Slides for "Intro to Systems Thinking" workshop. Session details and resources available here: http://pwoessner.wikispaces.com/Introduction+to+Systems+Thinking
3. Knowledge and Experience
0 5 10
I Recognize Dilbert I Have Heard of Jay Forrester
Systems Thinking Sends Me
Flowers On My
Birthday
4. The World’s Biggest Problems
• Armed Conflict
• Spread of Infectious Disease
• Growing Population
• Availability of Energy
• International Terrorism
• The Economy
• Climate Change
• Poverty, Hunger, Lack of Water
Date Source: Eurobarometer survey of the EU, 2011
Image Source: 123RF
7. Learning to solve this…
A car averages 27 miles per gallon. If gas costs $4.04 per
gallon, which of the following is closest to how much the gas
would cost for this car to travel 2,727 typical miles?
A. $44.44
B. $109.08
C. $118.80
D. $408.04
E. $444.40
Question Source: ACT Prep
Image Source: MarketMixup
8. won’t teach you to solve this.
The United States consumers more than 20% (7 billion barrels)
of the world’s oil supply annually yet only has 2% of the world’s
proven oil reserves. What factors will determine when we
reach “peak oil”—the point in time when the maximum rate of
petroleum extraction is
reached, after which the rate of
oil production is expected to
enter terminal decline?
Image Source: OnlineBikeMania
9. Systems Thinking
Traditional analysis focuses on the individual pieces of what is
being studied. Systems thinking focuses on how the things
being studied interact with the other constituents of the system.
Instead of isolating smaller
and smaller parts of the
system being studied, systems
thinking works by expanding
its view to consider larger and
larger numbers of interactions
as an issue is being studied.
Image Source: Flickr Creative Commons, by erwlas
11. Problem Solving: Pest Control
Problem: Insect “A” is damaging crops
Traditional Analysis Approach: Spray pesticide to kill the insects
Pesticide Application Insect “A” Declines Crops Flourish
OVER TIME…
Insect “A” Population Insect “B” Population
Insect “B” Population Explodes Crops Damaged Even More
12. What is a System?
A set of elements or parts that is coherently organized and
interconnected in a pattern or structure that produces a
characteristic set of behaviors, often classified as its “function” or
“purpose.” (Donella Meadows)
14. Elements
• Typically the most obvious part of
a dynamic system
• Changing elements often has
very little effect on the system
Elements
Image Source: Armchair GM
15. Interconnections
• Often involve the flow of
information
• Changing relationships usually
changes system behavior
Inter-
connections
Image Source: Creative Commons by ~IconTexto
16. Function
• Typically the least obvious part of
a dynamic system
• A change in purpose changes a
system profoundly
Function
Image Source: Antique Radios
17. Systems: Key Points
• A system is more than the sum of its parts.
• Many of the interconnections in systems operate through the
flow of information.
• The least obvious part of the system, its function or
purpose, is often the most crucial determinate of the system’s
behavior.
• System structure is the source of system behavior. System
behavior reveals itself as a series of events over time.
19. What is Thinking?
“Thinking consists of two activities: constructing mental models
and then simulating them in order to draw conclusions and
make decisions.” – Barry Richmond
Understanding the concept of a tree requires more information
than is available through sensory experience alone. It’s built on
past experiences and knowledge.
Source: Jeremy Merritt
23. Changing Thinking
Fold your arms the
way you would if you
were bored, with one
falling over the other.
Uncross your arms and
fold them again, the
other way, with the
other arm on top.
Image Source: Flickr Creative Commons by CJ Berry
24. Thinking in Systems
“The problems we
have created in the
world today will not be
solved by the level of
thinking that created
them.”
--Albert Einstein
Image Source: Flickr Creative Commons, by mansionwb
40. Modeling Systems
“Essentially, all models
are wrong, but some
are useful.”
--George Box (Emeritus
Professor of
Statistics, University of
Wisconsin-Madison)
Image Source: Wikipedia
41. Modeling Systems
We are limited in our capacity to form and reform mental
models. Systems modeling allows us to move from “what” to
“what if” and make our thinking visible
The basic building blocks of dynamic models are
stocks, flows, and loops
42. Stocks
• Stocks are the foundation of any system and are the elements
that you can see, feel, count, or measure
• Stocks do not have to be physical
43. Flows
• Stocks change over time through the actions of a flow
• A stock is the present memory of the changing flows within
the system
44. Loops
• A feedback loop is formed when changes in a stock affect the
flows into or out of that same stock
• Balancing feedback loops are stability seeking and try to keep
a stock at a certain level or within a certain range
• Reinforcing feedback loops occur when a system element has
the ability to reproduce itself or grow at a constant fraction of
itself
50. Exploring Models
• Forio NetSim
• MIT Sloan
• ISEE STELLA Models
Complete List of Models and Simulations
http://bitly.com/systems_thinking_2012
51. Getting Started
• Partner: Systems Thinking is
hard to master alone
• Read: Thinking in Systems
by Donella Meadows
• Identify: Articulate the
systems in your curriculum
• Create: Draw a simple
stock-flow-loop diagram
• Simulate: Explore a systems
model using the Habits of
Systems Thinkers
What do you consider to be the world’s biggest problems? Are these problems “new”?
