SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  28
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Guide to Understanding Commercial
Real Estate for Facility Managers
Brian Woolsey
Broker
Reveals All
Contents
Seven Habits of Highly Effective BrokersI.	
Start Early1.	
Assemble an All-Star Team2.	
Decide on the Best Transaction3.	
Have Multiple Options4.	
Craft a Winning RFP, Solicit Offers and Analyze5.	
Negotiate like a Pro6.	
Abstract and Manage the Lease7.	
Types of TransactionsII.	
Purchase/Sale1.	
Lease2.	
Sublease3.	
Build to Suit4.	
Sale-Leaseback5.	
Appraisal v. BOVIII.	
Top Ten Lease TermsIV.	
Termination Option1.	
Sublease Rights2.	
Holdover Clause3.	
Right of First Refusal4.	
Renewal Option5.	
Audit Rights6.	
Financial Guarantees7.	
Rent Concessions8.	
Tenant Improvements9.	
Maintenance & Repairs10.	
Resource GuideV.	
Market ResearchVI.	
Authors’ BiographiesVII.	
Brian Woolsey1.	
cassidyturley.com 1
Broker Reveals All
1. Start Early
Crafting the best real estate solution can take time especially if it is a large project, the lease expiration is not eminent or you are
trying to build or buy something. Size matters. The larger the project, the more visible it is within the organization which means there
are going to be more people weighing in on each decision which can ultimately slows the process down. Take this into consideration
before you decide to delay a project’s start date. Moreover, lease expirations are bad indicators of when to start. If something is
happening in your business, do something. Make the decision to talk with your existing landlord, sublease the space, or talk to
management about a “Blend and Extend”. Whatever the case may be, take action now.
Here are few specific transactions that characteristically take longer to complete then others. If these end up being the best
transaction for your organization be sure to begin right away.
Buying, Selling, Build to Suit:•	
These transactions can take longer to complete then leases for several reasons. First, often times there are fewer
opportunities to purchase then to lease, so the scarcity of available properties necessitates that in order to see enough
properties you have to start early. Additionally, in today’s market there are several properties that are “available” but because
of the ownership structure (i.e. foreclosure, special servicer, CMBS ownership) getting the property under contract for a price
you feel is fair may take several months, perhaps years.
“Blend and Extend” transactions:•	
Despite the long-term nature of a lease contract, tenants frequently have the ability to realign their lease terms according to
their business needs, even when several years remain on the lease. Blend-and-extend transactions allow a tenant to combine
costs associated with the existing lease with current market rates over an extended new period. The key is to use the allure
of an early renewal to negotiate a new lease. Often the tenant can negotiate concessions such as lower rents and additional
capital improvements.
Depending on the landlord, a blend-and-extend can either be easy or difficult to achieve. The goal is to get the landlord to
understand that given the high vacancy rates in their markets a blend-and-extent transaction can ensure:
1. Their buildings are full of credit-worthy tenants.
2. They don’t incur the risk and costs associated with having to remarket and lease space.
Moving Takes Time:•	
Moving can be a time consuming
process. If the best solution is in
another building, giving yourself
plenty of time to execute the move is
essential. Here area some guidelines
for moving an office:
I. Seven Habits of Highly Effective Brokers
cassidyturley.com 2
Broker Reveals All
2. Assemble an All-Star Team
There is nothing worse then discovering half way through a project that your vendor is either incompetent, not a good personality fit or
can not deliver the same value as one of their competitors. Additionally, the typical RFP/interview process can be difficult to judge the
team and to know exactly how the vendor will service your account. To use an analogy, how a present is wrapped is often not a good
indicator of what the gift.
If you can, test your vendor with a small project. Build trust and gage their abilities slowly. Ease into the relationship.
Another strategy is to proactively build relationships during down times with potential vendors so you have an arsenal of qualified and
trusted advisors that can make you look good and provide exceptional value – when you need them.
If you do not have time to qualify a vendor use the following tips as an aid to prequalify the people you hire.
Selecting a Broker
If your Master Broker is a national/international firm they should be able to find the best talent for the assignment in the market
you are working in. Be sure to learn about their process for hiring brokers in Small Town, USA or even in the larger markets. Do
they have a “best in class” approach or do they only hire people from within the same firm? Are you comfortable with that? Do they
have the flexibility to hire outside the firm if another person/firm would provide a better service? BEWARE: Some firms never hire
local representation!
Contrary to popular belief, from a licensing standpoint, there is little that differentiates a commercial real estate agent from a
residential real estate agent. In fact, in most states the real estate licensing requirements are identical. Over time two professional
organizations have emerged to make it easier to differentiate experience and qualifications. Either of the following professional
organizations also lists their members so you can locate brokers by geographic area.
CCIM (Certified Commercial Investment Member, www.ccim.com) Real estate agents with this designation•	
have to take a series of four real estate finance courses, pass a final exam and submit a resume and portfolio
of representative transactions. Brokers that hold this designation have a good handle on the financial aspects
of commercial real estate.
SIOR (Society of Industrial and Office Realtors, www.sior.com) Real estate agents with this designation have•	
demonstrated a mastery of commercial real estate through a combination of tenure in the business and
sustained production levels.
cassidyturley.com 3
Broker Reveals All
Selecting a Project Manager
Project Managers that specialize in moving can help you avoid costly mistakes along
the way. Use them. Leverage you time or your business by utilizing their skills.
Some brokers will provide project management service as part of their scope of
service? Looked around. You can probably find someone that would offer to either
include that service or rebate a percentage of the commission to pay for those services.
Selecting an Appraiser
There is really only one significant designation for commercial appraisers.
MAI (Member of the Appraisal Institute) - An appraiser who has earned the MAI designation is qualified to
and experienced in the performance of both residential and commercial properties. Many other appraisers
are only qualified for residential property. At one point, lenders were likely to require that an appraisal be
done by an MAI certified appraiser, or a member of another trade organization. Certified appraisals can
increase the chances of a favorable lending situation, since the lender will feel more comfortable. An MAI
certified appraisal offers lenders a reliability that allows them to be confident in their investment.
Selecting an Attorney
There is only one thing to look for when
hiring an attorney - a focus on real estate.
Most of the attorneys at the large firms
specialize in one aspect of law. Be sure to
hire one that is familiar with the customs of
the local market as wells as the requirements
of your organization. This will save you a lot of
time.
cassidyturley.com 4
Tip #1
Depending on the size of the transaction, you may be able to find a brokerage
team to provide project/construction management as part of their overall service
offering.
Tip #2
Trim your attorney’s fees in half. A good broker negotiates major business points
early in the RFP process leaving the details for the attorneys to work out.
Broker Reveals All
3. Decide on the Best Transaction
Choose the real estate transaction that best supports the business objectives of the firm. Understand what you need and which
transaction is best aligned to meet those needs. See section II. Types of Transactions, for a description of what organizational profiles
fit best with each transaction type. Taking the time to decide on the best transaction up front will save you a lot of time down the road.
4. Have Multiple Options
In real estate, the deal is never done until, it is done! You want to negotiate at least two deals in parallel all the way to final lease
signing. There are several reasons to do this. First, each property provides leverage in your negotiations with the other, including
the most powerful negotiations of all, the ability to walk from the deal. Additionally, if something happens at the eleventh hour to the
preferred option you have a back up in place to keep the project on schedule.
In most markets in the U.S. you can find the information you need to create a competitive bid for your tenancy by consulting online
services like LoopNet or CoStar. In the Midwest a good source is Xceligent. Most of these sites have a section that is free (although
limited in scope) for corporate users to search alternate properties.
Although, online sources are a great starting point, do not limit yourself to what is available online or currently being marketed. Make
sure your broker informs the market about your requirement. You will be surprised how many additional opportunities come your way
through this approach.
For overseas assignments, you can get market reports for most major cities for free from international real estate providers. These
reports will have current market rates as well as vacancy levels that will be useful in your negotiation.
cassidyturley.com 5
Broker Reveals All
5. Craft a Winning RFP, Solicit Offers and Analyze
After developing a negotiating strategy and conducting a market survey, in most cases creating and managing a customized Request
for Proposal (RFP) process that requests initial proposals from building owners is advisable. The objective in doing this is to:
Initiate meaningful negotiations with a clearly defined schedule for responding.•	
Create level playing field for owner responses.•	
Provide detailed information that will maximize leverage in renewal negotiations.•	
Obtain detailed and specific information regarding each proposed facility and its ownership and management.•	
Perform test-fit space planning, typically at the prospective landlord’s expense.•	
Obtain preliminary construction pricing, typically by the prospective landlord’s contractor.•	
Ensure that each facility is capable and caters to your optimal facility preferences.•	
Here is a sample RFP. Your broker should customize this for you.
cassidyturley.com 6
Broker Reveals All
cassidyturley.com 7
Analyze the Offers:
After receiving the proposals, your broker should prepare a financial analysis comparing the annual and total occupancy costs of
the most viable potential transactions, the facility objectives and the existing total occupancy cost benchmark. These analyses and
comparisons help to ensure that you are maximizing your leverage in the marketplace and driving down occupancy costs. Many
brokers also provide customized analysis and reporting.
You may want to also analyze the non-economic factors for each property. A “Non-Economic Comparison” organizes and rates the
intangible differences between properties. These comparisons help with ranking each property on issues such as ingress, egress,
closeness to public transportation, proximity to major freeways/highways, amenities in the building and neighborhood, as well as
many other issues that are important to your organization.
Broker Reveals All
cassidyturley.com 8
6. Negotiate like a Pro
“In life (and real estate) you don’t get what you deserve, you get what you negotiate.” Frank Sherwood
The three critical elements of a negotiation are time, information and power.
A. Time: The Chinese are masters at understanding time. They have the patience and the discipline that few western managers
can muster. Ideally, you need 12-24 months to complete a transaction. Negotiations have an ebb and flow of their own and time
is needed to leverage the marketplace. Regardless of when you start, most concessions occur at or near the deadline.
B. Information: Half of the negotiation issues are handled by preparing properly. A properly crafted RFP and managed process
can provide you with a lot of the information about the market that you will need to leverage your desired landlord.
C. The Power of Win-Win: Many people think “win – win” means I win twice. You need to understand what a win feels like to the
landlord. Know what the landlord wants and know what you can afford to give up. Then be methodical in giving it up slowly. Learn
to keep your automatic defenses under control and respond appropriately to issues from the other side.
Resources: The one human freedom that cannot be taken from you is the capacity to choose your attitude in any given set of
circumstances – to choose one’s own way. (Viktor Frankl, Man’s Search for Meaning) That statement holds the key to many of life’s
problems and is very useful in the art of Negotiation.
If you are looking for a good resource on negotiating we recommend You Can Negotiate Anything by Herb Cohen. He is widely
recognized as an expert in the negotiating field. His sequel Negotiate This is also worth a read.
Broker Reveals All
7. Abstract and Manage the Lease
What do you do now that your deal is done?
One of the easiest ways to prove your worth,
over and over to your boss is to come to
them proactively with reminders of your
fabulously negotiated lease options. To do
that you need to have those lease terms easily
accessible. If you have fewer then 10 leases in
your portfolio we would recommend a lease abstract for each lease and a master spreadsheet with everything rolled up - a master
timeline of sorts.
Each of the options you have negotiated has a time frame associated with it and the landlord is not going to remind you of when they
are. In fact, most of the time they are holding their breath hoping that the date passes without a peep from you. Sometimes just letting
your landlord know that you are aware of your options is enough to get them to come to the table to get a better deal.
Here is a simple template that you can use to begin abstracting your leases.
cassidyturley.com 9
Tip #3
Get lease administration/abstract/audit services for free. Several of the larger
brokerage firms will provide lease abstracting, lease administration and lease
audit services with an exclusive transaction management agreement. If your
portfolio is not large enough to do that, you may be able to negotiate fee
rebates to offset the costs for some of these services.
Broker Reveals All
Lease Maintenance
The industry average for incorrect rent
invoices is 90%. How are you managing
rent disbursements? Now that you’ve just
negotiated the best real estate transaction
of your career how do you ensure that all of
these great economic terms and options are
enforced properly?
