SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  12
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062
Financial Services
B2B payments: Cards
Future of Canadian Payments
November 3, 2010
CONFIDENTIAL | www.oliverwyman.com
1NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
B2B payments have a different economic model than B2C or C2B
Segments
Products
Processors
Networks/
Clearinghouses
Competition and
value capture
fundamentals
WholesaleConsumer/SB
Consumers/SB payments attributes
! Spread revenues dominate
fee revenues
! Payments are a product feature,
not the product itself
! Limited price and functionality
competition
! Distribution is the key to share
Wholesale payments attributes
! Fee revenues dominate
! Payments are the product
! Price competition is severe
! Processing scale and innovation are key
Alternative Payments
Mobile eWallets (PayPal) Others
Chequing
accounts
Credit Card
Cash
Management
Merchant
Acquiring
Commercial
Cards
FDC, TSYS –
MasterCard, VisaCPA, Interac
ACSS
(ACH)
Closed
Loops
(Amex) LVTS
(RGTS)
Symcor
Check-
free
Pre-
Paid
Mass
market
Premium
Small
business
Domestic
corporates
Multi-
national
FIs
2NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
Within North America, banks lost control over the last 30 years
2010 North American Card Payments Market
Total equity valuation: $270-$310 BN (estimated)
Total post-tax earnings: $21 BN (estimated)
Wholly bank-owned
Partially bank-owned
(e.g. equity stake)
Network switching Merchant acquiringIssuing
Processing
$56 BN equity value
9-14x P/E multiple
$70-$90 BN market cap
7-9x P/E multiple
100%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%20% 40% 60% 80%
$50-$65 BN
market cap
25-30x P/E
multiple
$80-$95 BN market cap
16-18x P/E multiple
First Data
Merchant Alliances
Note: Assumes 25% reduction from peak credit card issuing profit and no debit profits; PE multiple ranges are illustrative and drawn from publicly traded “pure plays”
3NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
Acquiring
Across the developed world, competitive forces are similar
Dynamics Comments
Slowing transaction growth ! Cash & checks displaced
! “Cardable” white space harder to find
Payments mix shift
! Credit-to-debit
! Standard to premium
! Higher scheme fees
! Volumes shifting to less profitable txs,
– Less impact in large IC+ merchants
– High impact profitable SME segment
! In Canada, credit is outgrowing debit
Regulatory reform ! Regulators pushing for greater
transparency and lower costs
Consolidation for scale ! Large merchants lead pricing pressure
Globalization ! Encroachment of US acquirers
! New class of competitor (the PSP) in
cross-border eCommerce
4NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
Acquiring
National Merchants provide scale; SME merchants generate profits
Large merchants SME
Average margin
10-15bp
(IC+)
65-70bp
(% of face value)
Credit GDV (C$ BN) $100-120 $140-160
Share of revenue 10-15% 85-90%
Canadian market bifurcation
(Similar to all other developed markets)
5NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
0% 5% 10% 15% 20%
First Data + alliances
Paymentech
Fifth Third + RBS
Global Payments
Elavon
Moneris
Heartland
TSYS
TD
Transfirst
All other
US Canada
North American merchant acquiring market structure
% of gross sales volume, estimated (2009)
Dominate high-
volume categories
Serve select large
merchant niches
Focus
on SME
Acquiring
Large merchants drive consolidation at the top of the market
45%
Some of the largest merchants are beginning to seek out
cross-border, North American solutions
6NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
Commercial Cards
Distinguished from SME by importance of MIS and absence of revolve
Corporate
Cards (T&E)
Procurement
Cards
Fleet
Cards
Small Business
Cards
Purpose Fund employee
travel
Purchase small
ticket items
Purchase gas
and repairs
Source of working
capital lending to SMEs
and to expedite
purchasing
Value
proposition
! Manage travel costs
! Fund employee travel
! Automate low-value
purchasing
! Supplier discounts
! Supplier discounts
! Fraud control
! Fleet management
! Access to credit
! Automate purchasing
Unique
features
! Reporting
! No preset
spending limit
! Level three reporting
! Discount capture
! Odometer capture
! Fraud reporting
! Discount capture
! NA
Market
structure
! American Express dominates
! Some major banks issue Visa/MC
versions, but have low share
! Closed loops lead,
e.g. Wright Express,
Voyager
! Gas company
proprietary cards
! Visa/MC universal
products
! American Express
is material
! Banks are major
players
Revenue
model
! Interchange
! Fees
! Interest income
! Interchange fees
! Other fee income
7NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
0
50
100
150
200
250
2006 2007 2008 2009
Spendvolume($BN)
12.6
12.7
12.8
12.9
13.0
13.1
13.2
13.3
RealGDP($TN)
American Express Visa/Mastercard Real GDP ($TN)
Commercial cards – Corporate cards
Slow growth (1.5% CAGR), dominated by American Express (~80% share)
Corporate card spend
AXP share 82% 81% 85% 81%
Source: Nilson report, Bureau of Economic Analysis, Oliver Wyman analysis
Note: Assumes 90/10 split on American Express corporate card volume between T&E and procurement cards
8NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
0
1
2
3
4
5
2006 2007 2008 2009
Spendvolume($BN)
$0.0
$0.5
$1.0
$1.5
$2.0
$2.5
$3.0
$3.5
$4.0
$4.5
$5.0
Fleet card spend Weighted average gas price
Commercial cards – Fleet cards
Slow growth, spend fluctuates with the price of gas
Source: Nilson report, Energy Information Administration, Oliver Wyman analysis
9NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
75
80
85
90
95
100
105
2006 2007 2008 2009
Spendvolume($BN)
Commercial cards – Procurement cards (P-cards)
A small share of overall B2B spend; American Express is a leader
… but share is low
Source: Nilson report, The Clearing House/Federal Reserve report, Oliver Wyman analysis
Note: Assumes 90/10 split on American Express corporate card volume between T&E and procurement cards
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Check Wire ACH Payment
card
%ofB2Btransactions
Spend is growing…
Note: this is share of
transactions, share
of spend is very low
10NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
P-cards cards face several obstacles to greater adoption
Obstacle Comments
Process Change
(Buyers & suppliers)
Integration to ERP systems via APIs (e.g. AXP/SAP)
Security
e.g. PCI compliance
Software as a service (SAAS) solutions
Costs
(Interchange & network fees)
1.80% + .10 for standard Level III tx
0.95-1.30% + $35-$40 for large ticket
Applicability
(Expanding internal adoption)
Increasing “cardable” spend (~40% of small
transactions on P-cards in adopting companies)
11NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com
Summary
Cards play a role in B2B, but face obstacles to greater adoption
! Much of the value in B2B cards is captured outside the traditional
banking system
! Merchant acquiring is the biggest segment, but faces slowing
growth, increasing globalization, and continuous pricing pressure
! Commercial cards target important niches, but only P-cards still
have substantial headroom for growth
– Corporate cards are almost fully adopted and usage fluctuates
with the economy
– Fleet cards are heavily adopted by target companies, but
revenues fluctuate with the price of gas
– P-cards are still growing, but face key obstacles to adoption
beyond low-ticket categories

