The document summarizes the findings of a rapid assessment of ICT skills demand in Indonesia. It found that 62% of ICT jobs available were for entry-level positions, with database query, HTML, and JavaScript being the most in-demand technical skills. Soft skills like teamwork and communication were also highly desired. The assessment recommends regular skills mapping, industry-TVET collaboration, and a focus on training marginalized groups and out-of-school youth. It proposes next steps like industry participation in upcoming career fairs and skills council meetings.
3. Methodology
• Rapid assessment to job vacancies:
• to newspaper and job portas/websites (most vacancies are from: jobsdb,
jobstreet, karir.com, topkarir, studentjob)
• 500 vacancies were analyzied.
• Findings are analyzed in overall, but also differentiated
based on level of experiences:
• Entry level: 0-2 years of work experiences
• Mid level: 25 months – 10 yeas of experiences
• Internship/apprenticeship
• ILO did the analysis by engaging Annisa P. Fauzia from
studentjob.id
• Report was completed in November 2018
4. Levels of ICT jobs available
7%
62%
31%
Job Level
Internship/Apprenticeship
Entry level (0-2 yr)
Mid level (25 mth-10 yr)
5. ICT technical skills that are in
demand
No. Technical Skills Working Area
1 Database query (SQL, MySQL,
mSQL)
Web Developer, Client Server, Database Programming,
Mobile Programming, IT Software Solution for Business,
Network Professional.
2 HTML Graphic Designer, Web Developer, Client Server
Programming, Database Programming, Mobile
Programming, IT Software Solution for Business, Network
Professional.
3 Javascript Graphic Designer, Web Developer, Client Server, Database
programming, Mobile Programming, IT Software Solution
for Business, Network Professional.
4 CSS Graphic Designer, Web Developer, Client Server
Programming, Mobile Programming, IT Software Solution
for Business, Network Professional.
5 PHP Web Developer, Database Programming, IT Software
Solution for Business, Network Professional.
6. ICT technical skills in demand, per
level
Entry Mid Internship/Apprenticeship
Database query (SQL, MySQL,
mSQL)
Database query (SQL, MySQL,
mSQL)
CSS
PHP Javascript Javascript
Javascript HTML HTML
CSS CSS jQuery
HTML Java Adobe Photoshop
7. Top ICT job titles:
• Looking from the job titles, the rapid assessment
finds the following jobs as the most in demand (for
all levels combined)
1. Web Developer/Programmer
2. Graphic Designer
3. Front End Developer/Programmer
4. Android Developer
5. Java Developer/Programmer
8. Top ICT job titles per level:
Entry Mid Internship/Apprenticeship
Web Developer/Programmer IT Developer/Programmer Web Developer/Programmer
Graphic Designer Java Developer Graphic Designer
Mobile Developer/Programmer
(Android & iOS)
Mobile Developer/Programmer
(Android & iOS)
Software Developer/Engineer
IT Support/Technical Support IT Manager/Leader Junior Web Designer
Animator Graphic Designer Junior Animator
9. Required level of education:
• For jobs in the ICT sector, the following level of
educations are the ones required by employers:
39
133
322
1
SMA/SMK D3 S1 S2
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
EDUCATION LEVEL
10. Monthly salary offered by
employers:
• On the monthly salary, the job vacancies offered
the following salaries (in order):
1. Rp. 3.000.000 – Rp. 5.000.000
2. Rp. 7.000.000 – Rp. 10.000.000
3. Rp. 10.000.000 – Rp. 15.000.000
4. Rp. 5.000.000 – Rp. 7.000.000
5. < Rp. 3.000.000
11. Job location
• Based on the rapid assessment, ICT jobs are mostly
available in:
1. DKI Jakarta
2. Tangerang
3. Bandung
4. DIY Yogyakarta
5. Surabaya
12. Collaboration with BBPLK Bekasi (1)
• BBPLK Bekasi has 12 training courses on ICT.
• Job areas that are most in demand based on the rapid
assessment are compare with training courses run by BBPLK
Bekasi. Based on that, the followings are BBPLK Bekasi’s
training courses that can answer the market demand:
1. Web Development
2. IT Software Solutions for Business
3. Network Professional
4. Graphic Design
5. (Client Server Programming)
13. Collaboration with BBPLK Bekasi (2)
• Compare with technical skills that are actually
needed/required, the rapid assessment shows the
followings:
Training in BBPLK Bekasi Technical skills required
Web Development PHP
IT Software Solution for Business SQL
Client Server Programming HTML
Network Professional Network Protocols Hardware
Graphic Designer Photoshop
14. Soft skills required
• The rapid assessment also looked into soft skills
demanded by employers and finds the followings:
1. Able to work independently and as part of a team.
2. Creative.
3. Communication skills.
4. Willingness to learn.
5. Work with high initiatives.
• Able to work in a team and communication skills
are consistently needed in all job levels.
15. Conclusions and
Recommendations
• Soft skills are equally important as technical skills.
• Thus, all of us need to make sure that job seekers and workers have
both soft and technical skill.