A. Don’t leave it up to your Landlord.
B. CAM Reconciliation: how do I know if the CAM reconciliation I got from my Landlord is accurate, what questions should I be
asking?
C. Real Estate Tax Protest: how do I know if I have a case, if I have several sites how do I prioritize, how do I select and manage the
attorney and their fees?
“The (real estate) market doesn’t value your (brokerage) services the same way that corporate real estate directors do. The market
pays you huge sums of money to negotiate transactions when really that is only part of the equation. We see just as much value in
managing the leases that we have in place.” - Minneapolis Fortune 50 Corporate RE Director
cassidyturley.com 1 0
Tip #4
If you haven’t done any lease/CAM audits recently, find a commercial real
estate company that will do this work on a percent recovery basis. The
savings can be enormous and the services are free. Sophisticated companies
do these each year.
Purchase/Sale
For privately held firms a purchase can provide tax advantages and can potentially reduce long term occupancy costs. It may also
provide equity appreciation.
For publicly held firms acquisitions are usually strategic in nature or support a unique long term capital investment in the Real Estate;
i.e. clean room, manufacturing, or other specialized functions where real estate is just a portion of the overall occupancy costs of the
location.
Generally these are a good fit for companies with the following characteristics:
Steady business•	
Good access to capital,•	
Return on investment in Real Estate is the same or better then investment in business.•	
Lease
This is a fitting transaction for organizations with the following profile:
Little to no up-front capital costs•	
Need flexibility•	
Want little to no management responsibilities•	
Lease might be the only option to get into the type of space your business requires (40th floor of a central Business District,•	
for example)
Timing – shorter time to get in•	
Capital is made available to invest in business•	
Sublease
This is a fitting transaction for organizations with the following profile:
Start up business•	
Location does not matter•	
Economics are a major concern•	
Need furniture, phone system or other office functions•	
Timing – typically little to no Tenant Improvements (TI) given. The “glove” either fits or it does not. Take the space or not.•	
Get in quick.
May represent the only option to get into a desired building•	
Depending on the size of the space they are often available on short term basis•	
Broker Reveals All
cassidyturley.com 1 1
II. Types of Transactions
Build to Suit
This is a fitting transaction for organizations
with the following profile:
Construction based on operational•	
issues can create efficiencies
The building will reduce occupancy•	
costs
Improve operational productivity•	
Other alternatives to lease/purchase•	
do not exist
Sale Leaseback
This is a structured finance transaction that involves two transactions that happened simultaneously. Typically, it involves the owner
occupant of the real estate selling the property to an investor and then leasing the space from the investor.
The sale price is based on a number of factors including: rental rate, tenant’s credit rating, length of lease, capitalization rates,
availability of funds, and other lease terms.
This is a popular transaction when the business is performing extremely well and cash is needed to reinvest in the business.
A Sale Leaseback can be helpful in:
Maximizing the sale price•	
Eliminating debt from balance sheet•	
Possibly shifting management responsibilities•	
Reducing occupancy costs•	
Reducing exposure to market fluctuations•	
Broker Reveals All
cassidyturley.com 1 2
Tip #5
Be sure to design the building with the “end game” in mind. Companies that
build buildings for their exclusive use have a tendency to over engineer them
and this hurts them when they go to exit the property. Think about the properties
next life. What simple adjustments can you make to the building’s design so it
can be more easily re-purposed when you are done with it?
Broker Reveals All
cassidyturley.com 1 3
Appraisal: an estimate of property value typically derived by an appraiser who is trained to “look backwards” in time to find prices of
“comparable properties” that were sold. Typically, they use three approaches to establish value. Virtually every appraisal needs at least
two approaches to serve as a check on one another. The three approaches are:
1.	 Income Approach
2.	 Sales Comparison Approach,
3.	 Cost Approach (Replacement Approach)
When to order appraisal: Tax Protest, Financing/Refinancing, Compliance with State and Federal licensure requirements,•	
Public Agencies responsible to State Auditor, Insurance Companies, Eminent Domain proceedings
What to look for: MAI, highest professional designation among commercial appraisers•	
Time: 3-6 weeks, 8 weeks in some cases•	
Price: $4,000-$10,000 (ask about differences in scope)•	
Receivable: 100-150 page document.•	
Broker Opinion of Value (BOV): an estimate of property value derived by a commercial real estate broker who is typically an expert on
the market that the subject property resides and given recent transactions, activity in the market and alternatives can provide a price
that the market would pay for the property. Generally, these estimates are based on recent sales, pending sales or investment activity
and CAP rate trends.
When to order a BOV: Making decision to buy/sell property, lease another property.•	
Time: 1-6 weeks•	
Price: free-$3,000•	
Receivable: 3-15 page document. Typically includes, comments on the market, summary and analysis of the existing•	
property’s position in the market, comparable sales and an estimate of value.
III. Appraisal vs. BOV
Broker Reveals All
cassidyturley.com 1 4
Termination Option1.	
This is an agreement by Landlord to provide Tenant the right to terminate the lease early on a predetermined date and
for a specified price. It may also be referred to as an Early Termination Option or Cancellation Option. Like many other
options (i.e. renewals, expansions) terminations options are not part of the landlord’s boilerplate lease. The only way you
will get this into the agreement is if you demand it. Do not get lulled into believing that you cannot get one either. While
almost all landlords take an extremely hard line on termination options if they want to gain or retain your tenancy they will
accommodate this request.
This is an extremely powerful option - perhaps the most powerful. Whether the company is growing extremely fast,
contracting, or simply needs the ability to react to a changing market a termination option is a must.
A typical termination clause will allow you to cancel the lease with 6 to 12 months written notice and provide a payment
for the unamortized transaction costs. These costs include tenant improvement allowances, project management fees,
legal fees, free rent and brokerage commissions. The tenant’s objective in this discussion is to reduce the amount of
notice required and to reduce the potential penalty fees. Focus on negotiating a lower interest rate, eliminating the
penalty and discussing the calculations for what is included as a “transaction cost”.
When negotiating a termination option remember that the first priority is simply to have this option. The penalty payment
is really a distant second because although it may seem like a large number, when it is compared to the next best option
(paying rent for the remainder of the term or subleasing) it often presents a compelling business argument. If your firm
is fortunate enough to have to exercise the option to accommodate its’ growth often times the penalty can be off-set by
concessions in the marketplace.
Sublease Rights2.	
This is the name given to an arrangement in which the tenant assigns the lease to a third party, thereby making the old
tenant the sublandlord (sublessor), and the new tenant the subtenant (sublessee).
Subleasing is a challenging process. Make sure you maximize your organization’s ability to get out from a lease liability by
eliminating or at least minimizing your landlord’s ability to block the transaction.
When negotiation sublease rights focus on:
A.	 Minimizing Landlord’s Time to Approve: Typically a tenant is required to notify the landlord in writing, asking
for prior approval of a sublease or an assignment. At a minimum you should add language that says the
landlord’s approval shall not be “unreasonably withheld”. However, you should also state a specific time limit
by which the landlord must respond. As they say, time kills deals. Don’t give you landlord the opportunity to do
this to you. Minimize the time the landlord has to approve your transaction. For example, ask to have a written
response within 5 days. If the landlord does not respond within the 5-day period you are free to execute the
sublease.
B.	 Minimizing Landlord’s Abilities to Veto your Transaction: The most common reason a landlord vetoes a sublease
is they do not like the subtenant’s finances or use. Your argument is this, so long as they can pay the rent and
IV. Top Ten Lease Terms
Broker Reveals All
cassidyturley.com 1 5
your firm is still on the hook, what difference should it make who it is? Have your attorney negotiate language
that is air-tight.
C.	 Extending the Subtenant the Same Rights: Additionally, you want to make sure that any options and rights that
you have, including rights to expand, renew and extend are able to be transferred to the subtenant. Landlords
like to restrict those rights as pertaining only to the original tenant. Failure to clarify the transfer rights can
significantly reduce the value of the sublease.
Holdover Clause3.	
The Holdover Clause describes the rent the tenant will pay after the lease expires. A lease without any term adds no
value to the building so landlords add Holdover Clauses to their leases with heavy penalties for staying in the space past
the lease expiration to create an incentive for tenants to make another long-term commitment to their space
Most landlords will typically start out asking for a 200% holdover penalty on the gross rent if the tenant stays beyond the
original term. Most brokers settle for a 150% holdover penalty. Perhaps you ask for 6 months beyond the original term
at the current rate. You can usually negotiate a more favorable result like 3 months at the current rate and 3 months at
125% if you do it early in the negotiation.
Expansion Options - ROFR or ROFO4.	
Right of First Refusal (ROFR) –
This is a contractual right that gives its holder the option to enter a business transaction with the owner of something,
according to specified terms, before the owner is entitled to enter into that transaction with a third party. This is
especially useful for any contiguous space. This allows the tenant to have the option to expand at favorable terms if
the business is doing well.
There are several variations of the ROFR. It is rarely part of the landlord’s boilerplate lease so it is up to the tenant or
its’ broker to make sure this is part of the negotiations. Your attorney can help you craft the perfect language for this
option.
In ordinary business how this would play out is the landlord would provide a proposal to a prospective tenant. At
such time as the prospective tenant and landlord have reached a preliminary agreement, the landlord would come
to the option holder to inform them of the terms of the deal and offer them the option to do the deal. Some things
to think about: as a tenant you want as much time as possible to make this decision. As the saying goes, “time kills
deals” so even if your decision is not to take the space you still might not want to inform them until the last day that
you need to as this time could derail the deal with the prospective tenant.
Right of First Offer (ROFO) -
Rights of First Offer are pro-tenant expansion rights which obligate the landlord to notify the tenant possessing such
rights (i.e., the ROFO tenant) that it desires to lease space subject to the ROFO. Although the landlord may or may
not have a specific tenant in mind for the space, a ROFO usually requires the landlord to makes a proposal covering
the business terms of a proposed lease for the applicable space. With a ROFO, usually no third party deal provides
the business terms for the landlord’s proposal, which is normally the case with a right of first refusal. These are
especially useful with contiguous space that is currently occupied. If possible, your goal should be to get a right to
lease the space before the existing tenant can renew.
Broker Reveals All
If the ROFO tenant does not elect to lease the space on the terms offered by the landlord in its notice, the landlord is
normally free to try to lease such space to any third party, provided it does so based upon the terms in its notice (or,
in some cases, on terms no more favorable than those contained in the landlord’s ROFO proposal). In many cases,
the landlord must make a deal for the space involved within a certain period of time, or the ROFO will “revive,”
requiring the landlord to offer the space to the ROFO tenant anew before making a third party deal.
Option to Renew5.	
This clause gives a tenant the right to extend the term of the lease, usually for a stated period of time and at a rent
amount provided for in the lease. Typically, the tenant has to give 6-12 months notice to landlord to exercise this option.
Negotiating a fixed price renewal eliminates the need to enter into a long negotiation 5 years down the road when you
may have fewer options in a tight market. A landlord’s typically position will be to offer a renewal at market rates. The
“market rate” statement introduces a lot of ambiguity into the process. To increase you flexibility and minimize the
number of budget surprises focus on a fixed rate renewal. If you have to go with “market rate” think about adding some
language to include market rate concessions (i.e. tenant improvement packages, free rent concessions, brokerage fees).
Audit Rights6.	
Some leases specifically grant tenants the right to review the books and records of the landlord to ensure that the charges
billed are correct. Many hours are expended negotiating and drafting operating expense, tax, utility and other similar
clauses. Yet, despite all of the “points” that a tenant may win in this negotiation, it frequently gives it all up by agreeing to
restrictions on its ability to enforce these provisions.
Errors are commonplace. Statistics show that close to 90% of invoices have mistakes, mostly because landlords’
administrative personnel do not tailor the bills to each individually negotiated lease. Any restriction that effectively
prevents the review from taking place should be removed from the lease.
As you approach your negotiations of this clause focus on the following:
Extending Time Limits:
Many landlords ask the tenant to provide a detailed written objection to the landlord’s bills within a very short time
period (in most cases 30-90 days) failing which the bill is “conclusive and binding” on the tenant, who is “deemed”
to have agreed to the bill as rendered.
The problem with accepting this limitation is that it is virtually impossible for most tenants to determine whether
there is anything wrong with the bill within 90 or even 180 days because making such a determination often