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Professional Expertise in Value Creation
Professional Expertise in Value CreationProfessional Expertise in Value Creation
Professional Expertise in Value Creationjohanw
 
Etude PwC Loan Portfolio Market Survey 2015
Etude PwC   Loan Portfolio Market Survey 2015Etude PwC   Loan Portfolio Market Survey 2015
Etude PwC Loan Portfolio Market Survey 2015PwC France
 
Deloitte Private Debt Conference Luxembourg | 17 November 2015
Deloitte Private Debt Conference Luxembourg | 17 November 2015Deloitte Private Debt Conference Luxembourg | 17 November 2015
Deloitte Private Debt Conference Luxembourg | 17 November 2015Thorsten Lederer 托尔斯滕
 
Deloitte UK & European Restructuring Market Outlook 2015
Deloitte UK & European Restructuring Market Outlook 2015Deloitte UK & European Restructuring Market Outlook 2015
Deloitte UK & European Restructuring Market Outlook 2015Thorsten Lederer 托尔斯滕
 
joint-report-by-jp-morgan-and-oliver-wyman-unlocking-economic-advantage-with-...
joint-report-by-jp-morgan-and-oliver-wyman-unlocking-economic-advantage-with-...joint-report-by-jp-morgan-and-oliver-wyman-unlocking-economic-advantage-with-...
joint-report-by-jp-morgan-and-oliver-wyman-unlocking-economic-advantage-with-...Robert Rosenberg
 
Making Hong Kong a #FinTech centre
Making Hong Kong a #FinTech centreMaking Hong Kong a #FinTech centre
Making Hong Kong a #FinTech centreCFTE
 
Baker Hill Client Meeting 2016: It's More Than A Credit Memo
Baker Hill Client Meeting 2016: It's More Than A Credit MemoBaker Hill Client Meeting 2016: It's More Than A Credit Memo
Baker Hill Client Meeting 2016: It's More Than A Credit MemoBaker Hill
 
Oliver Wyman Integrating Predictive Analytics in Assumption Setting - 2014 SO...
Oliver Wyman Integrating Predictive Analytics in Assumption Setting - 2014 SO...Oliver Wyman Integrating Predictive Analytics in Assumption Setting - 2014 SO...
Oliver Wyman Integrating Predictive Analytics in Assumption Setting - 2014 SO...Guillaume Briere-Giroux
 
Bcg Banking 2020
Bcg Banking 2020Bcg Banking 2020
Bcg Banking 2020JPStrategy
 
Misys acquires Custom Credit Systems, a leading provider of credit workflow ...
Misys acquires Custom Credit Systems, a leading provider  of credit workflow ...Misys acquires Custom Credit Systems, a leading provider  of credit workflow ...
Misys acquires Custom Credit Systems, a leading provider of credit workflow ...Misys
 
