Benjamin Franklin's quote about beer suggests it makes people happy. The document discusses the beer industry and its history. It provides an agenda covering topics like the history of beer, emerging and developed markets, production margins, growth opportunities, and M&A activity in the industry. The beer market is large and consolidated, with the top four brewers dominating 50% of global beer sales.
1. Beer Industry
«Beer is living proof that God loves
us and wants us to be happy» -
Benjamin Franklin
Jon Øyvind Bjørnstad
Christian Adeler Normann
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
2. Agenda
• History of Beer..............................................................3 • Emerging Markets......................................................36
• History of beer - last decade................................4 • Asia, Latin America and Eastern EU
• Global Macro Environ Analysis.............................5 • Developed Markets..................................................42
• Global Beer Environ Analysis.................................6 • EU, North America, Asia & Oceania
• How is beer made.......................................................8 • Social & Cultural Issue............................................46
• Overview of the global beer mk.........................9 • Self-Regulation.............................................................47
• Briefly - EU Beverages....................................13 • Risks...................................................................................49
• Briefly - Asian Markets...................................14 • Marketing & Advertising........................................51
• Beer the natural choice..........................................15 • Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR).........56
• Commodity prices & effects on beer • Conclusion.....................................................................57
prices/volumes........................................................16 • The BIG FOUR...........................................................58
• Production Margins..................................................18 • AB InBev.................................................................60
• Porter’s 5 Forces........................................................20 • SAB Miller..............................................................66
• Growth Opportunities...........................................21 • Heineken................................................................72
• M&A..................................................................................24 • Carlsberg................................................................80
• M&A - Our thoughts......................................27 • Ratios................................................................................87
• Investment Recommendation............................89
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
3. History of Beer
• Beer is one of the world’s oldest beverages, recorded back to the 6th millennium
• A very important drink in many cultures
• Family and microbreweries dominated around the world up untill the 20th century
• The hunt for taste versus the hunt for profits
• The development of the beer industry in the
USA
• Today a global and fiercely competitive
business
3
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
4. History of beer – the last decade
• Consolidation trends going even further
• The top 10
and their
market share
• The top 4
today dominating
• Other trends
• Financial
crisis impact
4
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
5. Global Macro Environmental Analysis
• Emerging markets almost 50% of global growth (4.3% Q1)
• Advanced economies weak growth, 2.5% compared to 3% from
last year.
• Developing economies projected a strong growth, but will decline
from 7.5% (2010) to 6.5% (2011)
• IMF figures usually over-
optimistic, so we
estimate slightly weaker
global growths
5
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
6. Global Beer Environmental Analysis
• 2010 - Beer brewers sales increase of 2.6% (2009 - 9.2%).
- Overall beer sales remain flat
- US beer sales down 1% (only growth seen in craft beers)
- US brewers 81% of US market share (imports gradually
increasing share)
- Consumer still remain taste conscious
- Beer industry performance correlated with economy
• Law and ethics:
- Stricter laws = drunk driving and smoking ban
- US Federal beer tax = 40% of retail cost of beer
- $18/gallon barrel (if produce <2million -->
discount $7 for first 60,000barrels).
6
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
7. Global Beer Environmental Analysis
• Diversity & Global Trends:
- 2011 global population 7bn -->
in 2050 - 9.5bn (majority growth
in developing countries)
- Wealth shifting to East&South
countries (Globalization)
- Changes in preferences and attitudes toward beer
consumption
• Technology:
• Advances --> necessary to maintain competitive advantage
& efficiency
7
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
9. Overview of the global beer market
• The beer industry:
– Consumer non-cyclical
• Outputs
– Beer, measured in barrels
• Major trends
– Consolidation
– Shifting in preferences in emerging markets
– Shifting in preferences in developed markets
• Compound annual growth rate of 3,5% globally – two very
different pictures
- Emerging markets showing strong growth with 6.8%
- Developed markets showing a negative growth of 3.4%
9
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
10. Overview of the global beer market
Global per capita consumption heavily skewed towards
developed countries
- Global per capita consumption at 28l a year
- North America 75 l
- Western Europe 66 l
- China 30 l
- Nigeria 10 l
Changes…
- Growth changed in light of crisis
- Who drives the growth?
