Presentation by Heather Piwowar at DataCite 2011 Summer Meeting, Aug 24 2011.

1. Data Citation
Challenges and Opportunities
from the perspective of
Tracking Data Reuse
Heather
Piwowar
DataONE
postdoc
with
NESCent
and
Dryad
@researchremix
DataCite
Summer
Meeting
August
2011

2. http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/ho/09/euwf/ho_24.45.1.htm

3. http://www.flickr.com/photos/jsmjr/62443357/

4. http://www.flickr.com/photos/camilleharrington/3587294608/

5. http://www.flickr.com/photos/rkuhnau/3318245976/

6. http://www.flickr.com/photos/conformpdx/1796399674/

7. http://www.flickr.com/photos/rkuhnau/3317418699/

8. http://www.flickr.com/photos/zemlinki/261617721/

9. http://www.flickr.com/photos/tracenmatt/3020786491/

10. http://www.flickr.com/photos/the-o/2078239333/

11. ?
http://www.flickr.com/photos/ryanr/142455033/

12. http://www.flickr.com/photos/archeon/2941655917/

13. http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/e/e6/Gamma_distribution_pdf.svg/500px-Gamma_distribution_pdf.svg.png

14. http://www.flickr.com/photos/jima/606588905/

16. http://www.flickr.com/photos/lofaesofa/248546821/

20. We have observed reuse of at 35%
of GEO datasets submitted in 2005.

21. Piwowar, Vision, Whitlock (2011)
Data archiving is a good investment.
Nature 473, 285
http://researchremix.wordpress.com/2011/05/19/nature-letter/

22. Tracking 1k

23. 10 * 100 = 1000

24. !"#$"%&'()'*++',*&*'#"-."'*/#01-2(%.' $!!"#
,!"#
+!"#
*!"#
1?6@AB:C2#@2#64D4642E4#
948:;1<4=>#
)!"#
(!"# 1?6@AB:C2#@2#DCC<2C<4#
'!"# 1?6@AB:C2#@2#<1AF4#
&!"# 1?6@AB:C2#@2#<4G<#
%!"#
$!"#
!"#
-./# 0123141# 56447184#

25. !&#$!!
456!
!"#$%&'()'*+,+'&%"-%-'.,-./01,23!
70890,0!
!&$$!!
:;,,<0-,!
!%#$!!
=>?@89!0?,;,09,!
A4563!
=>?@89!0?,;09,!
!%$$!! A70890,03!
=>?@89!0?,;09,!
A:;,,<0-,3!
!#$!!
!"!!!!
&$$'! &$$#! &$$(! &$$)! &$$*! &$$+! &$%$! &$%%!

26. Piwowar, Carlson, Vision (2011)
Beginning to track 1000 datasets from
public repositories into the published
literature. ASIS&T poster.
https://notebooks.dataone.org/tracking1000datasets/

27. My research blog:
ResearchRemix.wordpress.com
http://www.flickr.com/photos/myklroventine/892446624/

28. Data citation in the wild IDCC 2010 poster.

29. A best-practice
solution!

32. http://www.flickr.com/photos/nilsrinaldi/5157809483/

33. #1
Lack of tool support
for our best practice

39. Research Remix blog: http://bit.ly/aOwLoJ
“Tracking Dataset Citations Using Common Citation Tracking Tools Doesn’t Work”

40. Research Remix blog: http://bit.ly/aOwLoJ
“Tracking Dataset Citations Using Common Citation Tracking Tools Doesn’t Work”

41. We need more diversity
We need more players
We need start-ups

42. Abstracts are open.
Ref lists should be too.

43. #2
Our best practice doesn’t
scale to mega-reuse

45. !"#$%&'()'*+,+-%,-'&%)%&%./%*'$0'+&1/2%-'
,3+,'&%"-%*'456'*+,+7'/"#"2+18%'
$!!"#
,!"#
+!"#
*!"#
)!"#
(!"#
'!"#
&!"#
%!"#
$!"#
!"#
!# (# $!# $(# %!# %(# &!#

46. !"#$%&'()'*+,+-%,-'&%)%&%./%*'$0'+&1/2%-'
,3+,'&%"-%*'456'*+,+7'/"#"2+18%'
$!!"#
,!"#
+!"#
*!"#
)!"#
(!"#
'!"#
&!"#
%!"#
$!"#
!"#
!# (# $!# $(# %!# %(# &!#