HSBC Commercial Banking - Transforming Opportunity
HSBC Commercial Banking - Transforming OpportunityHSBC Commercial Banking - Transforming Opportunity
HSBC Commercial Banking - Transforming OpportunityQuarterlyEarningsReports2
 
Baker Hill Advisor for Relationship Lending Overview
Baker Hill Advisor for Relationship Lending OverviewBaker Hill Advisor for Relationship Lending Overview
Baker Hill Advisor for Relationship Lending OverviewBaker Hill
 
Microsoft Lending Reference Architecture
Microsoft Lending Reference ArchitectureMicrosoft Lending Reference Architecture
Microsoft Lending Reference ArchitectureMike Walker
 
Accenture 2015 Global Risk Management Study: North American Banking Report Ke...
Accenture 2015 Global Risk Management Study: North American Banking Report Ke...Accenture 2015 Global Risk Management Study: North American Banking Report Ke...
Accenture 2015 Global Risk Management Study: North American Banking Report Ke...accenture
 
Expert Judgement Credit Rating for SME & Commercial Customers
Expert Judgement Credit Rating for SME & Commercial CustomersExpert Judgement Credit Rating for SME & Commercial Customers
Expert Judgement Credit Rating for SME & Commercial CustomersMike Coates
 
Renaud Laplanche LendingClub 2014 Keynote
Renaud Laplanche LendingClub 2014 KeynoteRenaud Laplanche LendingClub 2014 Keynote
Renaud Laplanche LendingClub 2014 KeynoteSean Murray
 

En vedette (18)

European Retail and SME Credit Report 2015
European Retail and SME Credit Report 2015European Retail and SME Credit Report 2015
European Retail and SME Credit Report 2015
 
Bara ERM v2
Bara ERM v2Bara ERM v2
Bara ERM v2
 
Professional Expertise in Value Creation
Professional Expertise in Value CreationProfessional Expertise in Value Creation
Professional Expertise in Value Creation
 
Etude PwC Loan Portfolio Market Survey 2015
Etude PwC   Loan Portfolio Market Survey 2015Etude PwC   Loan Portfolio Market Survey 2015
Etude PwC Loan Portfolio Market Survey 2015
 
Deloitte Private Debt Conference Luxembourg | 17 November 2015
Deloitte Private Debt Conference Luxembourg | 17 November 2015Deloitte Private Debt Conference Luxembourg | 17 November 2015
Deloitte Private Debt Conference Luxembourg | 17 November 2015
 
Deloitte UK & European Restructuring Market Outlook 2015
Deloitte UK & European Restructuring Market Outlook 2015Deloitte UK & European Restructuring Market Outlook 2015
Deloitte UK & European Restructuring Market Outlook 2015
 
joint-report-by-jp-morgan-and-oliver-wyman-unlocking-economic-advantage-with-...
joint-report-by-jp-morgan-and-oliver-wyman-unlocking-economic-advantage-with-...joint-report-by-jp-morgan-and-oliver-wyman-unlocking-economic-advantage-with-...
joint-report-by-jp-morgan-and-oliver-wyman-unlocking-economic-advantage-with-...
 
Making Hong Kong a #FinTech centre
Making Hong Kong a #FinTech centreMaking Hong Kong a #FinTech centre
Making Hong Kong a #FinTech centre
 
Baker Hill Client Meeting 2016: It's More Than A Credit Memo
Baker Hill Client Meeting 2016: It's More Than A Credit MemoBaker Hill Client Meeting 2016: It's More Than A Credit Memo
Baker Hill Client Meeting 2016: It's More Than A Credit Memo
 
Oliver Wyman Integrating Predictive Analytics in Assumption Setting - 2014 SO...
Oliver Wyman Integrating Predictive Analytics in Assumption Setting - 2014 SO...Oliver Wyman Integrating Predictive Analytics in Assumption Setting - 2014 SO...
Oliver Wyman Integrating Predictive Analytics in Assumption Setting - 2014 SO...
 
Bcg Banking 2020
Bcg Banking 2020Bcg Banking 2020
Bcg Banking 2020
 
Misys acquires Custom Credit Systems, a leading provider of credit workflow ...
Misys acquires Custom Credit Systems, a leading provider  of credit workflow ...Misys acquires Custom Credit Systems, a leading provider  of credit workflow ...
Misys acquires Custom Credit Systems, a leading provider of credit workflow ...
 
HSBC Commercial Banking - Transforming Opportunity
HSBC Commercial Banking - Transforming OpportunityHSBC Commercial Banking - Transforming Opportunity
HSBC Commercial Banking - Transforming Opportunity
 
Baker Hill Advisor for Relationship Lending Overview
Baker Hill Advisor for Relationship Lending OverviewBaker Hill Advisor for Relationship Lending Overview
Baker Hill Advisor for Relationship Lending Overview
 
Microsoft Lending Reference Architecture
Microsoft Lending Reference ArchitectureMicrosoft Lending Reference Architecture
Microsoft Lending Reference Architecture
 
Accenture 2015 Global Risk Management Study: North American Banking Report Ke...
Accenture 2015 Global Risk Management Study: North American Banking Report Ke...Accenture 2015 Global Risk Management Study: North American Banking Report Ke...
Accenture 2015 Global Risk Management Study: North American Banking Report Ke...
 
