICORE sap_building_blocks
SAPience UserDay 2015 TheValueChain UMICORE sap_building_blocksSAPience UserDay 2015 TheValueChain UMICORE sap_building_blocks
SAPience UserDay 2015 TheValueChain UMICORE sap_building_blocksTheValueChain
 
PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING LEAN TOOLS IN PUMP INDUSTRY
PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING LEAN TOOLS IN PUMP INDUSTRYPRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING LEAN TOOLS IN PUMP INDUSTRY
PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING LEAN TOOLS IN PUMP INDUSTRYIRJET Journal
 
IRJET- Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) Concept
IRJET-  	  Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) ConceptIRJET-  	  Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) Concept
IRJET- Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) ConceptIRJET Journal
 
Just in-timeby stevespangler[1]
Just in-timeby stevespangler[1]Just in-timeby stevespangler[1]
Just in-timeby stevespangler[1]Sunder Ram. M
 
IRJET- Enhance the Capacity of Outer Tube Machining Cell
IRJET-  	  Enhance the Capacity of Outer Tube Machining CellIRJET-  	  Enhance the Capacity of Outer Tube Machining Cell
IRJET- Enhance the Capacity of Outer Tube Machining CellIRJET Journal
 

Similaire à Process and operational excellence synergies (20)

[Pem Zhipeng Xie] project management: lean six sigma
[Pem Zhipeng Xie] project management: lean six sigma[Pem Zhipeng Xie] project management: lean six sigma
[Pem Zhipeng Xie] project management: lean six sigma
 
Just In Time
Just In TimeJust In Time
Just In Time
 
IRJET- Implementing Lean Manufacturing Principle in Fabrication Process- A...
IRJET- 	  Implementing Lean Manufacturing Principle in Fabrication Process- A...IRJET- 	  Implementing Lean Manufacturing Principle in Fabrication Process- A...
IRJET- Implementing Lean Manufacturing Principle in Fabrication Process- A...
 
Project cycle
Project cycleProject cycle
Project cycle
 
Process improvement techniques and its applicability in pharma mfg an overview
Process improvement techniques and its applicability in pharma mfg   an overviewProcess improvement techniques and its applicability in pharma mfg   an overview
Process improvement techniques and its applicability in pharma mfg an overview
 
Transforming the manufacturing department of centrale laitière into a busines...
Transforming the manufacturing department of centrale laitière into a busines...Transforming the manufacturing department of centrale laitière into a busines...
Transforming the manufacturing department of centrale laitière into a busines...
 
Achieving Customer Specifications Through Process Improv.docx
Achieving Customer  Specifications Through  Process Improv.docxAchieving Customer  Specifications Through  Process Improv.docx
Achieving Customer Specifications Through Process Improv.docx
 
Resume-Johnson Shi.docx(1)
Resume-Johnson Shi.docx(1)Resume-Johnson Shi.docx(1)
Resume-Johnson Shi.docx(1)
 
Mtm Turkey Handout
Mtm Turkey HandoutMtm Turkey Handout
Mtm Turkey Handout
 
Jxhakim industrial 08'2016 ( updated )
Jxhakim industrial  08'2016 ( updated )Jxhakim industrial  08'2016 ( updated )
Jxhakim industrial 08'2016 ( updated )
 
Jxhakim industrial 08'2016 ( updated )
Jxhakim industrial  08'2016 ( updated )Jxhakim industrial  08'2016 ( updated )
Jxhakim industrial 08'2016 ( updated )
 
Zws Corporate Presentation Agile Implementation Approach
Zws Corporate Presentation  Agile Implementation ApproachZws Corporate Presentation  Agile Implementation Approach
Zws Corporate Presentation Agile Implementation Approach
 
Logistics Case Study
Logistics Case StudyLogistics Case Study
Logistics Case Study
 
S3 p2 lee_kong_hui
S3 p2 lee_kong_huiS3 p2 lee_kong_hui
S3 p2 lee_kong_hui
 
Lean Management Methods in Product Development – A Case Study
Lean Management Methods in Product Development – A Case Study Lean Management Methods in Product Development – A Case Study
Lean Management Methods in Product Development – A Case Study
 
SAPience UserDay 2015 TheValueChain UMICORE sap_building_blocks
SAPience UserDay 2015 TheValueChain UMICORE sap_building_blocksSAPience UserDay 2015 TheValueChain UMICORE sap_building_blocks
SAPience UserDay 2015 TheValueChain UMICORE sap_building_blocks
 
PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING LEAN TOOLS IN PUMP INDUSTRY
PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING LEAN TOOLS IN PUMP INDUSTRYPRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING LEAN TOOLS IN PUMP INDUSTRY
PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT USING LEAN TOOLS IN PUMP INDUSTRY
 
IRJET- Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) Concept
IRJET-  	  Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) ConceptIRJET-  	  Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) Concept
IRJET- Single Minute Exchange of Dies (SMED) Concept
 
Just in-timeby stevespangler[1]
Just in-timeby stevespangler[1]Just in-timeby stevespangler[1]
Just in-timeby stevespangler[1]
 
IRJET- Enhance the Capacity of Outer Tube Machining Cell
IRJET-  	  Enhance the Capacity of Outer Tube Machining CellIRJET-  	  Enhance the Capacity of Outer Tube Machining Cell
IRJET- Enhance the Capacity of Outer Tube Machining Cell
 

