Project cost management ,cost estimation cost control and evm for large epc projects and is essential for knowing the cost parameters for all construction engineers.
2. Project Cost Management
PCM
PROJECT COST MANAGEMENT
1) Project Cost Management for EPC/Construction Project:
Includes the processes required to ensure that the project is completed within the
approved budget.
Is primarily concerned with the cost of the resources required to complete project
activities. The necessary data and the essential tools of cost management activities
include the current and updated WBS, cash flow constraints, details of current estimates
and budgets, timely progress reports, accurate change reports, and cost management
software responsive to the specific needs of that particular project.
Should consider the effect of project decisions on the cost of using the project’s product.
For example: limiting the number of design reviews may reduce the cost of the project
at the expense of an increase in service costs and an increase in the customer’s operating
costs.
A broader view of project cost management is often referred to as life-cycle costing.
It involves including in-house making, out sourcing, and disposal costs when evaluating
various project alternatives. For example fabrication and installation ctc.
A creative approach used to optimize life cycle costs, save time, increase profits, improve
quality, expand market share, use resources more effectively, and solve problems is
called value engineering. For example pre-casting at yard and erecting at site in bridge
construction work.
Life cycle costing and value engineering techniques are used together to reduce cost and
time, improve quality and performance, and optimize the decision-making.
In many application areas, predicting and analysing the prospective financial
performance of the project’s product is done outside the project.
In some areas such as capital facilities projects, project cost management includes
predicting and analyzing the prospective financial performance of the project’s product.
In these situations, project cost management will include general management
techniques such as:
o Return on investment
o Discounted cash flow
o Payback analysis
Should consider the information needs of the project stakeholders and the different ways
and times stakeholders measure project cost. For example, the cost of a procurement item
may be measured when committed, ordered, delivered, incurred, of recorded for
accounting purposes.
When project costs are used as a component of a reward and recognition system,
controllable and uncontrollable costs should be estimated and budgeted separately to
ensure that rewards reflect actual performance.
The ability to influence cost is greatest at the early stages of the project. Early scope
definition and requirements identification are critical to reducing costs in a project.
The project must have a proactive and comprehensive risk management plan in place to
mitigate the impact of unexpected events.
3. Project Cost Management
PCM
2) Cost estimating techniques being used in EPC/Construction Project:
Methods used during cost estimating are:-
Analogous estimating: (top down estimating)
Uses the actual cost of a previous similar project as the basis for estimating the cost of
the current project
Is frequently used to estimate total project costs when there is a limited amount of
detailed information about the project. (e.g., in the early project phases)
Generally less costly than other estimating techniques, but it is also generally less
accurate. Most reliable when 1) the previous projects are similar in fact and not just in
appearance, 2) the individuals or groups preparing estimates have the needed expertise
Considered a form of expert judgment.
Parametric modelling:
Uses project characteristics (parameters) in a mathematical model to predict project cost
Models may be simple or complex. Simple example: Model the cost of constructing a
residential home based on square footage of living space. Complex example: Model
software development costs using thirteen adjustment factors, each of which has five to
seven points.
Most reliable when 1) the historical information used to develop the model was accurate,
2) the parameters used in the model are readily quantifiable, and 3) the model is scalable.
Bottom-up estimating:
Involves estimating the cost of individual activities or work packages, then summarizing
or rolling-up the individual estimates to get a project total
The cost and accuracy is driven by the size and complexity of the individual activity or
work package: smaller items increase both cost and accuracy of the estimating process.
The project management team must weigh the additional accuracy against the additional
cost.
Computerized tools:
Project management software spreadsheets and simulation/statistical tools are widely
used to assist with cost estimation.
Can simplify the use of the techniques described earlier and facilitate more rapid
consideration of costing alternatives.
. Other cost estimating methods such as vendor bid analysis.
3) Cost baseline estimation and Cost control in EPC/Construction Project
Considering the cost estimating inputs, Cost estimating relies on several project components
from the Initiation and planning process groups. This process also relies on historical
information and policies from the performing organization.
4. Project Cost Management
PCM
Using the Work Breakdown Structure
Of course the WBS is included—it’s an input to five major planning processes: cost estimating,
cost budgeting, resource planning, risk management planning, and activity definition.
Relying on the Resource Requirements
The only output of resource planning serves as a key input to cost estimating. The project will
have some requirement for resources—the skills of the labour, the ability of materials, or the
function of equipment must all be accounted for.
Calculating Resource Rates
The estimator has to know how much each resource costs. The cost should be in some unit of
time or measure—such as cost per hour, cost per metric ton, or cost per use. If the rates of the
resources are not known, the rates themselves may also have to be estimated. Of course, skewed
rates on the estimates will result in a skewed estimate for the project. There are four categories
of cost:
■ Direct costs- These costs are attributed directly to the project work and cannot be shared
among projects (airfare, hotels, and long distance phone charges, and so on).