How common is this type of problem in school?How common/important is this type of problem in life?
How common is this type of problem in school?How common/important is this type of problem in life?
Both types of analysis/thinking are important but the latter is often missing from schoolsSystems thinking is the process of understanding how a group of interacting, interrelated, interdependent components influence each other within the whole.Traditional analysis can’t always see the forest for the trees
Some studies suggest that the majority of the 25 insects that cause the most crop damage became problems because of exactly this type of approach
What are some common systems? What do they have in common?
A system is more than the sum of its partsMany of the interconnections in systems operate through the flow of informationThe least obvious part of the system, its function or purpose, is often the most crucial determinate of the system’s behaviorSystem structure is the source of system behavior. System behavior reveals itself as a series of events over time.
Textbooks, curriculum, administrators, presidents, etc. don’t affect major change within a system.Ex: Tony LaRussa and Albert Pujols left the Cardinals, but they are still the 11 time World Champs
Interconnects are often difficult to see but have great impact on the system.Ex: The shift from Web 1.0 to Web 2.0 changed the nature of the Internet, information, and online interactions
System functions seem obvious but may not be clear to all observersEx: Raytheon Company began as the American Appliance Company, a maker of machinery, motors and components (vacuum tubes). Today they make weapon defense systems (Patriot Missles).
If you want to change (or understand) a system, you MUST focus on system structure because structure drives behavior.
What are the Elements in this system? The Interactions? The Function?What are the problems with this system? What change(s) would make it better?
Barry Richmond is known as leader in the field of systems thinking and system dynamics[1] and for the development of the STELLA/IThinkmodelling environment for simulation.[2]The tree is actually a concept of something that exists in physical reality. The “tree concept” is a model.
Take a look at these images for a few moments and then think about what is happening inside your mind as you look at them. My guess is that with each image you thought about what happens next. If so, you were actually simulating a mental model forward in time. The images don’t show you what happened next, but you can probably make a pretty good guess. This guess is the result of simulating a mental model of what is depicted. And, you can simulate different outcomes. Notes Source: Jeremy Merritt
Take a look at these images for a few moments and then think about what is happening inside your mind as you look at them. My guess is that with each image you thought about what happens next. If so, you were actually simulating a mental model forward in time. The images don’t show you what happened next, but you can probably make a pretty good guess. This guess is the result of simulating a mental model of what is depicted. And, you can simulate different outcomes. Notes Source: Jeremy Merritt
Take a look at these images for a few moments and then think about what is happening inside your mind as you look at them. My guess is that with each image you thought about what happens next. If so, you were actually simulating a mental model forward in time. The images don’t show you what happened next, but you can probably make a pretty good guess. This guess is the result of simulating a mental model of what is depicted. And, you can simulate different outcomes. Notes Source: Jeremy Merritt
Step 1: Look at your arms and notice which one is on top. Notice how this feels? Is it comfortable? Does it feel normal?Step 2: How does that feel? What do you notice?Activity source: The Systems Thinking Playbook by Sweeney and Meadows
The Habits of a Systems Thinker, developed by the Waters Foundation, encompass a spectrum of thinking strategies that foster problem-solving and encourage questioning. Though “habit” is defined as a usual way of doing things, the Habits of a Systems Thinker do not suggest that systems thinkers are limited by routine ways of thinking. Rather, the Habits encourage flexible thinking and appreciation of new, emerging insights and multiple perspectives.
Note: The following “notes” for the Habits slides refer to the I Love Lucy clip shown on an earlier slide.Does the person in charge of that assembly line/factory system have the big picture? Do Lucy or Ethel?
What elements changed in the system?
Think about the structure of the assembly line; how does its structure affect its behavior?
What should the supervisor have done to gain better perspective and increase understanding?
What example of this did you see in the film clip?
Would the short term actions (gain) taken by the supervisor lead to long term pain?
How did the supervisor measure success?
It’s important to note that time delays work in both directions (before and after making changes).
What did the supervisor see as the leverage point in the system?
What unintended consequence(s) can you identify from the example clip?
What was the supervisor’s mental model of how the system worked? Did it account for different outcomes?
Examples from the clip?
The I Love Lucy clip illustrated a linear process (assembly line) driven by linear thinking. The cause-effect cycle was never considered.
A detailed rubric for LS, MS, US is available on the session wiki.
Everything we think we know about the world is a model. Our models have a strong congruence with the world, but fall far short of representing the real world fully.
Think of a stock as a container (e.g. bathtub) that can “hold” a measurable amount of something (e.g. water)
A stock takes time to change because a flow takes time to flow
The information delivered by a feedback loop can only affect future behavior; it cannot send a signal fast enough to correct behavior that drove the current feedback
Think back to our earlier example of insect control; what was the problem with that approach (Seek and Destroy) to resolving the problem?
This model from “Tracing Connections: Voices of Systems Thinkers” illustrates a more complete picture of the factors (elements) that influence this systemThese types of models can be created by students and are very helpful in identifying the important pieces (elements) and relationships.Creating a model for faculty morale or student achievement can be a great exercise for introducing teachers to ST principles.
This simple model (which I will demonstrate via STELLA) illustrates the spread of a disease through a population.What are the stocks? Flows? Loops?