Plus de Marcelo Costa

CEO awards Operational Excellence 2009
CEO awards  Operational Excellence 2009CEO awards  Operational Excellence 2009
CEO awards Operational Excellence 2009Marcelo Costa
 
CMO critical assessment to support EU FMD readiness
CMO critical assessment to support EU FMD readinessCMO critical assessment to support EU FMD readiness
CMO critical assessment to support EU FMD readinessMarcelo Costa
 
Using VSM to support the definition of Production Planning strategies of a ne...
Using VSM to support the definition of Production Planning strategies of a ne...Using VSM to support the definition of Production Planning strategies of a ne...
Using VSM to support the definition of Production Planning strategies of a ne...Marcelo Costa
 
Case study: Introducing a Changeover Program which fulfills a company-wide Pr...
Case study: Introducing a Changeover Program which fulfills a company-wide Pr...Case study: Introducing a Changeover Program which fulfills a company-wide Pr...
Case study: Introducing a Changeover Program which fulfills a company-wide Pr...Marcelo Costa
 
2012 Latin American HSE Conference - Cambe Site_v0
2012 Latin American HSE Conference - Cambe Site_v02012 Latin American HSE Conference - Cambe Site_v0
2012 Latin American HSE Conference - Cambe Site_v0Marcelo Costa
 
Novartis Environment Awards 2012
Novartis Environment Awards 2012Novartis Environment Awards 2012
Novartis Environment Awards 2012Marcelo Costa
 

Plus de Marcelo Costa (6)

CEO awards Operational Excellence 2009
CEO awards  Operational Excellence 2009CEO awards  Operational Excellence 2009
CEO awards Operational Excellence 2009
 
CMO critical assessment to support EU FMD readiness
CMO critical assessment to support EU FMD readinessCMO critical assessment to support EU FMD readiness
CMO critical assessment to support EU FMD readiness
 
Using VSM to support the definition of Production Planning strategies of a ne...
Using VSM to support the definition of Production Planning strategies of a ne...Using VSM to support the definition of Production Planning strategies of a ne...
Using VSM to support the definition of Production Planning strategies of a ne...
 
Case study: Introducing a Changeover Program which fulfills a company-wide Pr...
Case study: Introducing a Changeover Program which fulfills a company-wide Pr...Case study: Introducing a Changeover Program which fulfills a company-wide Pr...
Case study: Introducing a Changeover Program which fulfills a company-wide Pr...
 
2012 Latin American HSE Conference - Cambe Site_v0
2012 Latin American HSE Conference - Cambe Site_v02012 Latin American HSE Conference - Cambe Site_v0
2012 Latin American HSE Conference - Cambe Site_v0
 
Novartis Environment Awards 2012
Novartis Environment Awards 2012Novartis Environment Awards 2012
Novartis Environment Awards 2012
 

Dernier

Call Girls In Aerocity 🤳 Call Us +919599264170
Call Girls In Aerocity 🤳 Call Us +919599264170Call Girls In Aerocity 🤳 Call Us +919599264170
Call Girls In Aerocity 🤳 Call Us +919599264170Escort Service
 
miladyskindiseases-200705210221 2.!!pptx
miladyskindiseases-200705210221 2.!!pptxmiladyskindiseases-200705210221 2.!!pptx
miladyskindiseases-200705210221 2.!!pptxCarrieButtitta
 
DGT @ CTAC 2024 Valencia: Most crucial invest to digitalisation_Sven Zoelle_v...
DGT @ CTAC 2024 Valencia: Most crucial invest to digitalisation_Sven Zoelle_v...DGT @ CTAC 2024 Valencia: Most crucial invest to digitalisation_Sven Zoelle_v...
DGT @ CTAC 2024 Valencia: Most crucial invest to digitalisation_Sven Zoelle_v...Henrik Hanke
 
Event 4 Introduction to Open Source.pptx
Event 4 Introduction to Open Source.pptxEvent 4 Introduction to Open Source.pptx
Event 4 Introduction to Open Source.pptxaryanv1753
 
Genshin Impact PPT Template by EaTemp.pptx
Genshin Impact PPT Template by EaTemp.pptxGenshin Impact PPT Template by EaTemp.pptx
Genshin Impact PPT Template by EaTemp.pptxJohnree4
 
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.com
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.comSaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.com
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.comsaastr
 
The 3rd Intl. Workshop on NL-based Software Engineering
The 3rd Intl. Workshop on NL-based Software EngineeringThe 3rd Intl. Workshop on NL-based Software Engineering
The 3rd Intl. Workshop on NL-based Software EngineeringSebastiano Panichella
 
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...漢銘 謝
 
Work Remotely with Confluence ACE 2.pptx
Work Remotely with Confluence ACE 2.pptxWork Remotely with Confluence ACE 2.pptx
Work Remotely with Confluence ACE 2.pptxmavinoikein
 
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATION
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATIONRACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATION
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATIONRachelAnnTenibroAmaz
 
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptx
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptxEngaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptx
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptxAsifArshad8
 
Mathan flower ppt.pptx slide orchids ✨🌸
Mathan flower ppt.pptx slide orchids ✨🌸Mathan flower ppt.pptx slide orchids ✨🌸
Mathan flower ppt.pptx slide orchids ✨🌸mathanramanathan2005
 