- Distribution changes
- New segments
- Global beer?
10
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
11. Overview of the global beer market
• Where do we see growth?
– Emerging markets
– China the biggest consumer & producer
• Fastest growing international beer brand:
– Tuborg
– Premium segments rising
– Microbreweries – big business?
11
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
12. Overview of the global beer market
12
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
13. Briefly – European Beverages
• Outperformed index – does that count?
– Outperformed the Morgan Stanley Capital International Europe Index (MSCI) by 16% -
but underperformed the market
– Sector is estimated to trade around 30% premium to the index
– Strong relative performance the last years
– Top-line prospects accelerating
– Earnings growth affected by grain prices
– Decrease in consumption from 374
– Sales in Europe:
• €110 bn
• 2.1 mn jobs
• 17% of production is exported
• 10% of consumption is imports
13
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
14. Briefly – Asian Markets
• Strong growth
• Double-digit for all major Asian emerging markets
• Number one
consumer of beer
• Accounted for 37.7%
of global
consumption in 2010
14
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
15. Beer the natural choice?
• 95% of beer is water
• 3rd most popular drink (after water&tea)
• Easy to make, but standards are high
•One of the healthiest drinks
0 fats & cholesterol
- 94 calories (as in other drinks)
- Contains vitamins (barley when
malted --> vitamin B)
- Fibre, antioxidants and minerals -
silicon
- Low in sodium(salt) and high in
potassium
15
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
16. Commodity prices & effects on beer prices/volumes
YoY % change of main commodities affecting beer companies
130% 125%
- Forecast to raise next decade
108%
(40% by 2020 - global cereal
102%
stock in lowest)
87%
- Guilty:
-Unfavourable weather
65%
-Catastrophe in Japan
-Political uncertainty Africa &
46%
Near East
43%
27%
35% 34% -Strong increase oil prices
22%
-Uncertainty financial mks
9% and global economy
0% CARMI CF&BI Barley Maize (corn) Wheat Aluminium Rice
* CARMI - Commod. Agri.Raw Material Index
* CF&BI - Commod. Food&Beverage Index 16
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
17. Commodity prices & effects on beer prices/volumes
• Corporate responses/strategies:
-Consumer price increases
- need of strong consumer loyalty to ensure sales
-Cost-cutting
- absorbing costs = cost-cutting
-Supply chain M&A and strategic alliances
- fix price purchasing with commodity derivatives
- forward-buying --> to minimize value at risk
17
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
18. Risk & Conclusion
Production Margins
Costs Breakdown Large Brewery
2%
Packaging 4%1%
Tax 8%
Sales&Marketing
28%
Production
Malt 15%
Minor ingredients
Adjunts
Hops
17% 25%
18
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
19. Risk & Conclusion
Production Margins
COGS Margin
Gross Profit Margin
Gross Profit & COGS Margins as % of Revenues
100%
24%
44% 37%
75% 46%
Average 38%
50%
76%
56% 63%
25% 54%
AB InBev Carlsberg Heineken SABMiller
19
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
20. PORTER’s 5 Forces
Force Key Drivers Effect on Industry
Profit
Intensity of Rivalry High concentration; high 0
innovation
Substitutes Growing substitute industry; low -
switching cost
Bargaining power of Small suppliers relative to +
Suppliers brewers
Bargaining power of Consolidation of industry; -
Buyers distribution connected to
retailers
Threat of Entry High capital requirements, +
economies of scale, closed
distribution channels, high
government regulation
Overall market 0
20
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
21. Growth Opportunities
• Expansion into emerging markets (China world’s next big consumer)
100 96.00 40%
Beer Consumption incremental growth (2010-2015F) in mhl
Forecast contribution to industry growth (2011-2015)
80 32%
60 24%
39.7%
40 16%
20.20
17.30
20 12.90 8%
12.20
9.40 8.60
8.3% 6.10 5.30 4.60