Expert Judgement Credit Rating for SME & Commercial Customers
Expert Judgement Credit Rating for SME & Commercial CustomersExpert Judgement Credit Rating for SME & Commercial Customers
Expert Judgement Credit Rating for SME & Commercial Customers
 
Renaud Laplanche LendingClub 2014 Keynote
Renaud Laplanche LendingClub 2014 KeynoteRenaud Laplanche LendingClub 2014 Keynote
Renaud Laplanche LendingClub 2014 Keynote
 

Similaire à Andrew Dresner

Subscribed 2017: Land to Expand - Establish Foreign Legal Presence to Grow Re...
Subscribed 2017: Land to Expand - Establish Foreign Legal Presence to Grow Re...Subscribed 2017: Land to Expand - Establish Foreign Legal Presence to Grow Re...
Subscribed 2017: Land to Expand - Establish Foreign Legal Presence to Grow Re...Zuora, Inc.
 
Subscribed NYC 2017: Land & Expand: Your Strategy for Global Market Expansion
Subscribed NYC 2017: Land & Expand: Your Strategy for Global Market ExpansionSubscribed NYC 2017: Land & Expand: Your Strategy for Global Market Expansion
Subscribed NYC 2017: Land & Expand: Your Strategy for Global Market ExpansionZuora, Inc.
 
How to Maximize Discount Capture
How to Maximize Discount CaptureHow to Maximize Discount Capture
How to Maximize Discount CaptureTaulia
 
Installment payment solutions by Finview
Installment payment solutions by FinviewInstallment payment solutions by Finview
Installment payment solutions by FinviewWilliam Vermont
 
Credit cards-nj-understanding-electronic-payments
Credit cards-nj-understanding-electronic-paymentsCredit cards-nj-understanding-electronic-payments
Credit cards-nj-understanding-electronic-paymentsJennifer R Glass
 
World Payments Report 2014 Key Findings Presentation
World Payments Report 2014 Key Findings PresentationWorld Payments Report 2014 Key Findings Presentation
World Payments Report 2014 Key Findings PresentationCapgemini
 
Intuit - Investor Day Presentation 2012
Intuit - Investor Day Presentation 2012Intuit - Investor Day Presentation 2012
Intuit - Investor Day Presentation 2012investorsintuitinc
 
Investor meeting presentation final version
Investor meeting presentation final versionInvestor meeting presentation final version
Investor meeting presentation final versionvisainc
 
Visa report 02.04.16
Visa report 02.04.16Visa report 02.04.16
Visa report 02.04.16Andrea Casati
 
Clearitt | Cooperative Payments
Clearitt | Cooperative PaymentsClearitt | Cooperative Payments
Clearitt | Cooperative PaymentsRichardJohnsson
 
DisruptingBanking ABTEC 2015 Final
DisruptingBanking ABTEC 2015 FinalDisruptingBanking ABTEC 2015 Final
DisruptingBanking ABTEC 2015 FinalAwad Capital Ltd.
 
DisruptingBanking presentation at ABTEC 2015
DisruptingBanking presentation at ABTEC 2015DisruptingBanking presentation at ABTEC 2015
DisruptingBanking presentation at ABTEC 2015Ziad Awad
 
Thomas Storring - Reaching our international trade goals
Thomas Storring - Reaching our international trade goalsThomas Storring - Reaching our international trade goals
Thomas Storring - Reaching our international trade goalsonens
 
Brief for Transaction Processing Industry
Brief for Transaction Processing IndustryBrief for Transaction Processing Industry
Brief for Transaction Processing IndustryBerkeley Teate
 
Clearitt | Cooperative Payments
Clearitt | Cooperative PaymentsClearitt | Cooperative Payments
Clearitt | Cooperative PaymentsRichardJohnsson
 

Similaire à Andrew Dresner (20)

Subscribed 2017: Land to Expand - Establish Foreign Legal Presence to Grow Re...
Subscribed 2017: Land to Expand - Establish Foreign Legal Presence to Grow Re...Subscribed 2017: Land to Expand - Establish Foreign Legal Presence to Grow Re...
Subscribed 2017: Land to Expand - Establish Foreign Legal Presence to Grow Re...
 