Simulation-based Testing of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles with Aerialist
Simulation-based Testing of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles with AerialistSimulation-based Testing of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles with Aerialist
Simulation-based Testing of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles with AerialistSebastiano Panichella
 
Early Modern Spain. All about this period
Early Modern Spain. All about this periodEarly Modern Spain. All about this period
Early Modern Spain. All about this periodSaraIsabelJimenez
 
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory affair 1st sem CRR
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory  affair 1st sem CRRINDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory  affair 1st sem CRR
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory affair 1st sem CRRsarwankumar4524
 
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular Plastics
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular PlasticsDutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular Plastics
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular PlasticsDutch Power
 
PAG-UNLAD NG EKONOMIYA na dapat isaalang alang sa pag-aaral.
PAG-UNLAD NG EKONOMIYA na dapat isaalang alang sa pag-aaral.PAG-UNLAD NG EKONOMIYA na dapat isaalang alang sa pag-aaral.
PAG-UNLAD NG EKONOMIYA na dapat isaalang alang sa pag-aaral.KathleenAnnCordero2
 
PHYSICS PROJECT BY MSC - NANOTECHNOLOGY
PHYSICS PROJECT BY MSC  - NANOTECHNOLOGYPHYSICS PROJECT BY MSC  - NANOTECHNOLOGY
PHYSICS PROJECT BY MSC - NANOTECHNOLOGYpruthirajnayak525
 
Quality by design.. ppt for RA (1ST SEM
Quality by design.. ppt for  RA (1ST SEMQuality by design.. ppt for  RA (1ST SEM
Quality by design.. ppt for RA (1ST SEMCharmi13
 
SBFT Tool Competition 2024 -- Python Test Case Generation Track
SBFT Tool Competition 2024 -- Python Test Case Generation TrackSBFT Tool Competition 2024 -- Python Test Case Generation Track
SBFT Tool Competition 2024 -- Python Test Case Generation TrackSebastiano Panichella
 

Dernier (20)

Call Girls In Aerocity 🤳 Call Us +919599264170
Call Girls In Aerocity 🤳 Call Us +919599264170Call Girls In Aerocity 🤳 Call Us +919599264170
Call Girls In Aerocity 🤳 Call Us +919599264170
 
miladyskindiseases-200705210221 2.!!pptx
miladyskindiseases-200705210221 2.!!pptxmiladyskindiseases-200705210221 2.!!pptx
miladyskindiseases-200705210221 2.!!pptx
 
DGT @ CTAC 2024 Valencia: Most crucial invest to digitalisation_Sven Zoelle_v...
DGT @ CTAC 2024 Valencia: Most crucial invest to digitalisation_Sven Zoelle_v...DGT @ CTAC 2024 Valencia: Most crucial invest to digitalisation_Sven Zoelle_v...
DGT @ CTAC 2024 Valencia: Most crucial invest to digitalisation_Sven Zoelle_v...
 
Event 4 Introduction to Open Source.pptx
Event 4 Introduction to Open Source.pptxEvent 4 Introduction to Open Source.pptx
Event 4 Introduction to Open Source.pptx
 
Genshin Impact PPT Template by EaTemp.pptx
Genshin Impact PPT Template by EaTemp.pptxGenshin Impact PPT Template by EaTemp.pptx
Genshin Impact PPT Template by EaTemp.pptx
 
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.com
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.comSaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.com
SaaStr Workshop Wednesday w/ Kyle Norton, Owner.com
 
The 3rd Intl. Workshop on NL-based Software Engineering
The 3rd Intl. Workshop on NL-based Software EngineeringThe 3rd Intl. Workshop on NL-based Software Engineering
The 3rd Intl. Workshop on NL-based Software Engineering
 
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...
THE COUNTRY WHO SOLVED THE WORLD_HOW CHINA LAUNCHED THE CIVILIZATION REVOLUTI...
 
Work Remotely with Confluence ACE 2.pptx
Work Remotely with Confluence ACE 2.pptxWork Remotely with Confluence ACE 2.pptx
Work Remotely with Confluence ACE 2.pptx
 
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATION
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATIONRACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATION
RACHEL-ANN M. TENIBRO PRODUCT RESEARCH PRESENTATION
 
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptx
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptxEngaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptx
Engaging Eid Ul Fitr Presentation for Kindergartners.pptx
 
Mathan flower ppt.pptx slide orchids ✨🌸
Mathan flower ppt.pptx slide orchids ✨🌸Mathan flower ppt.pptx slide orchids ✨🌸
Mathan flower ppt.pptx slide orchids ✨🌸
 
Simulation-based Testing of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles with Aerialist
Simulation-based Testing of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles with AerialistSimulation-based Testing of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles with Aerialist
Simulation-based Testing of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles with Aerialist
 
Early Modern Spain. All about this period
Early Modern Spain. All about this periodEarly Modern Spain. All about this period
Early Modern Spain. All about this period
 
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory affair 1st sem CRR
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory  affair 1st sem CRRINDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory  affair 1st sem CRR
INDIAN GCP GUIDELINE. for Regulatory affair 1st sem CRR
 
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular Plastics
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular PlasticsDutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular Plastics
Dutch Power - 26 maart 2024 - Henk Kras - Circular Plastics
 
PAG-UNLAD NG EKONOMIYA na dapat isaalang alang sa pag-aaral.
PAG-UNLAD NG EKONOMIYA na dapat isaalang alang sa pag-aaral.PAG-UNLAD NG EKONOMIYA na dapat isaalang alang sa pag-aaral.
PAG-UNLAD NG EKONOMIYA na dapat isaalang alang sa pag-aaral.
 
