SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  2
“Engineering Culture:
              Control and Commitment in a High-Tech Corporation”                                          by Gideon Kunda

        What is the book about?                                                     Organizational Theories
Where? Silicon Valley, SysCom                             Metaphor (Morgan)           Theory               Commentary
When? 1990s (6 months of field work)
Who? Kunda, MIT student, Grade 2                          Organization as             Transactional        ‘Give & take’ – transactional (Williamson)
administrative support and Grade 4 tech                   economy                     cost theory          Hard work in return for appearance of security
workers support (management)
                                                          Organization as             Power Game           Power = “getting things done the way you
How? Participant observation ethnography
Why? Opportunity to study corporate power
                                                          power and politics          (Mintzberg)          want them done”
                                                                                                           Power is wielded through ‘informal’ ritualised
                                                                                                           messages (e.g. lunchtime seminars, annual
                                                                                                           picnics, etc.)

                 Main Themes                              Organization as             Similar to Z         Proceed based on intimacy, subtlety and trust
                                                          ‘family’ (or                Organizations        BUT – dark side of the ‘family’ – can be a
Kunda exposes the intentionality of Tech                  ‘culture’?)                 (Ouchi)              veneer for abuse or control
company's management use of various methods
of normative control to propagate its claims as a                                         Methodology Critique
familial work environment that operates
informally and allows for a flexibility which              “Going native” dangers – too close, friendships, unrepresentative sampling
promotes individual responsibility as the primary          2-Year write-up period in Tel Aviv. No further contact with sources
one’s career success.                                      Focused on tech workers. Ignored support workers, mostly female & non-
                                                            white.
A rewarding and life-long employment is the
company’s promise in exchange for one’s
personally commitment of their creativity and
initiative in the process of producing products
that are marketable and successful in generating
revenue. Kunda establishes that pervasive efforts
of Tech, from a well-espoused ideology that
involves “a moral purpose” as part of its daily
culture where repetition of Tech’s s mask an
elaborate and subtle form of normative control in
which the members' minds and hearts become
the target of corporate influence for the pursuit of
corporate, and by chance individual, revenue.
                                                       Kunda, G. (2006). Engineering culture: Control and commitment in a high-tech corporation. Temple University Press.
Poster presentation   engineering culture

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Engineering culture
Engineering cultureEngineering culture
Engineering culturePamela Fox
 
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...lauramcinerney
 
Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Page
Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One PageEducational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Page
Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Pagelauramcinerney
 
Middle tier structure (1)
Middle tier   structure (1)Middle tier   structure (1)
Middle tier structure (1)lauramcinerney
 
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letter
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letterE act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letter
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letterlauramcinerney
 
Engineering your culture / Oren Ellenbogen
Engineering your culture  / Oren EllenbogenEngineering your culture  / Oren Ellenbogen
Engineering your culture / Oren Ellenbogengeektimecoil
 
Lecture 1 culture and diversity week 1&2
Lecture 1 culture and diversity  week 1&2Lecture 1 culture and diversity  week 1&2
Lecture 1 culture and diversity week 1&2Nevzat Yildirim
 
Sustainable engineering
Sustainable engineeringSustainable engineering
Sustainable engineeringAber Refai
 
Sustainable Engineering - Practical Studies for Building a Sustainable Society
Sustainable Engineering - Practical Studies for Building a Sustainable Society Sustainable Engineering - Practical Studies for Building a Sustainable Society
Sustainable Engineering - Practical Studies for Building a Sustainable Society QuEST Forum
 
What Makes a Great Engineering Culture?
What Makes a Great Engineering Culture?What Makes a Great Engineering Culture?
What Makes a Great Engineering Culture?Edmond Lau
 
Building an Awesome Engineering Culture
Building an Awesome Engineering CultureBuilding an Awesome Engineering Culture
Building an Awesome Engineering CultureUri Nativ
 
Role of Engineers in Sustainable Development
Role of Engineers in Sustainable DevelopmentRole of Engineers in Sustainable Development
Role of Engineers in Sustainable DevelopmentSSA KPI
 
Language and Culture
Language and CultureLanguage and Culture
Language and CulturePaulVMcDowell
 
Code as Craft: Building a Strong Engineering Culture at Etsy
Code as Craft: Building a Strong Engineering Culture at EtsyCode as Craft: Building a Strong Engineering Culture at Etsy
Code as Craft: Building a Strong Engineering Culture at EtsyChad Dickerson
 

En vedette (15)

Engineering culture
Engineering cultureEngineering culture
Engineering culture
 
Rotherham tbnp
Rotherham tbnpRotherham tbnp
Rotherham tbnp
 
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...
 
Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Page
Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One PageEducational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Page
Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Page
 
Middle tier structure (1)
Middle tier   structure (1)Middle tier   structure (1)
Middle tier structure (1)
 
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letter
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letterE act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letter
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letter
 
Engineering your culture / Oren Ellenbogen
Engineering your culture  / Oren EllenbogenEngineering your culture  / Oren Ellenbogen
Engineering your culture / Oren Ellenbogen
 
Lecture 1 culture and diversity week 1&2
Lecture 1 culture and diversity  week 1&2Lecture 1 culture and diversity  week 1&2
Lecture 1 culture and diversity week 1&2
 
Sustainable engineering
Sustainable engineeringSustainable engineering
Sustainable engineering
 
Sustainable Engineering - Practical Studies for Building a Sustainable Society
Sustainable Engineering - Practical Studies for Building a Sustainable Society Sustainable Engineering - Practical Studies for Building a Sustainable Society
Sustainable Engineering - Practical Studies for Building a Sustainable Society
 
What Makes a Great Engineering Culture?
What Makes a Great Engineering Culture?What Makes a Great Engineering Culture?
What Makes a Great Engineering Culture?
 
Building an Awesome Engineering Culture
Building an Awesome Engineering CultureBuilding an Awesome Engineering Culture
Building an Awesome Engineering Culture
 
Role of Engineers in Sustainable Development
Role of Engineers in Sustainable DevelopmentRole of Engineers in Sustainable Development
Role of Engineers in Sustainable Development
 
Language and Culture
Language and CultureLanguage and Culture
Language and Culture
 
Code as Craft: Building a Strong Engineering Culture at Etsy
Code as Craft: Building a Strong Engineering Culture at EtsyCode as Craft: Building a Strong Engineering Culture at Etsy
Code as Craft: Building a Strong Engineering Culture at Etsy
 

Similaire à Poster presentation engineering culture

Identification boosts conflicts: a managerial paradox - 2012
Identification boosts conflicts: a managerial paradox - 2012Identification boosts conflicts: a managerial paradox - 2012
Identification boosts conflicts: a managerial paradox - 2012Marinella De Simone
 
Agile Learning Organisations 2.0
Agile Learning Organisations 2.0Agile Learning Organisations 2.0
Agile Learning Organisations 2.0Otti Vogt
 
The role of information and communications technology in socializing knowled...
The role of information and communications technology in  socializing knowled...The role of information and communications technology in  socializing knowled...
The role of information and communications technology in socializing knowled...Alexander Decker
 
Stop model - Knowledge sharing
Stop model - Knowledge sharingStop model - Knowledge sharing
Stop model - Knowledge sharingOra Setter
 
The Future of Work - 2001 Presentation
The Future of Work - 2001 PresentationThe Future of Work - 2001 Presentation
The Future of Work - 2001 PresentationJon Husband
 
The Relationship of Knowledge Identification and Creationwi.docx
The Relationship of  Knowledge Identification and Creationwi.docxThe Relationship of  Knowledge Identification and Creationwi.docx
The Relationship of Knowledge Identification and Creationwi.docxoreo10
 
Knowledge Management & Competitive Advantage
Knowledge Management & Competitive AdvantageKnowledge Management & Competitive Advantage
Knowledge Management & Competitive Advantageguest1b05ea
 
Knowledge Management in the Enterprise
Knowledge Management in the EnterpriseKnowledge Management in the Enterprise
Knowledge Management in the EnterpriseMike Smith
 
1997 New Avenues In Knowledge Creation
1997 New Avenues In Knowledge Creation1997 New Avenues In Knowledge Creation
1997 New Avenues In Knowledge Creationpbaumard
 
ManagingManipulating The Numbers Essay Example
ManagingManipulating The Numbers Essay ExampleManagingManipulating The Numbers Essay Example
ManagingManipulating The Numbers Essay ExampleJennifer Gutierrez
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)IJERD Editor
 
Spark the Change Montreal 2021 - Under Pressure - Jon Husband
Spark the Change Montreal 2021 - Under Pressure - Jon HusbandSpark the Change Montreal 2021 - Under Pressure - Jon Husband
Spark the Change Montreal 2021 - Under Pressure - Jon HusbandSpark the Change Montréal
 
Collaboration and Social Networking (KCB202 Week 2 Podcast)
Collaboration and Social Networking (KCB202 Week 2 Podcast)Collaboration and Social Networking (KCB202 Week 2 Podcast)
Collaboration and Social Networking (KCB202 Week 2 Podcast)Axel Bruns
 