7.1% 5.3% 4.3% 3.9% 4.2% 2.5% 2.2% 1.9%
0 0%
China Brazil Russia Vietnam USA Mexico India Thailand Ukraine Nigeria
21 Plato - March 2011
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
22. Growth Opportunities
• Saturation of traditional markets --> growth = strategic M&A
• reorganised industry and strengthened the big players
• Consumer preferring lighter and “healthier” beers --> new trend (40%
of all beer sold)
• Innovative product formats --> new trend = large packages
• Sales = ALL about strong branding & marketing
• Companies to be successful must focus on:
- variety (only 10% men loyal to a specific brand)
- relationships with distributors
- innovative marketing&advertising strategies to build brand
- control and reduce manufacturing costs
22
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
23. Growth Opportunities
• Forces with strong influence over next 3-5 years:
• Globalization
- creates bigger market + additional competition
• Consumer Preferences
- bigger portfolio of products
• Regulations
- consumption heavily regulated
• Sustainability
- programs to reduce, reuse and recycle materials
(environmental friendly)
23
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
24. M&A
• Main aims =
- develop economies of scale Top 10 companies as a % of market share
- increase product portfolio --> 70% 63%
international interest 53%
37%
• High consolidation 35%
- “Big four” - 50% all global 18%
beer consumed
0%
• “Big four” - in size, Boston Beer is 1% 2000 2010
of InBev --> minimal effects if acquired
• “Too big to need financing” to expand.
- Top companies profit increases of 7-12%
- Buying companies “out of their main scope”
24
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
25. M&A
• 2002: SAB PLC combined with Miller Brewing --> SABMiller
- Miller #2 in US and #6 in world
- SAB #4 world and brands in Africa, China and East EU.
- $5.6bn deal ($2bn in assumed debt and $3.6bn in stock --> 64%
stake of Miller - Phillip Morris will keep 36%)
- SABMiller #2 Brewer (Miller needed it to remain competitive)
- Sharper focus on selling beer
- 2004: InBev created from merger Interbrew and AmBev
- Interbrew paid €9.2 for 57% stake in Ambev (stock&debt deal)
- Interbrew was #3 in world by volume and Ambev #5
- Deal was giving InBev approx. 25% of world beer sales
25
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
26. M&A
M&A
• 2008: Anheuser-Busch and InBev merger to create AB InBev
• $52bn deal
• Created Global Beer Leader and Top 5 consumer companies
• Access to new local markets (geo diversity) - leader in top 5
world markets - no geo overlap
• 40% revenues from the US
• Coors acquires Molson in 2004
• Heineken purchased FEMSA (Early 2010)
26
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
27. M&A - Our thoughts
• Craft beer outlook
• Predictions in the future
– China
– Emerging markets
– Developed markets
• M&As
27
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
28. Craft Beer Outlook
• Prohibition killed off diversity, but what now?
• Recent growth in craft beer segment
• The three-tiered future?
– Macro
– Regional
– Micro
28
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
29. Predictions
• China
– Slowdown in consolidation
• Top 3 brands market share of 52.5%
• Over 80 M&As in the last decade
• Fewer good acquisition targets
• Opening new plants
instead of acquiring
businesses
29
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
30. Predictions
• Emerging markets
– Same as China in other markets?
– “hotshots” slowing down M&A pace
– M&A booms in “younger” emerging markets like a lot
of the African countries
• Developed markets
– Market division settled, best targets acquired already
– Acquiring craft brewers
• Pros
• Cons
30
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
31. M&A Predictions
• Foster’s
– SABMiller’s June 21st bid on Foster’s Group Limited
– Bid valued Fosters at USD 10 billion
– Market reactions to the bid and rejection
– What happens now?
• Foster’s is an attractive target
• Could trade at values of
5.40-50 per share, pricing
it as high as USD 11 billion.