PHYSICS PROJECT BY MSC - NANOTECHNOLOGY
PHYSICS PROJECT BY MSC  - NANOTECHNOLOGYPHYSICS PROJECT BY MSC  - NANOTECHNOLOGY
PHYSICS PROJECT BY MSC - NANOTECHNOLOGY
 
Quality by design.. ppt for RA (1ST SEM
Quality by design.. ppt for  RA (1ST SEMQuality by design.. ppt for  RA (1ST SEM
Quality by design.. ppt for RA (1ST SEM
 
SBFT Tool Competition 2024 -- Python Test Case Generation Track
SBFT Tool Competition 2024 -- Python Test Case Generation TrackSBFT Tool Competition 2024 -- Python Test Case Generation Track
SBFT Tool Competition 2024 -- Python Test Case Generation Track
 

Process and operational excellence synergies

  • 1. a Novartis company Process and Operational Excellence synergies: key drivers for cost savings Marcelo Costa SCM World Webinar 2013
  • 2. 2 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 About this presentation  The material presented today is an adaptation of the practical experience of a Continuous Improvement Program integration into an established Process Engineering department which supported a Pharmaceutical Packaging Operations plant to boost its objective of increasing productivity
  • 3. 3 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Contents 1) Introduction 2) Continuous Improvement Deployment 3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle 4) Packaging Optimization Approach 5) Throughput Time Approach 6) Cost Savings Approach
  • 4. 4 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Contents 1) Introduction 2) Continuous Improvement Deployment 3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle 4) Packaging Optimization Approach 5) Throughput Time Approach 6) Cost Savings Approach
  • 5. 5 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Introduction  The case study presented today is about an oral solid plant... Global pressure Local pressure  COGS  Headcount  Service level  No Global approach for continuous improvement  ....  Pricing pressure  Generic players  Long production lead-times, low-level agility  No local approach for continuous improvement in place  ....
  • 6. 6 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Excellence Optimization Prevention Stabilization Reactive Action Continuous Improvement – The Dilemma a long but sustainable journey ahead... straight to big wins! Operational Process Performance Build-up in excellence Sustainable gains Short term focus Contingency (quick wins)
  • 7. 7 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Key Challenges Scenario Objective Challenges  Increase plant capacity  How would we justify the investment making it sure we got the right equipment?  How much extra capacity could we find if we had less losses?  What problems could be resolved by bringing together people from different teams?  Increasing volume forecast  Products insourcing to increase supply flexibility and allow Interco transfers  OEE did not meet capacity needs, FTE reduction pressure
  • 8. 8 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Contents 1) Introduction 2) Continuous Improvement Deployment 3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle 4) Packaging Optimization Approach 5) Throughput Time Approach 6) Cost Savings Approach
  • 9. 9 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Continuous Improvement Deployment Process Engineering Focused Improvement Autonomous Maintenance Planned Maintenance Training and Education Office TPM Site Continuous Improvement DRIVE Project OEE/ PRODUCTIVITY –– THROUGHPUT TIME –– COST SAVINGS New In place
  • 10. 10 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Integration towards Business Goals OEE/ PRODUCTIVITY THROUGHPUT TIME  Reinforce OEE as main tool for systemic Capital Asset freeing up  Identify the main causes of non- productive time  Accurate standards for costing  Output, material and headcount optimization  Product allocation and sequence  Address the gap between bulk production and packaging  Reduce bulk holding time impacts  Synchronise support processes COST SAVINGS  Capital projects & new technologies  Generate opportunities for costing savings with attractive payback periods within pilot areas as well as the entire organization Process Engineering Continuous Improvement GoalsEnablersKeyDrivers  OEE, performance metrics and standards for product costing  Packaging Development: harmonization of specifications, materials optimisation and operational improvements  Yearly budget: OEE TGT, utilization, and optimized product line allocation definition  Fine planning: best product sequence to minimise the number of difficult changeovers  Cost savings portfolio management across the site  Capital projects for Innovation & Technology enhancement  Total Productive Maintenance (TPM)  Focused Improvement Pillar focused on identifying losses, performance indicators, actions prioritization and losses reduction  Autonomous, Preventive Maintenance and E&T Pillars focused on restore of basic machine conditions, preventive plans and staff training  Leadership on production lead time reduction and other continuous improvement initiatives New In place
  • 11. 11 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Contents 1) Introduction 2) Continuous Improvement Deployment 3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle 4) Packaging Optimization Approach 5) Throughput Time Approach 6) Cost Savings Approach
  • 12. 12 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 OEE  KPI to measure the overall ‘health’ of the Manufacturing Operation  The key enabler to increase capacity, through making maximum productive use of the asset capacity and resources OEE deployment: Should I measure and improve the OEE of all work centers?  Identify the constraint operations of the plant, because bottlenecks limit the throughput of the entire system  Improvement to any of the other operations is of no benefit to the total process Actual Process output Target Process output Maximum potential output