requires lots of steps: hiring a lease audit firm to review the lease and the bills; gathering needed internal
information; coordinating schedules for an audit; conducting an on-site review of the building’s books and records;
completing the analysis; preparing a report; presenting the findings to the landlord. Each step can take weeks or
months.
What is ironic about these clauses is that without a time limitation in the lease, the tenant’s right to audit is governed
by the statute of limitations. This is the time a party to a contract has to enforce its rights. In most states, should a
landlord bill a tenant incorrectly (i.e., breach its lease agreement), the tenant would have 4 to 10 years in which to
bring an action against the landlord. At a bare minimum, the tenant should have a year or two to review the charges.
cassidyturley.com 1 6
A. Have the smallest business units sign the lease. *
B. Submit your company’s financials.
C. Call / meeting for your CFO / banker & landlord.
D. Pay a security deposit OR offer
to pay a double security deposit.
E. Letter of Credit
(LOC) with a declining
balance. **
F. Personal / Corporate Guarantees ***
A few additional notes:
*A. Inc. vs. Corp.:Explore different business units that could sign the lease.
Most companies have several related companies: INC, LLC, etc. Explore using
the lowest or least credit worthy entity first. If that is your first position your next
position might be to have a parent company sign the lease.
**E. Letter of Credit (LOC) Generally, there is a small fee (similar to a loan origination
fee) and annual renewal charges to arranging a LOC but because the money stays with
the company you can continue to accrue interest. For businesses that require a high level of working capital
this can be difficult.
If you go this route it is reasonable to request a LOC with a declining balance. Meaning at the beginning of the lease the LOC might be for 100% of
the transaction costs but 25% of the way into the lease it might be for only 75% of the transaction costs, 50% into the lease it might be for 50%
and so on. Sometimes the landlord might require the balance to decline using an amortization schedule versus straight-line, like we have used here,
which is fairly common as well.
***F. Personal Guarantees. No one likes to give a personal guarantee but sometimes they are the only option if the owner cannot afford to have
capital on the sidelines for a LOC. Like the LOC seek a declining balance.
Broker Reveals All
Eliminating Restrictions on Who Can Do the Audit:
Another common restriction is to require the tenant to use a “Big-4” accounting firm, or a firm that is not
compensated on a contingency fee basis. The important point here is that a landlord has no legitimate interest
in telling a tenant who can work on its behalf. Would it ever tell a tenant not to use a certain attorney or broker?
Would the tenant ever think it appropriate to tell the landlord which HVAC contractor to use or how to compensate
it? Contingency audit firms exist because tenants don’t have the time to focus on these issues and can’t budget the
expense needed to audit leases on an hourly or fixed-fee basis. Thus, the result of this restriction is that although the
tenant has permission to verify the charges, in reality it most likely won’t be able to do so.
Financial Guarantees7.	
Guarantees, in their many forms, essentially help provide the landlord with an additional level of comfort that the contract
will be fulfilled in the event that tenant is not able make timely payments per its contractual obligation. Remember
that you are entering into a financial transaction that may not make the landlord whole until well over half way through
your term. So if you feel like there is some hesitation on the part of the owner that is why. Do your part to make them
comfortable with their investment. Start by knowing this: the minute you begin talking about Security Deposit you should
also be having a conversation
about the Letter of Credit, the
Personal Guarantee and the
concessions. All of these are part
of the conversation about financial
guarantees.
Here are a few ideas of things you can
offer, remembering that the only way to
minimize the Financial Guarantees is to
give the landlord a comfort level about your
company’s financial health. Start with the things
that don’t cost your organization anything and
proceed with some of the others if necessary.
cassidyturley.com 1 7
Broker Reveals All
Rent Concessions8.	
Concessions a landlord may offer a tenant
in order to secure their tenancy. While rental
abatement is one form of a concession, there
are many others such as: increased tenant
improvement allowance, signage, lower than
market rental rates and moving allowances. What is “fair” to ask for depends on your market. If you have hired a broker
they are the best source of information. A good broker should have “market comps” at their finger tips and be able to
send you them.
In some markets, it is fairly common to see one or more months of free rent for every year of term leased.
Another rent concession is smaller rent bumps. For years they were $0.50/year. In recent months we have seen more
$0.25/year bumps or flat rates of 2% and 3% annual increases. We anticipate rates will fall but they generally lag the bad
economic news by 12 to 18 months. We are still waiting for further rent face rate concessions.
Remember that part of “negotiations” or getting the best deal is vetting the options. In a market like we have today the
landlord profile makes a huge difference. In little time, through the RFP process and after a round or two of negotiations,
you will know who has the ability to make a deal and who does not. Depending on how many layers of approvals are
needed, how much debt is layered on the property, part of your ability to get a great deal will be simply selecting the right
landlord. Do not waste your breath explaining what the market is, make a deal with the landlord that has the ability and
appetite to make a “market” deal.
Let’s take a look at two potential buyer profiles. One is a local owner that has owned the property for the last 15 years.
The second is a out of state owner that paid a high price for their property just a few years ago and, oh, by the way, they
need to go to Germany to get final approval on the deal.
Which one do you think has more of an ability to “meet the market”? Clearly, it is the first owner. First, they read the
same daily paper and can see for themselves how bad the market is. Second, because they have owned it for a long time
they should have a lower basis in the property and more ability to provide rent concessions and still make their mortgage
payments.
Tenant Improvements9.	
Improvements made to the leased premises by or for a tenant. Generally, especially in new space, part of the negotiations
will include the improvements to be made in the leased premises by the landlord. The Tenant Improvement Allowance
(TI Allowance or Tenant Finish Allowance) defines the fixed amount of money contributed by the landlord toward tenant
improvements. The tenant pays any of the costs that exceed this amount.
Tenant Improvements could be considered a concession. Generally they are far and away the largest concession. Here
are some things to consider or keep in mind when negotiating the TI package.
Do your homework, get a space plan, get your changes added and then get construction pricing documents prepared
and get pricing so you know that the allowance being provided is enough cover the costs of the construction then make
sure the allowance covers your “other” costs.
cassidyturley.com 1 8
Tip #7
Request market comps from your broker. This can help to benchmark your
negotiations and keep your broker’s feet in the fire.
Broker Reveals All
Negotiate the ability to use a percentage of the allowance for “other” things. Generally, a Landlord is willing to give you
some money for moving, cabling and set up but often times it does not specify that it can be used for a construction
manager or project manager. Unless you have staff, make sure that you have at least negotiated the flexibility to fund an
outside staff person to coordinate the move, the drawings and the construction process and timeline.
Make sure if the construction bid does not include a line item for design fees that you add it back.
Negotiate the ability to get a credit for any unused allowance or negotiate the ability to use the total package for an
extended period of time. For instance, you might propose that up to 25% of the allowance may be used up to three years
following the lease commencement date.
Maintenance and Repairs10.	
This clause is critical. Without it, neither the landlord nor the tenant has any obligation to maintain or repair the premises
during the term of the lease. In order to avoid misunderstandings and potential lawsuits make sure that the landlord’s
responsibilities are clearly spelled out.
In multi-tenant buildings the landlord is typically responsible for maintain and repairing the property, the building and
the common areas. For example, one provision may state that the landlord shall replace all bulbs and tubes in building
standard light fixtures. Another clause would address maintenance and repair of big ticket items like HVAC units and
chillers.
cassidyturley.com 1 9
Broker Reveals All
V. Resource Guide
Finding Properties:
There are a number of resources that commercial real estate agents use to post listings and search available properties. One way to
pull quick data about a market is by accessing one of the following sites. One draw back to these sites is that they typically only cover
major metropolitan markets and properties over a minimum size. If you are looking for properties in “out-state” areas or for a small
property you might be out of luck.
www.loopnet.com
www.xceligent.com
www.costar.com
www.cityfeet.com
cassidyturley.com 2 0
Broker Reveals All
VI. Market Research
Cassidy Turley www.cassidyturley.com
Platsystems www.platresearch.com
Appraisal Data Network www.redi-net.com
Dollars & Cents of Shopping Centers / The SCORE by Urban Land Institute
Minnesota Shopping Center Association www.msca-online.com
International Council of Shopping Centers www.icsc.org
Bureau of Labor Statistics www.bls.gov
Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Data www.deed.state.mn.us
Moody’s Economy.com www.economy.com
Real Capital Analytics www.rcanalytics.com
GVA Marquette Advisors www.gvamarquetteadvisors.com
cassidyturley.com 2 1
cassidyturley.com 2 2
Brian W. Woolsey Vice President
200 South Sixth Street, Suite 1400 | Minneapolis, MN 55402
T 612.347.9308 F 612.347.9389
Brian.Woolsey@cassidyturley.com | cassidyturley.com
Experience
Brian Woolsey works as the leader of the Minneapolis Corporate Services team. In that role he is responsible for facilitating the
delivery of real estate services in the areas of tenant representation, transaction management, portfolio administration, strategic
planning, and project management to multinational and multi-market clients. In the past 18 months, Woolsey has completed
work for several Fortune 500 companies including: St. Jude Medical (314,000 sq ft, tenant representation), U.S. Bank
(multiple site dispositions), RSM McGladrey (130,000 sq ft, tenant representation), and Lawson Software (international tenant
representation).
Areas of Specialization
Corporate Services, Tenant Representation
Clients Served
Industry Presentations
Directors Reveal All: IFMA World Workplace Conference; Atlanta, Georgia; October 28, 2010
Broker Reveals All: IFMA Minneapolis/St. Paul Chapter; Minneapolis, Minnesota, March 3, 2010 (140 attendees)
Broker Reveals All: IFMA Tri-Chapter Symposium; Madison, Wisconsin; May 12, 2010 (50 attendees)
Broker Reveals All: IFMA World Workplace; Orlando, Florida; October 27, 2009 (160 attendees)
Trumpeting the Good News: BOMA Greater Minneapolis Area Chapter, Minneapolis, Minnesota; February 2009 (125 attendees)
Published Articles
“Broker Reveals All”, Facility Management Journal, March/April 2010
“Getting a Grip on Downtown Commuting Expenses”, Minnesota Real Estate Journal, November 2006
“Don’t Let Poor Planning Cost You a Smooth Office Move”, Minnesota Real Estate Journal, December 2005
Corporate Services
Corporate
AmeriPride•	
Home Services of America•	
Lawson Software•	
Nystrom & Associates•	
Old Republic Title•	
St. Jude Medical•	
U.S. Bank•	
Tenant
AgriBank•	
Audio Ruckus Recording•	
Amica•	
Barrington Capital Management•	
BlueZones•	
Charles Schwab•	
Children’s Home Society and•	
Home Services
Cummins•	
Dahlen Berg•	
Executive Suites of Minnesota•	
FICO•	
FVB Energy•	
Hallmark•	
High Bridge Audio•	
Honeywell•	
Inscape Publishing•	
Mattel•	
Marketing Lab•	
Minnesota Business Partnership•	
Minnesota Technology•	
Minnesota Vision Therapy•	
Minute Clinic/CVS•	
Mount & Borresen•	
N’Compass•	
Procter & Gamble•	
ReEntry House•	
RSM McGladrey/H&R Block•
cassidyturley.com 2 3
Industry Awards
2010 IFMA International Emerging Leader of the Year Award
2009 One Man Minneapolis, Semi Finalist
2008 Special Achievement Award, Minneapolis Downtown Council
2007 Rookie of the Year, IFMA Minneapolis/St. Paul Chapter
2007 Dorsey Circle of Excellence, Cassidy Turley
Community Leadership
International Facility Management Association (IFMA), Minneapolis-St. Paul Chapter President 2009-2010, World Workplace
Conference Programs Committee 2010, Featured Speaker 2009, 2010
U.S. Bank Skyway Open, Founder and Chairman, Board Member 2007-2009
AEON, CONNECT Founding Member, Cornerstone Society Member, Building Dreams Committee
National Multiple Sclerosis Society, Minnesota Chapter, Scholarship Committee 2009, MS 150 Cassidy Turley Team Captain 2008, 2009
IVEY Awards, Sponsor 2008-2010, Featured Presenter 2009
United Way, Emerging Leader, 2008-2010
Minneapolis Club, Swim & Fitness Committee, Young Members Committee
Medtronic Twin Cities Marathon, Course Marshall, 2007-2009
Education
University of Minnesota, B.B.A. in Finance - Carlson School of Management
Professional Affiliations
Minnesota Commercial Association of Realtors (MNCAR)
NAIOP Commercial Real Estate Development Association (NAIOP)
Certified Commercial Investment Member (CCIM), Candidate
cassidyturley.com 2 4
cassidyturley.com 2 5
Brian Woolsey
Cassidy Turley
200 South 6th Street
Minneapolis, MN 55402
Tel: 612/347.9308
Fax: 612/347.9389
Contact Information
About Cassidy Turley
Cassidy Turley is one of the nation’s largest commercial real estate service firms in the U.S., with 420 million square
feet of managed space in 57 locations and $15 billion in completed transactions for 2008. Cassidy Turley is a privately
held firm owned by its 360 shareholders created from the August 2008 merger of Colliers Turley Martin Tucker in
the Midwest, Cassidy & Pinkard Colliers in Washington, DC, Colliers ABR in New York City and Colliers Pinkard in
Baltimore, Charlotte and Raleigh, along with the addition of BT Commercial in Northern California (formerly affiliated
with NAI), BRE Commercial in Southern California and Phoenix (both formerly affiliated with Grubb & Ellis) and Colliers
Houston & Co. of New Jersey.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...
Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...
Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...Financial Poise
 