31
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
32. M&A Predictions
• Potential buyer: Asahi
– Leading brewer and soft-drink company
out of Tokyo, Japan
– 40% of Japanese beer market
– Stake in Foster’s Group already, acquired in 1990
– Cadbury Schweppes Australia acquired in 2009
– Moving into new markets
– Tsingtao stake acquired from ABInBev in 2009
– Is looking to expand in Asia and Oceania, an acquisition
of Foster’s would place them as a leading player in the
area.
32
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
33. M&A Predictions
• Megabrew – potential merger between ABInBev and SABMiller
– A merger would have positive and negative sides
• Pros: amazing growth, not much geographic overlap, one corporate HQ
• Cons: culture clash, US beer category, changes causing divesting, cultural risk
– Numbers don’t add up:
• High leverage deal meeting currency issues
• A huge amount of equity required
• Net-net it is harder to pull off than BUD because: 1) SAB offers lower synergies,
2) SAB’s emerging market cash flow makes it harder to lever, 3) SAB is on a
slightly higher multiple than BUD and 4) the execution risks are much higher.
• Discussions of a merger are not new, there were meetings in 2007, but InBev
were unwilling to pay a significant premium.
– Conclusion: We don’t see the benefits of a merger outweighing the
downsides.
33
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
34. M&A Predictions
• Molson Coors moving into India
– Joint Venture with Cobra India
– “beginning of a long-term commitment”
– Follows a 2009 deal between Molson Coors UK
and Cobra Beer covering sales outside south Asia.
34
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
35. M&A Predictions
• Opportunities in Africa
– Plenty of room for growth
– Heineken recently bought into the Ethiopian
market
– Nigeria and increased minimum wage
– SABMiller entering discount beer market
35
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
36. Emerging Markets
• Potential emerging markets
– Asia
– Latin-America
– Africa
– Eastern Europe
• Main trends:
– Rising disposable incomes
– Economic growth
– ”Westernizing”
• Areas and countries in detail:
36
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
37. Asia
ASIA
• Steady economic growth for some time
• China the main contributor
• More developed countries stalling or declining
• Two promising markets:
– China
– India
37
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
38. Latin-America
LATIN AMERICA
• In the long run we see tax benefits in markets like
Panama, Peru and Colombia
• Markets are concentrated with high entry-barriers
• Especially premium segments look promising
• Two promising markets:
– Mexico
– Brazil
38
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
39. Africa
AFRICA
• Mostly lager is produced here
• Re-usage of bottles delivered in store
• A lot of people, but a lot of uncertainty
• Some promising countries:
– South Africa
– Nigeria
– Ethiopia
39
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
40. Ethiopia - Growth Opportunity
• Beer consumption rising, and it’s still extremely low at 4 l per
capita a year, and much lower than its neighbouring countries
• Economic progress in the country
• Double digit growth rates projected and experienced in the
recent years
• Heineken and BGI Ethiopia
• Risks
– famine
40
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
41. Eastern Europe
EASTERN EUROPE
• Growth is expected to continue
• Driven by Russia
• Some growth in developed markets as well
• Interesting markets:
– Czech Republic
– Russia
41
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
42. Developed MARKETS
DEVELOPED markets
• Trends:
– Declining consumption
– Increased health awareness
• Changes in:
– Tastes
– Alcoholic beverages
– Drinking patterns
42
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
43. Europe
EUROPE
• UK – big business, but a declining
consumption trend
• Netherlands – Heineken
domination
• France – wine… and beer?
• Germany – beer a major
part of the culture.
• Poland – a big consumer
43
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
44. North America
NORTH AMERICA
• USA
– Few players dominate
– Three-tier system
• Canada
– International influence
– Microbrewers
44
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
45. Asia & OCEANIA
ASIA & Oceania
• Japan
– New products with lower tax
• South Korea
– High entry barriers
– Microbreweries
• Australia
– High consumption per capita
– Dominated by Foster’s
45
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
46. Social and Cultural Issues
Social & Cultural Issues
• History of opposition
– Alcohol always had enemies
• Sin taxes
– Affecting the end-customer
– Seen as a regressive form of taxation
• Religion
– Islam the only one with a non-alcohol policy
– Some extremist churches
• Science and medicine
– Long term use linked to cancer, heart disease, diabetes and liver failure
46
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
47. Self-regulation
Self-Regulation
• A code of practice or
set of guiding principles
governing the content
of advertisements.