• What needed now is not necessarily needed for the future;
and vice versa.
• We need to prepare future needs from now.
• Mapping of jobs and skills need in the world of work is
needed to develop education and training programmes that
can provide future needs.
• Do mapping on a regular basis.
• Carry out dialogue on a regular basis.
• Require all relevant parties: government, employers and job seekers
and workers.
17. ILO strategies to accelerate skills development
Partnership
Leveraging resources
and technologies
Orientation for
change
Stakeholder collaboration help improve the quality
and employment outcome of Technical and
Vocational Education and Training (TVET). It also
reduces the cost.
-> Apprenticeships, tripartite: government, employers
and trade unions
Using the existing resources and technologies to
improve the quality of and the access to training.
-> BLK, distance learning
We strive to accelerate skills development with effective interventions
Changing practices and behaviours of training
institutions help improve training outcome.
-> Gender equality, BLK management, out-of-school/pre-
employed youth, marginalized groups
-> Job Fair for People with Disabilities will be on 22-24
August 2019, at Atma Jaya University
18. Industry-TVET collaboration,
Work-based learning (WBL)
Work-based
Learning
• Focus on Apprenticeship
• Improving quality of National apprenticeship through
socialization on quality apprenticeship, pilot project
on hospitality, guidelines development and study.
• Discussion plan about International Standards on
apprenticeships at the ILO 2021 - 2022
Industry – TVET
collaboration
• Industry is the primary consumers of TVET graduates,
therefore, TVET system is driven by demand for
employment.
• TVET and Industry should be partnership based that
industries are encouraged to support and involved in
the meaningful way with TVET.
• Partnership: curriculum development, recruitment,
volunteers from industries, teachers quality, work
based learning, etc
• industry – TVET collaboration, on 26th June 2019, at
Perpustakaan Nasional
19. Access of women to training and employment
Pre-employed/out-
of-school female
youth
• Collaboration with BLK in ICT skills training,
which employs the aforementioned strategy:
orientation for change (e.g. gender sensitization
training); leveraging technologies and trends
(e.g. promotion through WhatsApp and
Instagram); and strengthening connection with
private sectors (e.g. career day, job fair).
• Career day for youth at BBPLK Bekasi on 15
August 2019 (date tbc)
• Objective: gain employment.
In-company soft skills
training for female
workers/employees
• Collaboration with business coalition and
directly with private companies, for provision of
soft skills training through peer-learning
methodology to low-skilled to mid-management
female employees; supported with live online
monitoring system accessible for the companies’
management.
• Currently on-going with companies and open for
new partnerships.
• Objective: retention and career advancement.
20. Distance learning
Awareness raising
workshops, a study visit
Pilot online training
Design two on-line
learning material
Assessment
Impact and cost-
effectiveness, learn
lessons
Mainstreaming
distance learning in
GoI policy
21. Improving the management of BLK
Significant role of BLK in school to work transition, particularly
for out-of-school/pre-employed youth
Government plan to build more BLKs (1,000 Community BLKs
in 2019, 3.000 by 2030)
Quality gap between national and provincial/city/ district
owned BLKs
Private sector collaborations, quality instructors and
management, and updated curriculum
22. Active Labour Market Policies: Linking
employment insurance, public employment
services and training
Employment
Insurance (EI)
Re-Skilling
Up-Skilling
Public
employment
services (PES)
Provide
technical inputs
and facilitate
the design of EI
Design and pilot capacity
building material for career
counsellors
On-going work with
BLK
23. Partnership opportunities
Partnership
Leveraging resources
and technologies
Orientation for
change
• Sector specific skills council/working group
• Work-based learning: job visit, job experiences,
internship and apprenticeship (both
teachers/instructors and youth)
• Companies’ visit to BLKs to share experiences
• Soft skills training for firms’ employees
• Developing distance/digital learning
• Piloting distance/digital learning
• Focus on out-of-school/pre-employed youth,
which is in abundance compare to high
school/college graduates
• Focus on marginalized groups: female, lower
economic and education background, people
with disabilities, LGBTQI, etc
24. Proposed immediate follow-up actions
Firms to participate as speaker on Career Day at BBPLK Bekasi,
in August (date to be confirmed)
Firms to participate in Job Fair for People with Disabilities, on
22-24 August 2019, at Atma Jaya University
Firms to come to the launching of documentation of industry
– TVET collaboration, on 26th June 2019, at Perpustakaan
Nasional
Firms to convene at a follow up meeting to establish sector
specific skills council, facilitated and led by the ILO. Proposed
time: early August 2019.
Follow up meetings between interested firms and the ILO on
various possible collaborations, e.g. internship,
apprenticeship, development of digital skills training, etc.
25. Terima Kasih
For more information, please contact:
Tendy Gunawan, gunawan@ilo.org
Dede Shinta Sudono, sudono@ilo.org
Hirania Wiryasti, wiryasti@ilo.org
Kazutoshi Chatani, chatani@ilo.org
ILO Jakarta Office
Menara Thamrin Level 22
Jl. M. H. Thamrin Kav 3
Jakarta Pusat