General Liability, Umbrella/Excess Coverage, Commercial Auto-Workers’ Compens...
General Liability, Umbrella/Excess Coverage, Commercial Auto-Workers’ Compens...General Liability, Umbrella/Excess Coverage, Commercial Auto-Workers’ Compens...
General Liability, Umbrella/Excess Coverage, Commercial Auto-Workers’ Compens...Financial Poise
 
Purchase Order Finance (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)
Purchase Order Finance (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)Purchase Order Finance (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)
Purchase Order Finance (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)Financial Poise
 
Is it Hard Money or Hard to Get Money?
Is it Hard Money or Hard to Get Money? Is it Hard Money or Hard to Get Money?
Is it Hard Money or Hard to Get Money? Joseph Andahazy
 
What Kind of Loan? (Series: Borrower or Lender BE)
What Kind of Loan? (Series: Borrower or Lender BE)What Kind of Loan? (Series: Borrower or Lender BE)
What Kind of Loan? (Series: Borrower or Lender BE)Financial Poise
 
An Introduction to a New Yet Old Funding Alternative (Series: Commercial Liti...
An Introduction to a New Yet Old Funding Alternative (Series: Commercial Liti...An Introduction to a New Yet Old Funding Alternative (Series: Commercial Liti...
An Introduction to a New Yet Old Funding Alternative (Series: Commercial Liti...Financial Poise
 
Global custodian--the Architecture of Trust
Global custodian--the Architecture of TrustGlobal custodian--the Architecture of Trust
Global custodian--the Architecture of TrustRobert D. Birnbaum
 
Asset based lending for 2017 and beyond
Asset based lending for 2017 and beyondAsset based lending for 2017 and beyond
Asset based lending for 2017 and beyondWade Henderson
 
Local firms turn to alternative funding
Local firms turn to alternative fundingLocal firms turn to alternative funding
Local firms turn to alternative fundingChristopher Hurn
 
Ten Types of Business Financing You May Not Have Tried
Ten Types of Business Financing You May Not Have TriedTen Types of Business Financing You May Not Have Tried
Ten Types of Business Financing You May Not Have TriedInsideUp
 
Leveraging & Protecting Trade Secrets in the 21st Century (Series: Intellectu...
Leveraging & Protecting Trade Secrets in the 21st Century (Series: Intellectu...Leveraging & Protecting Trade Secrets in the 21st Century (Series: Intellectu...
Leveraging & Protecting Trade Secrets in the 21st Century (Series: Intellectu...Financial Poise
 
Resolving Shareholder Disputes
Resolving Shareholder DisputesResolving Shareholder Disputes
Resolving Shareholder DisputesFinancial Poise
 
Factoring (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)
Factoring (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)Factoring (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)
Factoring (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)Financial Poise
 
Contracts - A Primer 20150421
Contracts - A Primer 20150421Contracts - A Primer 20150421
Contracts - A Primer 20150421James Kosa
 
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...Frank Fletcher
 
RNM Corporate Finance
RNM Corporate FinanceRNM Corporate Finance
RNM Corporate Financekalpeshbohra
 
14 Deadly Conditions of VC Term Sheets
14 Deadly Conditions of VC Term Sheets14 Deadly Conditions of VC Term Sheets
14 Deadly Conditions of VC Term SheetsMark Bakker
 
Contract drafting
Contract draftingContract drafting
Contract draftingNgô Thiên
 
Negotiation in Procurement - IQPC mining procurement and supply forum
Negotiation in Procurement - IQPC mining procurement and supply forumNegotiation in Procurement - IQPC mining procurement and supply forum
Negotiation in Procurement - IQPC mining procurement and supply forumPeter Spence
 

Tendances (20)

Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...
Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...
Help, My Business is In Trouble! (Series: Restructuring, Insolvency & Trouble...
 
General Liability, Umbrella/Excess Coverage, Commercial Auto-Workers’ Compens...
General Liability, Umbrella/Excess Coverage, Commercial Auto-Workers’ Compens...General Liability, Umbrella/Excess Coverage, Commercial Auto-Workers’ Compens...
General Liability, Umbrella/Excess Coverage, Commercial Auto-Workers’ Compens...
 
Purchase Order Finance (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)
Purchase Order Finance (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)Purchase Order Finance (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)
Purchase Order Finance (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)
 
Is it Hard Money or Hard to Get Money?
Is it Hard Money or Hard to Get Money? Is it Hard Money or Hard to Get Money?
Is it Hard Money or Hard to Get Money?
 
What Kind of Loan? (Series: Borrower or Lender BE)
What Kind of Loan? (Series: Borrower or Lender BE)What Kind of Loan? (Series: Borrower or Lender BE)
What Kind of Loan? (Series: Borrower or Lender BE)
 
An Introduction to a New Yet Old Funding Alternative (Series: Commercial Liti...
An Introduction to a New Yet Old Funding Alternative (Series: Commercial Liti...An Introduction to a New Yet Old Funding Alternative (Series: Commercial Liti...
An Introduction to a New Yet Old Funding Alternative (Series: Commercial Liti...
 
Lending Against Stock & Shares 2012
Lending Against Stock & Shares 2012Lending Against Stock & Shares 2012
Lending Against Stock & Shares 2012
 
Global custodian--the Architecture of Trust
Global custodian--the Architecture of TrustGlobal custodian--the Architecture of Trust
Global custodian--the Architecture of Trust
 
Asset based lending for 2017 and beyond
Asset based lending for 2017 and beyondAsset based lending for 2017 and beyond
Asset based lending for 2017 and beyond
 
Local firms turn to alternative funding
Local firms turn to alternative fundingLocal firms turn to alternative funding
Local firms turn to alternative funding
 
Ten Types of Business Financing You May Not Have Tried
Ten Types of Business Financing You May Not Have TriedTen Types of Business Financing You May Not Have Tried
Ten Types of Business Financing You May Not Have Tried
 
Leveraging & Protecting Trade Secrets in the 21st Century (Series: Intellectu...
Leveraging & Protecting Trade Secrets in the 21st Century (Series: Intellectu...Leveraging & Protecting Trade Secrets in the 21st Century (Series: Intellectu...
Leveraging & Protecting Trade Secrets in the 21st Century (Series: Intellectu...
 
Resolving Shareholder Disputes
Resolving Shareholder DisputesResolving Shareholder Disputes
Resolving Shareholder Disputes
 
Factoring (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)
Factoring (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)Factoring (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)
Factoring (BUSINESS BORROWING BASICS 2018)
 
Contracts - A Primer 20150421
Contracts - A Primer 20150421Contracts - A Primer 20150421
Contracts - A Primer 20150421
 
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...
100 Issues to Clarify with your M&A Counsel_Fletcher-Gottfried_ACC_ACC Docket...
 