• A process for the
establishment, review,
and application of the
code or principles.
• Why do this?
• Is it working?
47
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
48. Self-Regulationexamples..
Self-regulation Examples
• Australia
– Minimal legislation and requirements, self-regulatory
code organized in 1998
• Netherlands
– Some legislation, and Code of Beverages
• UK
– International Code of advertising
• South Africa
– Self-regulatory code set up in 1989 by ARA
48
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
49. RISKS
Risks
• Beer excise duty:
• Highly taxable product --> increase in tax
= increase sale price
• price-sensitive consumption
• Russia 200% increase implemented in 2010 --> increase prices
--> russian mk share under pressure
• Legal/Regulatory restrictions & changes:
• Several mks have restrictions on sales, availability and
advertising regulation
• Pressure from authorities&stakeholders to reduce alcohol
consumption --> impacting consumer behavior
• Economic environment:
• Global recession with weak GDP growth projected for 2011
• Poor/raising unemployment --> weak consumer demand
49
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
50. RISKS
Risks
• Commodity price volatility
• Input costs skyrocketing --> sales prices increasing
• Change in consumer preferences:
• Strong portfolios to meet consumer needs
• Critical to anticipate quickly to market needs
• Management capability impairment
• “Unstable” emerging markets
• Customary risk
• Political, economic and regulatory uncertainty
• Competition
•“eat or be eaten”
50
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
51. MARKETING & ADVERTISING
MARKETING & ADVERTISING
• Compete on POSITIONING: target, image, communication
• Marketing-driven business --> adds not necessarily to increase demand,
but to increase brand awareness --> develop brand image!
Sales & Mk Expenses (in Billion $) 2009 - 2010 Beer Industry Advertising Expenditures ($ in millions)
1170 1175 1175
5 1200
4.9 1083
3.75 1090 1027
985 979
2009 980 910
2.5 4.7 2010
2.3 870 800
1.25
2.0 764
1.7 2.1 2.1
1.8 760
0
InBev Carlsberg Heineken SABMiller 650
1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Source: Company Annual Reports
• Successful brands --> balance of “push” and “pull” strategies
• “push” - relationships with distributor - place brand on the shelf
• “pull” - marketing directly to consumer
51
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
52. MARKETING & ADVERTISING
MARKETING & ADVERTISING
• “Fight for space” (shelf placement):
• “Visual equity” is more important than “memory equity”
• product must be in consumer’s face - literally!!
• Shelf placement: (picture)
“TOP AREAS”:
- +20% # people seeing you & probability
of been chosen
“GOLDEN ZONE”:
- # “Facings”/chances increased
--> chances being bought = +28%
--> chances low mk share brands = 67%
• Strategies to claim space:
• multiple packaging --> billboard effect
• maximising types of beers to sell 52
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
53. MARKETING & ADVERTISING
MARKETING & ADVERTISING
• Advertising & marketing code: (follow certain ethical standards)
• Portray beer in a socially responsible way
• Communicating solely to adult consumers of legal drinking age
• 70% audience --> to be over drinking age
• Should not undervalue other competing beers
• only be factual, no interpretations
• Advertised at college campuses or events only when permitted
• Applied also to “product placement” of beer
• not portray sexually explicit activity as result of
consuming beer
• no graphic nudity
53
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
54. MARKETING & ADVERTISING
MARKETING & ADVERTISING
• “Basic” steps for building successful beer brand:
1. Identify target group
2. Brand message: clear & appealing
3. Creating brand image
4. Consistent quality
5. Brand recognition--> get share shelf for their products
6. Consumer ownership --> distinctive atmosphere
7. Packaging: compelling, interesting and comfortable
54
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
55. MARKETING & ADVERTISING
MARKETING & ADVERTISING
• Social Media Marketing (SMM):
• Rise of social networks
--> changed way people interact with brands
• “one-one” interaction with customers - presence on the same
playing field
• specific campaigns & promotions
• closely monitor customers and instant feedback
• SMM -> all in the same battlefield --> the one with most
strategical power --> will survive the battle
55
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
56. Corporate Social Responsibility
Corporate Social Responsability
• Promote responsibility of the brand
• Sustainable priorities:
• Discourage irresponsible drinking
• Making more beer using less water
• Reducing energy and carbon footprint