47. !"#$%&'()'*+,+-%,-'&%)%&%./%*'$0'+&1/2%-'
,3+,'&%"-%*'456'*+,+7'/"#"2+18%'
$!!"#
,!"#
+!"#
*!"#
)!"#
(!"#
'!"#
&!"#
%!"#
$!"#
!"#
!# (# $!# $(# %!# %(# &!#

48. http://www.nature.com/nature/authors/gta/

50. But wait!

56. #2
Our best practice doesn’t
can
scale to mega-reuse
(if we work at it)

57. Another place where having a few
big players is a bottleneck
Open reference lists.

58. #3a
Adoption of best practices
erode incentives in the
short term

59. ~70%
in multivariate
analysis

60. #3b
Data citations only matter
if they are valued

61. Please donʼt tweet or publicize this next bit...
Early results from an ongoing survey.
n=538

62. 9:/54351#,*;5+3#<4-#=82/1#,-#>0#?,+@#>,+5#5432/0#
(!"#
'!"#
&!"#
%!"#
$!"#
!"#
)*+,-./0# 6# 6# 758*+4/# 6# 6# )*+,-./0#
1234.+55# 4.+55#
9:/54351#;#<2//#.5*#=,+5#>2*4?,-3##
(!"#
'!"#
&!"#
%!"#
$!"#
!"#
)*+,-./0# 6# 6# 758*+4/# 6# 6# )*+,-./0#
1234.+55# 4.+55#
Do not publicize

63. 9:/54351#,*;5+3#<4-#=82/1#,-#>0#?,+@#>,+5#5432/0# 9#:/54351#2*#;2//#<5#=4/851##
(!"#
<0#>0#?8-15+#
(!"#
'!"#
'!"#
&!"#
&!"#
%!"# %!"#
$!"# $!"#
!"# !"#
)*+,-./0# 6# 6# 758*+4/# 6# 6# )*+,-./0# )*+,-./0# 6# 6# 758*+4/# 6# 6# )*+,-./0#
1234.+55# 4.+55# 1234.+55# 4.+55#
9:/54351#;#<2//#.5*#=,+5#>2*4?,-3## 9#:/54351#2*#;2//#<5#=4/851##
(!"# <0#>0#:+,>,?,-#,+#*5-8+5#@,>>2A55#
(!"#
'!"#
'!"#
&!"#
&!"#
%!"#
%!"#
$!"# $!"#
!"# !"#
)*+,-./0# 6# 6# 758*+4/# 6# 6# )*+,-./0# )*+,-./0# 6# 6# 758*+4/# 6# 6# )*+,-./0#
1234.+55# 4.+55# 1234.+55# 4.+55#
Do not publicize

64. Top-down

65. http://www.nsf.gov/pubs/policydocs/pappguide/nsf08_1/gpg_2.jsp

66. Bottom-up

71. Text
DataCite!

72. http://www.flickr.com/photos/ginable/325235488/

73. http://www.flickr.com/photos/ryanr/142455033/

74. http://www.flickr.com/photos/supersam5/216868485/

75. thank you
Todd Vision,
Jonathan Carlson, Estephanie Sta Maria,
Nicholas Weber, Sarah Judson,Valerie Enriquez
Jason Priem and Beyond Impact
Dryad and DataONE teams
The open science online community and those who
release their articles, datasets and photos openly
blog: ResearchRemix.wordpress.com

76. No consistent practice

77. We reviewed 500 articles in six major evolution and ecology
journals for evidence of data citation:
Sarah Judson, Data citation in the wild IDCC 2010 poster.

78. We reviewed 500 articles in six major evolution and ecology
journals for evidence of data citation:
Sarah Judson, Data citation in the wild IDCC 2010 poster.

80. In 2009, 116 articles cited ORNL DAAC data.
Finding these articles took 70-80 hours
across at least 12 resources
all chosen from a deep understanding
of this specific research domain
then the full text of all the hits were
manually reviewed
Valerie Enriquez interview with James Kidder
http://openwetware.org/wiki/DataONE:Notebook/Reuse_of_repository_data