RNM Corporate Finance
RNM Corporate FinanceRNM Corporate Finance
RNM Corporate Finance
 
14 Deadly Conditions of VC Term Sheets
14 Deadly Conditions of VC Term Sheets14 Deadly Conditions of VC Term Sheets
14 Deadly Conditions of VC Term Sheets
 
Contract drafting
Contract draftingContract drafting
Contract drafting
 
Negotiation in Procurement - IQPC mining procurement and supply forum
Negotiation in Procurement - IQPC mining procurement and supply forumNegotiation in Procurement - IQPC mining procurement and supply forum
Negotiation in Procurement - IQPC mining procurement and supply forum
 

En vedette

7 latest-dot-net-interview-questions
7  latest-dot-net-interview-questions7  latest-dot-net-interview-questions
7 latest-dot-net-interview-questionssadiqkhanpathan
 
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 1
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 1หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 1
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 1arachaporn
 
Antonella volpiprácticapowerpoint
Antonella volpiprácticapowerpointAntonella volpiprácticapowerpoint
Antonella volpiprácticapowerpointUvigo
 
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 4
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 4หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 4
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 4arachaporn
 
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 2
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 2หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 2
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 2arachaporn
 
PASEO brochure_2016
PASEO brochure_2016PASEO brochure_2016
PASEO brochure_2016Brie Kohrt
 

En vedette (9)

7 latest-dot-net-interview-questions
7  latest-dot-net-interview-questions7  latest-dot-net-interview-questions
7 latest-dot-net-interview-questions
 
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 1
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 1หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 1
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 1
 
Ploom
PloomPloom
Ploom
 
Antonella volpiprácticapowerpoint
Antonella volpiprácticapowerpointAntonella volpiprácticapowerpoint
Antonella volpiprácticapowerpoint
 
Technical questions
Technical questionsTechnical questions
Technical questions
 
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 4
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 4หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 4
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 4
 
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 2
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 2หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 2
หน่วยการเรียนรู้ที่ 2
 
Sample quesn
Sample quesnSample quesn
Sample quesn
 
PASEO brochure_2016
PASEO brochure_2016PASEO brochure_2016
PASEO brochure_2016
 

Similaire à Broker Reveals All

Successfully Investing in Multi.pdf
Successfully Investing in Multi.pdfSuccessfully Investing in Multi.pdf
Successfully Investing in Multi.pdfJohnEdward80
 
Colliers Retail Leasing Guide
Colliers Retail Leasing GuideColliers Retail Leasing Guide
Colliers Retail Leasing GuideExecutive Advisor
 
White paper subleasing office space
White paper   subleasing office spaceWhite paper   subleasing office space
White paper subleasing office spaceRobert Manekin
 
Buyers Guide To Contractor Mortgages
Buyers Guide To Contractor MortgagesBuyers Guide To Contractor Mortgages
Buyers Guide To Contractor Mortgagesrichardh11
 
How To Find And Secure Commercial Real Estate 11 4 08
How To Find And Secure Commercial Real Estate 11 4 08How To Find And Secure Commercial Real Estate 11 4 08
How To Find And Secure Commercial Real Estate 11 4 08Bob Canter
 
Guidelines to negotiate better for a commercial property lease
Guidelines to negotiate better for a commercial property leaseGuidelines to negotiate better for a commercial property lease
Guidelines to negotiate better for a commercial property leaseMove in Dubai
 
Why smart homebuyers work with an agent(finsihed)
Why smart homebuyers work with an agent(finsihed)Why smart homebuyers work with an agent(finsihed)
Why smart homebuyers work with an agent(finsihed)RandyBett
 
14 Things Every Investor Should Know About Commercial Real Estate
14 Things Every Investor Should Know About Commercial Real Estate14 Things Every Investor Should Know About Commercial Real Estate
14 Things Every Investor Should Know About Commercial Real EstateKatchen Company
 
Peer-to-Peer Lending is Growing in Popularity with Investors
Peer-to-Peer Lending is Growing in Popularity with InvestorsPeer-to-Peer Lending is Growing in Popularity with Investors
Peer-to-Peer Lending is Growing in Popularity with InvestorsDean Graziosi
 
REAL ESTATE LAW DUMBED DOWN 2022 - Representing the Commercial Tenant
REAL ESTATE LAW DUMBED DOWN 2022 - Representing the Commercial TenantREAL ESTATE LAW DUMBED DOWN 2022 - Representing the Commercial Tenant
REAL ESTATE LAW DUMBED DOWN 2022 - Representing the Commercial TenantFinancial Poise
 
Coaching Don't Sell Yourself Short
Coaching Don't Sell Yourself ShortCoaching Don't Sell Yourself Short
Coaching Don't Sell Yourself ShortMarki Lemons Ryhal
 
PX: certainty in every deal
PX: certainty in every dealPX: certainty in every deal
PX: certainty in every dealDominic Hawes
 
The 10 step checklist for buying an investment property
The 10 step checklist for buying an investment propertyThe 10 step checklist for buying an investment property
The 10 step checklist for buying an investment propertyMichael Putnam
 
PreferredSuppliersAug09CR
PreferredSuppliersAug09CRPreferredSuppliersAug09CR
PreferredSuppliersAug09CRKabir Shaal
 
FCD white paper final
FCD white paper finalFCD white paper final
FCD white paper finalTroy Schwehr
 
Chapter 3How We Get the Work In This Chapter ◆◆ How the .docx
Chapter 3How We Get the Work In This Chapter ◆◆ How the .docxChapter 3How We Get the Work In This Chapter ◆◆ How the .docx
Chapter 3How We Get the Work In This Chapter ◆◆ How the .docxketurahhazelhurst
 
Dlc Homebuyers Guide
Dlc Homebuyers GuideDlc Homebuyers Guide
Dlc Homebuyers Guidemdebokx
 
Thinking of Buying Space for your Practice?
Thinking of Buying Space for your Practice?Thinking of Buying Space for your Practice?
Thinking of Buying Space for your Practice?CBIZ & MHM Phoenix
 

Similaire à Broker Reveals All (20)

Successfully Investing in Multi.pdf
Successfully Investing in Multi.pdfSuccessfully Investing in Multi.pdf
Successfully Investing in Multi.pdf
 
Colliers Retail Leasing Guide
Colliers Retail Leasing GuideColliers Retail Leasing Guide
Colliers Retail Leasing Guide
 
White paper subleasing office space
White paper   subleasing office spaceWhite paper   subleasing office space
White paper subleasing office space
 
Buyers Guide To Contractor Mortgages
Buyers Guide To Contractor MortgagesBuyers Guide To Contractor Mortgages
Buyers Guide To Contractor Mortgages
 
How To Find And Secure Commercial Real Estate 11 4 08
How To Find And Secure Commercial Real Estate 11 4 08How To Find And Secure Commercial Real Estate 11 4 08
How To Find And Secure Commercial Real Estate 11 4 08
 
Guidelines to negotiate better for a commercial property lease
Guidelines to negotiate better for a commercial property leaseGuidelines to negotiate better for a commercial property lease
Guidelines to negotiate better for a commercial property lease
 
Why smart homebuyers work with an agent(finsihed)
Why smart homebuyers work with an agent(finsihed)Why smart homebuyers work with an agent(finsihed)
Why smart homebuyers work with an agent(finsihed)
 
14 Things Every Investor Should Know About Commercial Real Estate
14 Things Every Investor Should Know About Commercial Real Estate14 Things Every Investor Should Know About Commercial Real Estate
14 Things Every Investor Should Know About Commercial Real Estate
 
Peer-to-Peer Lending is Growing in Popularity with Investors
Peer-to-Peer Lending is Growing in Popularity with InvestorsPeer-to-Peer Lending is Growing in Popularity with Investors
Peer-to-Peer Lending is Growing in Popularity with Investors
 
REAL ESTATE LAW DUMBED DOWN 2022 - Representing the Commercial Tenant
REAL ESTATE LAW DUMBED DOWN 2022 - Representing the Commercial TenantREAL ESTATE LAW DUMBED DOWN 2022 - Representing the Commercial Tenant
REAL ESTATE LAW DUMBED DOWN 2022 - Representing the Commercial Tenant
 
Coaching Don't Sell Yourself Short
Coaching Don't Sell Yourself ShortCoaching Don't Sell Yourself Short
Coaching Don't Sell Yourself Short
 
PX: certainty in every deal
PX: certainty in every dealPX: certainty in every deal
PX: certainty in every deal
 
Navigating the Appraisal Process
Navigating the Appraisal ProcessNavigating the Appraisal Process
Navigating the Appraisal Process
 
The 10 step checklist for buying an investment property
The 10 step checklist for buying an investment propertyThe 10 step checklist for buying an investment property
The 10 step checklist for buying an investment property
 
PreferredSuppliersAug09CR
PreferredSuppliersAug09CRPreferredSuppliersAug09CR
PreferredSuppliersAug09CR
 
FCD white paper final
FCD white paper finalFCD white paper final
FCD white paper final
 
Chapter 3How We Get the Work In This Chapter ◆◆ How the .docx
Chapter 3How We Get the Work In This Chapter ◆◆ How the .docxChapter 3How We Get the Work In This Chapter ◆◆ How the .docx
Chapter 3How We Get the Work In This Chapter ◆◆ How the .docx
 
Dlc Homebuyers Guide
Dlc Homebuyers GuideDlc Homebuyers Guide
Dlc Homebuyers Guide
 
How to Finance Your Pretzelmaker Franchise
How to Finance Your Pretzelmaker FranchiseHow to Finance Your Pretzelmaker Franchise
How to Finance Your Pretzelmaker Franchise
 
Thinking of Buying Space for your Practice?
Thinking of Buying Space for your Practice?Thinking of Buying Space for your Practice?
Thinking of Buying Space for your Practice?
 