  • 13. 13 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Losses Tree Losses Attack & Elimination Unscheduled downtime Set up Effective Uptime Adjustment Breakdown/ Failure Speed Loss Minor Interruptions & Others Free up capacity out of existing facilities and personnel staff Unscheduled downtime Set up Effective Uptime Adjustment Breakdown/ Failure Speed Loss Minor Interruptions & Others Standard Speed Increase Losses Tree is a systematic approach to priority-set loss elimination Losses Attack & Elimination Increase availability by reducing speed loss, stoppages and changeover time Standard Speed Increase Reduce Effective Uptime by increasing maximum validated speed Losses Tree is used to create transparency on the major areas of non-productive time Losses Definition Losses Identification Working teams (Priority Teams) Application of Root Cause Analysis Tools CAPDO, PM Analysis 5 WHYs, 4M’s, etc. Evaluating Results Monitoring Results Sustain counter measures to avoid reoccurrences Roll out New Technologies (e.g. feeders) Blister Optimization Bulk in-process control (e.g. tablet hardness) Packaging material enhancement Machine capability
  • 14. 14 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Improvement Projects Defined in the yearly budget during capacity planning  OEE TGT Losses Trend Analysis Focused on identifying the outliers and preventing recurrence according to losses prioritization Continuously Periodically OEE Monitoring & Evaluation Losses Tree Correction & Prevention Daily Operations Meeting daily task accountability, team board Weekly Performance Meeting top problems and solutions, action tracking Yearly OEE Target Monthly Performance Review overall plant performance project management Yearly OEE Review Achievement of OEE TGTMaintenance of OEE TGT Process Improvement cycle 1st wave 2nd wave 3rd wave
  • 15. 15 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Contents 1) Introduction 2) Continuous Improvement Deployment 3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle 4) Packaging Optimization Approach 5) Throughput Time Approach 6) Cost Savings Approach
  • 16. 16 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Packaging Optimization Cycle Product Allocation Capacity Assessment Product Design Capital Projects Process Improvement  Leveling of packaging lines and bottleneck analysis  Operations utilization assessment and OEE TGT calculation  Process Improvement Cycle  Rationalization of packaging machine set ups  Blister optimization  Packaging materials harmonization  Capital projects for productivity increase5 4 1 2 3
  • 17. 17 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 1) Capacity Assessment L6 L5 L4 L3 L2 CAMBE FACILITIES FULL CAPACITY [ % ] DISPENSING tons/year 64% SMALL DISPENSING tons/year 66% MIXING tons/year 66% L1 GRANULATION 300kg tons/year 65% GRANULATION 30kg tons/year 72% TABLETING mio/year 84% CAPSULING mio/year 65% COATING 300kg tons/year 88% COATING 30kg tons/year 37% BLISTERING mio/year 88% Little room for shifts increase CARTONING mio/year 95% No room for shifts increase 655 108 63 88 316 265 4 264 6 315 417 58 208 171 51 CAMBE FACILITIES OVERVIEW 70 55 5 84 15 96 54 USED CAPACITY WORK CENTER  Bottleneck analysis to define working areas of process improvement: 1st Level 2nd Level
  • 18. 18 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013  Lines Utilization and OEE TGT definition: OEE calculated in order to achieve Target Utilization:  based on previous year losses  next year volume demand OEE challenged for:  stretching Target Utilization  redefining an achievable OEE (should still be a step change) 1) Capacity Assessment Working groups must be defined according to:  Bottleneck lines (higher utilization) to be prioritized  pareto losses stratification  output increase projects (products with higher contribution to utilization) 1 2
  • 19. 19 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Achievement of OEE TGT: Identify process improvement projects ensuring sustainable problem solving 2) Process Improvement C A P D High minor stoppages, further analysis revealed several short adjustments Focus group Causes: • Bulk clogging • Wrong unclogging procedure leading to feeder tubes damage • Unstable bulk process control (height) • Vibration system not working • Occurrence of damaged plugs Actions: • Revised preventive plan according to new findings • Revised spare parts list • Bulk troubleshooting • OPL training 23,4 down to 17,6 % 15,4 down to 8,0 % How much extra capacity could we find if we had less losses? Feeding System as the main cause
  • 20. 20 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 2) Process Improvement Maintenance of OEE TGT: KPIs actively used to generate reactive and preventive actions Overview WHO WHEN Status Blisterflex Linha 2: Tivemos problema de quebra de rolamento e desgaste das guias lineares O conjunto encontrava-se danificado devido a soltura das esferas do rolamento linear Alteração da task list de manutenção Marcos Abra 30-mar-12 CONCLUDED Cartopack Linha 2: Quebra de Taliscas As taliscas se quebram devido o blister ter comprimento mínimo estipulado, e caso haja alguma diferença entre as mesmas ocorre o enrrosco e consequente quebra Alteração do formato das guias de blister ( R$ 8.000,00) Marcos Abra30-mar-12 ONGOING Blisterflex Linha 6: Tivemos problema de quebra da mola de retorno da faca de corte. Ocorreu a quebra da mola por fadiga Criação da Task list de manutenção para facas Marcos Abra30-nov-11 CONCLUDED Cartopack Linha 6: Ocorreu um furo