Subscribed NYC 2017: Land & Expand: Your Strategy for Global Market Expansion
Subscribed NYC 2017: Land & Expand: Your Strategy for Global Market ExpansionSubscribed NYC 2017: Land & Expand: Your Strategy for Global Market Expansion
Subscribed NYC 2017: Land & Expand: Your Strategy for Global Market Expansion
 
Alejandro Garcia Monterde
Alejandro Garcia MonterdeAlejandro Garcia Monterde
Alejandro Garcia Monterde
 
How to Maximize Discount Capture
How to Maximize Discount CaptureHow to Maximize Discount Capture
How to Maximize Discount Capture
 
Trade connect finance all slides
Trade connect finance all slidesTrade connect finance all slides
Trade connect finance all slides
 
Paypal
PaypalPaypal
Paypal
 
Socket presentation 2014
Socket presentation 2014Socket presentation 2014
Socket presentation 2014
 
Installment payment solutions by Finview
Installment payment solutions by FinviewInstallment payment solutions by Finview
Installment payment solutions by Finview
 
Credit cards-nj-understanding-electronic-payments
Credit cards-nj-understanding-electronic-paymentsCredit cards-nj-understanding-electronic-payments
Credit cards-nj-understanding-electronic-payments
 
World Payments Report 2014 Key Findings Presentation
World Payments Report 2014 Key Findings PresentationWorld Payments Report 2014 Key Findings Presentation
World Payments Report 2014 Key Findings Presentation
 
Mott
MottMott
Mott
 
Intuit - Investor Day Presentation 2012
Intuit - Investor Day Presentation 2012Intuit - Investor Day Presentation 2012
Intuit - Investor Day Presentation 2012
 
Investor meeting presentation final version
Investor meeting presentation final versionInvestor meeting presentation final version
Investor meeting presentation final version
 
Visa report 02.04.16
Visa report 02.04.16Visa report 02.04.16
Visa report 02.04.16
 
Clearitt | Cooperative Payments
Clearitt | Cooperative PaymentsClearitt | Cooperative Payments
Clearitt | Cooperative Payments
 
DisruptingBanking ABTEC 2015 Final
DisruptingBanking ABTEC 2015 FinalDisruptingBanking ABTEC 2015 Final
DisruptingBanking ABTEC 2015 Final
 
DisruptingBanking presentation at ABTEC 2015
DisruptingBanking presentation at ABTEC 2015DisruptingBanking presentation at ABTEC 2015
DisruptingBanking presentation at ABTEC 2015
 
Thomas Storring - Reaching our international trade goals
Thomas Storring - Reaching our international trade goalsThomas Storring - Reaching our international trade goals
Thomas Storring - Reaching our international trade goals
 
Brief for Transaction Processing Industry
Brief for Transaction Processing IndustryBrief for Transaction Processing Industry
Brief for Transaction Processing Industry
 
Clearitt | Cooperative Payments
Clearitt | Cooperative PaymentsClearitt | Cooperative Payments
Clearitt | Cooperative Payments
 

Plus de catalyticgov

Plus de catalyticgov (11)

Greg Wolfond
Greg WolfondGreg Wolfond
Greg Wolfond
 
Andrew Nash
Andrew NashAndrew Nash
Andrew Nash
 
Peter Watkins
Peter WatkinsPeter Watkins
Peter Watkins
 
Vince D’Agostino & D’Arcy Delamer
Vince D’Agostino & D’Arcy DelamerVince D’Agostino & D’Arcy Delamer
Vince D’Agostino & D’Arcy Delamer
 
Michael McDerment
Michael McDermentMichael McDerment
Michael McDerment
 
Michael Adams
Michael AdamsMichael Adams
Michael Adams
 
Mickey McManus
Mickey McManusMickey McManus
Mickey McManus
 
David Birch
David BirchDavid Birch
David Birch
 
Chris Hamilton
Chris HamiltonChris Hamilton
Chris Hamilton
 
JSB presentation
JSB presentationJSB presentation
JSB presentation
 
Haag presentation
Haag presentationHaag presentation
Haag presentation
 

Dernier

LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Review
LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations ReviewLPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Review
LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Reviewthomas851723
 
Simplifying Complexity: How the Four-Field Matrix Reshapes Thinking
Simplifying Complexity: How the Four-Field Matrix Reshapes ThinkingSimplifying Complexity: How the Four-Field Matrix Reshapes Thinking
Simplifying Complexity: How the Four-Field Matrix Reshapes ThinkingCIToolkit
 
Effective learning in the Age of Hybrid Work - Agile Saturday Tallinn 2024
Effective learning in the Age of Hybrid Work - Agile Saturday Tallinn 2024Effective learning in the Age of Hybrid Work - Agile Saturday Tallinn 2024
Effective learning in the Age of Hybrid Work - Agile Saturday Tallinn 2024Giuseppe De Simone
 
Unlocking Productivity and Personal Growth through the Importance-Urgency Matrix
Unlocking Productivity and Personal Growth through the Importance-Urgency MatrixUnlocking Productivity and Personal Growth through the Importance-Urgency Matrix
Unlocking Productivity and Personal Growth through the Importance-Urgency MatrixCIToolkit
 
Call Us🔝⇛+91-97111🔝47426 Call In girls Munirka (DELHI)
Call Us🔝⇛+91-97111🔝47426 Call In girls Munirka (DELHI)Call Us🔝⇛+91-97111🔝47426 Call In girls Munirka (DELHI)
Call Us🔝⇛+91-97111🔝47426 Call In girls Munirka (DELHI)jennyeacort
 
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sector
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business SectorLPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sector
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sectorthomas851723
 