Organisational AnalysisAnalysing and Codifying Organisational .docx
Organisational AnalysisAnalysing and Codifying Organisational .docxOrganisational AnalysisAnalysing and Codifying Organisational .docx
Organisational AnalysisAnalysing and Codifying Organisational .docxvannagoforth
 
Week 5: Networked Power: Virals, Memes and Analysis #mc539
Week 5: Networked Power: Virals, Memes and Analysis #mc539Week 5: Networked Power: Virals, Memes and Analysis #mc539
Week 5: Networked Power: Virals, Memes and Analysis #mc539Jennifer Jones
 
From Motivation to Engagement
From Motivation to EngagementFrom Motivation to Engagement
From Motivation to EngagementJames W. Marcum
 

Similaire à Poster presentation engineering culture (20)

Identification boosts conflicts: a managerial paradox - 2012
Identification boosts conflicts: a managerial paradox - 2012Identification boosts conflicts: a managerial paradox - 2012
Identification boosts conflicts: a managerial paradox - 2012
 
Agile Learning Organisations 2.0
Agile Learning Organisations 2.0Agile Learning Organisations 2.0
Agile Learning Organisations 2.0
 
The role of information and communications technology in socializing knowled...
The role of information and communications technology in  socializing knowled...The role of information and communications technology in  socializing knowled...
The role of information and communications technology in socializing knowled...
 
Stop model - Knowledge sharing
Stop model - Knowledge sharingStop model - Knowledge sharing
Stop model - Knowledge sharing
 
The Future of Work - 2001 Presentation
The Future of Work - 2001 PresentationThe Future of Work - 2001 Presentation
The Future of Work - 2001 Presentation
 
The Relationship of Knowledge Identification and Creationwi.docx
The Relationship of  Knowledge Identification and Creationwi.docxThe Relationship of  Knowledge Identification and Creationwi.docx
The Relationship of Knowledge Identification and Creationwi.docx
 
Lab Task 1
Lab Task 1Lab Task 1
Lab Task 1
 
Knowledge Management & Competitive Advantage
Knowledge Management & Competitive AdvantageKnowledge Management & Competitive Advantage
Knowledge Management & Competitive Advantage
 
Knowledge Management in the Enterprise
Knowledge Management in the EnterpriseKnowledge Management in the Enterprise
Knowledge Management in the Enterprise
 
Learning Links
Learning LinksLearning Links
Learning Links
 
1997 New Avenues In Knowledge Creation
1997 New Avenues In Knowledge Creation1997 New Avenues In Knowledge Creation
1997 New Avenues In Knowledge Creation
 
Ihrmglobalthink3
Ihrmglobalthink3Ihrmglobalthink3
Ihrmglobalthink3
 
ManagingManipulating The Numbers Essay Example
ManagingManipulating The Numbers Essay ExampleManagingManipulating The Numbers Essay Example
ManagingManipulating The Numbers Essay Example
 
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
 
Spark the Change Montreal 2021 - Under Pressure - Jon Husband
Spark the Change Montreal 2021 - Under Pressure - Jon HusbandSpark the Change Montreal 2021 - Under Pressure - Jon Husband
Spark the Change Montreal 2021 - Under Pressure - Jon Husband
 
Collaboration and Social Networking (KCB202 Week 2 Podcast)
Collaboration and Social Networking (KCB202 Week 2 Podcast)Collaboration and Social Networking (KCB202 Week 2 Podcast)
Collaboration and Social Networking (KCB202 Week 2 Podcast)
 
Organisational AnalysisAnalysing and Codifying Organisational .docx
Organisational AnalysisAnalysing and Codifying Organisational .docxOrganisational AnalysisAnalysing and Codifying Organisational .docx
Organisational AnalysisAnalysing and Codifying Organisational .docx
 
Knowledge Gatekeepers
Knowledge GatekeepersKnowledge Gatekeepers
Knowledge Gatekeepers
 
Week 5: Networked Power: Virals, Memes and Analysis #mc539
Week 5: Networked Power: Virals, Memes and Analysis #mc539Week 5: Networked Power: Virals, Memes and Analysis #mc539
Week 5: Networked Power: Virals, Memes and Analysis #mc539
 
From Motivation to Engagement
From Motivation to EngagementFrom Motivation to Engagement
From Motivation to Engagement
 

Plus de lauramcinerney

Ico decision notice lm
Ico decision notice   lmIco decision notice   lm
Ico decision notice lmlauramcinerney
 
Research ed presentation notes handout
Research ed presentation notes handoutResearch ed presentation notes handout
Research ed presentation notes handoutlauramcinerney
 
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013lauramcinerney
 
Primary source analysis laura mc inerney
Primary source analysis   laura mc inerneyPrimary source analysis   laura mc inerney
Primary source analysis laura mc inerneylauramcinerney
 