na mangueira de sucção do vácuo na formação de cartuchos A mangeira se desgastou por ficar em contato com a chapa de proteção do equipamento Criação de um ponto de apoio para fixação da mesma Tiago Lessa 15-jan-12 CONCLUDED JAN CAPDo Result CommentsCheck Analyse Plan Do MTBF - PACKAGING 22,04 37,77 48,45 33,05 20,36 38,69 44,31 82,68 77,08 46,86 71,71 44,42 37,00 22,04 33,72 36,89 44,71 41,17 42,69 40,00 35,21 35,78 36,98 40,43 43,18 43,56 44,42 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 PY10 PY11 Jan Fev Mar Abr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dez YTD TGT12 MTBF(hours) MTBF MTBFAccumulated WHY? Losses tree review, countermeasures and improvement ideas - action plan, follow-up and feedback WHO? Process improvement associate, line technicians and operators WHAT? Dashboards and line boards (OEE & weekly planning, TPM) WHERE? Line WHEN? Weekly according to defined meeting calendar HOW? 1 2 4 5 6 7 8 9 11 12 13 14 15 16 18 19 20 21 22 23 25 26 27 28 29 30 Line 1 Line 2 Line 3 Line 4 Monthly Performance Review Weekly Performance Meeting 2nd and 3rd W: Line prioritization according to deviations from targets - Trigger Root Cause Investigation when required (30min) Management team Working Groups Working Groups 1st W: Visualization of relevant information directly on the shopfloor (10 min each line) 4th W: Follow-up according to was planned during weeks 2 and 3 (20 min) 5th W: Review performance, feedback about counter measures and recognize main issues Area Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Week 5
  • 21. 21 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Implement countermeasures and follow up Remove dust and dirt on and around the equipment to ensure basic GMP rules and enable inspection Identify and inspect:  Flaws  Basic Conditions  Hard to access areas  Sources of contamination  Safety  Lubrication points  Surrounding area Cleaning Inspection Countermeasures Abnormalities mapping Flaws, Basic Conditions and Safety abnormalities identified and recorded Establish the basic conditions to maintain equipment performance 23 4 1 Autonomous Maintenance:  Establishing simple and quick mechanisms for addressing and solving problems by everyone, before they occur  Enabling people to work and think at the same time! SC - Sources of Contamination HRA - Hard to Reach Areas Hard to Reach Areas Sources of Contamination A B E E D CB 0 0 A 0 C H 0 D 0 0 0 G 0 0 0 D 2) Process Improvement
  • 22. 22 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Basic Principles of GMP:  Avoidance of cross-contamination and mix-ups HSE Risk Identification:  elimination of safety failures 2) Process Improvement One Point Lesson:  preventing errors through knowledge spreading Correct vs. Incorrect: variable data assembling Correct vs. Incorrect: embossing station set up
  • 23. 23 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 3) Product Allocation Set up stratification: A: simplified cleaning B: A + form/ sealing exchange C: full cleaning w/o tooling exchange D: C + form/ sealing exchange E: blister format change Optimize packaging lines thru reducing tooling format changes: – set up downtime – material losses – operators patience... A B C D E  Find the right balance, useful rules: • high output machine  same blister size, low blister per package ratio, high volume products • low output machine  high mix, low volume, but evaluate “A or B” items allocated to ensure beginning of the month production Scenario 1: 1 blister format (h) # average Set Up A 252 234 1,1 Set Up B 54 32 1,7 Set Up C 10 6 1,6 Set Up D 226 91 2,5 Set Up E 0 0 0,0 541 363 1,7 Set Up Losses Tree: 14,8% Scenario 2: 2 blisters format (h) # average Set Up A 252 234 1,1 Set Up B 54 34 1,6 Set Up C 10 5 2,0 Set Up D 113 45,5 2,5 Set Up E 273 45,5 6,0 701 364 2,6 Set Up Losses Tree: 19,1% • Lines with same embarked technology • B2 with 1 blister format, B1 with 3 blister formats • B2 with a favorable product mix • As result, B2 capacity is almost 3 times higher than B1 Blister format
  • 24. 24 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Cartoner output is the mandatory output of the entire line 180 blisters minute 90 cartons minute divided by 2 blisters carton Before divided by 1 blister carton 180 blisters minute 180 cartons minute After Example: 10 tablets per blister 3 blisters per carton Before 15 tablets per blister 2 blisters per carton After 4) Product Design Blister Optimization: Reduce the number of blister per finished good (SKU): – increase output – reduce material consumption Secondary and Tertiary materials A B C 54 x 30 x 120 54 x 44 x 120
  • 25. 25 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 5) Capital Projects Project: semi-automatic case packer Capital Projects for productivity increase  Elimination of manual handling (reduction of one extra end-of-line FTE per shift) Evaluation of material specification complexity Evaluation of operational issues Harmonization:  From 3 Folding Boxes to 1 FB  From 3 Shippers to 1 Optimization:  FB positioning into SB according to Case Packer working sequence How would you justify the investment, and make sure you got the right equipment? Project: full packaging line (primary and secondary)  Replacement of old-fashioned primary machine which required 100% manual inspection of blisters  Elimination of manual packaging line (10 FTEs per shift)  Insource of alu x alu products Evaluation of material specification complexity Evaluation of operational issues Harmonization:  Products from 6 blisters stacking to 4  Allocation to lines with same blister format Optimization:  New blister insertion system for high blister stacking products