Broker Reveals All

  • 1. Guide to Understanding Commercial Real Estate for Facility Managers Brian Woolsey Broker Reveals All
  • 2.
  • 3. Contents Seven Habits of Highly Effective BrokersI. Start Early1. Assemble an All-Star Team2. Decide on the Best Transaction3. Have Multiple Options4. Craft a Winning RFP, Solicit Offers and Analyze5. Negotiate like a Pro6. Abstract and Manage the Lease7. Types of TransactionsII. Purchase/Sale1. Lease2. Sublease3. Build to Suit4. Sale-Leaseback5. Appraisal v. BOVIII. Top Ten Lease TermsIV. Termination Option1. Sublease Rights2. Holdover Clause3. Right of First Refusal4. Renewal Option5. Audit Rights6. Financial Guarantees7. Rent Concessions8. Tenant Improvements9. Maintenance & Repairs10. Resource GuideV. Market ResearchVI. Authors’ BiographiesVII. Brian Woolsey1. cassidyturley.com 1
  • 4. Broker Reveals All 1. Start Early Crafting the best real estate solution can take time especially if it is a large project, the lease expiration is not eminent or you are trying to build or buy something. Size matters. The larger the project, the more visible it is within the organization which means there are going to be more people weighing in on each decision which can ultimately slows the process down. Take this into consideration before you decide to delay a project’s start date. Moreover, lease expirations are bad indicators of when to start. If something is happening in your business, do something. Make the decision to talk with your existing landlord, sublease the space, or talk to management about a “Blend and Extend”. Whatever the case may be, take action now. Here are few specific transactions that characteristically take longer to complete then others. If these end up being the best transaction for your organization be sure to begin right away. Buying, Selling, Build to Suit:• These transactions can take longer to complete then leases for several reasons. First, often times there are fewer opportunities to purchase then to lease, so the scarcity of available properties necessitates that in order to see enough properties you have to start early. Additionally, in today’s market there are several properties that are “available” but because of the ownership structure (i.e. foreclosure, special servicer, CMBS ownership) getting the property under contract for a price you feel is fair may take several months, perhaps years. “Blend and Extend” transactions:• Despite the long-term nature of a lease contract, tenants frequently have the ability to realign their lease terms according to their business needs, even when several years remain on the lease. Blend-and-extend transactions allow a tenant to combine costs associated with the existing lease with current market rates over an extended new period. The key is to use the allure of an early renewal to negotiate a new lease. Often the tenant can negotiate concessions such as lower rents and additional capital improvements. Depending on the landlord, a blend-and-extend can either be easy or difficult to achieve. The goal is to get the landlord to understand that given the high vacancy rates in their markets a blend-and-extent transaction can ensure: 1. Their buildings are full of credit-worthy tenants. 2. They don’t incur the risk and costs associated with having to remarket and lease space. Moving Takes Time:• Moving can be a time consuming process. If the best solution is in another building, giving yourself plenty of time to execute the move is essential. Here area some guidelines for moving an office: I. Seven Habits of Highly Effective Brokers cassidyturley.com 2
  • 5. Broker Reveals All 2. Assemble an All-Star Team There is nothing worse then discovering half way through a project that your vendor is either incompetent, not a good personality fit or can not deliver the same value as one of their competitors. Additionally, the typical RFP/interview process can be difficult to judge the team and to know exactly how the vendor will service your account. To use an analogy, how a present is wrapped is often not a good indicator of what the gift. If you can, test your vendor with a small project. Build trust and gage their abilities slowly. Ease into the relationship. Another strategy is to proactively build relationships during down times with potential vendors so you have an arsenal of qualified and trusted advisors that can make you look good and provide exceptional value – when you need them. If you do not have time to qualify a vendor use the following tips as an aid to prequalify the people you hire. Selecting a Broker If your Master Broker is a national/international firm they should be able to find the best talent for the assignment in the market you are working in. Be sure to learn about their process for hiring brokers in Small Town, USA or even in the larger markets. Do they have a “best in class” approach or do they only hire people from within the same firm? Are you comfortable with that? Do they have the flexibility to hire outside the firm if another person/firm would provide a better service? BEWARE: Some firms never hire local representation! Contrary to popular belief, from a licensing standpoint, there is little that differentiates a commercial real estate agent from a residential real estate agent. In fact, in most states the real estate licensing requirements are identical. Over time two professional organizations have emerged to make it easier to differentiate experience and qualifications. Either of the following professional organizations also lists their members so you can locate brokers by geographic area. CCIM (Certified Commercial Investment Member, www.ccim.com) Real estate agents with this designation• have to take a series of four real estate finance courses, pass a final exam and submit a resume and portfolio of representative transactions. Brokers that hold this designation have a good handle on the financial aspects of commercial real estate. SIOR (Society of Industrial and Office Realtors, www.sior.com) Real estate agents with this designation have• demonstrated a mastery of commercial real estate through a combination of tenure in the business and sustained production levels. cassidyturley.com 3
  • 6. Broker Reveals All Selecting a Project Manager Project Managers that specialize in moving can help you avoid costly mistakes along the way. Use them. Leverage you time or your business by utilizing their skills. Some brokers will provide project management service as part of their scope of service? Looked around. You can probably find someone that would offer to either include that service or rebate a percentage of the commission to pay for those services. Selecting an Appraiser There is really only one significant designation for commercial appraisers. MAI (Member of the Appraisal Institute) - An appraiser who has earned the MAI designation is qualified to and experienced in the performance of both residential and commercial properties. Many other appraisers are only qualified for residential property. At one point, lenders were likely to require that an appraisal be done by an MAI certified appraiser, or a member of another trade organization. Certified appraisals can increase the chances of a favorable lending situation, since the lender will feel more comfortable. An MAI certified appraisal offers lenders a reliability that allows them to be confident in their investment. Selecting an Attorney There is only one thing to look for when hiring an attorney - a focus on real estate. Most of the attorneys at the large firms specialize in one aspect of law. Be sure to hire one that is familiar with the customs of the local market as wells as the requirements of your organization. This will save you a lot of time. cassidyturley.com 4 Tip #1 Depending on the size of the transaction, you may be able to find a brokerage team to provide project/construction management as part of their overall service offering. Tip #2 Trim your attorney’s fees in half. A good broker negotiates major business points early in the RFP process leaving the details for the attorneys to work out.
  • 7. Broker Reveals All 3. Decide on the Best Transaction Choose the real estate transaction that best supports the business objectives of the firm. Understand what you need and which transaction is best aligned to meet those needs. See section II. Types of Transactions, for a description of what organizational profiles fit best with each transaction type. Taking the time to decide on the best transaction up front will save you a lot of time down the road. 4. Have Multiple Options In real estate, the deal is never done until, it is done! You want to negotiate at least two deals in parallel all the way to final lease signing. There are several reasons to do this. First, each property provides leverage in your negotiations with the other, including the most powerful negotiations of all, the ability to walk from the deal. Additionally, if something happens at the eleventh hour to the preferred option you have a back up in place to keep the project on schedule. In most markets in the U.S. you can find the information you need to create a competitive bid for your tenancy by consulting online services like LoopNet or CoStar. In the Midwest a good source is Xceligent. Most of these sites have a section that is free (although limited in scope) for corporate users to search alternate properties. Although, online sources are a great starting point, do not limit yourself to what is available online or currently being marketed. Make sure your broker informs the market about your requirement. You will be surprised how many additional opportunities come your way through this approach. For overseas assignments, you can get market reports for most major cities for free from international real estate providers. These reports will have current market rates as well as vacancy levels that will be useful in your negotiation. cassidyturley.com 5
  • 8. Broker Reveals All 5. Craft a Winning RFP, Solicit Offers and Analyze After developing a negotiating strategy and conducting a market survey, in most cases creating and managing a customized Request for Proposal (RFP) process that requests initial proposals from building owners is advisable. The objective in doing this is to: Initiate meaningful negotiations with a clearly defined schedule for responding.• Create level playing field for owner responses.• Provide detailed information that will maximize leverage in renewal negotiations.• Obtain detailed and specific information regarding each proposed facility and its ownership and management.• Perform test-fit space planning, typically at the prospective landlord’s expense.• Obtain preliminary construction pricing, typically by the prospective landlord’s contractor.• Ensure that each facility is capable and caters to your optimal facility preferences.• Here is a sample RFP. Your broker should customize this for you. cassidyturley.com 6
  • 9. Broker Reveals All cassidyturley.com 7 Analyze the Offers: After receiving the proposals, your broker should prepare a financial analysis comparing the annual and total occupancy costs of the most viable potential transactions, the facility objectives and the existing total occupancy cost benchmark. These analyses and comparisons help to ensure that you are maximizing your leverage in the marketplace and driving down occupancy costs. Many brokers also provide customized analysis and reporting. You may want to also analyze the non-economic factors for each property. A “Non-Economic Comparison” organizes and rates the intangible differences between properties. These comparisons help with ranking each property on issues such as ingress, egress, closeness to public transportation, proximity to major freeways/highways, amenities in the building and neighborhood, as well as many other issues that are important to your organization.
  • 10. Broker Reveals All cassidyturley.com 8 6. Negotiate like a Pro “In life (and real estate) you don’t get what you deserve, you get what you negotiate.” Frank Sherwood The three critical elements of a negotiation are time, information and power. A. Time: The Chinese are masters at understanding time. They have the patience and the discipline that few western managers can muster. Ideally, you need 12-24 months to complete a transaction. Negotiations have an ebb and flow of their own and time is needed to leverage the marketplace. Regardless of when you start, most concessions occur at or near the deadline. B. Information: Half of the negotiation issues are handled by preparing properly. A properly crafted RFP and managed process can provide you with a lot of the information about the market that you will need to leverage your desired landlord. C. The Power of Win-Win: Many people think “win – win” means I win twice. You need to understand what a win feels like to the landlord. Know what the landlord wants and know what you can afford to give up. Then be methodical in giving it up slowly. Learn to keep your automatic defenses under control and respond appropriately to issues from the other side. Resources: The one human freedom that cannot be taken from you is the capacity to choose your attitude in any given set of circumstances – to choose one’s own way. (Viktor Frankl, Man’s Search for Meaning) That statement holds the key to many of life’s problems and is very useful in the art of Negotiation. If you are looking for a good resource on negotiating we recommend You Can Negotiate Anything by Herb Cohen. He is widely recognized as an expert in the negotiating field. His sequel Negotiate This is also worth a read.
  • 11. Broker Reveals All 7. Abstract and Manage the Lease What do you do now that your deal is done? One of the easiest ways to prove your worth, over and over to your boss is to come to them proactively with reminders of your fabulously negotiated lease options. To do that you need to have those lease terms easily accessible. If you have fewer then 10 leases in your portfolio we would recommend a lease abstract for each lease and a master spreadsheet with everything rolled up - a master timeline of sorts. Each of the options you have negotiated has a time frame associated with it and the landlord is not going to remind you of when they are. In fact, most of the time they are holding their breath hoping that the date passes without a peep from you. Sometimes just letting your landlord know that you are aware of your options is enough to get them to come to the table to get a better deal. Here is a simple template that you can use to begin abstracting your leases. cassidyturley.com 9 Tip #3 Get lease administration/abstract/audit services for free. Several of the larger brokerage firms will provide lease abstracting, lease administration and lease audit services with an exclusive transaction management agreement. If your portfolio is not large enough to do that, you may be able to negotiate fee rebates to offset the costs for some of these services.