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-EngineeringIntroduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineeringthomas851723
 
Beyond the Five Whys: Exploring the Hierarchical Causes with the Why-Why Diagram
Beyond the Five Whys: Exploring the Hierarchical Causes with the Why-Why DiagramBeyond the Five Whys: Exploring the Hierarchical Causes with the Why-Why Diagram
Beyond the Five Whys: Exploring the Hierarchical Causes with the Why-Why DiagramCIToolkit
 
Measuring True Process Yield using Robust Yield Metrics
Measuring True Process Yield using Robust Yield MetricsMeasuring True Process Yield using Robust Yield Metrics
Measuring True Process Yield using Robust Yield MetricsCIToolkit
 
Farmer Representative Organization in Lucknow | Rashtriya Kisan Manch
Farmer Representative Organization in Lucknow | Rashtriya Kisan ManchFarmer Representative Organization in Lucknow | Rashtriya Kisan Manch
Farmer Representative Organization in Lucknow | Rashtriya Kisan ManchRashtriya Kisan Manch
 
How-How Diagram: A Practical Approach to Problem Resolution
How-How Diagram: A Practical Approach to Problem ResolutionHow-How Diagram: A Practical Approach to Problem Resolution
How-How Diagram: A Practical Approach to Problem ResolutionCIToolkit
 
Motivational theories an leadership skills
Motivational theories an leadership skillsMotivational theories an leadership skills
Motivational theories an leadership skillskristinalimarenko7
 
From Goals to Actions: Uncovering the Key Components of Improvement Roadmaps
From Goals to Actions: Uncovering the Key Components of Improvement RoadmapsFrom Goals to Actions: Uncovering the Key Components of Improvement Roadmaps
From Goals to Actions: Uncovering the Key Components of Improvement RoadmapsCIToolkit
 
Shaping Organizational Culture Beyond Wishful Thinking
Shaping Organizational Culture Beyond Wishful ThinkingShaping Organizational Culture Beyond Wishful Thinking
Shaping Organizational Culture Beyond Wishful ThinkingGiuseppe De Simone
 
Paired Comparison Analysis: A Practical Tool for Evaluating Options and Prior...
Paired Comparison Analysis: A Practical Tool for Evaluating Options and Prior...Paired Comparison Analysis: A Practical Tool for Evaluating Options and Prior...
Paired Comparison Analysis: A Practical Tool for Evaluating Options and Prior...CIToolkit
 
Management and managerial skills training manual.pdf
Management and managerial skills training manual.pdfManagement and managerial skills training manual.pdf
Management and managerial skills training manual.pdffillmonipdc
 
Fifteenth Finance Commission Presentation
Fifteenth Finance Commission PresentationFifteenth Finance Commission Presentation
Fifteenth Finance Commission Presentationmintusiprd
 
Reflecting, turning experience into insight
Reflecting, turning experience into insightReflecting, turning experience into insight
Reflecting, turning experience into insightWayne Abrahams
 
原版1:1复刻密西西比大学毕业证Mississippi毕业证留信学历认证
原版1:1复刻密西西比大学毕业证Mississippi毕业证留信学历认证原版1:1复刻密西西比大学毕业证Mississippi毕业证留信学历认证
原版1:1复刻密西西比大学毕业证Mississippi毕业证留信学历认证jdkhjh
 

Dernier (20)

LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Review
LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations ReviewLPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Review
LPC Operations Review PowerPoint | Operations Review
 
Simplifying Complexity: How the Four-Field Matrix Reshapes Thinking
Simplifying Complexity: How the Four-Field Matrix Reshapes ThinkingSimplifying Complexity: How the Four-Field Matrix Reshapes Thinking
Simplifying Complexity: How the Four-Field Matrix Reshapes Thinking
 
Effective learning in the Age of Hybrid Work - Agile Saturday Tallinn 2024
Effective learning in the Age of Hybrid Work - Agile Saturday Tallinn 2024Effective learning in the Age of Hybrid Work - Agile Saturday Tallinn 2024
Effective learning in the Age of Hybrid Work - Agile Saturday Tallinn 2024
 
Unlocking Productivity and Personal Growth through the Importance-Urgency Matrix
Unlocking Productivity and Personal Growth through the Importance-Urgency MatrixUnlocking Productivity and Personal Growth through the Importance-Urgency Matrix
Unlocking Productivity and Personal Growth through the Importance-Urgency Matrix
 
Call Us🔝⇛+91-97111🔝47426 Call In girls Munirka (DELHI)
Call Us🔝⇛+91-97111🔝47426 Call In girls Munirka (DELHI)Call Us🔝⇛+91-97111🔝47426 Call In girls Munirka (DELHI)
Call Us🔝⇛+91-97111🔝47426 Call In girls Munirka (DELHI)
 
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sector
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business SectorLPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sector
LPC Warehouse Management System For Clients In The Business Sector
 
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-EngineeringIntroduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
 