  • 26. 26 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Packaging Pilot Lines results  Line 4: first TPM line +68% OEE: 30 to 50%  +80% Output: 1.500 to 2.700 packs/h  +47% OEE: 26 to 39%  +56% Output: 900 to 1.400 packs/h   Line 5: start up in Feb, first line with Early Management approach
  • 27. 27 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Packaging Area results  OEE and productivity: +23%  OEE: 40,8 to 50,1% Productivity: 0,39 to 0,49 mio packs/ FTE +24%   Blister Optimization: • 27 SKUs completed represent a significant improvement in sustainable packaging versus the packaging solutions that before existed Cost savings USD 201.200 Material reduction 3,3 tons aluminum (lidding material) 7,7 tons PVC | 12.9 tons PVdC (forming material) Packaging weight reduction SKUs specific: -9% for Trilax c/12 (3,6 tons/year); -5% for Doxuran 30 FCT (1 ton/year) GHG emissions transport 1,0 ton CO2e (from natural material only) Other savings Waste reduction, improved packaging lead- time and energy avoidance
  • 28. 28 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Contents 1) Introduction 2) Continuous Improvement Deployment 3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle 4) Packaging Optimization Approach 5) Throughput Time Approach 6) Cost Savings Approach
  • 29. 29 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Throughput Time  Elapsed time from material issue to Quality release of finished product buffer Scenario Objective  Improve systematically the planning process  End-to-end visibility  Not stable production planning  High TpT numbers Increasing  High inventory levels  Increased complexity (e.g. batch re- analysis)
  • 30. 30 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Process Flow Study and Areas of Opportunity Setor Pontos Críticos Documentação Fluxo Procedimento Chegada defasada das documentações (produção, embalagem e CQ) x Gargalo no acúmulo de documentação (tempo ocioso X picos de demanda) x Stock Out, interrompendo o fluxo de trabalho x Fluxo inadequado na Informação da data de validade do lote x Tempo excessivo para o encerramento dos desvios e ocorrências x Demora dos outros setores na correção dos documentos x Preenchimento incorreto da documentação - Sandoz x Preenchimento incorreto da documentação - Terceiros x Revisão da doc muito abrangente, não permitindo uma análise profunda pelo setor acarretando na passagem do erro para o próximo revisor x Controle de devolução de lotes de bulk para a Produção no caso de retrabalho x Stock out (quebra da programação) x Programação Embalagem: não recebe bulk no momento programado x Material sem custeio (financeiro) x Fluxo inadequado na Informação da data de validade do lote x Erros na configuração da documentação (PDF), ex: número de dígitos menor que o necessário x Inexistência da FT x Falta de material na linha: estrutura incorreta x Falta de material na linha: baixa performance da linha de embalagem x Falta de material na linha: sem material para reposição da linha no estoque x Falta de material no estoque acarretando mudança na programação x Falta de material na linha: erro na pick list, quantidade reservada errada x Fechamento "virtual", acarreta em um esforço extra de liberação parcial, ajuste de saldo x Descrição do código do material incorreto (IFT com estrutura) x Material na secundária incorreto (tamanho, tipo de bula ou cartucho) em relação à estrutura x Secundária tem que realizar reconciliação do documento da primária antes do apontamento Aguardar reconciliação do documento da primária para apontamento x Reconciliação de documentação: falta de campos assinados x Reconciliação de documentação: divergência na quantidade de material x Material em QT na hora do apontamento x Aluminio Impresso em QT na hora do apontamento x Estrutura do produto não "respeita" a alocação x Documentos com o mesmo tipo de grandeza porém cada um com uma unidade diferente ex: kg e g x Ajuste de estoque: fluxo financeiro x Falta de ferramental x Ajuste de estoque:diferença entre a necessidade e o tam do lote padrão do cliente x Atraso na geração do documento mestre (produtos novos ou alterações) x Falta de material na pesagem: erro na pick list, quantidade reservada errada x Ajuste de estoque:diferença entre a necessidade e o tam do lote padrão do cliente x Erro na quantidade/ falta de material na pick list x IFP x Ausência de MP dentro da área de pesagem (pick list correta) x EPI adequados para situações ou produtos novos x MP vencida (no momento da reserva estava ok) x MP com problemas de qualidade x Ajuste de estoque: fluxo financeiro x Material sem custeio (financeiro) x Custeio incorreto do produto (refazer processo IFS) x Falta de material "não consumível" ex: sacos plásticos, lacre x Falta de fração no pallet (pesagem, granulação, mistura) x Inserção de dado incorreto no relatório (equipamento mistura) x Perda de material pelo operador ou perda de material no bin x Documentação: erro de transcrição x Documentação: etiqueta, pesagem, assinatura x Stock out (quebra da programação) x Erros no preparo das "soluções" x Erro na transcrição de informação (documentação CQ) x Erro no input de dados (HPLC) x Falta de reagentes x Organização: MP analisadas junto com a ser analisadas etc... x Impressão do método em toda a análise (perda de papel) x Stock Out, interrompendo o fluxo de trabalho x Perda da documentação x OSS identificada apenas na reconciliação da documentação x Gargalo de documentação no fechamento do laudo Assuntos que deveriam ser vistos antecipadamente Erros operacionais Erros em documentos (treinamento, mudança no doc, etc) Organização Fluxo entre clientes (internos ou externos) Planejamento/ Programação Finanças GQ Embalagem Produção CQ Staging Bulk Prod. QC Packaging QA Waste does not add any value to a product Incidental activity Work that does not directly add customer value, but which is currently necessary to maintain Value-added activity Work that directly increases the value of the product Areas of Opportunity 1. Production Flows 2. Administrative Flows 3. Material Flows 4. Documentation 43% 54% 3% Brainstorming