• Packaging reuse and recycling
• Working towards zero-waste operations
• Encouraging enterprise development in value chains
• Benefiting communities
• Respecting human rights
• Transparency and ethics
56
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
57. “Conclusion”
Conclusion
• Seek growth in Emerging markets --> critical role in global beer
• Rise in purchasing power of middle class and investment in
food&drink supply chain infrastructure
• Developed markets:
• Reinvest themselves, attracting younger generations
• Strong branding & marketing with diverse portfolio
• Areas of concern for success in the industry:
• Unpredictable commodity prices
• Changing tastes
• Consolidation (M&A in emerging mks)
• Political, Legal, Regulatory issues, effectively managing needs of
governments
• Technological dimension
57
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
58. The BIG FOUR!
“Beer is a wholesome liquor....it abounds with nourishment.”
Dr. Benjamin Rush, American physician
58
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
59. Regional Breakdown Comparison
Asia Pacific
13%
C&E EU Western EU Americas
North America 31% 29%
7%
Western EU 35%
8%
C&E EU Africa
Latin America 14% 21%
37% Asia Pacific
5%
South Africa Asia
22% Latin America
31% 16%
Asia North&West EU
2%Africa 43%
12% Eastern EU
EU
North America 41%
14% 19%
59
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
61. • The leading global brewer
• Top-5 consumer products
• 114 000 employees worldwide
• Operations in 23 countries
• Strives to be the “best beer company in the world”
• 36.3 billion USD in revenue in 2010
• Number one or two position in 19 countries
• Committed to responsible drinking with programs operating in each
market
• Committed to achieving 99% recycle & reuse rate by 2012
61
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
62. Highlights
Highlights
• Q1 2011 results broadly in line with consensus
• Price-mix better than expected at 6.1%
• Results in North America – Slow but steady improvement
• Brazil was weak as expected – margins expanded on the back of strong
gross profit and cost savings
62
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
63. Regional Breakdown
• North America
– Continued suffering from unemployment
– Top-line weakness offset by organic expansion and reduciton
in barley costs
• Latin America North
– New brewery in Brazil online in Q3 2011 Asia Pacific
– Volume growth in Brazil slowing down due to 13%
• Heavy rain & flooding C&E EU
• Deliberate volume/ share management 7% North America
• Modest slowdown in GDP growth 35%
• General inflation nearing minimum wage increases Western EU
8%
• Latin America South
– Volumes showing continued sequential improvement
Latin America
driven by beer 37%
– Revenue growth remained strong
63
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
64. Regional Breakdown
• Western Europe
– Organic trends remain weak
– Strong bottom-line margin expansion
– Minor growth expected for 2011
• Central & Eastern Europe
– Modest growth partly offsetting the decline last year
– Price-mix up 16.5%
– Projected growth of around 9% in 2011
• Asia
– Trends driven by BUD’s Chinese operation
– Almost 10% organic revenue growth
– Expected revenue growth (Bern) of around 10% along with margin expansion of about
110 bps
64
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
65. RiskRisks & Conclusion
& Conclusions
• Risks
– QE in the US leading to high inflation and dollar value falling
– Intensification of competition in the US and Brazilian markets
– Disposal process failing
– FX risks
– ZBB-cost reduction program failing to meet targets
– Global crisis in oil supply could put pressure on commodities
• Conclusion
– Underperformed peers and MSCI Europe for the first months of 2011
– Closed the gap in April
– Management has a great track record
– Currently at a 4% premium to peers, we expect 10%
– Rating: OUTPERFORM
65
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
67. SABMiller
• Basic Facts:
• Covers 75 countries on 6 continents South Africa
22% Latin America
31%
Asia
• Employs over 70,000 people 2%
Africa
12%
North America EU
• Well balanced portfolio (developed and 14% 19%
emerging mks)
• Over 200 different brands
• International premium brands: Pilsner
Urquell, Peroni, Miller and Grolsch
• 20% market share in China
67
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
68. SABMiller
Highlights
• 6% EBITA growth
• Strong FCF generation (reduction 200m in CapEx)
• +80% EBITA coming from high growth emerging markets
(plus MillerCoors synergies)
• Positive growth prospects in emerging markets (Asia & Africa)
• Strong momentum into F12 - improvement top-line growth as
Colombia recovers from last years tax hike, and C&E Euro beer
markets pick up
•Hedged 50% their input costs.
