4. Five way model:
Level of confidence on the vertical axis.
Method of action on the horizontal axis.
Individualistic Adventurer
CONFIDENT
Guardian
Celebrity
ANXIOUS
CAREFUL IMPETUOUSSTRAIGHT
ARROW
5. Description:
• The Adventurer: People who are willing to
put it all on one bet and go for it because they
have confidence.
• Difficult to advise
• Willing to take risk
• Volatile clients from an investment counsel
point of view.
6. • The Celebrity: These people like to be
where the action is. They are afraid of being
left out. They really do not have their own
ideas of investment.
• Best prey for maximum broker.
7. • The Individualist: These people tend to go
their own way and are typified by the small
business person or an independent professional
such as lawyer, CA or engineer.
• Trying to make their own decision in life,
• Carefully going about things,
• Certain degree of confidence,
• Rational investors with whom the portfolio
managers can talk sense.
8. • The Guardian: Typically as people get older
and begin considering retirement, they approach
this personality profile.
• Careful and little bit worried about their money.
• Preserve their assets.
• Not interested in volatility or excitement.
• Lack confidence in their ability to forecast the
future and look for guidance.
9. • The Straight Arrow: Well balanced,
cannot be placed in any quadrant and hence
fall near center.
• On average this group of client is the average
investor.
10. Barnewall model:
• Marilyn MacGruder Barnewall’s psychographic
investor model distinguish between two
relatively simple investor types:
1. Passive investors
2. Active investors
11. • Passive investors are those investors who
gained their wealth passively.
Includes professional like Corporate manager, CA, lawyers,
medicos, politicians, bankers, journalist etc.
• Active investors are those individual who have
risked their own capital in order to earn their
wealth.
• Their tolerance of risk is higher than their
need for security.
Entrepreneurs are active investors.
12. The Eight investor Personality types:
Visual depiction is as:
Idealist(I) Pragmatist(P)
Framer(F) Integrator(N)
Reflector(T) Realist(R)
So there are 8 possible investor personality types:
IFT, IFR, INT, INR, PFT, PFR, PNT, PNR
13. Idealism/ Pragmatism (I/P)
• Idealist end: Overestimate their investing
abilities.
• Display too much optimism about capital market.
• Don’t seek out information that contradicts their
views
• Often disinclined towards thorough research,
they fall prey to speculative markets fads.
• They are subject to the following biases: Over-
confidence, optimism, self-attribution, illusion of
control, repetitiveness etc.
14. • Pragmatists end: Display realistic grasp of their
own skills and limitation as investors.
• Not too over confident about the capital
markets and demonstrate a healthy dose of
skepticism regarding their investing abilities.
• Do research for confirmation.
• Typically not susceptible to the mentioned
biases.
15. Framing/ Integration (F/N)
• Framers tend to evaluate each of their
investment through a particularistic lens and don
not consider how each investment fits into an
overall portfolio plan.
• Too rigid in their mental approach to analyze
problems.
• Framer’s portfolio appears to comprise
disassociated “pots” of money rather than a
composite of complementary interrelated
investment.
• Susceptible to biases like: Conservatism, mental
accounting, ambiguity etc.
16. • Integrators are characterized by an ability to
contemplate broader contexts and
externalities.
• Correctly view the portfolio as system whose
components can interact and balance one
another.
• Flexible in approach to markets.
• Not susceptible to the biases.
17. Reflecting/ Realism(T/R)
Reflectors have trouble living with the
consequences of their decision and have difficulty
taking actions to rectify their behaviors.
Justify and rationalize incorrect actions and
hesitate to own up decisions that have not
worked out beneficially.
Susceptible to these biases: Cognitive dissonance,
endowment, self control , regret, status quo,
hindsight etc.
18. • Realists have less trouble coming to terms
with the consequences of their choices.
• Don’t tend to scramble for excuses in order to
justify incorrect actions.
• Assume responsibility for their mistakes.
• Easier time with decision making under
pressure.
• Not susceptible to any biases.