■ Variable costs- These costs vary depending on the conditions applied in the project (number
of meeting participants, supply and demand of materials, and so on).
■ Fixed costs- These costs remain constant throughout the project (the cost of a piece of rented
equipment for the project, the cost of a consultant brought onto the project, and so on).
■ In-direct costs- These costs are representative of more than one project (utilities for the
performing organization, access to a training room, project management software license, and
so on)
Estimating Activity Durations
Estimate of the duration of the activities, which predict the length of the project, are needed for
decisions on financing the project. The length of the activities will help the performing
organization calculate what the total cost of the project will be, including the finance charges.
Recall the formula for present value? It’s PV= FV/(1+R)n; PV is the present value, FV is the
future value, R is the interest rate, and n is the number of time periods. The future value of the
monies the project will earn may need to be measured against the present value to determine if
the project is worth financing, as shown here:
Finance charges
Future Value 1.46cr Present Value 1.0cr
Calculations of the duration of activities are needed in order to extrapolate the total cost of the
work packages. For example, if an activity is estimated to last 14 hours and Excavator’s cost
per hour is Rs.2000, then the cost of the work package is Rs.28000. The duration shows
management how long the project is expected to last and which activities will cost the most and
provides the opportunity to re-sequence activities to shorten the project duration—which
consequently shortens the finance period for the project.
5. Project Cost Management
PCM
Another aspect the project manager and management may have to determine is the long-term
worth of a product in regard to tax deductions. There are three approaches to deduct product’s
cost:
■ Straight-line depreciation allows the organization to write off the same amount each year.
The formula for straight-line depreciation is Purchase Value minus Salvage Value divided by
Number of Years in Use. For example, if the purchase price of a crane is 3cr and the salvage
value of the crane in 10 years is Rs1cr, the formula would read: (3-1)/10= Rs0.2cr
■ Double-declining balance is considered accelerated depreciation. This method allows the
organization to double the percentage written off in the first year. In our above example, a single
deduction was Rs0.2cr per year, which is 10 percent of the total deduction across the ten years.
With double-declining, the customer would subtract 20 percent the first year, and then 20
percent of the remaining value each subsequent year. In our example, the deducted amount for
year one would be Rs0.4cr. For year two it’d be Rs0.36cr, and year three it would be Rs0.152cr.
This is a great method for equipment that you don’t anticipate to have around for a very long
time—such as computer equipment.
■ Sum of the year’s depreciation is like a magic trick. It works by writing out the number of
years the equipment is in production and adding each year to the year before. In our example it
was 10 years, so we’d do this: 10+9+8+7+6+5+4+3+2+1=55 (note the largest to smallest). The
sum of the years, 55, becomes our denominator; the five, for the first year, is our numerator. So
for the first year, we’d deduct 10/55 of the crane cost after the salvage amount
Using Estimating Publications
There are, for different industries, commercial estimating publications. These references can
help the project estimator confirm and predict the accuracy of estimates. If a project manager
elects to use one of these commercial databases, the estimate should include a pointer to this
document for future reference and verification.
Using Historical Information
Historical information is proven information and can come from several places:
■ Project files- Past projects within the performing organization can be used as a reference to
predict costs and time. Caution must be taken that the records referenced are accurate,
somewhat current, and reflective of what was actually experienced in the historical project.
■ Commercial cost-estimating databases These databases provide estimates of what the
project should cost based on the variables of the project, resources, and other conditions.
■ Team members Team members may have specific experience with the project costs or
estimates. Recollections may be useful, but are highly unreliable when compared to
documented results.
Referencing the Chart of Accounts
This is a coding system used by the performing organization’s accounting system to account
for the project work. Estimates within the project must be mapped to the correct code of
6. Project Cost Management
PCM
accounts so that the organization’s ledger reflects the actual work performed, the cost of the
work performed, and any billing (internal or external) that was charged to the customer for the
completed work.
Acknowledging the Cost of Risk
The impact of risks, for positive or negative effect, must be evaluated and considered in the cost
estimates. For example, should a risk come into play, the mitigation of the risk may require
adding several activities to squelch the risk. The expense of the activities would add cost to the
project.
4) Application of Cost Estimating Techniques in EPC/Construction Project Analyzing
Cost Estimating Results
The output of cost estimating is the actual cost estimates of the resources required to the
complete the project work. The estimate is typically quantitative and can be presented in detail
against the WBS components or summarized in terms of a grand total, by phases of the project,
or by major deliverables. Each resource in the project must be accounted for and assigned to a
cost category. Categories include the following:
■ Labour costs
■ Material costs
■ Travel costs
■ Supplies
■ Hardware costs
■ Software costs
■ Special categories (inflation, cost reserve, and so on)
The cost of the project is expressed in monetary terms, such as rupees, dollars, euros, or yen,
so management can compare projects based on costs. It may be acceptable, depending on the
demands of the performing organization, to provide estimates in staffing hours or days of work
to complete the project along with the estimated costs. As projects have risks, the cost of the
risks should be identified along with the cost of the risk responses.