Work in progress primary source analysis
Work in progress   primary source analysisWork in progress   primary source analysis
Work in progress primary source analysislauramcinerney
 
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012lauramcinerney
 
Elpa 9462 history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerney
Elpa 9462   history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerneyElpa 9462   history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerney
Elpa 9462 history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerneylauramcinerney
 
Young people in the media
Young people in the mediaYoung people in the media
Young people in the medialauramcinerney
 
Ashars citizenship work
Ashars citizenship workAshars citizenship work
Ashars citizenship worklauramcinerney
 
Parth, imran, akbar surveys
Parth, imran, akbar   surveysParth, imran, akbar   surveys
Parth, imran, akbar surveyslauramcinerney
 

Plus de lauramcinerney (20)

Ico decision notice lm
Ico decision notice   lmIco decision notice   lm
Ico decision notice lm
 
Research ed presentation notes handout
Research ed presentation notes handoutResearch ed presentation notes handout
Research ed presentation notes handout
 
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013
 
Primary source analysis laura mc inerney
Primary source analysis   laura mc inerneyPrimary source analysis   laura mc inerney
Primary source analysis laura mc inerney
 
Work in progress primary source analysis
Work in progress   primary source analysisWork in progress   primary source analysis
Work in progress primary source analysis
 
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012
 
Elpa 9462 history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerney
Elpa 9462   history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerneyElpa 9462   history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerney
Elpa 9462 history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerney
 
Young people in the media
Young people in the mediaYoung people in the media
Young people in the media
 
Parth proof
Parth proofParth proof
Parth proof
 
Citizen cw
Citizen cwCitizen cw
Citizen cw
 
#1 citizen animation
#1 citizen animation#1 citizen animation
#1 citizen animation
 
Ashars citizenship work
Ashars citizenship workAshars citizenship work
Ashars citizenship work
 
EMA Campaign Update
EMA Campaign UpdateEMA Campaign Update
EMA Campaign Update
 
Jazz riot sentencing
Jazz   riot sentencingJazz   riot sentencing
Jazz riot sentencing
 
Ahmed's work
Ahmed's workAhmed's work
Ahmed's work
 
Ahmed's petition
Ahmed's petitionAhmed's petition
Ahmed's petition
 
Bhavik citz
Bhavik citzBhavik citz
Bhavik citz
 
Parth, imran, akbar surveys
Parth, imran, akbar   surveysParth, imran, akbar   surveys
Parth, imran, akbar surveys
 
Feraaz ppt
Feraaz pptFeraaz ppt
Feraaz ppt
 
Talha ppt
Talha pptTalha ppt
Talha ppt
 

Poster presentation engineering culture

  • 1. “Engineering Culture: Control and Commitment in a High-Tech Corporation” by Gideon Kunda What is the book about? Organizational Theories Where? Silicon Valley, SysCom Metaphor (Morgan) Theory Commentary When? 1990s (6 months of field work) Who? Kunda, MIT student, Grade 2 Organization as Transactional ‘Give & take’ – transactional (Williamson) administrative support and Grade 4 tech economy cost theory Hard work in return for appearance of security workers support (management) Organization as Power Game Power = “getting things done the way you How? Participant observation ethnography Why? Opportunity to study corporate power power and politics (Mintzberg) want them done” Power is wielded through ‘informal’ ritualised messages (e.g. lunchtime seminars, annual picnics, etc.) Main Themes Organization as Similar to Z Proceed based on intimacy, subtlety and trust ‘family’ (or Organizations BUT – dark side of the ‘family’ – can be a Kunda exposes the intentionality of Tech ‘culture’?) (Ouchi) veneer for abuse or control company's management use of various methods of normative control to propagate its claims as a Methodology Critique familial work environment that operates informally and allows for a flexibility which  “Going native” dangers – too close, friendships, unrepresentative sampling promotes individual responsibility as the primary  2-Year write-up period in Tel Aviv. No further contact with sources one’s career success.  Focused on tech workers. Ignored support workers, mostly female & non- white. A rewarding and life-long employment is the company’s promise in exchange for one’s personally commitment of their creativity and initiative in the process of producing products that are marketable and successful in generating revenue. Kunda establishes that pervasive efforts of Tech, from a well-espoused ideology that involves “a moral purpose” as part of its daily culture where repetition of Tech’s s mask an elaborate and subtle form of normative control in which the members' minds and hearts become the target of corporate influence for the pursuit of corporate, and by chance individual, revenue. Kunda, G. (2006). Engineering culture: Control and commitment in a high-tech corporation. Temple University Press.