68
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
69. SABMiller
Regional Breakdown
• Latin America:
• 2% revenue growth, with flat organic volume
( Colombia 50% of region - impacted by VAT increase)
• North America
• Flat organic revenue growth (declining volumes)
• Impact of economy uncertainty and unemployment
• Benefiting from MillerCoors strong synergies/cost
savings
• Central&Eastern Europe:
• Flat sales growth
• Challenging trading conditions
69
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
70. SABMiller
Regional Breakdown
• Africa:
• Strong top-line and improvement in capacity utilisation
• 24% volume growth
• Asia:
• Very strong top-line performance
• 14% org revenue growth (drivers China & India)
• Increased marketing support behind key brands
• South Africa:
• 8% revenue growth
• Market share stabilised (after loosing Amstel brand)
70
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
71. SABMiller
Risks
• The south-african governm. radically changes duty regime
• A global crisis in the supply of oil could further put pressure on
commodities in general and alu, energy & glass in particular.
• Significant FX movements
• Intensification of market battles with AmBev in
South American
• Further consumption slowdown in major
economies such as South Africa, Colombia,
Peru or Polan.
71
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
73. Heineken
• Owns over 125 breweries in more than 70 countries
• 3rd largest brewer in the world
• Employs approx. 54.000 people
• More than 170 international brands (including Cruzcampo, Tiger
Beer, Żywiec, Starobrno, Zagorka, Birra Moretti, Ochota,
Murphy’s, Star and of course Heineken Pilsener).
73
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
74. Heineken
Highlights
• Last 10 years it has gone from trading at a 130% premium to
peers in 2000 to a current 10% discount (over-exposure to low
growth W Europe and over reliance in the US market)
• Acquisition of FEMSA --> exposure to high-growth EM
(Mexico&Brazil, but well below SABMiller)
• Development of premium segment --> top-line
growth
• Improving margins (cost saving & synergies
from FEMSA deal)
74
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
75. Heineken
Regional Breakdown
• Western EU
• Challenging trading conditions
(leader in UK, Netherlands, co-leader but loosing
territory in Spain)
• Offset by cost savings
• Largest revenue & profit pool (42% & 31%) Western EU Americas
31% 29%
• C&E EU
• 20% & 14% in volume and profit C&E EU Africa
• Improvement primarily on the back of 14%
Asia Pacific
21%
economic recovery 5%
• Russia stabile after 27% drop in 2010 (market 6%
down)
• 33% market share in Romania&Poland (attractive mks)
75
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
76. Heineken
Regional Breakdown
• Americas
• 29% of groups profits
• FEMSA deal improves prospects (45% of Mexican
market)
• Opportunity to develop further the premium segment
in Mexico&Brazil
•Africa & Middle east:
• 21% of group profits
• Strong growth (notable Nigeria, Heineken #1 leader)
• Strong driver for profits and huge potential
consumption increase
• Asia Pacific: (operating mainly through JV’s) - 5% of profits
• Favorable GDP growth --> earnings growth
76
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
77. Heineken
Relevant Info.:
• FEMSA acquisition (2,5bn) changed growth profile and TCM
programme (total cost management) gives triumph of hope.