Refining the Cost Estimates
Cost estimates can also pass through progress elaboration. As more details are acquired as the
project progresses, the estimates are refined. Industry guidelines and organizational policies
may define how the estimates are refined, but there are three generally accepted categories of
estimating accuracy:
■ Rough order of magnitude- This estimate is “rough” and is used during the Initiating
processes and in top-down estimates. The range of variance for the estimate can be –25 percent
to +75 percent.
■ Budget estimate- This estimate is also somewhat broad and is used early in the Planning
processes and also in top-down estimates. The range of variance for the estimate can be –10
percent to +25 percent.
7. Project Cost Management
PCM
■ Definitive estimates- This estimate type is one of the most accurate. It is used late in the
Planning processes and is associated with bottom-up estimating.
The range of variance for the estimate can be –5 percent to +10 percent.
Considering the Supporting Detail
Once the estimates have been completed, supporting detail must be organized and documented
to show how the estimates were created. This material, even the notes that contributed to the
estimates, may provide valuable information later in the project. Specifically, the supporting
detail includes the following:
■ Information on the project scope work- This may be provided by referencing the WBS.
■ Information on the approach used in developing the cost estimates
This can include how the estimate was accomplished and the parties involved with the estimate.
■ Information on the range of variance in the estimate For example, based on the estimating
method used, the project cost may be Rs 220,000 ± Rs15, 000.
This project cost may be as low as Rs205, 000 or as high as Rs235, 000.
5) Use of Project Reserves (Contingency Reserve & Management Reserve) in
EPC/Construction Project
Contingency Reserve:
The allocation of extra funds to cover uncertainties and improve the chances of finishing on
time.
Specific provision(s) to mitigate random or unknown project risks from causing project failure
or frequent baseline changes.
Reserves (2 Types): Provision in project plan to mitigate cost and/or schedule risk.
Contingencies are needed because
• Project scope may change
• Cost estimation must anticipate interaction costs
• Normal conditions are rarely encountered
• Global Economic Slowdown
• Commodity Price Volatility
Reserves–Known Unknowns
Cost Estimating Tool
Contingency allowance
Discretion of PM
Anticipated but not certain events
8. Project Cost Management
PCM
Potentially overstates costs
Part of project scope and baseline
e.g. weather, productivity…
Budgeting Tool -Mgmt. Contingency
Unplanned but potentially required changes to scope & baseline
Approval needed for PM to spend
May result from risk register
NOT part of project baseline
NOT part of EVA
e.g. risks, approved changes…
6) Application of Project Cost Budget in EPC/Construction Project
The process of allocating the overall cost estimates to individual activities or work
packages to establish a cost baseline for measuring project performance.
Inputs include: cost estimates, WBS, project schedule, and risk management plan.
Methods used during cost budgeting include: cost budgeting tools and techniques which
are the same tools used for cost estimating.
Outputs include: Cost baseline
A time-phased budget used to measure and monitor project cost performance.
It is developed by summing estimated costs by period and is usually displayed in the
form of an S-curve.
Many projects, especially larger ones, may have multiple cost baselines to measure
different aspects of cost performance. For example, a spending plan or cash-flow forecast
is a cost baseline for measuring disbursements.
7) Project Cost Monitoring and Control in EPC/Construction Project
The process of:
Influencing the factors that create changes to the cost baseline to ensure that changes
are beneficial
Determining that the cost baseline has changed
Managing the actual changes when and as they occur.
Cost control includes:
Monitoring cost performance to detect and understand variances from plan.
Ensuring that all appropriate changes are recorded accurately in the cost baseline.
Preventing incorrect, inappropriate, or unauthorized changes from being included in the
cost baseline.
Informing appropriate stakeholders of authorized changes.
Acting to bring expected costs within acceptable limits.
Inputs include: cost baseline, performance reports, change requests, and cost management plan
9. Project Cost Management
PCM
Performance reports:
Provide information on project scope and cost performance such as which budgets have
been met and which have not.
May also alert the project team to issues that may cause problems in the future.
The methods used in cost control include:
Cost change control system:
Defines the procedures by which the cost baseline may be changed.
Includes the paperwork, tracking system and approval levels necessary for authorizing
changes.
Should be integrated with the integrated change control system.
Performance measurements: Used to access the magnitude of any variations which do
occur.