Beyond the Five Whys: Exploring the Hierarchical Causes with the Why-Why Diagram
Beyond the Five Whys: Exploring the Hierarchical Causes with the Why-Why DiagramBeyond the Five Whys: Exploring the Hierarchical Causes with the Why-Why Diagram
Beyond the Five Whys: Exploring the Hierarchical Causes with the Why-Why Diagram
 
Measuring True Process Yield using Robust Yield Metrics
Measuring True Process Yield using Robust Yield MetricsMeasuring True Process Yield using Robust Yield Metrics
Measuring True Process Yield using Robust Yield Metrics
 
Farmer Representative Organization in Lucknow | Rashtriya Kisan Manch
Farmer Representative Organization in Lucknow | Rashtriya Kisan ManchFarmer Representative Organization in Lucknow | Rashtriya Kisan Manch
Farmer Representative Organization in Lucknow | Rashtriya Kisan Manch
 
How-How Diagram: A Practical Approach to Problem Resolution
How-How Diagram: A Practical Approach to Problem ResolutionHow-How Diagram: A Practical Approach to Problem Resolution
How-How Diagram: A Practical Approach to Problem Resolution
 
Motivational theories an leadership skills
Motivational theories an leadership skillsMotivational theories an leadership skills
Motivational theories an leadership skills
 
sauth delhi call girls in Defence Colony🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
sauth delhi call girls in Defence Colony🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Servicesauth delhi call girls in Defence Colony🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
sauth delhi call girls in Defence Colony🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
 
From Goals to Actions: Uncovering the Key Components of Improvement Roadmaps
From Goals to Actions: Uncovering the Key Components of Improvement RoadmapsFrom Goals to Actions: Uncovering the Key Components of Improvement Roadmaps
From Goals to Actions: Uncovering the Key Components of Improvement Roadmaps
 
Shaping Organizational Culture Beyond Wishful Thinking
Shaping Organizational Culture Beyond Wishful ThinkingShaping Organizational Culture Beyond Wishful Thinking
Shaping Organizational Culture Beyond Wishful Thinking
 
Paired Comparison Analysis: A Practical Tool for Evaluating Options and Prior...
Paired Comparison Analysis: A Practical Tool for Evaluating Options and Prior...Paired Comparison Analysis: A Practical Tool for Evaluating Options and Prior...
Paired Comparison Analysis: A Practical Tool for Evaluating Options and Prior...
 
Management and managerial skills training manual.pdf
Management and managerial skills training manual.pdfManagement and managerial skills training manual.pdf
Management and managerial skills training manual.pdf
 
Fifteenth Finance Commission Presentation
Fifteenth Finance Commission PresentationFifteenth Finance Commission Presentation
Fifteenth Finance Commission Presentation
 
Reflecting, turning experience into insight
Reflecting, turning experience into insightReflecting, turning experience into insight
Reflecting, turning experience into insight
 
原版1:1复刻密西西比大学毕业证Mississippi毕业证留信学历认证
原版1:1复刻密西西比大学毕业证Mississippi毕业证留信学历认证原版1:1复刻密西西比大学毕业证Mississippi毕业证留信学历认证
原版1:1复刻密西西比大学毕业证Mississippi毕业证留信学历认证
 