  • 12. Broker Reveals All Lease Maintenance The industry average for incorrect rent invoices is 90%. How are you managing rent disbursements? Now that you’ve just negotiated the best real estate transaction of your career how do you ensure that all of these great economic terms and options are enforced properly? A. Don’t leave it up to your Landlord. B. CAM Reconciliation: how do I know if the CAM reconciliation I got from my Landlord is accurate, what questions should I be asking? C. Real Estate Tax Protest: how do I know if I have a case, if I have several sites how do I prioritize, how do I select and manage the attorney and their fees? “The (real estate) market doesn’t value your (brokerage) services the same way that corporate real estate directors do. The market pays you huge sums of money to negotiate transactions when really that is only part of the equation. We see just as much value in managing the leases that we have in place.” - Minneapolis Fortune 50 Corporate RE Director cassidyturley.com 1 0 Tip #4 If you haven’t done any lease/CAM audits recently, find a commercial real estate company that will do this work on a percent recovery basis. The savings can be enormous and the services are free. Sophisticated companies do these each year.
  • 13. Purchase/Sale For privately held firms a purchase can provide tax advantages and can potentially reduce long term occupancy costs. It may also provide equity appreciation. For publicly held firms acquisitions are usually strategic in nature or support a unique long term capital investment in the Real Estate; i.e. clean room, manufacturing, or other specialized functions where real estate is just a portion of the overall occupancy costs of the location. Generally these are a good fit for companies with the following characteristics: Steady business• Good access to capital,• Return on investment in Real Estate is the same or better then investment in business.• Lease This is a fitting transaction for organizations with the following profile: Little to no up-front capital costs• Need flexibility• Want little to no management responsibilities• Lease might be the only option to get into the type of space your business requires (40th floor of a central Business District,• for example) Timing – shorter time to get in• Capital is made available to invest in business• Sublease This is a fitting transaction for organizations with the following profile: Start up business• Location does not matter• Economics are a major concern• Need furniture, phone system or other office functions• Timing – typically little to no Tenant Improvements (TI) given. The “glove” either fits or it does not. Take the space or not.• Get in quick. May represent the only option to get into a desired building• Depending on the size of the space they are often available on short term basis• Broker Reveals All cassidyturley.com 1 1 II. Types of Transactions
  • 14. Build to Suit This is a fitting transaction for organizations with the following profile: Construction based on operational• issues can create efficiencies The building will reduce occupancy• costs Improve operational productivity• Other alternatives to lease/purchase• do not exist Sale Leaseback This is a structured finance transaction that involves two transactions that happened simultaneously. Typically, it involves the owner occupant of the real estate selling the property to an investor and then leasing the space from the investor. The sale price is based on a number of factors including: rental rate, tenant’s credit rating, length of lease, capitalization rates, availability of funds, and other lease terms. This is a popular transaction when the business is performing extremely well and cash is needed to reinvest in the business. A Sale Leaseback can be helpful in: Maximizing the sale price• Eliminating debt from balance sheet• Possibly shifting management responsibilities• Reducing occupancy costs• Reducing exposure to market fluctuations• Broker Reveals All cassidyturley.com 1 2 Tip #5 Be sure to design the building with the “end game” in mind. Companies that build buildings for their exclusive use have a tendency to over engineer them and this hurts them when they go to exit the property. Think about the properties next life. What simple adjustments can you make to the building’s design so it can be more easily re-purposed when you are done with it?
  • 15. Broker Reveals All cassidyturley.com 1 3 Appraisal: an estimate of property value typically derived by an appraiser who is trained to “look backwards” in time to find prices of “comparable properties” that were sold. Typically, they use three approaches to establish value. Virtually every appraisal needs at least two approaches to serve as a check on one another. The three approaches are: 1. Income Approach 2. Sales Comparison Approach, 3. Cost Approach (Replacement Approach) When to order appraisal: Tax Protest, Financing/Refinancing, Compliance with State and Federal licensure requirements,• Public Agencies responsible to State Auditor, Insurance Companies, Eminent Domain proceedings What to look for: MAI, highest professional designation among commercial appraisers• Time: 3-6 weeks, 8 weeks in some cases• Price: $4,000-$10,000 (ask about differences in scope)• Receivable: 100-150 page document.• Broker Opinion of Value (BOV): an estimate of property value derived by a commercial real estate broker who is typically an expert on the market that the subject property resides and given recent transactions, activity in the market and alternatives can provide a price that the market would pay for the property. Generally, these estimates are based on recent sales, pending sales or investment activity and CAP rate trends. When to order a BOV: Making decision to buy/sell property, lease another property.• Time: 1-6 weeks• Price: free-$3,000• Receivable: 3-15 page document. Typically includes, comments on the market, summary and analysis of the existing• property’s position in the market, comparable sales and an estimate of value. III. Appraisal vs. BOV
  • 16. Broker Reveals All cassidyturley.com 1 4 Termination Option1. This is an agreement by Landlord to provide Tenant the right to terminate the lease early on a predetermined date and for a specified price. It may also be referred to as an Early Termination Option or Cancellation Option. Like many other options (i.e. renewals, expansions) terminations options are not part of the landlord’s boilerplate lease. The only way you will get this into the agreement is if you demand it. Do not get lulled into believing that you cannot get one either. While almost all landlords take an extremely hard line on termination options if they want to gain or retain your tenancy they will accommodate this request. This is an extremely powerful option - perhaps the most powerful. Whether the company is growing extremely fast, contracting, or simply needs the ability to react to a changing market a termination option is a must. A typical termination clause will allow you to cancel the lease with 6 to 12 months written notice and provide a payment for the unamortized transaction costs. These costs include tenant improvement allowances, project management fees, legal fees, free rent and brokerage commissions. The tenant’s objective in this discussion is to reduce the amount of notice required and to reduce the potential penalty fees. Focus on negotiating a lower interest rate, eliminating the penalty and discussing the calculations for what is included as a “transaction cost”. When negotiating a termination option remember that the first priority is simply to have this option. The penalty payment is really a distant second because although it may seem like a large number, when it is compared to the next best option (paying rent for the remainder of the term or subleasing) it often presents a compelling business argument. If your firm is fortunate enough to have to exercise the option to accommodate its’ growth often times the penalty can be off-set by concessions in the marketplace. Sublease Rights2. This is the name given to an arrangement in which the tenant assigns the lease to a third party, thereby making the old tenant the sublandlord (sublessor), and the new tenant the subtenant (sublessee). Subleasing is a challenging process. Make sure you maximize your organization’s ability to get out from a lease liability by eliminating or at least minimizing your landlord’s ability to block the transaction. When negotiation sublease rights focus on: A. Minimizing Landlord’s Time to Approve: Typically a tenant is required to notify the landlord in writing, asking for prior approval of a sublease or an assignment. At a minimum you should add language that says the landlord’s approval shall not be “unreasonably withheld”. However, you should also state a specific time limit by which the landlord must respond. As they say, time kills deals. Don’t give you landlord the opportunity to do this to you. Minimize the time the landlord has to approve your transaction. For example, ask to have a written response within 5 days. If the landlord does not respond within the 5-day period you are free to execute the sublease. B. Minimizing Landlord’s Abilities to Veto your Transaction: The most common reason a landlord vetoes a sublease is they do not like the subtenant’s finances or use. Your argument is this, so long as they can pay the rent and IV. Top Ten Lease Terms
  • 17. Broker Reveals All cassidyturley.com 1 5 your firm is still on the hook, what difference should it make who it is? Have your attorney negotiate language that is air-tight. C. Extending the Subtenant the Same Rights: Additionally, you want to make sure that any options and rights that you have, including rights to expand, renew and extend are able to be transferred to the subtenant. Landlords like to restrict those rights as pertaining only to the original tenant. Failure to clarify the transfer rights can significantly reduce the value of the sublease. Holdover Clause3. The Holdover Clause describes the rent the tenant will pay after the lease expires. A lease without any term adds no value to the building so landlords add Holdover Clauses to their leases with heavy penalties for staying in the space past the lease expiration to create an incentive for tenants to make another long-term commitment to their space Most landlords will typically start out asking for a 200% holdover penalty on the gross rent if the tenant stays beyond the original term. Most brokers settle for a 150% holdover penalty. Perhaps you ask for 6 months beyond the original term at the current rate. You can usually negotiate a more favorable result like 3 months at the current rate and 3 months at 125% if you do it early in the negotiation. Expansion Options - ROFR or ROFO4. Right of First Refusal (ROFR) – This is a contractual right that gives its holder the option to enter a business transaction with the owner of something, according to specified terms, before the owner is entitled to enter into that transaction with a third party. This is especially useful for any contiguous space. This allows the tenant to have the option to expand at favorable terms if the business is doing well. There are several variations of the ROFR. It is rarely part of the landlord’s boilerplate lease so it is up to the tenant or its’ broker to make sure this is part of the negotiations. Your attorney can help you craft the perfect language for this option. In ordinary business how this would play out is the landlord would provide a proposal to a prospective tenant. At such time as the prospective tenant and landlord have reached a preliminary agreement, the landlord would come to the option holder to inform them of the terms of the deal and offer them the option to do the deal. Some things to think about: as a tenant you want as much time as possible to make this decision. As the saying goes, “time kills deals” so even if your decision is not to take the space you still might not want to inform them until the last day that you need to as this time could derail the deal with the prospective tenant. Right of First Offer (ROFO) - Rights of First Offer are pro-tenant expansion rights which obligate the landlord to notify the tenant possessing such rights (i.e., the ROFO tenant) that it desires to lease space subject to the ROFO. Although the landlord may or may not have a specific tenant in mind for the space, a ROFO usually requires the landlord to makes a proposal covering the business terms of a proposed lease for the applicable space. With a ROFO, usually no third party deal provides the business terms for the landlord’s proposal, which is normally the case with a right of first refusal. These are especially useful with contiguous space that is currently occupied. If possible, your goal should be to get a right to lease the space before the existing tenant can renew.
  • 18. Broker Reveals All If the ROFO tenant does not elect to lease the space on the terms offered by the landlord in its notice, the landlord is normally free to try to lease such space to any third party, provided it does so based upon the terms in its notice (or, in some cases, on terms no more favorable than those contained in the landlord’s ROFO proposal). In many cases, the landlord must make a deal for the space involved within a certain period of time, or the ROFO will “revive,” requiring the landlord to offer the space to the ROFO tenant anew before making a third party deal. Option to Renew5. This clause gives a tenant the right to extend the term of the lease, usually for a stated period of time and at a rent amount provided for in the lease. Typically, the tenant has to give 6-12 months notice to landlord to exercise this option. Negotiating a fixed price renewal eliminates the need to enter into a long negotiation 5 years down the road when you may have fewer options in a tight market. A landlord’s typically position will be to offer a renewal at market rates. The “market rate” statement introduces a lot of ambiguity into the process. To increase you flexibility and minimize the number of budget surprises focus on a fixed rate renewal. If you have to go with “market rate” think about adding some language to include market rate concessions (i.e. tenant improvement packages, free rent concessions, brokerage fees). Audit Rights6. Some leases specifically grant tenants the right to review the books and records of the landlord to ensure that the charges billed are correct. Many hours are expended negotiating and drafting operating expense, tax, utility and other similar clauses. Yet, despite all of the “points” that a tenant may win in this negotiation, it frequently gives it all up by agreeing to restrictions on its ability to enforce these provisions. Errors are commonplace. Statistics show that close to 90% of invoices have mistakes, mostly because landlords’ administrative personnel do not tailor the bills to each individually negotiated lease. Any restriction that effectively prevents the review from taking place should be removed from the lease. As you approach your negotiations of this clause focus on the following: Extending Time Limits: Many landlords ask the tenant to provide a detailed written objection to the landlord’s bills within a very short time period (in most cases 30-90 days) failing which the bill is “conclusive and binding” on the tenant, who is “deemed” to have agreed to the bill as rendered. The problem with accepting this limitation is that it is virtually impossible for most tenants to determine whether there is anything wrong with the bill within 90 or even 180 days because making such a determination often requires lots of steps: hiring a lease audit firm to review the lease and the bills; gathering needed internal information; coordinating schedules for an audit; conducting an on-site review of the building’s books and records; completing the analysis; preparing a report; presenting the findings to the landlord. Each step can take weeks or months. What is ironic about these clauses is that without a time limitation in the lease, the tenant’s right to audit is governed by the statute of limitations. This is the time a party to a contract has to enforce its rights. In most states, should a landlord bill a tenant incorrectly (i.e., breach its lease agreement), the tenant would have 4 to 10 years in which to bring an action against the landlord. At a bare minimum, the tenant should have a year or two to review the charges. cassidyturley.com 1 6