  • 31. 31 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013  Synchronisation between end of manufacturing and packaging  Optimised sequence of orders - “packaging point of view” (pacemaker) 1. Production Flows Production Control Monthly planning Dispensing I I I Granulation Tableting Packaging Packaging Production Control Monthly planning oxox oxox Dispensing Granulation Tableting II I before after - pacemaker process, monthly demand scheduling Lead Time = WIP / Production Rate
  • 32. 32 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013  Collaborative Planning Process with weekly reports and reviews • at SKU level – what, when, who and why! 2. Administrative Flows
  • 33. 33 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 packaging room 3. Material Flows  Bulk pallets in parallel to packaging rooms: bulk operator left the pallet in any open position  Buffer not organized according to lines product allocation  Too many time wasted searching from the right bulk batch  No visual management if a batch was left behind before after  Bulk pallets in line with rooms: bulk operator places the pallet in the correct line according to the product allocation  Packaging material from Staging to be placed according to bulk position and priority  Reduced time to search for materials even if product prioritization has been changed  Clear visual management of all batches
  • 34. 34 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 4. Documentation  Finished good data-sheet simplification As is After Improvement Result D% Checking items 13 8 - 5 - 38,5% Page numbers 11 4 - 7 - 63,6% Pages per year 13.200 4.800 - 8.400 before after
  • 35. 35 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 TpT Results 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 WorkingProcess(kUSD) PY ACT -40% 950 960 970 980 990 1000 1010 1020 1030 1040 Volume(kbulkunits) PY ACT 5% -67%  TpT: 85,6 to 27,9 days On time % (orders released on TGT): 30 to 71% +136%  What problems could be resolved by bringing together people from different teams?
  • 36. 36 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Contents 1) Introduction 2) Continuous Improvement Deployment 3) OEE, Losses Tree and Process Improvement Cycle 4) Packaging Optimization Approach 5) Throughput Time Approach 6) Cost Savings Approach
  • 37. 37 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Costing Savings Approach  DRIVE is a global program that focuses on tracking and reporting of cost improvements initiatives
  • 38. 38 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 COGS reduction 0.28 0.02 0.45 Total Bulk 2.43 Total Bulk 2.15 Total Bulk 2.13 Total Bulk 1.69 0 1 1 2 2 3 3 Manufacturing Breakdown 0.05 0.01 0.09Pack 0.44 Pack 0.39 Pack 0.38 Pack 0.290 1 1 2 2 3 3 Baseline Short-term (2012) Short-term (2013) Mid-term (2015) Packaging Breakdown 0.33 0.03 0.53 TPC 2.87 TPC 2.54 TPC 2.51 TPC 1.98 0 1 1 2 2 3 3 Product Cost Evolution • API Price negotiation • Yield Factor increase • Opadry scrap reduction • Reduced Coating processing time • Batch size increase • New API supplier • Forming foil: new supplier under development • Lidding foil: 21 microns to 25 • Leaflet: New Supplier BID2012
  • 39. 39 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013  Bulk Production What: automatic CIP detergent re-filling Why: “always had been done” manually by 2 operators  Maintenance What: calibration station for up to 8 equipment simultaneously Why: speed up calibration task previously done one after other Initiatives across areas (1 of 2)  Logistics In-bound What: optimized layout and material flow layout for sampling Why: QC analysts spent much time searching for materials to sample  IT What: 2S (Sort + Set in order) in Data Storage for 100% of associates Why: TechOps used to pay USD 95k for data storage (almost 1 Tb) and storage quota was almost exhausted
  • 40. 40 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Initiatives across areas (2 of 2)  Utilities What: Energy Management based on PDCA methodology Why: offset production growths, pursue energy cost savings whilst reducing CO2 emissions 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 26,000 27,000 28,000 29,000 30,000 31,000 32,000 33,000 0 500 1,000 1,500 EnergyinGJ mio SDU Energy Trend: Production vs. Consumption Trend before EM* *EM = Energy Management started in mid 2010 Trend first 2 yrs. Trend after 2 yrs.
  • 41. 41 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Takeaways  Do not wait for a Global approach to start your journey into Excellence • but having a global support would spare you a lot of stress  Do not copy and paste Continuous Improvement programs to your organization • it must be devised based on your needs and adapted to your company’s culture  Do not ask your staff “what can we do better?” • give them a standard framework to focus on the process and results – What to do and When to do It  Do not work harder, work smarter • priority-set loss elimination  Do not only rely on a few well-intentioned people to sustain your journey • drive accountability through company’s Values and Job descriptions  Bad apples can jeopardize your Excellence journey • Leader’s job is to make sure things are working - no pain no gain
  • 42. 42 Process and Operational Excellence synergies | SCM World Webinar 2013 Thank you! For further feedback, questions and suggestions please contact marcelo.costa_rodriguez@sandoz.com +49 39203 71-6762