• YTD in line with market and outperforming peers (2010 -
outperformed MSCI EU by 4% & underperf. peers by 6%)
• Px way below 90s levels (driven by high US growth)
• 230% premium to peers in 2000 to 10% discount today
• Paying expensive prices for acquisitions
• Solid export figures to the USA
77
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
78. Heineken
Near Future
• Expect moderate pressure on input costs
• Significantly improved FCF generation
• approx. 3x in the last 2-3 years
• 5 year profit expectations
• Strong deliverance mainly from FEMSA synergies and
ongoing savings from CM
• All regions to deliver strong growth
• Lower costs
78
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
79. Risks
• Timing and execution of cost saving programme slower than expected
• Breakdown in three-tier distribution system in the USA would expose
producers of beverage alcohol to greater margin pressure from retailers
• Significant FX movement such as a decline in the dollar
• Global crisis in supply of oil could put further upward pressure on
commodities in general and especially aluminum, glass & energy
• Price of oil weakening significantly could put Nigerian and Russian under
pressure and be significant drag on group profits
79
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
81. • Founded in 1847 in Denmark, outside Copenhagen
• World’s 4th largest brewery group
• Employing 41 000 people
• Characterized by great diversity in:
– Brands
– Markets
– Cultures
• Ambition of becoming the fastest growing global beer company
• Main regions of operation
– Eastern Europe
– Northern & Western Europe
– Asia
81
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
82. Highlights
• 2011 a rollercoaster in terms of quarters, we expect 2012 to be more
even
• 2010 performance a bit light
• Net profit (pre-exceptionals) in-line with expectations
• Guidance: 2-4% market volume growth in Russia.
– Overall a high single-digit percentage growth in operating profit in 2011
• Adjusting EPS estimates to account for weaker than expected recovery
from increased input costs in Eastern Europe
82
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
83. Guidance & Outlook
• Operating margin targets
– Northern & Western Europe at 15-17%
– Eastern Europe at 26-29%
– Asia at 15-20%
– Carlsberg Group at around 20%
83
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
84. Regional Breakdown
• Eastern Europe
– Organic volumes declined by 9%,
but revenue increased by 11% organically
– Negative price mix of 2% as a response to the excise hike
– Operating margins contracted 1280 bps in Q4, a total of
80bps contraction in 2010
– Net volume expected to grow 5% in 2010
– Expect significant price increase to recover from the 1
extra RUB in excise and higher input costs
– Positive results from Ukraine Asia
16%
North&West EU
43%
Eastern EU
41%
84
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
85. Regional Breakdown
• Northern& Western Europe
– Weak top-line offset by strong margin expansion
– Volumes flat during 2010
– Significant improvement in UK
– Expect a 1% decrease in volume in 2011
• Asia
– Strong growth in volume 14% and revenue 17%
– Contraction in Q4 2010
– Margin expansion of 280bps in FY10 vs FY09
– Expected regional strength to continue with 10% organic
volume growth and 13% organic revenue growth
85
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
86. RisksRisk & Conclusion
& Conclusion
• Upside risks
– Geopolitical and macroeconomic factors causing FX appreciation
– Faster West European recovery
– Exceeding cost-cutting expectations in N&W Europe
– Inflation decreasing
– Recent surge in raw material prices quick return
• Downside risks
– Russian government putting pressure on alcohol consumption
– Geopolitical and macroeconomic factors causing FX depreciation
– Inflation increasing
– Prolonged recession in Western Europe
– Altering strategy for group, reducing value
– Slips in management’s ability to deliver
• Conclusion
– Share price rallied in 2010, but has halted as input cost headwinds were announced
– Believe that it should be traded at a discount to its peers
86
Tuesday, 9 August 2011
89. Investment& Conclusion
Risk Recommendation!
- Solid Ratios
- Regional breakdown
- Strong position in emerging
markets (Americas & Africa)
Western EU Americas
31% 29%
- Share price with room to grow
- Femsa acquisition synergies
- All areas to deliver strong growth C&E EU Africa
14% 21%
Asia Pacific
5%
89
Tuesday, 9 August 2011