  • 19. A. Have the smallest business units sign the lease. * B. Submit your company’s financials. C. Call / meeting for your CFO / banker & landlord. D. Pay a security deposit OR offer to pay a double security deposit. E. Letter of Credit (LOC) with a declining balance. ** F. Personal / Corporate Guarantees *** A few additional notes: *A. Inc. vs. Corp.:Explore different business units that could sign the lease. Most companies have several related companies: INC, LLC, etc. Explore using the lowest or least credit worthy entity first. If that is your first position your next position might be to have a parent company sign the lease. **E. Letter of Credit (LOC) Generally, there is a small fee (similar to a loan origination fee) and annual renewal charges to arranging a LOC but because the money stays with the company you can continue to accrue interest. For businesses that require a high level of working capital this can be difficult. If you go this route it is reasonable to request a LOC with a declining balance. Meaning at the beginning of the lease the LOC might be for 100% of the transaction costs but 25% of the way into the lease it might be for only 75% of the transaction costs, 50% into the lease it might be for 50% and so on. Sometimes the landlord might require the balance to decline using an amortization schedule versus straight-line, like we have used here, which is fairly common as well. ***F. Personal Guarantees. No one likes to give a personal guarantee but sometimes they are the only option if the owner cannot afford to have capital on the sidelines for a LOC. Like the LOC seek a declining balance. Broker Reveals All Eliminating Restrictions on Who Can Do the Audit: Another common restriction is to require the tenant to use a “Big-4” accounting firm, or a firm that is not compensated on a contingency fee basis. The important point here is that a landlord has no legitimate interest in telling a tenant who can work on its behalf. Would it ever tell a tenant not to use a certain attorney or broker? Would the tenant ever think it appropriate to tell the landlord which HVAC contractor to use or how to compensate it? Contingency audit firms exist because tenants don’t have the time to focus on these issues and can’t budget the expense needed to audit leases on an hourly or fixed-fee basis. Thus, the result of this restriction is that although the tenant has permission to verify the charges, in reality it most likely won’t be able to do so. Financial Guarantees7. Guarantees, in their many forms, essentially help provide the landlord with an additional level of comfort that the contract will be fulfilled in the event that tenant is not able make timely payments per its contractual obligation. Remember that you are entering into a financial transaction that may not make the landlord whole until well over half way through your term. So if you feel like there is some hesitation on the part of the owner that is why. Do your part to make them comfortable with their investment. Start by knowing this: the minute you begin talking about Security Deposit you should also be having a conversation about the Letter of Credit, the Personal Guarantee and the concessions. All of these are part of the conversation about financial guarantees. Here are a few ideas of things you can offer, remembering that the only way to minimize the Financial Guarantees is to give the landlord a comfort level about your company’s financial health. Start with the things that don’t cost your organization anything and proceed with some of the others if necessary. cassidyturley.com 1 7
  • 20. Broker Reveals All Rent Concessions8. Concessions a landlord may offer a tenant in order to secure their tenancy. While rental abatement is one form of a concession, there are many others such as: increased tenant improvement allowance, signage, lower than market rental rates and moving allowances. What is “fair” to ask for depends on your market. If you have hired a broker they are the best source of information. A good broker should have “market comps” at their finger tips and be able to send you them. In some markets, it is fairly common to see one or more months of free rent for every year of term leased. Another rent concession is smaller rent bumps. For years they were $0.50/year. In recent months we have seen more $0.25/year bumps or flat rates of 2% and 3% annual increases. We anticipate rates will fall but they generally lag the bad economic news by 12 to 18 months. We are still waiting for further rent face rate concessions. Remember that part of “negotiations” or getting the best deal is vetting the options. In a market like we have today the landlord profile makes a huge difference. In little time, through the RFP process and after a round or two of negotiations, you will know who has the ability to make a deal and who does not. Depending on how many layers of approvals are needed, how much debt is layered on the property, part of your ability to get a great deal will be simply selecting the right landlord. Do not waste your breath explaining what the market is, make a deal with the landlord that has the ability and appetite to make a “market” deal. Let’s take a look at two potential buyer profiles. One is a local owner that has owned the property for the last 15 years. The second is a out of state owner that paid a high price for their property just a few years ago and, oh, by the way, they need to go to Germany to get final approval on the deal. Which one do you think has more of an ability to “meet the market”? Clearly, it is the first owner. First, they read the same daily paper and can see for themselves how bad the market is. Second, because they have owned it for a long time they should have a lower basis in the property and more ability to provide rent concessions and still make their mortgage payments. Tenant Improvements9. Improvements made to the leased premises by or for a tenant. Generally, especially in new space, part of the negotiations will include the improvements to be made in the leased premises by the landlord. The Tenant Improvement Allowance (TI Allowance or Tenant Finish Allowance) defines the fixed amount of money contributed by the landlord toward tenant improvements. The tenant pays any of the costs that exceed this amount. Tenant Improvements could be considered a concession. Generally they are far and away the largest concession. Here are some things to consider or keep in mind when negotiating the TI package. Do your homework, get a space plan, get your changes added and then get construction pricing documents prepared and get pricing so you know that the allowance being provided is enough cover the costs of the construction then make sure the allowance covers your “other” costs. cassidyturley.com 1 8 Tip #7 Request market comps from your broker. This can help to benchmark your negotiations and keep your broker’s feet in the fire.
  • 21. Broker Reveals All Negotiate the ability to use a percentage of the allowance for “other” things. Generally, a Landlord is willing to give you some money for moving, cabling and set up but often times it does not specify that it can be used for a construction manager or project manager. Unless you have staff, make sure that you have at least negotiated the flexibility to fund an outside staff person to coordinate the move, the drawings and the construction process and timeline. Make sure if the construction bid does not include a line item for design fees that you add it back. Negotiate the ability to get a credit for any unused allowance or negotiate the ability to use the total package for an extended period of time. For instance, you might propose that up to 25% of the allowance may be used up to three years following the lease commencement date. Maintenance and Repairs10. This clause is critical. Without it, neither the landlord nor the tenant has any obligation to maintain or repair the premises during the term of the lease. In order to avoid misunderstandings and potential lawsuits make sure that the landlord’s responsibilities are clearly spelled out. In multi-tenant buildings the landlord is typically responsible for maintain and repairing the property, the building and the common areas. For example, one provision may state that the landlord shall replace all bulbs and tubes in building standard light fixtures. Another clause would address maintenance and repair of big ticket items like HVAC units and chillers. cassidyturley.com 1 9
  • 22. Broker Reveals All V. Resource Guide Finding Properties: There are a number of resources that commercial real estate agents use to post listings and search available properties. One way to pull quick data about a market is by accessing one of the following sites. One draw back to these sites is that they typically only cover major metropolitan markets and properties over a minimum size. If you are looking for properties in “out-state” areas or for a small property you might be out of luck. www.loopnet.com www.xceligent.com www.costar.com www.cityfeet.com cassidyturley.com 2 0
  • 23. Broker Reveals All VI. Market Research Cassidy Turley www.cassidyturley.com Platsystems www.platresearch.com Appraisal Data Network www.redi-net.com Dollars & Cents of Shopping Centers / The SCORE by Urban Land Institute Minnesota Shopping Center Association www.msca-online.com International Council of Shopping Centers www.icsc.org Bureau of Labor Statistics www.bls.gov Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Data www.deed.state.mn.us Moody’s Economy.com www.economy.com Real Capital Analytics www.rcanalytics.com GVA Marquette Advisors www.gvamarquetteadvisors.com cassidyturley.com 2 1
  • 24. cassidyturley.com 2 2 Brian W. Woolsey Vice President 200 South Sixth Street, Suite 1400 | Minneapolis, MN 55402 T 612.347.9308 F 612.347.9389 Brian.Woolsey@cassidyturley.com | cassidyturley.com Experience Brian Woolsey works as the leader of the Minneapolis Corporate Services team. In that role he is responsible for facilitating the delivery of real estate services in the areas of tenant representation, transaction management, portfolio administration, strategic planning, and project management to multinational and multi-market clients. In the past 18 months, Woolsey has completed work for several Fortune 500 companies including: St. Jude Medical (314,000 sq ft, tenant representation), U.S. Bank (multiple site dispositions), RSM McGladrey (130,000 sq ft, tenant representation), and Lawson Software (international tenant representation). Areas of Specialization Corporate Services, Tenant Representation Clients Served Industry Presentations Directors Reveal All: IFMA World Workplace Conference; Atlanta, Georgia; October 28, 2010 Broker Reveals All: IFMA Minneapolis/St. Paul Chapter; Minneapolis, Minnesota, March 3, 2010 (140 attendees) Broker Reveals All: IFMA Tri-Chapter Symposium; Madison, Wisconsin; May 12, 2010 (50 attendees) Broker Reveals All: IFMA World Workplace; Orlando, Florida; October 27, 2009 (160 attendees) Trumpeting the Good News: BOMA Greater Minneapolis Area Chapter, Minneapolis, Minnesota; February 2009 (125 attendees) Published Articles “Broker Reveals All”, Facility Management Journal, March/April 2010 “Getting a Grip on Downtown Commuting Expenses”, Minnesota Real Estate Journal, November 2006 “Don’t Let Poor Planning Cost You a Smooth Office Move”, Minnesota Real Estate Journal, December 2005 Corporate Services Corporate AmeriPride• Home Services of America• Lawson Software• Nystrom & Associates• Old Republic Title• St. Jude Medical• U.S. Bank• Tenant AgriBank• Audio Ruckus Recording• Amica• Barrington Capital Management• BlueZones• Charles Schwab• Children’s Home Society and• Home Services Cummins• Dahlen Berg• Executive Suites of Minnesota• FICO• FVB Energy• Hallmark• High Bridge Audio• Honeywell• Inscape Publishing• Mattel• Marketing Lab• Minnesota Business Partnership• Minnesota Technology• Minnesota Vision Therapy• Minute Clinic/CVS• Mount & Borresen• N’Compass• Procter & Gamble• ReEntry House• RSM McGladrey/H&R Block•
  • 25. cassidyturley.com 2 3 Industry Awards 2010 IFMA International Emerging Leader of the Year Award 2009 One Man Minneapolis, Semi Finalist 2008 Special Achievement Award, Minneapolis Downtown Council 2007 Rookie of the Year, IFMA Minneapolis/St. Paul Chapter 2007 Dorsey Circle of Excellence, Cassidy Turley Community Leadership International Facility Management Association (IFMA), Minneapolis-St. Paul Chapter President 2009-2010, World Workplace Conference Programs Committee 2010, Featured Speaker 2009, 2010 U.S. Bank Skyway Open, Founder and Chairman, Board Member 2007-2009 AEON, CONNECT Founding Member, Cornerstone Society Member, Building Dreams Committee National Multiple Sclerosis Society, Minnesota Chapter, Scholarship Committee 2009, MS 150 Cassidy Turley Team Captain 2008, 2009 IVEY Awards, Sponsor 2008-2010, Featured Presenter 2009 United Way, Emerging Leader, 2008-2010 Minneapolis Club, Swim & Fitness Committee, Young Members Committee Medtronic Twin Cities Marathon, Course Marshall, 2007-2009 Education University of Minnesota, B.B.A. in Finance - Carlson School of Management Professional Affiliations Minnesota Commercial Association of Realtors (MNCAR) NAIOP Commercial Real Estate Development Association (NAIOP) Certified Commercial Investment Member (CCIM), Candidate
  • 28. Brian Woolsey Cassidy Turley 200 South 6th Street Minneapolis, MN 55402 Tel: 612/347.9308 Fax: 612/347.9389 Contact Information About Cassidy Turley Cassidy Turley is one of the nation’s largest commercial real estate service firms in the U.S., with 420 million square feet of managed space in 57 locations and $15 billion in completed transactions for 2008. Cassidy Turley is a privately held firm owned by its 360 shareholders created from the August 2008 merger of Colliers Turley Martin Tucker in the Midwest, Cassidy & Pinkard Colliers in Washington, DC, Colliers ABR in New York City and Colliers Pinkard in Baltimore, Charlotte and Raleigh, along with the addition of BT Commercial in Northern California (formerly affiliated with NAI), BRE Commercial in Southern California and Phoenix (both formerly affiliated with Grubb & Ellis) and Colliers Houston & Co. of New Jersey.