Earned value management (EVM): All EVM Control Account Plans (CAPs) must
continuously measure project performance by relating and comparing three independent
variables:
Planned Value (PV): the physical work scheduled to be performed including the estimated
value of this work (BCWS).
Earned Value (EV): the physical work actually accomplished including the estimated value of
this work (BCWP),
Actual Cost (AC): the costs incurred to accomplish the earned value.
Additional planning: Prospective changes may require new or revised cost estimates or
analysis of alternative approaches.
Computerized tools: project management software and spreadsheets are often used to track
planned costs versus actual costs and to forecast the effects of cost change.
Outputs from cost control: revised cost estimates, budget updates, corrective action, estimate
at completion (EAC), project closeout, and lessons learned.
Revised cost estimates:
Modifications to the cost information used to manage the project.
Appropriate stakeholders must be notified as needed.
Revised cost estimates may or may not require adjustments to other aspects of the
project plan.
Budget updates:
A special category of revised cost estimates.
Involve changes to an approved cost baseline.
Estimate at completion (EAC): A forecast of the most likely total project costs based on project
performance and risk quantification.
10. Project Cost Management
PCM
Project closeout:
Processes and procedures should be developed for the closing or cancelling of projects.
Example: Statement of Position (SOP 98-1 issued by the America Institute of Certified
Public Accountants) requires that all the costs for a failed information technology
project be written off in the quarter that the project is cancelled.
8) Application of EVM (Earned Value Management) method in EPC/Construction
Projects for Project control and monitoring
The problem of reporting work completed without the associated cost is resolved by Earned
Value (EV). EV combines effort and time into a single rupees schedule. Financial data is
important to a project manager because it can help manage a project to a successful completion.
Earned Value Analysis:
PV (BCWS)
Planned value or budgeted cost of work scheduled. Equates to the physical work scheduled and
the associated budget for the scheduled work. What was the planned spending for a given period
of time?
EV (BCWP)
Earned value or budgeted cost of work performed. Equates to the physical work accomplished
and the associated budget for this accomplished work. What work has been completed and what
measurement is used to establish the accomplished value of these items? EV is the bridge
between PV and AC. It is the key to relating three independent variables which can be used to
measure the performance of the project and obtain a forecast for the future.
AC (ACWP)
Actual Cost or Actual Cost of Work Performed. Equates to the physical work accomplished
and the actual cost of this accomplished work. What has been completed and what is the actual
cost of these items?
BAC
Budget at Completion = Total Budgeted Costs. What is the project’s budget?
EAC
Estimate at Completion (Estimated Costs at Completion)
Depending on the situation, EAC may be calculated by different means.
1) EAC = AC + ETC when original assumptions are flawed
2) EAC = AC + (BAC - EV) when variances are considered to be atypical and not expected to
occur again.
11. Project Cost Management
PCM
3) EAC = AC + (BAC-EV)/CPI where CPI is a cumulative. Used when variances are considered
typical.
4) EAC = BAC/CPI This is the old formula used by PMI.
Know this one and use it if the only information you have is BAC and CPI and you are asked
to calculate EAC. What is the total project expected to cost? How much will the project cost at
completion?
ETC
Estimate to Complete (Estimate of the additional funds needed to complete the project). ETC
ETC= EAC - AC
What is the estimate of additional funds needed to complete the project?
VAC
Variance at Completion. The difference between the total amount the project was supposed to
cost (BAC) and the amount the project is now expected to cost (EAC).
VAC = BAC – EAC
CPI
Cost Performance Index (cost performance factor, measures efficiency)
CPI = EV/AC, a value of less than 1.0 indicates less productivity than expected. This is a
measure of the financial wellbeing of the project. How efficient is the project? How fast are
things getting done from a financial point of view?
CV
Cost Variance (valued in rupees). This is a measure of the financial wellbeing of the project.
CV = EV - AC, a value of zero indicates that the project is on budget.
How far off are the scheduled cost of things to be completed from the actual amount spent?
SPI
Schedule Performance Index (schedule performance factor, measures effectiveness). Indicates
which portion of the planned schedule was actually accomplished.
SPI = EV/PV, a value of less than 1.0 indicates less has been completed than was scheduled.
How well is the project progressing in comparison to the expected progression?
SV
Schedule Variance (valued in rupees).
SV = EV - PV, a value of zero indicates that the project is on schedule.
How far off schedule is the project from a financial point of view?
12. Project Cost Management
PCM
PC
Percent Complete (real value of work accomplished). Tells the PM how much of the project
has been completed.
PC = EV/BAC
How much of the project has been completed?
TCPI
To-Complete Performance Index (verification factor)
TCPI = (BAC-EV)/BAC-AC) (a cost index). Values for the TCPI index of less than 1.0 is good
because it indicates the efficiency to complete is less than planned.
How efficient must the project team be to complete the remaining work with the remaining
money?