Andrew Dresner

  • 1. NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062 Financial Services B2B payments: Cards Future of Canadian Payments November 3, 2010 CONFIDENTIAL | www.oliverwyman.com
  • 2. 1NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com B2B payments have a different economic model than B2C or C2B Segments Products Processors Networks/ Clearinghouses Competition and value capture fundamentals WholesaleConsumer/SB Consumers/SB payments attributes ! Spread revenues dominate fee revenues ! Payments are a product feature, not the product itself ! Limited price and functionality competition ! Distribution is the key to share Wholesale payments attributes ! Fee revenues dominate ! Payments are the product ! Price competition is severe ! Processing scale and innovation are key Alternative Payments Mobile eWallets (PayPal) Others Chequing accounts Credit Card Cash Management Merchant Acquiring Commercial Cards FDC, TSYS – MasterCard, VisaCPA, Interac ACSS (ACH) Closed Loops (Amex) LVTS (RGTS) Symcor Check- free Pre- Paid Mass market Premium Small business Domestic corporates Multi- national FIs
  • 3. 2NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com Within North America, banks lost control over the last 30 years 2010 North American Card Payments Market Total equity valuation: $270-$310 BN (estimated) Total post-tax earnings: $21 BN (estimated) Wholly bank-owned Partially bank-owned (e.g. equity stake) Network switching Merchant acquiringIssuing Processing $56 BN equity value 9-14x P/E multiple $70-$90 BN market cap 7-9x P/E multiple 100% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%20% 40% 60% 80% $50-$65 BN market cap 25-30x P/E multiple $80-$95 BN market cap 16-18x P/E multiple First Data Merchant Alliances Note: Assumes 25% reduction from peak credit card issuing profit and no debit profits; PE multiple ranges are illustrative and drawn from publicly traded “pure plays”
  • 4. 3NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com Acquiring Across the developed world, competitive forces are similar Dynamics Comments Slowing transaction growth ! Cash & checks displaced ! “Cardable” white space harder to find Payments mix shift ! Credit-to-debit ! Standard to premium ! Higher scheme fees ! Volumes shifting to less profitable txs, – Less impact in large IC+ merchants – High impact profitable SME segment ! In Canada, credit is outgrowing debit Regulatory reform ! Regulators pushing for greater transparency and lower costs Consolidation for scale ! Large merchants lead pricing pressure Globalization ! Encroachment of US acquirers ! New class of competitor (the PSP) in cross-border eCommerce
  • 5. 4NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com Acquiring National Merchants provide scale; SME merchants generate profits Large merchants SME Average margin 10-15bp (IC+) 65-70bp (% of face value) Credit GDV (C$ BN) $100-120 $140-160 Share of revenue 10-15% 85-90% Canadian market bifurcation (Similar to all other developed markets)
  • 6. 5NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% First Data + alliances Paymentech Fifth Third + RBS Global Payments Elavon Moneris Heartland TSYS TD Transfirst All other US Canada North American merchant acquiring market structure % of gross sales volume, estimated (2009) Dominate high- volume categories Serve select large merchant niches Focus on SME Acquiring Large merchants drive consolidation at the top of the market 45% Some of the largest merchants are beginning to seek out cross-border, North American solutions
  • 7. 6NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com Commercial Cards Distinguished from SME by importance of MIS and absence of revolve Corporate Cards (T&E) Procurement Cards Fleet Cards Small Business Cards Purpose Fund employee travel Purchase small ticket items Purchase gas and repairs Source of working capital lending to SMEs and to expedite purchasing Value proposition ! Manage travel costs ! Fund employee travel ! Automate low-value purchasing ! Supplier discounts ! Supplier discounts ! Fraud control ! Fleet management ! Access to credit ! Automate purchasing Unique features ! Reporting ! No preset spending limit ! Level three reporting ! Discount capture ! Odometer capture ! Fraud reporting ! Discount capture ! NA Market structure ! American Express dominates ! Some major banks issue Visa/MC versions, but have low share ! Closed loops lead, e.g. Wright Express, Voyager ! Gas company proprietary cards ! Visa/MC universal products ! American Express is material ! Banks are major players Revenue model ! Interchange ! Fees ! Interest income ! Interchange fees ! Other fee income
  • 8. 7NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com 0 50 100 150 200 250 2006 2007 2008 2009 Spendvolume($BN) 12.6 12.7 12.8 12.9 13.0 13.1 13.2 13.3 RealGDP($TN) American Express Visa/Mastercard Real GDP ($TN) Commercial cards – Corporate cards Slow growth (1.5% CAGR), dominated by American Express (~80% share) Corporate card spend AXP share 82% 81% 85% 81% Source: Nilson report, Bureau of Economic Analysis, Oliver Wyman analysis Note: Assumes 90/10 split on American Express corporate card volume between T&E and procurement cards
  • 9. 8NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com 0 1 2 3 4 5 2006 2007 2008 2009 Spendvolume($BN) $0.0 $0.5 $1.0 $1.5 $2.0 $2.5 $3.0 $3.5 $4.0 $4.5 $5.0 Fleet card spend Weighted average gas price Commercial cards – Fleet cards Slow growth, spend fluctuates with the price of gas Source: Nilson report, Energy Information Administration, Oliver Wyman analysis
  • 10. 9NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com 75 80 85 90 95 100 105 2006 2007 2008 2009 Spendvolume($BN) Commercial cards – Procurement cards (P-cards) A small share of overall B2B spend; American Express is a leader … but share is low Source: Nilson report, The Clearing House/Federal Reserve report, Oliver Wyman analysis Note: Assumes 90/10 split on American Express corporate card volume between T&E and procurement cards 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Check Wire ACH Payment card %ofB2Btransactions Spend is growing… Note: this is share of transactions, share of spend is very low
  • 11. 10NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com P-cards cards face several obstacles to greater adoption Obstacle Comments Process Change (Buyers & suppliers) Integration to ERP systems via APIs (e.g. AXP/SAP) Security e.g. PCI compliance Software as a service (SAAS) solutions Costs (Interchange & network fees) 1.80% + .10 for standard Level III tx 0.95-1.30% + $35-$40 for large ticket Applicability (Expanding internal adoption) Increasing “cardable” spend (~40% of small transactions on P-cards in adopting companies)
  • 12. 11NYC-MOWAD1MKT-062© 2010 Oliver Wyman ! www.oliverwyman.com Summary Cards play a role in B2B, but face obstacles to greater adoption ! Much of the value in B2B cards is captured outside the traditional banking system ! Merchant acquiring is the biggest segment, but faces slowing growth, increasing globalization, and continuous pricing pressure ! Commercial cards target important niches, but only P-cards still have substantial headroom for growth – Corporate cards are almost fully adopted and usage fluctuates with the economy – Fleet cards are heavily adopted by target companies, but revenues fluctuate with the price of gas – P-cards are still growing, but face key obstacles to adoption beyond low-ticket categories